╌>

What would real democracy look like?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  james-martin2  •  11 years ago  •  37 comments

What would real democracy look like?

What would real democracy look like? from Big Picture on Vimeo .

What is a real democracy? Dr Shiva describes the current systems of democracy worldwide as a sham. Representative democracy has been hijacked by an 'economic dictatorship', led by a handful of multinational corporations. She calls for a true democracy which recognizes the value of all living systems.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Real democracy ended with the demise of ancient Athens ...

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

The insidious partnership between economic dictatorship and representative democracy will last and thrive until such time as people finally figure out that they cannot change the system from within. That may take awhile.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Yes, the uninformed echo chamber keeps spouting that the word democracy means something very different from the word republic, and the informed yawn and yawn and yawn having heard this story a hundred thousand times before.

Meanwhile, the informed know that the distinction comes down to one word being Greek and the other being Latin.

The informed say this over and over and over again, but the uninformed keep repeating the echo chamber. And it all starts feeling like the little boy who just keeps crying wolf and wolf and wolf and wolf....

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

There is nevertheless a strong distinction between a democracy & a republic irregardless of language origins . If the "informed" refuse to recognize that they are wearing blinders . BTW democracy has some serious limitations of its own . Posting a propaganda video does not address that .

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Alternatively, people could choose not to sell their vote.
 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

If only our elected representatives would follow that advice. Congressional votes don't come cheap.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Neither do the votes to elect them.
 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

A real democracy would be unbearable to watch too! Sooner or later it would turn violent, et tu badfish?

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

Well how do I get some of this cheddar? I've been voting for free all this time. Should I hassle Jill Stein, Cynthia McKinney, Ron Paul, and Ralph Nader until they pay me for previous votes on their behalf? Somehow I doubt I'll get much bank.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

"There is nevertheless a strong distinction between a democracy & a republic irregardless of language origins."

Okay, I'll let you practice your typing skills on that. What's the difference between a republic and a democracy?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Why?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
They buy us with commercials, speeches, and promises.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I'll let you practice your typing skills on that.

So good of you to let me , your majesty . I'll merely say that democracy is a direct tally of the population's votes . In a republic there are more layers .

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

Then find someone to put on the ballot who won't run commercials and refuses to give speeches and offer promises. I'll vote for'em. But then would not this person being buying my vote with his silence?

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

Even in the idyllic "Real Democracy" the power struggles would be corrupt and bloody. Shakespeare wasn't the original thought behind the Julius Caesar death scene. It is human nature to kill, to get something of perceived value. Human nature isn't developed by voting.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
My point is that people complain about corporate money in elections. Such money would have no effect if people did not give their vote to whoever had the most commercials.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Even before they turn bloody they develop other methods of eliminating political opposition . In ancient Athens they had the practice of voting to banish unpopular citizens from the country .

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

BOOM! Now that's a point I can definitely agree with. It's the reason I gave up voting for the "Big 2" parties back in the early 80's. Unfortunately, my guys never win.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Since he's not gonna win anyway I suggest throwing away your vote with style : George Zimmerman for president !

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

True "REAL" Democracy, 50.0000009% of the vote wins all simple majority rules all.

The simple minded always fall back on this as the panacea for all the ills of the world.

It is the same mantra Lenin used to incite the masses in revolt. (but of course he never told them their "Votes" would never ever count)

Sounds neat, you know what we would have in this country under simple majority rules?

Sure as hell wouldn't be any gun banning going around, Wouldn't be any abortions either.

How about gays remaining in the closet unless they really wanted to risk their lives? How about slavery being legal? How about the military enforcing civilian law? Right to work? but only at the wages that barely allow you to live.

Would be a hollywood wild west show.

Anarchy sounds nice, until you actually have it.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

"True "REAL" Democracy, 50.0000009% of the vote wins all simple majority rules all."

Other forms of democracy are possible which are non-majoritarian. One example is constitutional democracies (or republics, if you prefer Latin over Greek). This allows for basic constitutional rights which prevent the majority from running roughshod over minorities -- sometimes. But there are other options, including hybrids with these constitutional systems.

Parliamentary systems are said to sometimes allow for non-majoritarian systems of democracy, such as proportional representation. I can't say I really understand these systems, or whether they in fact do so.

My own preference at the moment is to distribute most decision-makingpower from the centralized giantism seen in many governments (e.g., USA) to the local level -- especially those powers most appropriate to the local level. However, great care has to be taken in distributing power in this way not to provide more power to those who would use it to dominate and exploit others, especially minorities -- e.g., racial and ethnic groups, LGBT people, women, various minorities.... This is obviously an outrageously difficult political agenda to serve, for far too many people want to accumulate power rather than disperse it. Such people are undemocratic in spirit. They would have nothing to do with democracy if it were to interfere with their longing to insure special privilege for themselves (or their group).

Various approaches to consensus decision making which are non-majoritarian have long existed, but are little tried in societies where competition and domination are held up as virtues greater than cooperation, sharing and giving. These obviously would work best in small scaled local communities comprised of people who deeply care for one another.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

But that is what this nation was founded to be. And was for it's first 120 years.

It was all lost on the issue of popular election of representatives.

And the citizens voted for it overwhelmingly, and our representative democracy went away. We exchanged it for a corporatist oligarchy.

And we don't even know who is the actual leader.

It has has reared it's ugly head over the last 20 or so years, and I find it strange that no one has noticed until recently.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Reply by Nowhere Man :

But that is what this nation was founded to be. And was for it's first 120 years.

It was all lost on the issue of popular election of representatives.

And the citizens voted for it overwhelmingly, and our representative democracy went away. We exchanged it for a corporatist oligarchy.

This has the feel of a historical sketch of a skeleton type, mostly bones, little flesh. Could you flesh out the history for us in greater detail? How did it progress? What was the timeline? Details, please?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

My sense of the history is different, somewhat. My sense is that the "founders" never intended the USA to be of, by and for "the people," in any sense we could recognize as "the people" today, and that the "founders" had intended a "representational" form of government from the beginning. They deeply distrusted "democracy," which they equated with "anarchy" (See David Graeber's The Democracy Project ). They crafted a quasi-democratic society which, they hoped, would always prevent the common people from holding power or influence -- because they wanted a stratified system of owners, slaves and working poor.... The slaves and working poor were basically seen as servants for the owning class, who were to be the "representatives".

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Read up on the 17th Amendment.

Then read up on the discussion the Constitutional Convention had on how to deal with the problem of wealth and how it effects government and what they decided to do about it.

Then we will have a basis for discussion.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Will do!

Meanwhile ...

A Discussion With Anarchist Activist and Scholar David Graeber, Author of The Democracy Project

...

" Then read up on the discussion the Constitutional Convention had on how to deal with the problem of wealth and how it effects government and what they decided to do about it."

What in particular would you have me read on this topic?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

I need more to go on. I sincerely want to understand your narrative, but I don't have the luxury of time necessary to guess what you mea n. It's as though we're talking about tea pots and you bring up a giant topic like physics and you say, "Have a look at gravitational field theory," but I'm needing to understand how to find a tea pot that doesn't dribble when I pour from it.

_________________________________________________

Seventeenth Amendment to the United States Constitution
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Seventeenth Amendment in the National Archives

The Seventeenth Amendment ( Amendment XVII ) to the United States Constitution established the election of United States Senators by the people of the states. The amendment supersedes Article I, 3 , Clauses 1 and 2 of the Constitution, under which senators were elected by state legislatures .

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

...how to find a tea pot that doesn't dribble when I pour from it.

Some wise man invented the funnel, some wiser man mounted said funnel on the teapot itself and invented the spout.

It is easy to find info in technical aspect of how we lost our representative republic.

It is even more difficult to find out why the constitution was written that way. It's not something the oligarchs want you knowing.

But over the years the information has been coming out.

Everyone knows that the founders seriously considered the governments that came before it, not at the convention itself or in it's proceedings but in their writings to each other.

As far as the reasons for the formulation of the Senate in the constitution and the reasoning they used, I'll see if I can find some online references for you.

I mean I could recite what I have learned, but without references there are many here in the group that would claim I'm full of it.

So keep this thought, I will be back with sources.... Smile.gif

I prefer a pot that doesn't dribble either.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Consensus isn't just about agreement. It's about changing things around: You get a proposal, you work something out, people foresee problems, you do creative synthesis. At the end of it you come up with with something that everyone thinks is okay. Most people like it, and nobody hates it.

David Graber

Yes it's called the art of compromise, the Founders were well aware of it and based the congress upon it. What has happened is that congress no longer compromises. On ANYTHNG.

The last time we failed to compromise 500,000 Americans died. I only hope we do not reach that point again, but history has a way of repeating itself.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

" Some wise man invented the funnel, some wiser man mounted said funnel on the teapot itself and invented the spout."

Then a bunch of brain dead maroons started attaching faulty spouts on tea pots by the millions, spouts which dribble rather than pour. Go on, test a bunch of tea pots and see if you can find some that work as to be expected. Half of 'em don't, I suspect.

Go to minute 2:15 here for a sense of my complaint.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Engineers do like to "Improve" things don't they....

{Chuckle}

I suspect your right....Smile.gif

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

"Engineers do like to "Improve" things don't they....

{Chuckle}"

Well, the designers and makers of things these days (usually mass produced crap from China) don't seem to recognize any need to test things in the real world which they had previously "tested" on paper or in computer aided design images. If it works in theory, by golly, it should work in your kitchen.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

"Yes it's called the art of compromise, the Founders were well aware of it and based the congress upon it. What has happened is that congress no longer compromises. On ANYTHNG."

Well, there was no Golden Age in our past, I think. But certainly things have gotten from mediocre (or bad) to much worse. (I say "have gotten" to keep up the sound a of a tea-sipping Brit, for fun.)

American politics, if an "art," resembles novice chain saw "art"..., or perhaps Dynamite art. It is certainly not collaborative art. It is just warfare. But it's much worse than that, because the battles are sleight of hand misdirection and the front lines are diversions.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Bzzztt. No. That's not right. Thanks for playing.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Clearly this is only a game to you since you are not supplying an explanation . Pardon me if I think of you as a liar ...

 
 

Who is online





72 visitors