╌>

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: Renewable Energy Is Key to U.S. Growth

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  michael-c  •  14 years ago  •  19 comments

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: Renewable Energy Is Key to U.S. Growth
Some excellent insights comparing the pros and cons of various sources of energy.
"We need to be energy independent but we can't look into the future by looking in a rearview mirror and say that we're going to do that through carbon," Kennedy says in an exclusive interview with The Daily Ticker.The idea that there's not a future for wind and solar energies in the U.S. is just a hoax."

"Government has picked the winners," he notes. "We give to the oil industry; we give $55 billion in direct subsidies each year. That's more than all the renewables put together have ever gotten in history. If we stripped away the subsidies, coal could not compete in the marketplace. Oil could not compete in the marketplace and nuclear definitely could not. You know, you can burn prime rib to make energy, why are we going with the most expensive stuff?" ( link )

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Michael C.
Freshman Participates
link   seeder  Michael C.    14 years ago

There are two different models for industry and you have to ask yourself: what do we want for the American economy? Do we want to measure the economy by how many millionaires it produces or do we want to measure the economy by how, and this is how we ought to be measuring it, by how it produces jobs and the dignity of jobs over the long term for every American?"

America should make a big bet on renewables, says Kennedy. Doing so will not just reduce our dependence on Mid-East oil. It will also help build a major new industry that will create thousands of jobs, bolster American manufacturing, and help build a much more sustainable and healthy economy.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Anytime someone mentions the Koch brothers he is likely to be a demagogue . They simply don't have all that much power or influence .

His factoids are so confused . He blames environmental mercury on coal but then goes on to include oil in that assessment . That part is wrong .His take on miners jobs is ridiculous . He wants them to have job security .Why should miners have more security than others ? Almost no one has job security these days .

As an engineer I am not entirely taken with current solar technology . There are other renewables which are better ... a lot better but only if they are applied properly . I should do an article on that but I would be surprised if anyone even looks at this one let alone a more technical one .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Solar cannot be used practically in an urban environment to obtain a useful % of the power needed . It can be used in the desert where land is extremely cheap . But then you have the problem of how to transmit the power back to urban areas where it would be used .
But land usage is not the issue I was concerned about . I was referring to EROEI . That ratio is not particularly large over the useful lifespan of the typical solar panel . I have seen some sterling cycle devices which might do better in that regard but I'm not certain of the number for them .

I agree with most of the rest of your comment . As to rare earths , they don't have to be a problem . The US shut down its only rare earth mining facility a few years back . It was due to the competition from China . China's lack of safety standards for dealing with the accompanying radioactive materials means they can mine those materials with no regard for the safety of their workers .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[It just requires such a high cost to create a facility that large for such a low power density.]]

The cost would be a lot less if the panels were located in the desert where land is cheap . And if the panels/devices were more efficient the power density would be better . The panels on the market today are not practical for the life span that they have compared to the energy it costs to manufacture them .

[[Energy invested isn't the only factor, there are pure cost accounting issues. ]]

I have no doubt that there are financial issues but if the engineering ratio EROEI is not large enough there is no point even looking at the financials .

And I certainly agree about the impractical view that many have about solar energy . But that is because it is a religion and not sci/tech from their POV .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

Nice seed Michael.

:~)

Our ongoing addiction to Mideast oil leaves us dependent on countries that are often unstable and hostile. Developing our own domestic energy resources and investing in renewable energy lessens this dependence.

That's enough for me. Energy independence is a matter of national security.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[EROEI is just one of those financial numbers that you look at.]]

Do you even know what it stands for ? It is an engineering ratio . There is NO money in that calculation at all . Of course money comes into the picture but if EROEI is inadequate there is no point in looking at the financials .It will not work . OTOH if it is adequately sized then the financials come into play .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

OK , I can agree with that . My point is that the BTU values of the energy inputs and outputs [irregardless of their costs] have to reach a certain minimum value . If they don't there is no point in doing the extra financial work .You would certainly not be adding energy into the system if that ratio is less than 1 . For most solar panels the ratio is about 5 which is a lot less than most other forms of energy .

Sometimes it is not apparent what all of the inputs are . For example when building solar panels you have to look at the energy inputs that go into their manufacture and installation . And if the returned energy [based on its expected lifespan] is too small you are not helping the "environment" nor the economy nor energy independence .

In any case the financial analysis changes a lot over time . But the BTU energy ratio does not .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[So the ratios are changing. Still not cost effective in my mind, but it is improving. ]]

Sure ... but the ratio for any panel you are evaluating is going to be constant if it is manufactured the same .

[[Something that would change that equation significantly is to source those materials, wherever possible, from the moon or asteroids.]]

Unless you are talking about materials we don't have in abundance [even if they are hard to extract] then I doubt that would be practical with the space tech we have now . Maybe someday if they can build the space elevator it would be more realistic but that is also not achievable yet .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

EI ,

[[If this were a primary factor in our energy choices, then we wouldn't even be having this conversation in our society, about hybrids, electric vehicles etc... We would have all converted to electric vehicles years ago, starting in the 70's. ]]

Your are talking about the past . The battery technology was not ready for the application . But now the technology is close to being ready for real commercialization .

[[What is far more important is the form of that energy, in particular, the storability of that energy depending on the targeted application, loss of energy in the creation of that storable energy really isn't that large a factor. We have shown that as a society, we are willing to waste so much energy to create that form. ]]

Yes , the form of that energy is the issue . That is precisely the problem with IC cars . They are almost
100 % dependent on petroleum . As a result our economy is addicted to petroleum . In order to break that addiction we need transportation with fuel flexibility . And that is precisely what the electric car is best at .
The fuel is not burned inside the car . It is burned at large utility plants which can handle a variety of inputs including renewables and nuclear and fossil fuels .
There is no need for a heavy IC engine which can't deal with anything but a highly refined petroleum product .There is only a need for a fast charging , high capacity battery .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Which is precisely my point, that it isn't the Energy output based on Energy input that is the primary factor]]

Focus EI focus . The context for that was evaluating the suitability of current day solar panels . Compared to other forms of energy they are wanting in EROEI . Wind power is a lot better by comparison as are almost all sources of energy .

[[And I am not sure, from a usage standpoint, what is the difference between a heavy car engine and a heavy car battery.]]

I am . The e-car has regenerative braking . That heavy battery does not waste energy because it is recaptured during braking . The heavy IC engine car does not recapture braking energy . It is simply wasted as heat .

[[Batteries for all intents and purposes are a very low density storage device, and with the Volt, one of its actually very real issues is that it is prone to catch on fire if it is charged too quickly.]]

Try reading that link I posted above . That new design solves the problems due to rapid charging and discharging . It should solve the fire problems .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Ahhh so now you are on a specific application and nothing more.]]

That was the argument I was making all along . I guess you don't read comments but here is what I said previously :
But land usage is not the issue I was concerned about . I was referring to EROEI . That ratio is not particularly large over the useful lifespan of the typical solar panel . I have seen some sterling cycle devices which might do better in that regard but I'm not certain of the number for them .

As to wind power , the siting of the turbines is critical . Some regions have an unreasonably long payback time but some do not .

[[That only matters in city driving, but overall, you still need to carry that mass around. ]]

Not entirely but mostly valid . As to embedding magnets in the roadways that would be an impractical scheme for many reasons .
By comparison the e-car is highly realistic [once they develop a battery which meets the requirements ] . It is a much more likely technology than that embedded magnet idea .

And I'm getting the idea that you don't like reading other people's stuff nor following their links . Does that make you an asshole ?

You don't like the U. of Michigan disc motor ? Do you have any reasons for taking that position ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

As you implied that new battery design is not tested under commercial conditions nor has mass manufacturing been set up . But it has promise . The article said it uses lithium nanotubes . If so that would be unique and brand new .

[[As for the U of Michigan disk motor, it has the same problems as the Wankel Rotary, but quite honestly I don't see how it can generate enough torque to do anything practical. ]]

That motor is not designed to produce a lot of torque . It is only supposed to be used in a hybrid car to charge a generator . That generator runs the e-motors . They supply the torque .

[[As for the embedded magnets, I never said it was practical, I said it was one way to create a system that would literally reduce the mass of a vehicle which would lower energy consumption.]]

Reducing mass is important in that in increases rolling resistance . It also causes large losses during braking .But if a battery [yes I am battery obsessed !] has sufficient energy density , the battery does not have to be that massive .

[[The problem with sterling engines isn't that they don't work, its that it is almost impossible to build a sterling engine of a size that would be commercially viable, a problem that you don't have with solar. ]]

I am not talking about sterling for direct drive power . I am referring to a tracking parabolic device which focuses the solar onto a sterling engine . It apparently is a lot more efficient than solar panels and they are already being deployed .

[[There are many reasons why it isn't viable, that one on its own isn't one of them. ]]

I don't see what your opinion is based on . Solar panels have the lowest EROEI of all of the energy sources .The extremely low value is a limiting factor by itself . I'm sure there are other factors as well .

And I certainly agree with the R&D spending on alternative energy , even Solyndra . It failed because the field is so competitive and fast changing .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Torque and HP are related, so if you don't produce torque, you aren't really producing any power, and therefore you can't charge up batteries. ]]

They are proportional . But the other factor is rotational speed . You can get power from very high RPMs and low torque .
That is exactly how the Chrysler gas turbine functioned .

[[They were actually saying it would be used to power the wheels. ]]
That's not what I've seen . But if you have a link I'll look at it . Likewise I'm pretty sure I have links that will indicate it is a hybrid only car .

[[again, it is still a matter of whether they can scale to practical use]]
I notice that you haven't asked for a link . As I said , this device is already deployed in solar farms and is producing power . It is a large Sterling cycle device . I think it was successful based on new materials they did not have only a decade ago .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I can't see why materials would make much of a difference.]]

As I understand it , the issue is one of heat loss through the cylinder walls and piston . But if they were made with
[or coated with ] ceramic materials there is a lot less heat loss .

As to the disc engine since you didn't put up a link I did . Here is the inventor talking about this device :


At 1:11 he starts referring to "having some batteries" and regen braking which would make this a hybrid design .
Also at 2:44 he refers to attaching a generator and producing 25 kw .

[[Very high RPMs are generally going to be too noisy.]]

That might be a serious problem .

[[the problem with the disc engine is 'when are we going to see more from it?' This is not something that is new ]]
As far as I can tell it is fairly new ... perhaps 3 to 5 years since it was designed . I'm not sure of when they built the 1st prototype or ran the 1st test .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[And again, he says it small and cheaper to produce.]]

Well , it is a lot smaller than a cylinder engine . And based on the fact that there are far fewer parts I can't see how it could be anything but cheaper to produce . That said I expect the machining would need to be very precise since it is operating at high RPMs . You would know a lot more of what is involved in manufacturing precise tolerances than I would .

[[Oh, and did you miss the part at 0:37 where they attained 'efficiency gains, already, just by theory'? ]]

I saw that . But theory plays a big part in the conception of these devices . He was referring to the [Port ?] Humphrey cycle . I am not familiar with that but here is a link about the Humphrey cycle engine : http://www.pulse-jets.com/oldforum/se.php?subid=1236&seid=8260&... Here is another link about CVC engines : ...

[[As for Stirling engines, heat transfer/loss is how they work. The use of ceramics would essentially do one thing, allow the engine to work at higher pressure but then you are talking about a steam engine. ]]

Why ? This engine does not heat water to produce steam .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[With regards to the disc engine, because it is operating at high RPM's, it will generate a lot of heat, which is something that would require cooling.]]

You may be right . What is that statement based on ?

[[Also, any application of a load (lets say a generator, which would be the application in a hybrid vehicle) would require just as much power (torque) to be created to overcome that load/resistance.]]

Again , you are equating power with torque . It is not that simple . Power is obtained from torque * [rotational speed] . You can make up for low torque with high RPMs .

[[If this really was a breakthrough, he would be demonstrating a working prototype before he released one second of footage. ]]

Perhaps that was his way of attracting funding . However , you might be onto something about a premature public release . I'm gonna do a google search to see if there have been newer updates ...

[[The 'designer' thinking that he could outsmart more than a hundred years of engineering with something so simple that anyone should have been able to figure it out. Well life isn't that simple. It really isn't. ]]

The design of this CVC engine is not based on anything in my knowledge base . So I am reluctant to either defend it or attack it . You might do well to look at the aviation week link I posted above .

[[People can call me a pessimist in this, but quite frankly, in this particular case, it is total bollocks, one of yet another in a long series of perpetual energy machines, which promise the world, but do nothing but spend money. ]]

It's OK to be a pessimist . But this is not a perpetual energy machine in any sense . Calling it that is completely unwarranted . He is burning fuel to produce power . That is NOT perpetual energy . The only argument you can make is that the efficiency is not as great as he is claiming . Frankly your arguments have been less than compelling ... all of them . So far I have seen nothing that you even understand what he is trying to do .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I read the aviation week article when it came out. It's application is in the field of rocketry, which are very high temperature, high pressure combustion environments. The Brayton cycle isn't that different]]

Like the Chrysler gas turbine Brayton cycle engine this is likely to be produce very high exhaust heat .So I am inclined to agree with you about the high exhaust temperatures as well as the high noise levels .
But Brayton cycle devices do not have cooling . They simply emit very high temperature exhaust . That is not a desireable feature in a car nor is high noise . Based on those potential problems I am inclined to reject this concept as not practical in the automotive environment . But I am not convinced that he does not know what he is doing . I do NOT see this idea as violating the laws of physics . It is NOT A PERPETUAL MOTION MACHINE .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I suspect that they made working copies of smaller engines, but can't seem to scale it up. ]]

From your 2nd link :

Mueller says they have four working bench prototypes.

"We have enginesreal, working, good-sized modelsrunning right now," he says.

Also :"The engine was obviously hard to design," he says. "But it's easy to manufacture. There are many partiesnational and internationalnow interested in it, both in the automotive and base power sectors. Interest in the engine, that's not a problem."

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

I still reject the concept based on excessively high exhaust temperature and noise level but it still could be useful for military applications . It might also be of value for the trucking industry . But as you implied , the proof is in the successful working models .

 
 

Who is online



107 visitors