╌>

I call that... Civil War

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  malamuteman  •  13 years ago  •  48 comments

I call that... Civil War

This article is derived from a portion of a comment I left in another one of my articles...

I said the following in one of my articles nearly 4 years ago (and I have quoted it dozens, perhaps hundreds of times)...

We Americans are a very diverse people, and I believe our diversity is what makes us a strong nation. That is, even though I am a proud Liberal, I believe the conservative counter to my beliefs is a good thing for America. But it is ONLY good if we all recognize that none of us will get everything we want, if we look for ways to accommodate the needs and even the wants of the people who are most different from us, if we are not only willing but proactively seeking compromise; THEN diversity is good. On the other hand, if we are proactively seeking to divide, that is bad for America! It makes us weaker, less productive, and generally a less healthy nation.

Perhaps the central point of every controversial article I have ever written can be described as a PLEA for compromise and cooperation. Whether it is on the issue of guns and whether or not they should be regulated, or how we are taxed, how much we are taxed, and what those tax dollars are spent on, or climate change, or environmental and resource abuses, we are "polarized." I gotta tell ya... It looks to me like there are many people in this county who want it to be polarized. I call that... "civil war."


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
TinStl1
Freshman Silent
link   TinStl1    13 years ago

I call that... "civil war."

I have to agree, though it's not gotten to the trenches yet... but it's certainly in the halls of congress, on the airwavesand in many a living room...

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

TinSti,

...it's not gotten to the trenches yet...

And I surely hope it doesn't ever get to the trenches again!!! The war in the halls of Congress, the airwaves, and our living rooms still has a very detrimental effect on our nation. I wonder why people who refuse to compromise don't see that getting everything the way they would most like to have it, leaving half the nation to have none of what it wants, destroys the very thing that made this nation great and strong from its inception right through to the beginning of contemporary intransigence... cooperation.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

On the other hand, this "war" is far more "civil" than the last. Too many Americans are so completely certain that their point of view is the only correct one that we will never have compromise or cooperation. Diversity was the cornerstone of this Country! People flocked here seeking freedom. Our government (left AND right) have gone far beyond their authority in limiting our freedoms. It is time for that to end. Am i advocating rebellion? Yes - but not with guns. Lets do make this war "civil". Get your asses out there and encourage everybody to vote the bastards out - liberal and conservative. Make every politician pass a test on the meaning of the Constitution in order to even run for office. if they can't define "Liberty", if they can't define "Freedom" then they can't legislate it.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Boudicea,

I would have a hard time disagreeing with much (if anything) you have said in that comment... Still there are a few "code words" in your comment that make me think you and I may not share common views on some things. So... I am curious, and I hope you will kindly answer a probing question:

Do you think taxes used to to bring a minimal and reasonably decent quality of life to every citizen, especially citizens who have worked hard but nonetheless failed to achieve that decent quality of life, are an infringement of the "Liberty" and "Freedom" of citizens who HAVE, also through their own hard work, achieved a good quality of life???

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Well, MalamuteMan, that's a good question. Although I am a Libertarian, and believe that we should take care of ourselves and our families FIRST and foremost, I am not opposed to using tax dollars (in a limited amount) for the Deserving Poor. Yes, many people work hard and cannot make ends meet. It is the generational poor - those locked into "poverty" because they rely on government handouts for everything - which I oppose giving to.

Of course, that is also government's fault. When you are in a situation where your food, medical needs, shelter, day care, transportation, phone, etc are provided to you by Uncle Sam (and Uncle Sam wrote the rules so that you lose ALL benefits if you try to get out of your situation) it becomes easier to just say "Oh, what the hell" and stay right where you are. To those people I say "Have a little self-respect and get off your ass. Go to work"

Now is it infringement on the liberty and freedom of those who have achieved much? Of course it is - it is the textbook definition of "redistribution of wealth". Realistically, there's not much we can do to avoid the reality of the situation, though. Children shouldn't starve, or go without shelter or medical attention, which means we are forced to support their parents as well

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Thanks for the thoughtful reply Boudicea!

For the record, my once ill defined political ideology seems to be crystallizing into democratic socialism... that oft maligned "Euro Socialism."

I don't favor anything even remotely like the kind of wealth redistribution proposed Marx, I do find the highly taxed and highly government supported society of Denmark, Norway, and other European countries very appealing. I have enjoyed a great deal of success in my life, much of it coming from my entrepreneurial endeavors. Still I find it difficult to enjoy my success, knowing others have worked as hard or harder for their chance at success as I have, and yet have failed to realize it.

A pet peeve of mine is the way rhetoric is used to disguise one's real intentions or to mis-characterize the intentions of others. "Redistribution of wealth" is one of those terms that is a bit problematic for me... because that is very much a two way street... and there has indeed been a great deal of wealth redistribution in America over the last 3 or 4 decades... but it has been redistributing largely from the middle class to the very wealthy.

Another area where I suspect we probably have differing views is "regulation." I can't imagine how there could be a clearer example of why regulation is needed than the nearly catastrophic collapse of the American (and therefore world) economy brought on by capitalist abuses arising from insufficient regulation. I am not anti-capitalism... In fact I think capitalism can be a very good thing. But simple observation tells me that human nature cannot be trusted to self-regulate.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

we are more divided now than at any time since the war.

all according to plan

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

I agree JoAnne. I thing it is someones plan... I'm not completely sure whose plan, but I've got a few ideas. Who do you think is engineering this plan???

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

anyone that would benefit from non-enforcement of the rule of law.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

too bad the second amendment is only about hunting.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

JoAnne,

I don't know what to make of your comments... They are interesting, but so short as to be both provocative and difficult to understand. Maybe that is your intention, I don't know. I don't want to discourage you from participating, but I would sincerely appreciate it if you would provide a bit more information.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Care to offer any specific examples?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

The corporatists and the wealthy have the most to benefit from the non-enforcement of law. They are already at the top of the food chain if you want to draw a parallel.

I'm open to consider other ideas though.....

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Well, we probably do have differences of opinion on regulation. My biggest problem with regulation is that they are usually written in such h z manner that small businesses have a hard time complying due to financial considerations. Big business, though their bought and paid for politicians due side what the regulations are going to be. It ultimately serves to stifle competition. I believe that there should be way fewer regulations and severe, harsh consequences for undesirable outcomes. Regulations stifle creativity.. we need to concentrate less on how something is going to be accomplished and more on getting things accomplished.
P.s. I am enjoying dis us sing this with you

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

The corporatists and the wealthy have the most to benefit from the non-enforcement of law. They are already at the top of the food chain...

I agree sailor! And they have already benefited greatly...

I hope you don't mind me calling you sailor. I always try to address people as they want to be addressed, but while I think "Fly Navy" is a great idea, it doesn't sound like a person to me. At first I was going to try Navy Guy, but then I thought... for all I know you might be female. So I ended up trying "sailor." If you don't like that I apologize, and I'll go back to Fly Navy or whatever you most like.

You can call me Mal...

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

First of all, America is not a democracy, it is a Republic. And where or when did i say that "government" in general was not MY government? Yes, I did elect some of them and i assure you that I make my displeasure known when they act contrary to my beliefs.

 
 
 
TinStl1
Freshman Silent
link   TinStl1    13 years ago

I agree sailor! And they have already benefited greatly...

they should they own the lawmakers....

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

I believe that there should be way fewer regulations and severe, harsh consequences for undesirable outcomes.

I thought regulations is what gives definition to what acceptable behavior is and what the consequences for bad behavior would be. Also, there are some kinds of bad behavior that are so bad that applying a penalty after the fact brings about a heck of a lot of suffering for many people that is not mitigated by the penalty.

I think creativity is a very good thing. But without some regulation corporations can get a little bit too creative. With the removal of GlassSteagall the banks "created" some untenable credit default swap abominations... and the KNEW there were bad... requiring average people to come to the rescue just to prevent a total catastrophe. I agree that the absence of harsh penalties was a rather grotesque flaw in the way that was handled. But I prefer to "stifle" that sort of "creativity" before it ever gets started. Reiterating what I said, simple observation demonstrates that most people will not restrain themselves just because it might be bad for others. If they see an opportunity that can be exploited for their advantage, they will take it... and then they will justify their actions by saying people who were too stupid to see the folly of the scheme deserve to pain of falling victim to the scheme.

I don't mean to denigrate your ideology Boudicea, and I have no idea how you developed you ideas, but many Libertarians idolize Ayn Rand. I find many of the things she proposed absolutely flabbergasting. I listened to an interview of Ayn Rand by Mike Wallace (on YouTube) in which she said several things that left me shaking my head... among them...

"Weakness does not deserve love."

That was another way of expressing her notion that altruism is amoral. That is about as antithetical to the the kind of world that appeals to me as it is possible to be. I realize the premise of this article is yet another of my pleas for compromise... but I wonder what would be even half way between what she wanted and what I want.

I am enjoying dis us sing this with you

Me too!

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

they should they own the lawmakers...

Huh??? I don't understand...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

too bad the second amendment is only about hunting.

Please explain your one-liners; are they forms of innuendo or what exactly?

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Oh never mind... I figured it out... Mal is slow...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I think is a very good thing that our differences are not so much aligned with geographical borders. Being from KY, and my family has lived here since 1812, it isn't any kind of a picnic for a state to be at war with itself.

During the last Civil War, KY was a border state-- we supplied 80,000 troops to the north, and 11,000 troops to the south. Yet, we were 'reconstructed', and have never been able to pull out of the resulting economic slump. Many reasons why, but it seemed to be a death blow to the economics of the state. After reconstruction, we had more supporters for the south than before the war. Why? We were treated as traitors, when we, too, fought and died for the Union. Sigh!

At the Battle for Atlanta, both Generals Hood, were brothers from KY, fighting against one another. And that was typical of the times.

Based on my knowledge of what happened here in KY, I only pray that all of us can come together to compromise and work together for a more perfect union of our people.

Perhaps I should publish my Civil war journals here-- the stories of some of the women in my family. Which side they were on, what they saw, and what they suffered. Maybe, if we could put it in the context of today's times, we could all be more willing to compromise.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Hi Dowser,

Maybe, if we could put it in the context of today's times, we could all be more willing to compromise.

As I said in the article, I think there are people in this country who want polarization... That was made evident by President Obama's efforts to find compromise on various issues... It was an unattainable goal... He would go out with a proposal that had been put forward by Republicans, and they would reject their own proposal. What could possibly make it more clear that polarization was their goal.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I think you're right.

The "my way or the highway" attitude is NOT conducive to fair and equal governing, compromise, and plain old just getting along with one another.

Great article, Mal! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I pray that I never have to. Please God.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Didn't you get the memo? Spin it however you like, America is a Republic specifically to protect the rights of minorities. Also, you might live in your own little world where anyone who disagrees with you is a fan of the Koch's, but that does not make it true. Sorry, but I am not a republican. hate to burst your bubble. Try some new rhetoric. Lol

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Well just let me say I spent 16 years in the mortgage business and it was NOT the credit swaps that created the problem, it was the abuse of them that was the problem. But I am talking about different kinds of regulations. For example, why are there regulations on how many toys a day care center must have on hand per child? Why are there 700000 pages of regulations on how an oil tank can be installed at a gas station. It makes far more sense to say install the tank however u want but be prepared to go to jail if they leak.
As for Rand, she was more of an idealist where I am more of a pragmatist. There are certain things that need some regulation but we have gone overboard simply because congress needs something to do.
And if you want to talk about exploitation, who is more guilty of that than politicians?
Now it is important to distinguish between the pure libertarian philosophy and the far more realistic libertarian party platform. that's is huge.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Oh, that is a real adult comment

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Bob, I didn't like you over there and I don't like you here. In the future, when you respond to my intelligent conversation to someone else I am simply going to ignore you. Understood?

flameaway some people don't understand exaggeration. Some people don't understand that THE VAST MAJORITY to day care centers are privately owned and privately funded. Some people just want to insult. Reminds me of why I hated NV

 
 
 
Dee Kay
Freshman Silent
link   Dee Kay    13 years ago

I think you pretty well summed up what is happening in this country today flameaway.

Until the average citizen realizes that it truly is an us vs them mentality employed by the elites, whether that is in the financial industry, government, media, etc., we will continue to focus on our differences instead of our common interests and common goals. Those in power know what buttons to push to keep people at each others throats. Instead of focusing the blame on those very elite who are destroying our country and our environment, we fight amongst ourselves over a lot of petty issues and a few larger ones.

Fear and hate are two of the most powerful forces to keep the citizens riled up. People need to start thinking with their heads, not their emotions. It is time for every citizen to be responsible for doing their share to make this a better country for all by voting out any politician who continually stokes the fears and hatred.

If our politicians are on the wrong side of issues that benefit the citizen over special interests, they need to be voted out. We can only take care of those politicians who represent us, and hope that others will do the same for their own politician. We can turn this country back to doing what is in the best interests of the citizens but it won't be quick or easy.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I do understand your point, Mal. But I have to ask, without intending to inflame......

how do you compromise if you find the other side of the argument to be 180 degrees out of what you think is proper?

I'll use one you and I have, to the best of my knowledge, never bumped heads about- abortion. If a person considers abortion to be murder, how can they compromise with someone who calls a fetus "Not yet human"? I happen to be in the middle somewhere. Is it "civil war" to defend what you consider to be a human baby from what you consider to be murder? I know I couldn't walk away fromsomeone having an abortionif that were my belief. For me, compromise on what to have for dinner, or what movie to see, or even whther to legalize pot or not is easy. But certain core beliefs cannot be compromised if I want to look in the mirror in the morning and like who I see. Am I making sense to you?

 
 
 
AverageAmericanWorkingGirl
Freshman Silent
link   AverageAmericanWorkingGirl    13 years ago
 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Fly works too. Hell, I'll answer to "hey you." and a host of other hings as well. Make it anyway you want! The important thing is the conversation.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

a carpet bagger, by any name is still pondscum

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

"Perhaps the central point of every controversial article I have ever written can be described as a PLEA for compromise and cooperation."

Perhaps that is the problem. We should be showing the positives of being in the middle and not fighting to defend our position to those of polar ideas. Letting them speak negative and destroy themselves within.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    13 years ago

You have a good point Neale. Abortion is a particularly tough issue. One place that people on opposite sides of that topic could possibly find some common ground is by joining forces to do everything possible to minimize the need for abortion. Sex education, contraception, etc. Another place for common ground would be to provide extra financial support to a child born to a mother who might not want to have a child on the grounds that she could not afford to give it a decent start in life. Interestingly, many of the people who oppose abortion also oppose contraception and sex education... and many abortion opponents are also opposed to providing support to poor children. Go figure.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Now, here we can agree somewhat.Grin.gif

I firmly believe in sex education- just not in public education! (LOL). I do not believe that teaching children about sex makes them want to run out and have sex. I have 3 boys, all home schooled. We have taught sex-ed to each as they hit 10 years old (my daughter is 8, so she has a couple years to wait).We take each child to visit the NICU, because they were too young (except for the oldest) to see their sister in it. We take them to the WIC office to see the kinds of crap people have to go through to support their child when they are dumb enough to get pregnant or to impregnate at a young age. We have taught them about contraception, and that no matter how good it is, there is only one type that is 100% effective- abstinence.

I'm against abortion because I'm an atheist. I don't believe in GOD or souls. So when that tissue mass some refer to as a fetus and others refer to as an unborn child is aborteed, that is it. There is no trip to Heaven for the little soul to bask in the light of a fairy tale. There is no re-shuffle to the next available tissue mass. So for me, it take extraordinary efforts to avoid that necessity. One of my good friends considers it the woman's right to evict an unwanted tenant, but wants to see abortion cheap and easy, and so rarely needed because all children are wanted. Me, until we have artificial wombs that an unwanted fetus can be moved to if another wants it, I cannot, in good conscience, advocate that a woman raped, or the victim of an incest pregnancy carry that baby for 9 months. The mental horror would be immense (though many women over the centuries have done so, and even today do so, without obvious damage, the choice MUST be Hers). To save the woman's life is a no-brainer. Save the life we know, and sadly sacrifice the one we don't. My wife had to make that choice, and risked her own life (against my wishes) to give our daughter the 4 more weeks developement she needed to survive outside the womb. She was born at 24 weeks. So I've been on both sides of some of this argument.

But I also know people to whom abortion is murder, plain and simple, with no way to justify it. I wish they could learn to teach contraception to their kids, but that is a sin to them, too. How can we ask them to compromise that? I don't know how. I can give them my view, and I have. But where is there room for them to compromise on it, if by compromising, they must, to them, advocate murder AND lose their immortal soul? And there are other issues where it is ME who cannot compromise.

Compromise is a great word. It keeps marriages together ( or tears them apart when it doesn't happen). It makes the world go 'round in so many ways. But as I have said before, there are times when it is a word most foul. And when that is the case, sadly, it CAN lead to that civil war you reference in the article.

Well, I've rambled enough tonight. Later, my friend.

 
 

Who is online






112 visitors