╌>

Letterman: Obama "Not Telling The Truth" About Romney And Auto Bailout

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  14 years ago  •  16 comments

Letterman: Obama "Not Telling The Truth" About Romney And Auto Bailout

Letterman: Obama "Not Telling The Truth" About Romney And Auto Bailout

DAVE LETTERMAN, HOST: Here's what upset me last night this playing fast and loose with facts. And President Obama cites the op-ed piece that Romney wrote about Detroit, 'Let them go bankrupt, let them go bankrupt.' And last night he brings it up again, 'Oh no, Governor, you said let them go bankrupt, blah blah blah, let them go bankrupt, blah.' And Mitt said, 'No, no, check the thing, check the thing, check the thing.'

Now, I don't care whether you're Republican or Democrat, you want your president to be telling the truth, you want the contender to be lying. And so when we found out today or soon thereafter that, in fact, the President Obama was not telling the truth about what was excerpted from that op-ed piece, I felt discouraged.

RACHEL MADDOW, GUEST: Because the 'Let Detroit Go Bankrupt' headline, you felt like, was inappropriate?

LETTERMAN: The fact that the President is invoking it and swearing that he was right and that Romney was wrong and I thought, well, he's the president, of course he's right. Well, it turned out no, he was taking liberties with that.

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2012/10/24/letterman_obama_not_telling_the_truth_about_romney_and_auto_bailout.html?fb_action_ids=548685211814180&fb_action_types=og.likes&fb_source=aggregation&fb_aggregation_id=288381481237582

Romney called for a structured bankruptcy in a New York Times op-ed in 2008 titled Let Detroit Go Bankrupt Mr. Romney on Monday told WEWS-TV in Cleveland that he deserved some praise for the auto industrys recovery. (In fact, that headline was written by the paper, not Mr. Romney, who originally submitted the piece as, The Way Forward for the Auto Industry.)

Instead of the government directly loaning the companies money, as they did, Romney called for private lending with the government guaranteeing the loan.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

Romney's article ended as follows:

The American auto industry is vital to our national interest as an employer and as a hub for manufacturing. A managed bankruptcy may be the only path to the fundamental restructuring the industry needs. It would permit the companies to shed excess labor, pension and real estate costs.

The federal government should provide guarantees for post-bankruptcy financing and assure car buyers that their warranties are not at risk. In a managed bankruptcy, the federal government would propel newly competitive and viable automakers, rather than seal their fate with a bailout check.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

So when Obama becomes less accurate it's because he is attempting to be more pointed; but, when Romney is less accurate, it's because he is a lying, evil weasel...ok, got it.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

The financial markets being frozen were the reason why the auto companies went bankrupt.

Eh, not so sure about that. This was coming for years before the financial collapse. Being unable to compete because of high labor cost (union) and poor management, led to inferior products in the Marketplace. Folks bought imports even though they cost more at the dealer because of better mileage and less maintenance outlay. The recession may have been the straw that broke it's back, but it was not the reason the big 3 struggled.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

I know mice cannot read but you have no such excuse. I spoon fed you by quoting Romney but you either did not read it or don't understand plain English. HHere it is again:

Romney called for a structured bankruptcy in a New York Times op-ed in 2008 titled Let Detroit Go Bankrupt Mr. Romney on Monday told WEWS-TV in Cleveland that he deserved some praise for the auto industrys recovery. (In fact, that headline was written by the paper, not Mr. Romney, who originally submitted the piece as, The Way Forward for the Auto Industry.)

Instead of the government directly loaning the companies money, as they did, Romney called for private lending with the government guaranteeing the loan.

End quote:

GM DID go bankrupt. GM today is not the same company as ten years ago. That one went bankrupt and a brand new company was formed in late 2010. In the process the original holders were wiped out and the company was handed over to the union Obama supporters. Many dealerships, especially those held by Republicans, were shut down.

Obama invested $50 billion to take majority ownership in 2009. Thenew GM stockissued in Dec. 2010shortly reached almost $40 in Jan.2011. It closed today at $23.70. It sold $13.5 billion worth of GM shares in November 2011 in the low 20s, cutting its stake from 61% to about 33%. The U.S.'s stake is down to 26.5%. The Treasuryrecovered about $23 billion in bailout funds it extended to GM. For the Treasury to break even, GM shares would have to reach about $53, so don't hoild your breath.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Did anyone play the whole video? The distinction made by Obama was that at the time of the Detroit bailout, THERE WAS NO PRIVATE MONEY AVAILABLE FOR A STRUCTURED BANKRUPTCY; consequently, the only way to save the industry and all the related jobs and businesses, was via the Federal government.

Bain ironically was asked to assist in saving Detroit, but because of the Bush economic mess, it wouldn't help out.

It's what Obama said at the debate.

NEW YORK (CNNMoney) -- Would the U.S. auto industry be doing as well as it is today if it was Mitt Romney completing his first term as president?

Romney argues that his plan for the industry in his now-famous November 2008 New York Times op-ed piece, " Let Detroit go bankrupt ," was what the Obama administration eventually did: a managed bankruptcy at both companies. He insists that he was not in favor of the companies going out of business.

But in the 2008 piece, Romney said the money needed to keep General Motors ( GM , Fortune 500 ) and Chrysler Group alive during bankruptcy should have come from the private sector, with the government providing only "guarantees for post-bankruptcy financing." Those guarantees would have made lenders whole if the automakers subsequently defaulted.

The problem was that there was no one available to write checks for the automakers other than the government in late 2008 and early 2009.

The financial markets had melted down in the wake of the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy. Treasury was pumping billions into the nation's banks, who were not willing to then lend money to a struggling auto industry -- or anyone else.

...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

If the US had guaranteed the loan, as Romney proposed,the money would have become available.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

The reason why the financial industry was the 'trigger' (maybe that is a more accurate word)

Ok, gottchya.

Now if there was more time (say 6 months to a year) for something to be negotiated, then that may have been a different story, but that kind of time wasn't available in light of the completely IDIOTIC behaviour of people fucking procrastinating to the point of a crisis, but that is something that we constantly see in Washington and elsewhere. Just look at the debt ceiling crisis. Same fracking bullshit.

Brotha, ain't that the truth!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

You don't have the facts ... check them.

...

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

Okay, I'm spit-balling here a bit, but do you get my question?

I think that is exactly the question many have in mind. At what point is a company responsible for their own success or failure?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Let's stop looking the other way ...

Romney Profited From Auto Bailout

By: David Dayen Thursday October 18, 2012 8:30 am

Greg Palast has a new story out about Mitt Romneys profit from Delphi Automotive, an auto parts subsidiary of GM, during the auto rescue.

No bailout of GMor Chrysler, for that mattercould have been successful without saving Delphi. So, in addition to making massive loans to automakers in 2009, the federal government sent, directly or indirectly, more than $12.9 billion to Delphiand to the hedge funds that had gained control over it [...]

By the end of June 2009, with the bailout negotiations in full swing, the hedge funds, under (hedge fund manager and top Romney donor Paul) Singers lead, used their bonds to buy up a controlling interest in Delphis stock. According to SEC filings, they paid, on average, an equivalent of only 67 cents per share.

Just two years later, in November 2011, the Singer syndicate took Delphi public at $22 a share, turning an eye-popping profit of more than 3,000 percent. Singers fund investors scored a gain of $904 million, all courtesy of the US taxpayer. But thats not all. In the year since Delphi began trading publicly, its stock has soared 45 percent. Loebs gains so far for Third Point: $390 million. The gains for Silver Point, headed by two Goldman Sachs alums: $894 million. John Paulsons fund, which has already sold half its holdings, has a $2.6 billion gain. And Singers funds and partners, combining what theyve sold and what they hold, have $1.29 billion in profits, about forty-four times their original investment [...]

Altogether, in direct and indirect payouts, the government padded these investors profits handsomely. The Treasury allowed GM to give Delphi at least $2.8 billion of funds from the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) to keep Delphi in business. GM also forgave $2.5 billion in debt owed to it by Delphi, and $2 billion due from Singer and company upon Delphis exit from Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The money GM forgave was effectively owed to the Treasury, which had by then become the majority owner of GM as a result of the bailout. Then there was the big one: the governments Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation took over paying all of Delphis retiree pensions. The cost to the taxpayer: $5.6 billion. The bottom line: the hedge funds paydays were made possible by a generous donation of $12.9 billion from US taxpayers.

The way in which the hedge fund syndicate secured these taxpayers dollars for Delphi sounds pretty much like blackmail. For example, according to Steven Rattner, the auto czar, Delphi demanded an immediate cash infusion of $350 million or they would stop supplying to GM. Oh, and Delphi promptly fired all the unionized workers at Delphi, cut health care for all their nonunion pensioners, and took the production jobs to China. Delphi employs less then 5,000 US workers, from a high of 25,000.

How do the Romneys figure into this? They have at least $1 million invested in Paul Singers Elliott Management, per their 2011 and 2012 financial disclosure. Based on that investment, they made at least $15.3 million on the deal, which involved ripping off the US taxpayer, shedding US jobs in favor of China, and using leverage created by the auto bailout to do it. Most of these profits have been kept offshore to avoid US taxes, of course. The Romneys protest that these investments are all held in a blind trust, but the executor of their blind trust is Romneys personal lawyer.

Just another day in the life of a vulture capitalist, I guess.

There is a silver lining, however: if Paul Singer becomes an influential advisor in a Romney White House, that might mean well get national marriage equality after all .

...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

At what point is a company responsible for their own success or failure?

You tell me, Larry. Here's what happened when Republicans were talking aginst the Detroit bailout.

Republican Senators like Bob Corker (Tennessee), Richard Shelby
(Alabama), Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (Kentucky) and Senators
Tom Coburn (Oklahoma), Jon Ensign (Nevada), David Vitter (Louisiana)
and Jim DeMint, (South Carolina), initially sabotaged the bridge loan
for Detroit car-makers. They demanded that the UAW (United Auto
Workers) take an upfront fifty percent pay cut and make benefit
concessions over and above those they had already made.

Hiding behind the false pretense of "protecting taxpayers," their actual agenda was to break not just the UAW, but American unions across the board -- and in the process, kill Detroit as the capitol of American car manufacturers.

Were this simply the usual pro-organized-wealth, anti-working person,
anti-middle class Republican ideological appeal to the self-indulgent
right-wing base that almost always votes against its own economic
interests in exchange for religious pandering and project funding,
that would have been insidious enough. But this was not mere
ideology, this was part of a self-serving plot at the direct expense
of middle class Americans which was already underway!

Alabama is home to plants for Mercedes-Benz, Honda, Hyundai and
Toyota, Tennessee is in the process of getting a new Volkswagen plant and is already home to Nissan's North American headquarters, and Kentucky, site of Toyota's biggest plant outside Japan -- all subsidized foreign car manufacturers with AMERICAN TAX DOLLARS! AMERICAN! Advantages given to foreign car makers are: clearing of land, building of facilities and ultimately, one Japanese car maker received the land as a gift! These are the same Republicans who have been telling American taxpayers that "foreign auto makers can manufacture for less because of the UAW!"

While on the surface, such political slights-of-hand appear to favor
the American consumer, in reality, it does the opposite because these
foreign auto makers have been getting our tax dollars and then
sending the profits that these dollars enable -- OUT OF THE COUNTRY!

And no surprise, messages left for some GOP senators have asked if
"campaign contributions played any role in their decision-making."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

A bailed out General Motors expanded its small truck and SUV manufacturing in China soon after closing down similar facilities in Janesville, Wisconsin -- the plant Barack Obama pledged to save and keep open for another hundred years in 2008.

Not true ... an oft-repeated Republican lie!

The facts:

First, some context. Ryan reportedly recalled this event incorrectly just days ago, during an August 16 speech in Ohio.

Ryan reportedly alleged that Obama said he'd "keep that plant open," and therefore broke his promise because the plant closed.

"That plant was shut down in 2009. I remember President Obama visiting it when he was first running, saying he'll keep that plant open," Ryan said, according to the Janesville Gazette. "One more broken promise."

The Detroit News pointed out that Obama made no such promise in the February 13, 2008, speech, and indeed, we've seen no account suggesting that Obama did. Here is the quote at issue, according to an account kept by the Council on Foreign Relations:

"I know that General Motors received some bad news yesterday, and I know how hard your governor has fought to keep jobs in this plant. But I also know how much progress you've made -- how many hybrids and fuel-efficient vehicles you're churning out," Obama said. "And I believe that if our government is there to support you, and give you the assistance you need to re-tool and make this transition, that this plant will be here for another hundred years."

By "bad news," Obama apparently was referring to GM's February 12, 2008, announcement that it had a $38.7 billion adjusted net loss for 2007.

As for the GM plant going to China -- I wish the bailout had stipulated against such a move, but, the U.S. will make money on the loan, AND, all of the jobs that were saved because of the bailout are still intact.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    14 years ago

Too bad we did not bail out Penn/Central, Worldcom and Enron.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago
The issue isn't the investment ; it's the hypocrisy.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Excuse me for not spelling it out!

Bain Capital Turned Down Chance to Invest in GM

Elspeth Reeve 3,877 Views Feb 20, 2012

Mitt Romney says that he opposed the government bailout of Detroit because the private market would have provided loans so GM and Chrysler could go through managed bankruptcy, but it turns out the firm Romney once led, Bain Capital, turned down the chance to do so. The government's auto task force asked Bain Capitol if it would like to invest in GM's European operations, The New York Times ' Jeremy W. Peters reports, but Bain said no thanks. Detroit executives and Obama administration officials say that Romney is wrong: government money was necessary because at the worst of the financial crisis, private companies would not have lent the $80 billion the automakers needed. Based on The Times report, we now know that the government's argument was true in the case of at least one company: the one Romney helped found and shape.

This isn't the first reported connection between Romney's former businesses and the Detroit bailout.In Jaunary, CNBC reported a Bain & Company employee advised the auto task force on closing some dealerships in November 2009. (The company initially denied the report, before admitting it was true.) That is an uncomfortable fact for Romney, who wrote a Times op-ed in 2008 headlined " Let Detroit Go Bankrupt ," and defended it last week in the Detroit News . Romney argued in the latter essay that without a bailout, GM and Chrysler would be as healthy as they are today, but unions wouldn't have gotten such a nice "sweetheart deal" out of it. But that's not how many in the auto industry in Michigan see it, Peters reports. Bob Lutz, a former vice chairman for General Motors, told him he was still so mad at Romney he mailed in his absentee ballot for Rick Santorum.Lutz said of Romney's op-ed:I think all of us in the auto industry who knew what the situation was were profoundly disappointed and, I would say, angry... We all saw it for what it was, which was a political ploy to the right. Mike Jackson, chief executive and chairman of AutoNation, was nicer to Romney, but still thinks he was wrong. As the auto retailer told The Times :

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Yes Romney's position on the matter, as exemplified by the editorial, was self serving and particularly clueless, but please leave it at that.

So YOU get to decide the significance of the hypocrisy ... is that how it works?

It's all right to take over a company to cannibalize it and fuck the workers in order to line your own pockets, but investing in a company to keep it viable in America and save 800,000 plus American jobs ... no so much.

 
 

Who is online





102 visitors