╌>

Clerk sues Kentucky governor over gay marriage directive

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dowser  •  11 years ago  •  7 comments

Clerk sues Kentucky governor over gay marriage directive

Original AP article here.

685_discussions.jpg?width=400 ASHLAND, Ky. (AP) The Kentucky clerk who sued for refusing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples has filed a lawsuit against the governor, claiming he violated her religious freedom by telling all clerks that they must either issue licenses or resign.

On June 26, the day the U.S. Supreme Court ruled gay marriage bans unconstitutional, Gov. Steve Beshear directed the state's 120 county clerks to comply and begin issuing licenses to all couples.

Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis filed the federal lawsuit against Beshear on Tuesday, alleging that the directive violated her "sincerely held religious beliefs."

Davis and several other clerks refused to issue licenses; 17 sent signed letters of protest to Beshear's office. The governor maintained they must either adhere to the Supreme Court's ruling or step aside.

Four couples sued Davis last month after she denied them licenses.

The conservative law firm Liberty Counsel filed a third-party lawsuit on Davis' behalf, claiming that the governor should be liable for the couples' claims against her. She also asked the judge to force Beshear to find a way to accommodate her Christian conviction that limits marriage to a union between a man and a woman.

"In no uncertain terms, Governor Beshear's policies and directives are intended to suppress religion even worse, a particular religious belief," Davis' lawsuit alleges, adding, "In doing so, Governor Beshear is forcing clerks like Davis to choose between following the precepts of her religion and forfeiting her position, on one hand, and abandoning one of the precepts of her religion in order to keep her position, on the other hand."

Davis' lawsuit also names Wayne Onkst, commissioner of the Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives, as a defendant. His office is responsible for creating a template for marriage licenses, and updated the design to remove references to "bride" and "groom."

Both the governor and the library department declined to comment on Davis' suit.

Legal experts have said Davis' religious freedom arguments are unlikely to protect her from fulfilling her governmental duties as a public servant.

To me, the woman has a job to do, as a pubic servant. Not every law requires her definite seal of approval to be enforced. I don't think this lawsuit will fly very far, other than to register a protest. She needs to be suing the Supreme Court, not the governor...

Thanks for coming by!


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    11 years ago

I think that when you run for public office, such as County Clerk-- an elected position, you have the responsibility to uphold the law, whether you like it or not.

I doubt this goes very far...

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

One might seek to distinguish discrimination based on race (or gender) and discrimination based on sexual orientation on the ground that discrimination based on sexual orientation is sometimes based on sincere religious conviction while presumably that would not be the case for racial discrimination or gender discrimination. Professor Robin Wilson makes this argument in connection with public accommodations and gay marriage: The religious and moral convictions that motivate objectors to refuse to facilitate same-sex marriage simply cannot be marshaled to justify racial discrimination.[65] An examination of American history shows the proposed distinction is baseless. Slavery,[66] racial discrimination and segregation,[67] and opposition to womens rights[68] were all supported by strong religious arguments bolstered by citations to the Bible.[69] As scholarly work has shown, these religious views were deeply held by many people.[70] That Professor Wilson finds it impossible to marshal religious arguments for segregation is, to a great degree, a tribute to the success of the Civil Rights Movement and civil rights laws, generally without exemptions for religious objectors.

Not only could religious arguments for segregation be marshaled, they were marshaled. For example, Senator Robert Byrd of West Virginia cited the Bible in opposition to the Civil Rights Act of 1964.[71] Reverend Jerry Falwell attributed the Brown v. Board of Education desegregation decision to Chief Justice Warrens failure to know and follow Gods word; Falwell also preached against racial intermarriage.[72] Falwell and Byrd were not alone.

The trial judge who upheld Virginias anti-miscegenation statute in the 1967 case of Loving v. Virginia cited the fact that God had put the races on separate continents as proof that he did not intend for the races to mix.[73] Earlier, in 1867, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld segregation in railway cars.[74] The court explained that [t]he natural law which forbids [racial intermarriage] and that social amalgamation which leads to a corruption of races, is as clearly divine as that which imparted to [the races] different natures.[75] The Pennsylvania courts appeal to divine authority was used by state supreme courts in Indiana, Alabama, and Virginia to support the validity of statutes banning interracial marriages and by decisions in Alabama and Kentucky to support segregation of transportation and higher education.[76] The latest use of this language came in a 1955 Virginia decision.[77] [T]he theology of separate races constituted a kind of cultural religion that permeated the hearts and minds of attorneys and judges throughout the courts of the South for a hundred years after the Civil War.[78]

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    11 years ago

So, do you think this lawsuit will go very far?

I'm not sure that I understand what you mean... Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    11 years ago

Probably so! Though I don't know of specific instances!

My Grandma used to the say the bible in one man's hand is as dangerous as a gun, in another's.

Grin.gif

Oh, and by the way, KY never seceded. We contributed 80,000+ men to the north and only 22,000 to the south. I'm not sure I understand your links to slavery on this issue... Grin.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Follow the law or resign from public office

Sounds reasonable to me, that same principle could put a lot of folks in Washington out work Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Dowser    11 years ago

It sounds reasonable to me, too. I don't know what the KY governor can do about it.

 
 

Who is online



Freefaller


68 visitors