Should These Firearms be Banned
I wanted to really try and understand why people want certain firearms banned. I honestly can't follow their logic in words...so I wanted to try visual.
This way, people can tell me what image they are discussing, describe what it is about the firearm that they believe should make it more heavily restricted than...say a handgun.
And if you aren't a person that necessarily wants an outright ban on various firearms, andonly think some of these weapons should be more heavily regulated than others, I would like to hear your take on that, too.
Image 1)
Image #2)
Image #3)
Tags
Who is online
137 visitors

OK. So help me out here. Which of these needs to be restricted or banned and why.
As a side note, I'm not looking for tap-dancing and "non-answers" like *whichever ones the courts say should be banned*. I'm looking for YOUR opinion. There are many people who have closely held beliefs regarding which firearms should be restricted or banned and why. I'm looking for those beliefs and opinions.
If the answer is "none of them", that's great, too. But if that's NOT the answer, then I genuinely want to know your thought processes behind why.
Hmmm. No takers yet. Gee. I wonder if that means gun grabbers can't identify what they want everyone to relinquish if it doesn't have a name by it.
Nah. That can't be it.
Wow. Grumpy today.
Should I take this to mean that you don't have enough faith in your conviction to even say:
"I would prefer to see #1 banned because it has a pistol grip" (or some other feature) Or I would prefer to see #3 banned because of the large capacity."
I mean come on, John. You've decried high capacity magazines several times on this site. Now...all of a sudden...you're shy about it?
See? Now this is someone that has the sack to answer. Obviously, I disagree, lol. But I gotta admire a guy that has courage of conviction and isn't afraid to say what he believes.
Obviously, getting people to agree to ban the #1 skeet shooting shotgun on the market would never happen, but hey...I give you credit for stating your position.
HA! A fashionista gun owner. I love it.
Then why are you still here, John?
Shoo.
I was going to say the third one, because it looks like a cheap piece of crap. Then I noticed that it's an airsoft gun made to look like a double eagle. So I'm kinda right.
The first one is a Crosman air rifle. So, this is a joke article?
Bravo Dylan
That was indeed, the larger point. It wasn't intended to "trick" anyone nor was it intended as a joke. I had every intention of revealing what each one was, once I let responses come in a bit.
For the record...the middle one is a real Ruger 10/22. Semi-automatic. The deadliest of the three, (bottom one is a BB gun)
I have to hand it to Mickey for coming in here and sticking to what he's been saying all along. Ban all semi-automatics (technically, all three of these cound be comsidered "semi automatic", though)
But I'm amazed at how silent...or instantly defensive...the rest of the gun control posters became when they didn't have labels or names to go by.
Gang...the gun control debate might lead to changing our laws. Please don't change those laws based on appearances of guns. KNOW what it is that you want to ban, be able to identify it and most importantly, know WHY you want to ban it and how you believe doing so will lead to less crime.
I think their silence tells all, Royal. If you put up an article about the ideology surrounding the control debate, you get them hitting on it like crazy. And quickly. But put one up where they actually have to demonstrate at least a modicum of knowledge and they disperse quickly.
Actually, Mickey...you were the exception to the rule. You stayed true to form. You said that your stance was to ban semi-automatics a week ago and you stuck with it today.
Even though I don't agree with you, I admire courage of conviction, and you have it, babe.
Unlike some others, you didn't get instantly snarky and defensive or fear speaking up at all.
And in a sense...they ARE all semi-automatics, in that they only fire one round when you pull the trigger. (that's what a semi-automatic does).
I suppose it could even be said that the bottom one (the BB gun) is "high capacity". lol
Dear heart...you've said three times now, that you aren't participating in it. I said "fine" and even told you to shoo. Yet you still keep showing up. Why is that?
None.....the proposed ban is to manipulate the masses into believing guns are the problem. Then they will eventually take all our guns away from us. Fear monger, yes I am. And with every reason on earth to be. Have you tried to buy any ammo lately? Or have you tried to buy a gun lately. Some are almost impossible to get. The government is buying up all the ammo of all different calibers. The government has bought enough ammunition to fight 10 Iraqi wars. Maybe we could cut back on that.
Get in line and take your medicine. There's a big picture here that it seems too many are missing. Hell.....they're even banning fingers:
Kid, 6, Expelled For Pointing Fingers Like A Gun And Saying Pow
I don't know.....there must be something in the water or some kind of hypnotic trance going on. I say ban psychotic drugs that are prescribed to your children by intellectual psychiatrist that are destroying their lives. Maybe just ban psychiatrist. That would suit me.
Okay....
Believe it or not, this is the first time that I have weighed in on the issues revolving around guns, gun control, and crime.
1) In my opinion....It will be impossible to write legislation banning any sort of semi-automatic weapon that makes sense and is just to law abiding gun owners, unless it is the will of the people that all semi-automatic weapons are to be banned.
2) In my opinion...I personally see no need or use for semi-automatic weapons patterned after the likes of their military cousins the M-16 or the AK-47. My type of sport hunting involves a bolt action rifle of higher caliber than the aforementioned, and a pump style shotgun. But that is my type of hunting. Even in the case of coyotes, and feral hogs, there are better weapons of choice for people of all shapes and sizes. This is my opinion.
3) In my opinion.... there are very few occasions where one is going to need a magazine capacity of more than six rounds. Pistol target shooting might be the exception. The pistol is an exception as its sole use is to kill something at short range, period. The magazine capacity for semi-automatic pistols should be limited to 20 rounds or less. With that in mind, all semi-automatic weapons should be limited in the capacity of their magazines to no more than 20 rounds in an effort to make viable legislation possible.
4) In my opinion..... owning one of the semi-autos patterned after their military counterparts is akin to owning a Harley. More of a status thing, or a way to say "look at me". The situation is made worse for having loud pipes on the Harley in its case, and a black or cammo finish on the semi-auto.
5) In my opinion.... The NRA has stopped serving gun owners and hunters beyond token items like hunter safety programs, and are the lobbying arm of the gun manufactures. They just want to make profit selling things that when used properly, kill. Their motives are worse than the tobacco industry, at least tobacco use doesn't kill outright.
6) In my opinion.... All we hear from the loudest of gun owners is their percieved rights under the 2nd Amendment. I say perceived rights, because it is going to take a specific and pointed ruling by the SCOTUS on exactly on how the constitution should apply to civilian gun ownership in the here and now. What thoughtful gun owners need to be doing is coming to the table with ideas to help law enforcement in reducing the number and use of guns in crimes. In short, all we see are excuses as to why we can't obtain useful, meaningful and enforceable gun legislation. The medical industry needs to come to the table too to make it possible to gain access to those under treatment or medication that would make them more apt to want to kill either themselves, or those around them.
Hope you got my message to you Pat
You're right, John. I should have said that we have a couple of gun control advocates (Mickey and Fly) who were willing to clearly articulate their position.
We have a whole lot of very silent gun control advocates.
We have one trollish, snarky gun grabber that only knows how to attack others and doesn't seem to have a clue, what he wants to ban. (You)
Fair enough?
Now. You have no self control when people challenge your opinion. Lets see if you AT LEAST have self control to do what you say you're going to do.
Contribute or leave.
Ever looked at the state of FL on a map? We need to eliminate that.
Then it's a good thing that individuals don't get to write law. Especially for female gun owners. To address just a couple of your points:
And most of my type of hunting (upland birds) involves a 12 or 20g shotgun. However, on those days that I don't want to cripple hogs or want to shoot in a tournament, a lightweight gun that has no recoil, is accurate and fits me well is ideal.
I know a lot of people who own Harley's because of their quality, durability and customization. Status might be why YOU would own a Harley. But you are projecting that on everyone else. A lot of women own a Harley Sportster. Why? Because it fits them well and it's high quality.
Just how familiar are you with the NRA? Because you seem to harbor some of the same delusions about them that a lot of people do. (A) I doubt they are making a whole lot of money off of a person's $25 a year membership considering the massive amount of freebies, discounts and even life insurance a person gets with membership. (B) Because of the NRA, we don't have a bunch of gun-owning housewives running around with no training, as they are the ONLY organization that is sensitive about creating training environments specifically for women in non-intimidating settings. (C)They are the ONLY organization that puts it's trainers through a rigorous course before certifying them. Apparently, you would rather people be taught how to shoot by Joe Blow veteran with PTSD who fancies himself an "expert" on gun safety training? (D) I am the Dir. of Communications for a state based Affiliate of the NRA. Since I am on the inside of this on a daily basis and dealing with State issues, I think I have a little bit better idea who the NRA is "for" than you do. There has not been a single communication from them that focuses on manufacturers. Only the rights of citizens. Without them, we would have Sheriff's in this state that fancy themselves "bad asses" and would still be issuing permits to their good ol' boy network only.
Your above paragraph describes the AARP more than it does, the NRA
Then where/who are they getting their money from Pat to become such a powerful lobby in congress.
I don't even own a gun except a BB gun I've had for 20 plus years and an old 410 I inherited. But I'm thinking about getting one. I found it is not as easy as you would think. Since the government has bought up most of the ammunition of all calibers especially the most popular and everyone else that can see the light has bought most of the guns, this administration has been the biggest spender on gun and ammunition in my life time. Hey.....maybe we would save some jobs by cutting back on those expenses, but that's another story.
Where I come from there are more bears than there has been in 100 years. You don't just go walking out in the woods these days without a gun unless you're a fool. When you wake up and see a half dozen deer destroying your livelihood you've worked so hard to provide an income for your family, a six shooter just won't do the job.
When you live in the big city where the government has already programmed you to fear the law as much as you fear the criminals because crime is being committed by both then you are already lost and there is no use trying to communicate with you. You'll gladly turn your gun in and the criminals that plan on busting your door down in the next couple of weeks are rejoicing, because they can get a gun anytime they want and it won't be registered either. It may cost a little more, but it's just a tool they like to have to do their chosen job.
So do you think the government is coming to take your guns? Not right away, only one small step at a time. I don't think they should ban any of the guns that aren't banned right now. I'm not interested in having the government tell me what to do. My God, they've already told me I have to pay taxes on something because I didn't buy it, but that's another story. I've always been accustomed to paying taxes on purchases not the other way around. States are different than the Federal Government and they call it what it is, a fine.
So turn in your guns, law abiding citizens. Lose your right to have one and suffer punishment for not following the law and become a felon yourself when you try to protect your family from the real criminals, which are the ones on the street and the ones in Washington. Remember they both still will have guns even when you don't any longer. And they will have the big magazines as well. They'll probably be exceptions to the new laws that allow the rich and famous to continue to have their protection by having paid guards. We'll become just what they planned.
As for me, I plan on buying a gun and probably passing it on to the corrupt government in time, since I am a law abiding citizen, and I won't be able to keep it anywhere near me anyway in the future.
Have you ever had any problems with the IRS. Step out of line and you'll see how things work, even if you haven't done anything wrong.
How Will They Confiscate Your Guns?
...
Watch out for the deer. They'll be a whole lot more running into your cars and SUVs.
Do you contribute to causes you believe in, Fly? Or do you just expect those causes to represent you in a manner you deem acceptable and keep your wallet strapped to your ass?
Like it or not, they are a popular organization with many Americans supporting them. Live with it. And with this administration's latest sabre rattling on gun control, all they've done is make them even MORE popular. Their membership swelled to all time record highs last month. And it wasn't anything they did. It was the marketing Obama did for them.
There is also their merchandise. I just bought a cool sweatshirt. Made in the USA. Surely, you aren't against voluntary consumer purchases.
Tell ya what...you keep up with the conspiracy theory that the NRA cares nothing about gun rights or American civilians and is "really" getting their palms greased by those big' ol' bad free enterprise, popular gun manufacturers and I'll meet you back over on John's "paranoid" thread...K?
"Never let a good crisis go to waste."
Alinsky's Rules for Radicals
The tenth rule of the ethics of rules and means is that you do what you can with what you have and clothe it in moral arguments. the essence of Lenin's speeches during this period was "They have the guns and therefore we are for peace and for reformation through the ballot. When we have the guns then it will be through the bullet." And it was. P.36-37
The organizer dedicated to changing the life of a particular community must first rub raw the resentments of the people of the community; fan the latent hostilities of many of the people to the point of overt expression. He must search out controversy and issues, rather than avoid them, for unless there is controversy people are not concerned enough to act. P.116-117
"Power comes out of the barrel of a gun!" is an absurd rallying cry when the other side has all the guns. xxi
If the organizer begins with an affirmation of love for people, he promptly turns everyone off. If, on the other hand, he begins with a denunciation of exploiting employers, slum landlords, police shakedowns, gouging merchants, he is inside their experience and they accept him. P.98
The job of the organizer is to maneuver and bait the establishment so that it will publicly attack him as a "dangerous enemy." P.100
Just for clarity...this is a rumor that the NRA is working diligently to squash. Please don't buy into it. It's not the 'government' buying everything up. In fact, their purchases have been pretty reasonable. It's the rise in consumer purchases that are causing scarcity.
Of course, we better not tell the gun grabbers here that the NRA is trying to set the record straight on this rumor instead of promoting it. It will shatter their invented image of the NRAand may damage their fragile little psyche.
...
As attacks on our Second Amendment rights increase, there is a predictable uptick in the number of internet rumors concerning firearms and ammunition.
The latest rumor is actually a variation of an old one , and claims that George Soros owns "most of the ammunition manufacturing companies and many arms manufacturers," and that he's "selling ONLY to the government right now."
This simply isn't true. Current ammunition shortages are driven by consumer demand, which has spiked due to the ongoing attacks on gun owners rights. To read a statement by the National Shooting Sports Foundation refuting this latest rumor, please click here .
and another one....
...
If you take the number of agencies that will be using this ammunition CBP, Citizenship and Immigration Services, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), ICE, the U.S. Secret Service, Transportation Security Administration, the DHS police force, and all the guards that protect the various buildings these agencies are housed in, and spread that out over 5 years, you start to see that 450 million rounds really isn't that large of an order. Especially considering it is used for training purposes like firing range and live fire exercises, on-the-job use (though that is very limited), and to shore up their supplies. In fact, there are 65,000 70,000 law enforcement personnel at DHS who would be covered under this ammunition contract. If DHS were to purchase all 450 million rounds over 5 years, then that would equate to only about 1,384 rounds of ammo per year per law enforcement [officer] assuming the lower estimate of only 65,000 law enforcement personnel at DHS. Considering those agents go through training exercises several times per year, that is not a lot of ammunition .
That being the case, do you know how much ammunition was bought by the government say starting in 2000 until today or a few years ago?
Nope. All I've kept track of is rolling 12 month totals. That's all I really need to do for my responsiblity with the organization I'm involved with. It's actually dropped in the past few years as the wars are winding down.
I don't really watch the prices either, as I have access to very reasonably priced/price controlled ammunition. For people not that lucky...I've heard it's sky-rocketed though. Basic supply and demand, I guess.
So the fact is Pat N......We don't really know, do we? I figure since Bush and the Iraqi government made the agreement for us to be out of Iragi by December, not Obama as most Americans believe, we would have bought less ammunition for the military, but these other organizations within the government are the ones I'm talking about, not the military. Your job only gives you responsibility for what you've stated. How do you know it is reasonable then when you only know about the last 12 months? Thank you for putting the article up, but we really don't know, do we? The NRA is trying to squash this rumor you say. You know, there are other rumors being squashed as well by the media and the government. I certainly don't know, but I wonder why the National Weather Service has a need for so much ammunition. I know the government buys, let's call it futures, to get a better price with an order for later on. Is this the case? I've heard that. When law abiding citizens aren't committing the crimes then I figure they shouldn't be the ones punished by the laws.
It reminds me we are having record revenues with less people working, more people receiving benefits from food stamps to free phones and we have to cut back on the working people's benefits and jobs and raise taxes. Who is receiving the punishment?
No.......just one scoop at a time and then one day there's no more scoops left, except in the bowl you didn't scoop from. It's still filled to the top.
Gun bans - Don't think it can happen, watch
Banned guns and gun crime goes up
This is what will happen if we ban guns
And as I pointed out, int he NRA link, those totals are more than reasonable. Read the second link I provided. It goes into detail on why it's reasonable.
I said ROLLING 12 month total. Not a static 12 month total. And for every month I've looked at, it's been steady or down. Plus, I trust the NRA's stats on totals going back further.
WHat I am essentially saying is that my spreadsheet goes back 12 months. I COULD get on the net like anyone else and waste time digging for info going back to 2000, but I'm simply not inclined to do that because there is ample evidence from sources I trust that have already tracked those numbers from more reliable data than the net.
So you're putting the NRA in the same catagory as the media and the government when it comes to protection of 2A rights? Sorry. I can't buy into that. They are the number one advocate for gun rights and I agree with them wholeheartedly that if responsible gun owners want to be taken seriously, spreading rumors about government takeovers of ammo and guns isn't the way to do it. Especially when those rumors sprang from the internet and there is no factual data to back them up. If we don't want the gun grabbers to label us "loons", then we need to not act like loons.
That was covered int he link from the NRA that I supplied. Specifically:
Another recent rumor questioned a request for 46,000 rounds of.40-caliber ammo by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. NOAA inadvertently fueled that speculation through a clerical error that suggested the ammunition was destined for the National Weather Service. NOAA later clarified that the ammunition was actually for the little known Fisheries Office of Law Enforcement , which enforces laws against illegal fishing and marine life importation. The ammunition is for 63 personnel, amounting to about 730 rounds per officer .
Look.... I'm not putting the NRA into the same category as the media. I support them 100%. If I implied that, it was not my intention. As far as finding stuff on the internet always being wrong and getting your information elsewhere always right, I don't agree. Thanks for the clarification of the NOAA. My wrong. Personally, I don't care if I'm labeled a loon by the loons. I'm still free to be a loon if I so choose to be one as far as I know.
Please if you will provide those reliable sources you trust. Not trying to be sarcastic, but I would like to take a look at them or at least know of the reliable sources you're referring. It would be beneficial to all.
CNN- Obama To BAN Guns
TOTAL Gun Ban
I never said the internet was always wrong. I said the data sources that the NRA has access to is more reliable. They come straight from budgetary offices. Not an agenda driven website.
I already did. The NRA. Who gets their data from the P&L from the various agencies within the federal government under the Freedom of Information Act.
You say you "support them 100%", yet when I put up data from them based on actual budget numbers that doesn't confirm the internet rumors floating around out there and in fact, asks people to stop promoting them...it appears that your support for them wains.
Don't forget the "semi-automatic" slingshot
Common Sense
Maybe 98%. Thanks for this article and the Conservative article. Have to get it on to get some work done but I'll leave you with this:
Don't Let 'Em Take Your Gun
You left out the Hello Kitty Bubble Gun...an extremely dangerous weapon...so dangerous that a five year old discussing it's relative merits as compared to the Princess Bubble Gun merited a ten day school suspension:
Obama Busted for Lying, by MSNBC, About His Support For A 100% Hand Gun Ban
I'd say it is pretty transparent.
It may not be apparent where you are heading when you take that first step, but remember a step at a time and you realize after a while you have arrived at your destination. Do we want to walk down that road? Evolving, I guess?
More government school over-reaction.
Geez...who are these little, heathen children who DARE speak of Hello Kitty bubble guns or bite ther pop-tarts into the shape of a .45 cal.? We need to isolate them. They are obviously a detriment to the student body and are the next generation of whacko, looney-bin gun nuts.
Okay, this is the best one I've seen yet...in terms of "over reaction" by school officials:
Evidently "shooting some B Ball outside of the school" is now a terroristic threat...in the mind of one woman, anyway...
What about semi-automatic paintball guns, Mickey?
Are you sure? They are semi automatics and they cause death.
Washington The government issued sharp warnings on Wednesday to paintball gun users, announcing new safety measures while investigations continue into two deaths caused by canisters flying off the guns.
Finally. John admits he wants these weapons banned because he finds them "frightening".
Guess what, John? To most people, they aren't frightening at all. They are so easy to handle, a child could do it. They are accurate, lightweight and have no recoil.
But thanks for finally admitting you are afraid of the appearance of an inanimate object and just want it to go away
All excellent questions. And I suspect you won't get reasonable answers to them.
OK. So lets use AR-15's as an example. Lets say the gun grabbers get their wish and the AR-15 is banned from future sales.
over 1 million have been sold since 1963. Looking forward to your thoughts regarding how leaving those 1 million on the streets would have the effect on crime you seem to think it will
Good luck getting a gun rights advocate to agree to sell for pennies on the dollar, a firearm the government just turned into a collector's item by banning the future sales of.
Really. So where has that answer been used? Funny thing...I've never seen you complain about it. And I've seen you complain about ALOT when it comes to guns.
I'm just asking you to think more than surface deep. If the AR15 is banned from fututre sales, what about the 1,000,000 + already on the street?
Seriously, John. If you can't support your position to the point of having it challenged by one simple question, then even YOU have to admit that it's a pretty weak position.
I won't even go into asking you what you would do about all of the AR knockoffs, like the Mossberg AR-15 22LR and ask you if you are in favor of banning AR-15's or AR-15 style firearms. That simple question would really "anger" you.
I'm not a "gun fan" per se...but I do believe that instituting a ban on a previously legal and Constitutionally guaranteed right is something that will cause far more harm than good.
I can forsee a thousand "Ruby Ridge" scenarios...do we want that? Do we really want to exacerbate the already fractured sense of identity that we now have by infringing on someone's civil rights to the degree they feel they must defend themselves? Even ifyou personallydon't feel they have a right to bear arms, they certainly do...and I can tell you that it is a right that as recently as 40 years ago was considered unquestioned...something that only criminal activity could strip from you.
This is not a partisan issue...many Liberals and Democrats are gun owners and also feel that their rights are being trampled upon in an effort to control the criminal activity in this country, and they see, as I do, that the proposed legislation is beyond futile, it is counterproductive.
It is too late to remove all weapons from this country. It is way too late. Without sacrificing our rights to privacy and allowing our own homes to be invaded in the quest for weapon destruction...and really, how utterly impossible that would be...I could hide a small arsenal of weapons and without totally destroying my house, yard, barn and surrounding woods, they could not find them...we will never be able to eradicate weapons...not to mention the fact that there are more than enough gunsmiths in this country to be able to make more whenever they chose...or the obvious reality that they can walk across the border in droves.
Are we going to have a zero tolerance policy that will require the removal of art, movies, etc...any depictions of violence? It happened in our schools...and look how well that has turned out.
And...why are we looking only at "how" these violent mass shootings occur. Should we not be looking at "why" instead? Psychotropic drugs are the most likely contributing factor...should we hold physicians who prescribe them accountable when and/or if their patient goes off the deep end and those "feelings of depression and mood swings" that the drug manufacturers warn about right on the damn label escalate into another mass shooting?
Let's just say that your side succeeds in it's aims to remove all weapons...and despite the denials from the anti-gun crowd, we all know that is the ultimate goal...what happens then? History tells us what happens then.
Bombs.
Is it really worth ending school shootings in order to introduce school bombings? That was the intent at Columbine, you know...they only resorted to shooting people because the bombs didn't go off. Horrific as Columbine was, it could have been far worse. It could have been another Bath School disaster, had they been as proficient in bomb making as Andrew Kehoe was...38 children dead, 6 adults dead, 58 more injured.
If we want to end this type of violence, we need to look past the weapon to the persons pulling the triggers. You want to eliminate a symptom...but the symptom is not the disease.