The Answer is More Guns ... ???
Special credit to Angry White Man for inspiring me to write this article.
People of all persuasions have had much to say about the tragedy in Connecticut, but there is one suggestion I find utterly ludicrous. In short that is
If more citizens were armed then perpetrators of these crimes could be stopped by average citizens.
This is not the first time following a mass shooting I have heard the Wild West suggestion, and sadly I suspect it will not be the last. Its sad because there are likely to be more mass murders, and sad because many gun advocates refuse to consider anything aiming to limit inappropriate use of guns. They tell us the founding fathers gave us the Second Amendment to protect us from a potentially tyrannical government, and any limitation will lead directly to tyranny. I ask Did the founding fathers intend for elementary school teachers to be armed with lethal weapons to defend their students? Did the founding fathers want a reenactment of the shootout at the OK corral in a dark movie theater or a crowded mall? Would the founding fathers have crafted the Second Amendment differently if semi-automatic assault rifles and easily concealed handguns were common weapons of their time instead of mussel loading muskets?
Someone offered this rhetorical question
Load a pistol and lay it on a table, then tell me how many people it kills?
Then the same person suggested we consider the case of the knife-wielding man who injured 22 children and one adult outside a primary school in central China implying that limiting guns wouldnt stop crazy people from doing crazy things. Heres how I answered his question
When a crazy guy picks the loaded gun up off that table 20 innocent children and 7 adults are slaughtered... when a crazy guy picks the knife up from that table people are injured .
Both incidents are bad... and both are attributable to crazy people... but one incident is much worse than the other. I am all for making every possible effort to cure mental illness, but there is no way we will ever eradicate it. I want to make myself very clear...
I am not advocating that we "eradicate" guns!!!
I only ask that we look at all sides of this problem. Do what we can to minimize mental health problems in our society. Steer our society way from violence as a solution to problems. Make guns available to responsible people, but at the same time do everything possible to keep guns out of the hands of unstable and irresponsible people.
A while back I wrote an article titled "Too bad...", the main point of the article was...
Too bad we wait to make changes until the pain of not changing is worse than the pain of changing.
So now I ask
Is the slaughter of 20 innocent children and 7 adults, the horror for their families, the trauma for many dozens of other children and their families... is that enough pain to inspire us to change???
More guns is not the answer!!!

More guns is not the answer!!! But I thing that it would be good to... Steer our society way from violence as a solution to problems.
I prefer a world that promotes and strives for nonviolence.
In light of Wayne LaPierre's comments at his big news conference on Friday, and his doubling down on Meet The Press on Sunday... I just thought I would give this article another run...
Quoting my article...
You're not alone Angry White Guy...
I think you're right Neetu! At the very least, it would be different and more clearly define. The NRA... or as I like to call them... NARPA... The National Assault Rifle Profiteering Association... wants to define it so as to maximize their profits.
No matter how we choose to describe the Bushmaster AR-15 and the other weapons he had available, they can certainly be accurately described as a weapon that can be effectively used to slaughter people... including innocent people... innocent children!
Whether the Bushmaster was in the car or not (I heard that early on, but later heard that it was used), he used something that was able to put 3 to 4 rounds into each of 26 people in a matter of a few minutes. Neetu's point is that instruments of this kind...
You may argue that the Second Amendment was given to American citizens so that they COULD wage war on the government if it became too oppressive.
Most Americans are unhappy with our government is some way or other. Only a very few Americans feel they need to arm themselves for the purpose of waging war.
I have said this many many times, and I am going to keep saying it until it is no longer true...
America is PRESENTLY in the midst of an ideological civil war.
I sincerely hope it does not escalates...
I much prefer compromise, cooperation, and reason, to war.
Bruce,
I didn't say that I "support giving up our Second Amendment right." I would appreciate it if you would refrain from putting words in my mouth. In fact, I put a fair amount of thought in to writing my comment, and I think it would be nice, if you want to reply, if you would reply specifically to things I actually did say.
Thanks for making yourself clear.
The founding fathers had very good cause to give us the Second Amendment. They had just finished fighting a war against a government they felt was unfairly oppressive... and they would have had no chance in that war without weapons that were equal to the weapons of the government they were fighting. Many things have change in the 240 years or so since they gave us the Second Amendment right. No one can say what the founding fathers would have done if they knew about present day society or weapon technology. But here is how I feel about it...
Or for that matter, to wage war on our government.
I suspect you feel differently, Bruce.
Do you feel you need to carry a gun for self-protection???
If so, I am sorry you feel so threatened.
Even more importantly, do you feel you need to be armed for the purpose of fighting our government???
If so, I'd say you really are an "Angry Guy." Persistent anger is not a good thing.
Robert,
Any thoughts about doing something to make people in our society less inclined to choose "shooting" as the solution to their problems???
If more guns equals a safer America, how come, with 50% of the world's guns already in America ...
WE'RE NOT SAFE?
But look ... I'm open minded ... if some armed teachers had been protecting those firefighters ...
Just sayin' ...
Anyway ... when Republicans take us over the fiscal cliff and Republican Governors refuse to implement Obamacare cutting THE MENTAL HEALTH COMPONENTS ...
We'll be safer ...
Right (wing)?
Hmmm... You don't think...
has any bearing on this tragedy... or that it might not serve to mitigate this problem???
Well DUH, Mal!!!! Of course Robert doesn't think that. His solution to this senseless violence is... more violence... or like the title of the article says... "The Answer is More Guns..."
Did you know that that United States Air Force has planes ...
... with guns and ...
... bombs?
Drones anyone?
How 'bout we get real ... in 1780 your militia might have a chance ...
Not today.
The geography and geology prevent bombing Afghan into the stone age even though it's still mostly there ... fighting a conventional ground war in Afghanistan is also insanity. But most of all ... the two super powers ... the U.S. and the Soviets, had they combined rather than pursued their interests separately, could have defeated the various insurgencies.
If the government has a huge military ... that's what I'm saying.
You tell me why we need the 2nd Amendment ... in 2012 you don't need it to Constitutionally or otherwise do ... the impossible; you have the right to bear arms ... I have no problem with that ... no problem with the militia either, but if you believe those rights make you a viable opposition to the United States of America, you're psychotic.
Got any tanks, drones, carpet bombs?
Bruce,
I see nothing in what I said that suggests I am assuming that.
Actually, I made the reference to "Angry Guy" because I thought your previous blog handle was "AngryWhiteMan." If that is not correct, that is my bad... and if so, I hope you will forgive me.
I too am disappointed in our current government, but I suspect disappointed for different reasons than you... and that difference between your disappointment and my disappointment really is the crux of the issue from my perspective. That's because we are both Americans, and if we do happen to want (for the sake of discussion) diametrically different things, then the conflict (and as such, the problem) is with us, not the government. As American citizens, I feel it is incumbent upon us to find ways to cooperate, compromise, and just plain old get along with fellow Americans who want different things than we each personally want. Even though there are some people who have declared "ideological" war on the government, the ideological civil war of which I speak is between us citizens... between me and the people who think of me as "the enemy."
Perhaps you feel what I have said in this article is an assault on your values.
Perhaps you feel...
Personally, I feel that idea is 180 degrees off. If both those things are true, then how do we resolve that conflict??? Will we each resolve to cooperate and seek compromise with other Americans who want something wildly different than what we personally want... or will we declare those other Americans to be "the enemy"???
Do you honestly think they wouldn't if they believed they stood between a Waco gang or a McVeigh or Ruby Ridge or Skinhead insurgency?
What do you consider tyranny ... really ... describe exactly what you think would be seen as tyranny by the overwhelming majority of Americans.
Mike,
No matter who "wins" such a war... What is to become of the people, currently American citizens, who are on the "losing" side??????? As I said in a comment to Bruce, I feel this is a conflict between the citizens of this country, not between the citizens and the government. The insurrection I fear is from people who view government implementation of the will of the American majority as tyranny.
How about if a student becomes "the shooter" seconds after he breaks the glass ... angry parent glass breaker maybe ...
It wouldn't have to be ... I was just citing what it has been up until now.
"The past is prologue."
...if you are serious about reducing multiple murders in a school, you have to admit that armed opposition would have been, and is, the only fix.
Sorry, Robert... That isn't my view... and I hardly find the present risk acceptable!
Mike,
First Mike, I am not anti-gun... I am pro-peace.
If we pursue only "protection" then it seems we have given up all prospect of living in a world that is predominantly peaceful where protection is less of a concern.
I pretty much agree with most of that, Mike... Regarding this...
Why would I expect anything else...
[Mal trudges off into the night... with a kick me sign stuck on his tail...]
What ... that Egyptian god statue ? How could you let that get away Mouse ?
Reduce the number of assault weapons and high capacity magazines and you reduce the potential number of citizens/individuals (normal and otherwise) who will possess them and use them (for whatever purpose).
It is not reasonable to compare the propriety and praise of law enforcement personnel with AR weaponry to that of the public-at-large, 40% of which attain weapons without background checks.
No one believes that all assault weapons and high capacity clips can or will be taken out of the hands of non-law enforcement individuals ... but because we can't get ALL isn't a reason not to try and get as many as possible.
That's like "thinking" since we can't cure all disease, we shouldn't try to cure any.
Jason, you have said that the military would defect in an insurgency, I say that it will be the same as it was in the Civil War, some would defect, but, for the most part the military would stay intact, which would mean that the insurgents would find themselves in the same situation that the South found itself in in 1860 through 1865, facing the full might of the United States military, and today it is one heck of a lot stronger than it was then.
In the real world, there will eternally be aftermath situations; my objective is to reduce the potential number of those aftermath situations by reducing the number of assault weapons and high capacity clips ... 31 rounds - 21 rounds = 10 potential aftermath victims vs. 31.
Armed security personnel in schools is not a new concept and even though you derided my earlier comments about how those personnel have been laid off because of the actions of same Republican legislators who haven't had the balls to join the post-Newtown conversation, those NRA-pimp legislators ... it is nevertheless the reality.
Compare a country with 300 million guns to a MINEFIELD; as the number of landmines are removed, the number of victims of landmines becomes both potentially and actually fewer.
Aftermaths occur because conditions are ripe for aftermaths. Trained Security personnel in schools and fewer assault weapons, etc., makes a lot more sense than more of one but the same number of the other.
The real world is almost never "either/or." The combination of the two is more potentially effective than either one or the other alone.
The layoff of security personnel at the hands of those who also are under the thumb of the NRA is no red herring ... it's a disgusting irony.
I'm going to say it again ... please stop talking down to me ... you don't hold the high ground on recognition. Make your case and let the readers decide what's relevant or not.
Again ... only the NRA plays that "liberals want to take away all guns."
I wrote in quite plain, clear language ...
For you to misrepresent my position and make it appear as if I said or believed that ALL assault weapons, etc., could be eliminated ... is disingenuous ... every life saved (or potentially so), every tragedy made however much less probable ... is worth the effort.
So, are you suggesting that I am the lone liberal who does not advocate removing all guns? The NRA propaganda has been pushing endlessly, the myth that liberals and Obama want to take away everyone's guns ... you misrepresent me again by implying that I tried to represent the position of all liberals. And you more-or-less misrepresent as does the NRA, how the majority of, or, how ALL liberals feel regarding "gun control."
A Frank Luntz poll of NRA MEMBERS (not of LaPierre the paid gun manufacturer pimp) revealed that 74% of those members want background checks on all gun sales ... and more.
Or maybe you should realize that "contrasting" positions represent a ... you know ... a contrast.
So which is it, Mike? You said I don't represent all liberals ... and I said I never implied that I did. Can't you take "yes" for an answer? There is a range of opinion.
You are still stuck in the NRA propaganda ... who says "gun control" equals the total elimination of guns? There is no "the left." Wayne LaPierre foists that pile of bullshit to frighten the gullible into running out to buy more guns because "THE BAN IS COMING!"
A ban on assault weapons (to the extent it's enforceable), a ban on high capacity clips and background checks altogether is what "gun control" means to reasonable Americans.
Again ... stop misrepresenting the realities; it is unrealistic to think ALL guns can be banned, confiscated, etc. and realistic people know that.
If we can't discuss what I actually state ... we have nothing to discuss. I'm not Bob, Bob isn't me.
Reality isn't an either/or proposition.
Sounds scary until you see the particulars ...
One can never predict with certainty who will feel about what.
The objective is not to make private gun ownership impossible, rather to make it potentially less dangerous for innocent would-be victims.
In an ideal world, nothing is registered ...
... an no one is murdered.
Nothing in the legislation advocates repealing the 4th Amendment. Does anyone come to your house to check your car registration, property deed, bank statements ... you get the idea ... that these and other entities are registered does not mean illegal search and seizures will follow.
That's the NRA-generated paranoia/propaganda ...
If someone stole you car ... or guns ... you might want to be able to recover them through your PROOF OF OWNERSHIP, their REGISTRATION.
We're not fingerprinting everybody ... nor is that being advocated. More NRA-style hyperbole.
At the moment, it requires more ID to by allergy medication than a gun.
That's insanity.
It was not about showing ID; it was about requiring people who had, in some cases, voted for decades at the same polling place, who had long ago and for many years verified their identification ... suddenly being required to obtain a photo ID, that by jumping through a series of hoops which were, by design, intentionally difficult to jump through.
Am I a liar then, Bruce?
The gun show loophole is real ... 74% of NRA members acknowledge that ...
By removing as many of the current assault weapons and high capacity clips from where criminals can access them, and, preventing as many additional ones from becoming accessible, we don't eliminate either every gun or every criminal ... that's just common sense ... but we make some sort of a dent. We do something rather than trying to do nothing at all.
The NRA pushes this crazy notion that "since we can't eliminate all, we may as well not bother trying to eliminate any."
And tragically, some folks buy that kind of false assumption.
We can't cure all disease either ... so, should we not bother to treat any?
Jason,
If you read my comment, I did not state nor imply that a ban would TOTALLY PREVENT criminals and others from getting assault weapons somewhere else. I said that it reduce all of those somewhere else's ... fewer weapons ... not a complete absence of weapons.
I reiterate ...
I have no illusion of even near-perfection ... just fewer assault weapons.
Mike, that just isn't the way it goes; you do not have the right to sell controlled substances or anything else the sale of which is regulated by law unless you do it in compliance with the law. You may do it in violation of the law but it's not a right.
Gun shows are the place to go to EASILY PURCHASE GUNS WITHOUT FIRST PASSING A BACKGROUND CHECK; it's easier and safer than dealing with some dude on the street, in a crack house or from a gang. But it's still a loophole.
That's true as long as the business being conducted doesn't violate any laws. The law is the law ... some laws are easier to break without being discovered ... it doesn't mean that it's not illegal.
I have no illusion of a perfect world, nor do I delude myself into believing that because some people commit crimes without consequences, that we'd somehow be better off without laws.
I don't own, nor have I ever owned firearms of any kind.
I have close friends who hunt and shoot ... even have police officer friends with whom I've gone target shooting; I'm more accurate than a couple of them ironically. But I'll never own a firearm ... legally or otherwise.
And I can cast a dryfly 50 feet into a stiff breeze and drop it 3 feet upstream from where a Rainbow rises ...
Enjoy your guns, Mike; guys like you and Bruce and Jason are not the problem ... but accidents and rage can be unpredictable ... and I have never heard of someone lifting a fly rod in anger and killing another person.
I can live with that.
A child being shot to death by an unregistered shooter is more absurd.
My objective is to reduce the probabilities ... AGAIN ... I have no illusions of even near-perfection ... just a few less dead people.
A tank's armor defends against projectiles. It is no defense against fire. Molotov cocktails will do a tank in in a hurry. The fire extinguishers in a tank are a one-shot deal and they only work inside the tank. If the fire is burning outside, the engine draws the flames right back in.
Any kind of aircraft has to have a safe place to land.
There is not an infinite supply of fuel and supplies on military bases. It has to get there by truck or train. Somebody has to produce that fuel and supplies.
You can't wage war on the very people you depend on to keep you fighting.
Arm the school employees. Only the ones that volunteer. If Dawn Hochsprung had come out of her office with a pistol, the whole thing might have never happened. If she'd gotten off one shot, even if she missed, it might have been enough to cause Adam Lanza to turn and run.
These mass murders seek out places where they can do their killing totally unopposed. Somebody shooting back messes up their game plan. Lanza killed himself when the cops started showing up. He had no intention of dealing with someone who could firght back.
An opinion on gun control - Part 1
There was *one* armed guard at Columbine, for a campus big enough to hold 2000 students and staff. It was also lunch time, and he was in his patrol car, eating his lunch.
In effect, there was *no* armed guard inside Columbine.
Community Resource Officer Called to Back Lot
The other teachers, alerted to the noise, lock their doors, call 911, and then defend the children in their classroom, until help arrives.
These mass murderers do not want armed opposition. Bullets flying in their direction ruins their plan. Even if the defenders don't accomplish anything but to act as "speed bumps", they still slow the shooter down, maybe enough for help to arrive.
It may be too late for that. There's people being pushed off subway platforms, and robberies beingcommitted using gasoline. We may have already gone past the point where passivity only ensures disaster.
Compliance has always been a reality ... unfortunately, human nature cannot be trusted to act with integrity or live by the Golden Rule. Law enforcement comes along with law for the same reason.
Do I need to explain why vehicle operators need to be insured?
Now, if you want to talk about real government abuse of power ... I'm with you. Yesterday ...
The solution is to address the root causes of violence in our country and do the hard, expensvie work to rectify the sit rep.
This should not even be a 2nd Amendment debate. The fact that it is only illustrates the naive, short sighted nature of our general national debates. We are about as collectively aware as a bucket of cat fish....
Sure it is.
I hoard guns to protect my family from Republicans and Teabaggers.
Hmmmm ... when you put it in those terms, that Wayne La Pierre thing about "the only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is with a good guy with a gun "
Seems utilitarian to a degree.
Who'd a thunk it?