" According to Graeber , it was his idea to "occupy" a plot of ground, rather than physically protest banks."
Not true. Graeber never said that at all. What happened was...
Occupy Wall Street: An interview with Kalle Lasn, the man behind it all
...
What David Graeber added to the mix (and to the historical process) was to propose the creation of a General Assembly.
Scroll down here for the name, David Graeber:
For more detail, look at actual historical accounts from reliable sources, or see David Graeber's own writings, such as his book The Democracy Project . But don't just make stuff up out of thin air. Thanks.
"OWS was a complete failure. Even Graeber says it's legacy was just in getting people to think differently about things. Whoop de doo."
Your perspective is distorted, JR, by your conflation of a mass action (with many local solidarity actions all over the world) with the movement. Also, you conflate this action's brand name "occupy wall street" (OWS) with the movement. Therefore, your sense of its beginning and ending is askew. The movement lives on, though it appears to be largely dormant. But the movement will pop up again, like mushrooms after a good rain. It will have other names and brands. It will have similar, but different tactics.... In fact, it never went away! It's just not reported under that brand name, and the mainstream (corporate) media don't often report on this movement -- as they'd like not to have it spread any further, obviously.
Conflating "Occupy Wall Street" as "the movement" is a very popular mistake, but one without much historical merit upon a careful look at the history of the actual movement, which predates OWS and lives on.
JR - You are arguing for my point, but apparently you don't know it yet. You said "David Graeber says he was the founder of Occupy Wall St." ... and I said that's not a fact. And between you and me we have since established that it is not a fact, just as I said.
Graeber DID say that he and some his friends and co-activists did collaborate on shifting the energy dynamic of early OWS from a "vertical" to a "horizontal" structure by advocating for the creation of a General Assembly (which is a horizontal structure). It's all right there in his own words!
"If I recall, at the time Graeber was a little miffed that he wasn't being given more credit. He has said that without him OWS would have been a one day protest at bank locations in lower Manhattan."
This is not historically accurate. You made this all up in your imagination. If you want to show otherwise, bring evidence. But I know there is no such evidence, as I've read the history (and Graeber) extensively. You are a VERY POOR historian.
"Like I said, characterize that how you like, it doesn't matter much to me. I just remember what I saw."
If the facts don't much matter to you, as you just admitted, why go on misrepresenting them -- unless to propagandize with the use of misrepresented facts?
This is anarchy in a single book
A Conversation With Anarchist David Graeber
... and for those wanting more info than a book cover:
We're not supposed to provide links? Huh?
Both of these statements are demonstrably false.
Make google your friend, they are book covers
But for the google challenged
The Anarchy for Dummies Book Cover is a cartoon image
" According to Graeber , it was his idea to "occupy" a plot of ground, rather than physically protest banks."
Not true. Graeber never said that at all. What happened was...
Occupy Wall Street: An interview with Kalle Lasn, the man behind it all
...
What David Graeber added to the mix (and to the historical process) was to propose the creation of a General Assembly.
Scroll down here for the name, David Graeber:
For more detail, look at actual historical accounts from reliable sources, or see David Graeber's own writings, such as his book The Democracy Project . But don't just make stuff up out of thin air. Thanks.
JohnRussell :
Your perspective is distorted, JR, by your conflation of a mass action (with many local solidarity actions all over the world) with the movement. Also, you conflate this action's brand name "occupy wall street" (OWS) with the movement. Therefore, your sense of its beginning and ending is askew. The movement lives on, though it appears to be largely dormant. But the movement will pop up again, like mushrooms after a good rain. It will have other names and brands. It will have similar, but different tactics.... In fact, it never went away! It's just not reported under that brand name, and the mainstream (corporate) media don't often report on this movement -- as they'd like not to have it spread any further, obviously.
Conflating "Occupy Wall Street" as "the movement" is a very popular mistake, but one without much historical merit upon a careful look at the history of the actual movement, which predates OWS and lives on.
JR - You are arguing for my point, but apparently you don't know it yet. You said "David Graeber says he was the founder of Occupy Wall St." ... and I said that's not a fact. And between you and me we have since established that it is not a fact, just as I said.
Graeber DID say that he and some his friends and co-activists did collaborate on shifting the energy dynamic of early OWS from a "vertical" to a "horizontal" structure by advocating for the creation of a General Assembly (which is a horizontal structure). It's all right there in his own words!
This is not historically accurate. You made this all up in your imagination. If you want to show otherwise, bring evidence. But I know there is no such evidence, as I've read the history (and Graeber) extensively. You are a VERY POOR historian.
If the facts don't much matter to you, as you just admitted, why go on misrepresenting them -- unless to propagandize with the use of misrepresented facts?
Actually, unlike the majority of your comments, this reference material is directly on point with the topic of the article.
It starts at the beginning of the feelings and actions of anarchy
A pseudo-intellectual like yourself should have been able to figure that out