Whoa! Romney Was Right!
The state of Michigan is the most recent to impose "Right-to-Work" law.
An intentionally deceptive euphemism, a "Right-to-Work" law enables individuals to work for an employer without requisite membership in a union that negotiates their salaries, working conditions and benefits. Under this law, such workers are neither obligated to join a union, nor, to pay union dues. And Right-to-Work law also kills what is known as "agency shop," under which employers deduct a fee from the wages of non-union workers to ensure that such non-union workers, who benefit from the unions bargaining efforts, make a contribution towards those efforts.
Republicans in bed with corporations hate both the idea and existence of unions, collective bargaining and agency shop in other words, virtually anything that helps the middle class and working poor improve the quality of their lives and those of their families! And why? Two words POWER and MONEY -- which are interchangeable.
There are at east two great ironies in the "Right-to-Work" scenario; first, "Right-to-Work" is predicated on that human-type known colloquially as the "freeloader," who, by definition is a person who takes advantage of others' generosity without giving anything in return. Irony number one; in what has been called the 2012 "comment of the year," candidate Mitt Romney (on May 17, 2012),in essence said that 47% of Americans would never take personal responsibility and care for their lives.
The irony? It's the freeloaders who happily and without reservation make the anti-union "Right-to-Work" strategy work! They help fulfill the Republican/Corporate Welfare Recipient-objective of destroying organized labor by de facto bankrupting it!
Irony number two ... the freeloaders not only help erode or destroy the viability of the services they mooch, they ultimately LOSE MORE THAN WHAT THEY SAVE IN UNION DUES PAYMENTS BECAUSE THEIR SALARIES, BENEFITS (and working conditions) ERODE MORE with the demise of the union ... A DEMISE THEY CAUSE! If a $40,000/year worker pays 1% of his salary in union dues, it costs him roughly $400/year. If the agency shop fee is say, half of that, the savings to the employee is about $200/year. Saving $200 a year while likely losing thousands in salary and benefits is less-than-intelligent and "less-than-intelligent" is what "Right-to-Work" proponents count on.
In the fact-based world where common sense prevails, what reasonable human being believes in the notion of the proverbial "free lunch"? What reasonable person would either work gratis or, expect anyone who provides him with goods or services to work without compensation? None that I know.
A month or more ago, I thought Mitt Romney didn't have a clue about the "average Joe." Turns out, he seems to be correct roughly 47% of the time.
Dang You think you know someone

Sometimes, someone else's bottom line ...
Is extracted from YOUR bottom.
Serves ya' right if you enable it.
I'll respond if we're going to have an actual discussion. I'll begin ...
Let's start by not making straw men ... I did not and have not called unions "noble." As a (retired) union official, I'll be the first to tell you "unions are not, nor were they ever intended to be 'noble'."
Unions formed because laborers were exploited mercilessly by managements ... that included children, women, etc., dangerous, unhealthy working conditions, sexual harassment with no recourse ...
Union membership has declined over the last thirty years because of right-to-work laws and job exportation to cheap-labor countries where workers are paid pennies on the dollar and, where, in some places, workers are locked in, nets are placed around buildings because of the suicides ...
As union membership has declined in the U.S. ALL MIDDLE INCOME WAGES, UNION AND NON-UNION HAVE DECLINE PROPORTIONATELY ... except for CEO wages which have increased by 300-400% ...
[[Unions formed because laborers were exploited mercilessly by managements ]]
That is accurate but it has no bearing on what is happening now . They got greedy demanding an ever increasing % of corporate income . The result was union companies went into decline . If you can look you will see many examples of that . GM and Hostess come immediately to mind .
[[Union membership has declined over the last thirty years because of right-to-work laws and job exportation to cheap-labor countries where workers are paid pennies on the dollar and, where, in some places, workers are locked in, nets are placed around buildings because of the suicides ...]]
Yup , and those are the countries which need unions NOW .
As to that graph it only shows that there are other factors influencing US manufacturing .
The one thing that I'm convinced of is that "Right to Work" states are only right to get paid the minimum wage and right to get fired states.
Hi A., how are you doing today?
Doin' all right; happy to see you.
Sorry, what destroyed the industry was the failure of managements to manufacture automobiles that the public wanted ... gas guzzlers instead of fuel efficient cars; that opened the way for the Japanese manufacturers like Honda and Toyota.
One of your sources ... Michigan Economic Development Corporation ... a corporation ... pro business/anti-union.
Your other source ... Professor Mark J. Perry's Blog for Economics and Finance ... held a joint appointment as a scholar at The American Enterprise Institute .
Neocon shills with conflict-of-interests issues.
Would you trade several thousand dollars in order to save $200? Some freeloader types stupidly would; please re-read the article if you already have, and, of course, if you have not ... this would be a good time.
Those who think that "Right to work" is a good thing need to take a look at the states that have had this law for a few years like North Carolina and Florida, right to work is the same as telling someone they have a right to get fired or to work for lower wages, to work for no benefits, to work ungodly hours. When I was working food service I was listed as the head cook, Chef, and a few other titles, the fact is during this time I had the right to work what ever hours the employer wanted me to work, normally I worked 16 hour days six days a week, and during special events like the Wellcraft Boat Show I had to work 72 hours straight before I got a break and then I was "requested" to stay at the hotel, (I worked for the Hyatt in Sarasota then), in a room with six other cooks until our next shift eight hours later. The money was alright, and the benefits at the Hyatt were good as well, but, the Hyatt has hotels everywhere and some are Union, so, they have to make things good at most of their hotels, but, in Florida if you don't like the conditions you work under you have a choice, keep your mouth shut and work or quit and find another job, the Hyatt had the best working conditions and pay of any place in the area, and those weren't the best conditions in the nation.
I'll clear it up.
Their jobs have been outsourced for years.
You can't substantiate that ... many can't find decent jobs out of college because the Corporations, when not outsourcing, are sitting on $2 trillion.
Not so ... just not so. Factories have closed due to outsourcing and venture capitalism.
More tomorrow ...
[[Factories have closed due to outsourcing and venture capitalism.]]
You are missing an important factor ...
It's true; I missed stating that corporate profits in the U.S. are at record highs.
My bad.
The 1% in this country raise their standard of living by lowering that of the middle class and working poor. That's been going on for thirty years ...
The shitstorm's coming ... Republicans/Organized Wealth are being called out ... somewhere in their greedy, criminal-rich hearts, they know the country is turning against them; the voter suppression they tried to impose failed -- one doesn't try and stop a vote unless one knows the vote will go against him. Same with Michigan Governor/Republican Legislature rushing through a law that only 6% of the state approves of ... things are done in a sneaky, sleazy manner when the sneaky, sleazy POS that do them know they're doing something self-serving and foul.
Shitstorm's coming, Rich.
I missed mentioning that as well ...
I'm slipping.
[[The 1% in this country raise their standard of living by lowering that of the middle class and working poor. ]]
Not exactly . That is a result of the factor I'm referring too . And you are still missing what I'm talking about .
Well how 'bout you explain it to me rather than let on that you know something that I don't?
Spell it out.
The missing factor is automation .
Companies are NATURALLY COMPETITIVE with each other . In order to survive they attempt to reduce their costs as much as possible . That way they can offer the best products at the lowest prices . That is how the market works . If US companies don't do this , foreign companies will eat their lunch . So what US companies do is :
1] export jobs to low labor cost countries and
2] introduce automation to improve productivity .
It has nothing to do with greed as you keep loudly proclaiming . It has to do with survival of the company itself .
Correctly done the above 2 strategies do insure the survival of a company but at the expense of labor .
Labor is NOT an intentional casualty of this conflict . It is collateral damage in the war between corporations .
The real question is what can be done about this . Bellowing about corporate greed has no effect .
70% of the American economy is consumerism. How many "consumers" can companies eliminate before they destroy the consumer-demand for their products or services?
Greed causes blindness to its ultimate consequence ... self-destruction.
There's a reason for the coining of the phrase ... "a race to the bottom."
[[70% of the American economy is consumerism. How many "consumers" can companies eliminate before they destroy the consumer-demand for their products or services?]]
I cannot find fault with that point . But I am not defending what corporations do either . I am simply explaining their motivations in the current highly competitive environment . Until someone can come up with something which works better than simple market forces things are going to continue in the current direction . I am not smart enough or creative enough to come up with such a scheme . But if someone else comes up with another approach I will be happy to look it over .
Well, having been on all three sides if the union coin, I must say that I am about as anti-union as they come, even though they USED to do a good job. I'm quite cool with "Freedom From Forced Unionization" laws. But I still like ya, Mac!!
I can agree much with Mike. Before we ever got out of high school, we were working, and I had already began work in an apprentice type position. Before that, if we wanted something, (when we were 11-16 yrs of age) we had to find a way to earn it- my parents would not try to buy it for us. While there was ample LOVE, there was no desire by our parents or grandparents to 'spoil' us by solving our own (childish) dilemmas. That gave us the opportunity to both reason/solve and the choice to have/not have. We learned a work ethic, and we were glad to 'start somewhere' if offered a chance to get our foot in the door at a company. What is different today?
Actually, lots. The 'ME' generation has been shown (by Corporate consumer psychology masters) to buy, buy, buy... and does not know how to run a tight ship- budget, so that one is ABLE to start with a lesser wage and work their way up.A college degree does not make one INTELLIGENT- it makes one trained in a particular field somewhat-, but it does not teach anything about how to work, like we learned as children. It does not teach how to delay gratification, how to mend clothing, how to cook for a month on $50.00 and do well with that! Thus, younger generations believe they cannot afford to work for a lesser wage, and that a lesser wage ( or a particular JOB is beneath them.)
I too believe unions played an important part, when they were needed, but that it is time for them to go away now. CORPORATE and the decisions made by our politicians, have taken much work away- and sent it to GLOBAL CORPORATESVILLE. We as a nation, need to reconsider all our positions, and I, for one, would take any job I was able to have, then work my way up and out of that- if I was unsatisfied with the job itself and/or the income I was earning.