╌>

Judge: Town's speeding cameras are '3 Card Monty' scam

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  maya-ingalls  •  13 years ago  •  3 comments

Judge: Town's speeding cameras are '3 Card Monty' scam

Judge: Town's speeding cameras are '3 Card Monty' scam

If you happen to drive too fast through Elmwood Place, Ohio, the cards are stacked against you, according to a judge who calls the village's automated speeding camera "a scam that motorists can't win."

Hamilton County Common Pleas Judge Robert Ruehlman on Thursday ruled that the village's ordinance violated due process. He issued an injunction barring itsenforcement.

There have been numerous legal challenges across the U.S. to red-light camera laws but observers said this is the first ruling they know of striking down a municipality's speeding-camera law.

"Speed-camera cases have been litigated but we have not come across one where a judge has said, 'Stop this,'"attorney Mike Allen, whose firm brought the case, told MSN News on Friday. "I think it's going to touch off a firestorm around the country. I really do."

Calls and emails by MSN News to Elmwood Place village officials and police Chief William Peskin were not immediately returned on Friday. Allen said he expects the village to appeal.

Ruehlman sprinkled colorful language in his ruling striking down Elmwood's "automated speed enforcement program," which is carried out by Optotraffic , a Lanham, Md.-based company, under a contract with the village. Optotrafficgets a40 percent cut of the revenues from fines it collects.

The two cameras installed in town reportedly resulted in 6,600 speeding citations three times the village's population - at $105 a pop in the first month after enforcement began in September.

The judge, who heard arguments in January , found that the ordinance fails to provide due process to people receiving a notice of fines in the mail. He said the village doesnt have a sign warning motorists that traffic cameras are in operation, as required by state law.

To challenge the $105 fine, a motorist has to pay $25 for a hearing that is "nothing more than a sham!" the judge wrote. At the hearing, he said, the "witness" for the village testifies from a report produced by the company that owns the speed-monitoring unit. Since the "witness" was not present when the alleged violation occurred, he or she can't be cross-examined, Ruehlman wrote.

Read more: Judge: Town's speeding cameras are '3 Card Monty' scam


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Alyssa Ingalls
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Alyssa Ingalls    13 years ago

I got one of these tickets a long time ago. Never paid it either. I learned that if you do not receive your ticket within the 30 days of the snapshot, then they cannot collect, and then again, they have no real proof that you even received a ticket since it is not mailed to you with a signature required.

I never paid, ad they never came after me either.

So if you get one, do not admit guilt, and do not fill out the forms and send them in. They have to prove that you got it in the mail within the 30 days, and they are not going to waste time taking you to court to try and collect.

The whole red lite and speeding cams are all a sham, and they all need to be taken down imo.

 
 
 
charger 383
Professor Silent
link   charger 383    13 years ago

ban all speed cameras

 
 
 
Alyssa Ingalls
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Alyssa Ingalls    13 years ago

Agreed Charger 383

 
 

Who is online







137 visitors