Chuck Hagel for Secretary of Defense
Really?
Why?
I watched the committee confirmation hearing held by the Senate and I could not for the life of me discern any outstanding abilities, qualities or potential that Mr Hagel possessed for the position of Secretary of Defense.
That being said, does it matter or should he be confirmed simply because he is the person that the President wants for the job?
In my view, he should not be confirmed unless he is the best qualified person for the job or can at least demonstrate that he is minimally qualified.
During the hearings, Mr Hagel on multiple occasion had to correct something he had said because his aides informed him that h had misspoke either about his position on a subject or the administration's position on an issue.
At once point, Senator Levin (committee chairman) actually told Mr Hagel what he (Mr Hagel) should have sad about the government's position on containment in Iran.
He totally lacks the professional poise and persona of Sec Clinton, Sec Panetta, Sec Gates, Sec Kerry for cripes sake of any cabinet member in recent memory.
So should he be confirmed simply because he was nominated or do we want a little more in our Cabinet Secretaries?
Tags
Who is online
131 visitors

As we enter a period of historic change in the Department of Defense, is Mr Hagel really the best that the U.S. can do for Secretary of Defense?
I think of people like Admiral Mullen and members of Secretary Panetta's staff that have been mentioned and wonder, is there no one else?
IN the confirmation hearings, Mr Hagel was unsure of his positions, the president's positions and at times seemed unable to answer direct questions.
Is this the right man to negotiate with and work with Congress in the reformation of the nation's military forces?
E I
No argument from me that the pool of qualified candidates is likely very limited, but it seems there must be a pool
Other than Adm Mullen no one leaps immediately to mind I will ponder) but As I watched the entire confirmation hearing (had the flu and was in bed),I could not fathom why anyone would follow Mr Hagel even out of idle curiosity to see where he was going.
And now is the time for real leadership in the DoD and the time for a person that can work with the Congress (where Mr Hagel seems to have limited respect) and our allies as we transform the look of U.S. military presence around the world.
John
So you think the founders included the "advice and consent"power of the Senate simply to annoy future presidents?
And second question
Perhaps not the best qualified then, but at lest someone who knows without prompting what his positions and the positions of the president are on issues affecting the department he has been nominated to head.
John
Only if he is confirmed
In my view, someone with more qualifications than being able to say Yes Sir to Pres Obama is needed at the DoD at this point in time
There are those who think Mr Hagel would not be the best representative of the country as Secy of Defense and to my those peoples' opinions matter and this is not a trivial matter. The Congress must be able to work with the secretary and many of them do not think this is possible.
He may get the 6o votes, but if he does it is a significant downgrade in the position from the past couple secretaries.
I think Dick Cheney would disagree with that observation. While SOD under Bush 1, he created the "Army for hire" paradigm outsourcing DOD jobs to private industry. In between administrations, he became wealthy running a company that took advantage of the outsourcing. As VP - well we all know where that got us....
Lets not forget the line of sucesssion. It is a consideration. The SOD is pretty high up on the list. Can you ever envision Mr Hagel as President?
At what price to the nation?
A failure in military readiness, national security or national defense at this point in history could be catastrophic
The budget?
John
I know a lot of people with MBA's and Doctorates that I would not follow across the street because they do not have sense enough to watch for traffic
Education and do nothing board memberships do not prepare people for service at the highest level of government
Well it is not the end of it and I hope he is not confirmed
E I
It is indeed
ARTieA
Absolutely not!
John
I could not imagine her as mayor of Wasila much less as President and am glad that she seems to be fading from the national view
That's not true, if you are speaking cabinet appointments.
...
Hmmmm, what's good for the goose ....
Even if you mean just the Sec Def, again, not true. Think John Tower.
...
Funny, seems the truth is tough nowadays.