Seattle restaurant succeeds with $15 minimum wage, but broader effects of pay law uncertain
In this photo taken Monday, July 27, 2015, Bob Donegan, president of Ivars Seafood Restaurants, stands below a Native American artwork in one of the company's restaurants in Seattle. After Seattle's new minimum wage law took effect last April 1, Ivars announced that it was jacking up its prices by about 21 percent, eliminating tipping as a routine procedure, and immediately paying all its hourly workers a $15 per hour. They began the new pay rate three years earlier than the law required. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
By GENE JOHNSON, Associated Press
SEATTLE (AP) Menu prices are up 21 percent and you don't have to tip at Ivar's Salmon House on Seattle's Lake Union after the restaurant decided to institute the city's $15-an-hour minimum wage two years ahead of schedule.
It is staff, not diners, who feel the real difference, with wages as much as 60 percent higher than before. One waitress is saving for accounting classes and finding it easier to take weekend vacations, while another server is using the added pay to cover increased rent.
Seattle's law, adopted last year after a strong push from labor and grass-roots activists, bumped the city's minimum wage to $11 an hour beginning April 1, above Washington state's highest-in-the-nation $9.47. Scheduled increases that depend on business size and benefits will bring the minimum to $15 within four years for large businesses and seven years for smaller ones.
There's little data yet on how the law is working.
"To the extent that we can look at macro patterns, we're not seeing a problem," Seattle Mayor Ed Murray said.
As Washington, D.C., and other cities consider following Seattle, San Francisco and Los Angeles in phasing in a $15-an-hour minimum wage, Ivar's approach, adopted in April, offers lessons in how some businesses might adapt. Ivar's Seafood Restaurants President Bob Donegan decided to raise prices, tell customers that they don't need to tip and parcel the added revenue among the hourly staff.
For some of the restaurant's lesser-paid workers including bussers and dishwashers that's meant as much as 60 percent more. Revenue has soared, supportive customers are leaving additional tips even though they don't need to, and servers and bartenders are on pace to increase their annual pay by thousands, with wages for a few of the best compensated approaching $80,000 a year.
"It's been a surprise," Donegan said. "The customers seem to like it, the employees seem to like it, and it seems to be working, at least in this location."
Rochelle Hann, 25, is a second-generation worker at Ivar's. Like her mom, she has performed a variety of roles, including serving, bookkeeping and even dressing up as a giant clam. If she keeps working 30 hours a week, her annual pay will jump about $12,000 money she's socking away for accounting classes at a community college.
"Before, I felt like it was maybe not quite paycheck-to-paycheck, but now I don't even have to worry about it," she said. "I just went away for the weekend, and it was an easy expense."
Brett Richards, a 50-year-old singer and guitarist, has worked 25 years in food service, including the past eight at Ivar's. Before, he made minimum wage, plus tips. Now, he gets $15 an hour, plus a share of the 21 percent menu price increase, plus any additional tips customers leave. He expects to make almost $7,000 more this year, money that's helping him with his increased rent and with taking his kids out to eat a little more often.
Other industries with minimum wage employees could have a tougher time as worker pay climbs.
"What we expect to observe is this is not going to be a policy that's universally good for everybody or bad for everybody," said Jacob Vigdor, a University of Washington professor who is leading a study of Seattle's minimum wage law. The study includes recurring surveys of 700 Seattle businesses and ongoing interviews with about 50 low-wage workers and their families.
Downtown Emergency Services Center, which relies heavily on government contracts to provide housing and other services for chronically homeless residents, might need to cut those services unless the city boosts its funding.
"The economic justice that would be happening for our employees would be borne by our clients, who are extremely vulnerable people," executive director Daniel Malone said.
| |
TAGS: Associated Press
Tags
seeder
Kavika
11 years agoHaving lived in various countries around the world, ''no tipping required'' is not unusual at all.
Perhaps there on to something with this approach.
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoKavika
Good article thanks for posting it - I agree there could be a "rest of the story" to these increases.
Anecdotally, there is a restaurantthat many locals patronize on a regular basis. A daughter of a family friend has been working there waiting tables since she started college almost 6 years ago (she is in graduate school now) and I talked to her about this phenomena the last time we saw her. She works 8 hours per day, five days per week (Tue through Sat) and makes $5.00 per hour plus tips (the Ohio min for tipped employees is $4.05). She serves 4 to5 groups per hourfor a total of 32 to40 groups per shift (avg 36) depending on how busy it is and says that she seldom receives a tip of less than $5.00 per group (sometimes much more) which on the low end comes to say $4.50 x 36 groups = $162.00 in tips per shift plus $40 in hourly wages for a total of $202.00 per shift.
At $15 per hour and no tips she would receive $120 per shift
Of course health insurance and a retirement plan could be considered added compensation, but she currently has neither gets her insurance through the exchange.
She thinks she is better off with her current compensationand I see her point
Of course all situatons will be different
Cerenkov
11 years ago
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoShe works 5 days per week 8 hours per day and has for several years.
She is paying her way through graduate school
What big picture is she not seeing?
Waitressing jobs are normally not looked at as careers but rather as transitional positions. so again I ask what big picture is she not seeing?
Cerenkov
11 years ago
seeder
Kavika
11 years agoI'll be gone for the next 3 to 4 hours. I'm leaving the article open.
Please debate it, but keep it civil.
Thanks
Cerenkov
11 years ago
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoRougy
You are now mixing apples and oranges - the question is whether she is better off with her current hourly wage plus tips or $15 per hour and no tips.
I acknowledged that he ahs no insurance in the position, it is not a career position, it is a transitional job.
You pontificated and deflected, but failed to answer the simple direct question is she better off financially with her current wage plus tips or $15 per hour and no tips. Do the match and answer the question.
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoYou have a strange concept of math I guess
She is in Ohio and an employer of less than 50 employees does not have to offer health insurance (see PPACA) and the restaurant where she works (about 12 employees) does not and likely would not if the minimum wage was raised to $15 so that is moot in the question I asked you which is only about her earnings.
Is she better earning $120 per shift or $202 per shift accepting that she has no employer provided insurance in either case?
It is an easy question
Cerenkov
11 years ago
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoSince you are reluctant to answer a simple question, because it does not support your view, I guess we are at an impasse.
seeder
Kavika
11 years agoOK guys I'm back.
RIO, of course the current way she is getting paid is better for her. There is no question about that. But what we have here is a young lady that will be going for an advanced degree in the field of her choice.
We have on the other hand, thousands of people that will be in food industry for the rest of their lives. For them, the Ivar's model is great. Is it the only model? I don't think so, this is a transition era that, I'm sure, we'll see many different models, based on industry, location etc.
There are always going to be exceptions to every case, both pro and con.
If I'm not mistaken, there are exceptions to the $15 minimum wage. That is if you in a ''tip'' position and industry I don't believe that the $15 applies.
I'll have to research it to be sure though.
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoKavika
I appreciate the perspective - thanks.
Perhaps the real problem is that people are choosing food service as a career rather than a transitional position to a career, which requires time, effort and hard work to attain.
seeder
Kavika
11 years agoRIO, without people making food service a career, what would they do. Perhaps they aren't cut out for collage, and it's something that they enjoy doing.
I know a few people that work in the food service industry as a career. One went on to open her own dining facility.
Also having lived in countries where tipping was not expected, I saw no difference in the quality of service rendered vs a U.S. tipping establishment.
Robert in Ohio
11 years agoKavika
One went on to open her own dining facility.
That is quite different from choosing a career as a busboy or waiter, that is working towards a goal of a real career
seeder
Kavika
11 years agoRIO, no, actually it isn't. The lower rungs of the service industry are bus boys/bar boysetc. Those positions are used as either a starting point to move up to waiter/bartender/cook etc. Or it is simply a transit position. People make their own choice.
The actual question here is the minimum wage. I, for one do not see a problem with the minimum wage reaching $15 between 2017 and 2020.
Sophia Descertes
11 years agoI'm glad that these restaurant people are getting paid a little more money, but I don't know how anyone can live on just $15 an hour when a meal at a restaurant costs $50.
seeder
Kavika
11 years agoSophia, there are restaurants that have meals for less than $50. You just have to look for them.
