╌>

As Romney Repeats Trade Message, Bain Maintains China Ties

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  rescue  •  14 years ago  •  28 comments

As Romney Repeats Trade Message, Bain Maintains China Ties

The tale of Asimco Technologies, an auto parts manufacturer whose plants dot eastern China, would seem to underscore Mitt Romney s campaign-trail complaint that Chinas manufacturing juggernaut is costing America jobs.

ine years ago, the company bought two camshaft factories that employed about 500 people in Michigan. By 2007 both were shut down. Now Asimco manufactures the same components in China on government-donated land in a coastal region that China has designated an export base, where companies are eligible for the sort of subsidies Mr. Romney says create an unfair trade imbalance.

But there is a twist to the Asimco story that would not fit neatly into a Romney stump speech: Since 2010, it has been owned by Bain Capital , the private equity firm founded by Mr. Romney, who has as much as $2.25 million invested in three Bain funds with large stakes in Asimco and at least seven other Chinese businesses, according to his 2012 candidate financial disclosure and other documents.

That and other China-related holdings by Bain funds in which Mr. Romney has invested are a reminder of how he inhabits two worlds that at times have come into conflict during his campaign for the White House.

As a candidate, Mr. Romney uses China as a punching bag. He accuses Beijing of unfairly subsidizing Chinese exports, artificially holding down the value of its currency to keep exports cheap, stealing American technology and hacking into corporate and government computers.

How is it Chinas been so successful in taking away our jobs? he asked recently. Well, let me tell you how: by cheating.

But his private equity dealings, both while he headed Bain and since, complicate that message.

Mr. Romney also has millions invested in a series of Bain funds that have a controlling stake in Sensata Technologies, a manufacturer of sensors and controls for vehicles, aircraft and electric motors that employs 4,000 workers in China. Since Bain took over the operation in 2006, its investment has quadrupled in value. Bain continues to own $2.6 billion worth of Sensatas shares.

Two years ago, Sensata bought an operation that made automobile sensors in Freeport, Ill. At the first meeting with the plants 170 workers, Sensata managers announced that by the end of 2012 all the equipment and jobs would be relocated, mostly to Jiangsu Province. Workers have staged demonstrations, pleading for Mr. Romney to intervene on their behalf.

Chinese engineers, flown to Freeport for training on the equipment, described their salaries as a pittance compared with Freeport wages. Tom Gaulrapp, who has operated machines at the factory for 33 years, said he fears he will go bankrupt after he loses his job on Nov. 5.

READ MORE:

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/10/us/politics/as-romney-repeats-trade-message-bain-maintains-china-ties.html?ref=us

Please no personal attacks. Thanks, Rescue


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

What Bain does today is not relevant to Romney.

Not so; what's relevant is that Romney condemns the very trade policies with China that he created as prototypes while at Bain without taking the responsibility for creating and implementing them.

That's called "hypocrisy."

And it's my opinion that the right-wing accepts his multiple hypocrisies and positions of convenience without repudiation because to many of its adherents, this election is simply a matter of black-and-white.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

I'm not aware of that ... but it too is irrelevant. Romney condemns others for allegedly continuing what he has created, practiced and endorsed.

Can't have it both ways.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    14 years ago

It's pretty simple. Romney holds STOCK in Bain. He doesn't RUN it anymore. Using your logic, someone whose retirement plan has stock in Bain is ALSO responsible for outsourcing. (In addition to being an intelligent investor, of course)

Bain Makes Money. THAT is why it is successful. It saves companies, saves the lion's share of the jobs that will otherwise get cut, and makes money for investors and the for the US government that taxes those investors AND Bain Capital FOR those profits. Got a problem with that?

(Sorry, RD, but I can't support ya on this one!Grin.gif )

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Bain Makes Money.

Yeah ... by exporting American jobs and cannibalizing American companies; it's Romney's prototype ... which he simultaneously fails to talk about candidly ... while condemning and blaming others for those very practices.

If I smacked you in the head then repudiated other guys who subsequently smacked you in the head, I'd be likewise a hypocrite.

BUT WAIT ... THERE'S MORE!

Republicans kill U.S. jobs bill designed to curb job outsourcing

Republicans in the U.S. Senate blocked a bill designed to help American job growth by providing tax break incentives to companies investing in jobs in America while at the same time removing existing tax breaks gained by companies that outsource jobs beyond U.S. borders.

Present law allows companies to take a tax deduction for the movement of equipment and people beyond U.S. borders. This bill would have removed such tax deductions and, in addition, it would have provided a 20% tax incentive to companies who moved overseas jobs back to American soil.

Despite the defection of four Republicans who voted for S.3364 Bring Jobs Home Act , the final vote, 56 yeas to 42 nays , was not enough to pass the 60 vote threshold needed to move the bill forward to a simple majority vote.

...

UNTIL ROMNEY REPUDIATES THIS ... he's a hypocrite and a fraud!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Let me be clear about this- I'm not voting for EITHER asshole. (Romney or Obama). But if Obama was capable of saving this country, his 4 years would have shown SOME faint sign of a recovery. But there hasn't been one. Obama is AT LEAST as big a liar and fraud as Romney. But blaming Romney for the actions of Bain in 2010, is as asinine as blaming Obama for the actions of the Illinois Senate in 2010. Blame both for actions that occurred during their tenure in the respective organizations. NOT for what occurs after they stopped being active members of the organizations.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

if Obama was capable of saving this country, his 4 years would have shown SOME faint sign of a recovery. But there hasn't been one.

Romney still has investments in China ... and your statement is quite inaccurate.

In addition to the 5 million jobs added ... replacing a big percentage of the 8 million lost under Bush ...

Obama ... (I'll post the other 200 or so later if you like) ...

  • Overhauled the food safety system;
  • Approved the Lily Ledbetter "Equal Pay" for women rule;
  • Ended "Don't Ask/Don't Tell" discrimination in the military;
  • Passed the Hate Crimes bill in Congress;
  • Appointed two progressive women to the U.S. Supreme Court including the first Latina;
  • Pushed through the Affordable Health Care Act, outlawing denial of coverage for pre-existing conditions, extending until age 26 health care coverage of children under parent's plans, steps toward "Medicare for All;"
  • Expanded the State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) health care for children;
  • Pushed through a $789 economic stimulus bill that saved or created 3 million jobs and began task of repairing the nation's infrastructure;
  • Overhauled the credit card industry, making it more consumer friendly;
  • Established the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and used a recess appointment to keep it on track in the face of GOP attempts to derail it;
  • Also outmaneuvered GOP in naming two members of the National Labor Relations Board blocked by the Republicans in their attempt to shut down the NLRB;
  • Won two extensions of the debt ceiling and extensions of unemployment compensation in the face of Republican threats to shut down the U.S. government;
  • Pulled troops out of Iraq and began draw down of troops in Afghanistan.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[by exporting American jobs and cannibalizing American companies]]

Confusing cause and effect ?
You make it sound as if the American jobs would stay in country if Bain were not involved . But that is not the case. The reality of the global labor market means that those jobs are going to be exported . What is not inevitable is that the entire company goes belly up . That is what a good private equity company like Bain can do . And sometimes they can save American jobs as well by careful restructuring .

One more thing : the labor market is shifting . China is no longer the sink for those outsourced jobs .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

You make it sound as if the American jobs would stay in country if Bain were not involved . But that is not the case. The reality of the global labor market means that those jobs are going to be exported .

That doesn't exonerate Bain for its share and its part ... and there's still that item ...

Republicans kill U.S. jobs bill designed to curb job outsourcing

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Outsourcing isn't Romney's prototype. Outsourcing has been an american business phenomenon long before Romney even got into the business world.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

What part of "global labor market" don't you get ?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Let's Start at the very beginnnnning

A very nice place to start

When you read you begin with A B C

When you Obama you begin with liesto me!( Sue me)

5 million new jobs- Total bs. Doesn't take into account the average of over 150,000 jobs LOST each month.

hate Crimes bill is asinine. making crimes worse because someone yells "Nigger" or "Honkey" during the commission is stupid.

Supreme Court women appointees- Bad and worse. Not for being women, but for their blatantly biased decisions PRIOR to their appointments. And the failure of at least one of them to recuse herself from the HC debate, since the government's arguments WERE WRITTEN BY HER DURING HER STINT AS OBAMA'S SOLICITOR GENERAL.

Pushed through Obamacare. NOT a praiseworthy accomplishment, but rather a supreme example of him being Socialist in Chief. Not something I supported in any way. (one of the reasons I don't like Romney, either, FYI)

Expansion of SCHIP- see above. NOT a good idea.

The Stimulus Bill- A failure in every way. Those 3 million imaginary jobs are no plus. And it did nothing to repair "infrastructure". As Obama said, "Those shovel ready jobs weren't as shovel ready as we imagined they were."

Overhauling credit card industry- not the government's job.

CFPB- bad plan, not the government's job, again.

Keeping the NLRB going- more pro-union crap. I know, I was union. Bad plan, corrupt organizarion.

Extending our debt ceiling- successfully finishing off our Triple A Credit Rating.

And got us INTO Syria, kept GITMO open, continues the War on Terror, USA Patriot Act, DHS, TSA,....

Face it. He's a fucking failure. Good riddance to bad rubbish.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

yeah he saved the 'titanic', but the derelict is still floating in the middle of the atlantic.

Metaphors are nice ... but this doesn't say anything ...

Obama's Stimulus Saved the U.S. Economy - Private Debt Dropped $4 T...

attribution: The Economist

President Obama's stimulus was a success. It stopped a second Great Depression. An explosion of private debt, enabled by financial deregulation and lax enforcement of rules during the Bush years created a financial bubble similar to the one that triggered the Great Depression. When the bubble burst private debt was rapidly destroyed and credit lines were slashed. The destruction of private debt was massively deflationary. The Federal Reserve tried to stimulate lending by slashing interest rates to banks to zero, but that was not enough to offset the destruction of money caused by the collapse of housing prices and the debt bubble. President Obama and the Democratic Congress of 2009-10 prevented another Great Depression by public spending which saved state jobs, primarily jobs for teachers, police, and firefighters. Saving those jobs and funding new jobs to build and repair infrastructure stopped the deflationary spiral the economy was entering. President Obama and Democrats have successfully reduced the total p... can opposition.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

What part of "global labor market" don't you get ?

Don't talk down to me; American jobs are not in any way detrimental to a global economy.

Corporate profits in the U.S. are at record levels ... greed is what kills jobs here. The real question is ... "are you in favor of outsourcing ... and the consequences here?"

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Saying he's accomplished nothing and interpreting based on your views that what has been done amounts to nothing are quite different things.

Debt ceiling for example ... the Republicans caused that bu holding the country hostage for tax cuts for the rich ...

5 million new jobs- Total bs. Doesn't take into account the average of over 150,000 jobs LOST each month ... tell that to those now working who were not prior to Obama; and the jobs/highway bill killed by Republicans would added 1 million more ...

Supreme Court ... biased decisions ... tell it to Clarence Thomas and his wife ...

You stated your point, I, mine ... we disagree.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

If you don't want me to "talk down to" you , then start speaking the language of economics instead of union based rhetoric . You complain the Repubs are killing U.S. jobs bill designed to curb job outsourcing .
But the alternative to losing jobs is losing corporations . They don't have to stay in the US . They can move the entire operation including headquarters out of the country . Is that preferable ?

[[greed is what kills jobs here.]]

No ... just competitiveness . There is a difference .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

The PPACA fixed the wrong problem in health care, which is that health care in the United States just costs far too much.

No, it fixed part of the problem ... to fix it all the way ... UNIVERSAL/SINGLE PAYER and the end of for-profit health care/health insurance.

H.R. 676 FAQ

What is H.R. 676?

H.R. 676, also called the United States National Health Insurance Act, is a bill to create a single-payer, publicly-financed, privately-delivered universal health care program that would cover all Americans without charging co-pays or deductibles. It guarantees access to the highest quality and most affordable health care services regardless of employment, ability to pay or pre-existing health conditions.
What is "single-payer"?
The term single-payer describes the kind of financing system that H.R. 676 uses. It means that one entity--in this case, established by the government--handles all billing and payment for health care services. Right now, there are thousands upon thousands of "payers"-- HMOs, PPOs, bill collection agencies, etc. The sheer volume of paperwork required by our current system means that administrative waste accounts for roughly 31% of the money spent on health care . The single-payer system would eliminate the wasteful paperwork and administrative costs, redirecting more of our health care dollars to providing care.

Medicare is perhaps the best known single-payer system. Essentially, H.R. 676 would improve Medicare and expand it, so that it covers all Americans, regardless of their income.


Who will be eligible for health care coverage under H.R. 676?

All Americans will be eligible for health care coverage. Every person who enrolls in the program and receive a United States National Health Insurance Card and individual ID number, and that is all anyone will need to receive care.

What health care services are covered?

The program established by H.R. 676 will cover all medically-necessary services without charging co-pays or deductibles. The services covered will include: primary care; inpatient, outpatient and emergency hospital care; prescription drugs; durable medical equipment; hearing, dental and vision care; chiropratic treatment; mental health services; and long-term care.
What about "catastrophic" care? Will I ever reach a limit for coverage?
No. There are no limits on coverage. Just as you will never pay a co-pay or a deductible under the universal national health care program, you will never reach a ceiling on your coverage.

Will I be able to choose my doctor?

Yes. Patients will have their choice of physicians, providers, hospitals and clinics. The financing will be public, but the providers will all remain private.

No co-pays or deductibles-- what's the catch? Will I actually pay less for health care?

There is no catch. Both families and employers will pay significantly less for health care.

Currently, the average family of four covered by an employer-provided health care plan spends roughly $4,225 on health care each year, including premiums, services, prescription drugs and supplies. This figure does not include the annual Medicare payroll tax, currently at 1.45%. Under the plan created by H.R. 676, a family of four making the median income of $56,200 would pay about $2,700 in payroll tax for all health care costs. No deductibles, no co-pays, no worrying about catastrophic coverage.

Employers who provide health insurance currently pay, on average, 74% of employee health premiums. For a family of four, the average employer share is $8,510 per year. Under H.R. 676, the employer pays a 4.75% payroll tax, not a premium to health insurance companies. For an employee making the median family income of $56,200 annually, the employer would pay roughly $2,700.

Estimates taken from: Employer Health Benefits 2006 Annual Survey, Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and Educational Trust; Consumer Expenditure Survey, U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics; and Study by the Center for Economic Research and Policy.

How will the transition to the new system work?

The full conversion to a non-profit, single-payer universal health care program will not take place overnight once the bill is passed. The total transition time will be roughly a 15-year period. Important elements of the transition will include:
Private health insurance companies will be prohibited from selling coverage that duplicates any benefits included in the universal national health care program. The private companies will, however, still be able to sell coverage for services that are not deemed medically necessary, such as many cosmetic surgery procedures.
Private insurance company workers who are displaced as a result of the transition will be the first to be hired and retained by the new single-payer entity. Any of the displaced workers who are not rehired will receive two years of unemployment benefits.

How will the universal program be paid for?

First, switching to a single-payer system will lead to billions of dollars saved in reduced administrative costs. Those savings will be passed on through the system and allow coverage for all Americans. Additional savings in the overall cost of health care will come from annual reimbursement rate negotiations with physicians and negotiated prices for prescription drugs, medical supplies and equipment.

Second, a "Medicare For All Trust Fund" will be created to ensure a dedicated source of funding in addition to annual appropriations. Sources of funding will include:

Maintain current federal and state funding for existing health care programs
Closing corporate tax loopholes
Repealing the Bush tax cuts for the highest income earners
Establish employer/employee payroll tax of 4.75% (includes present 1.45% Medicare tax)
Establish a 5% health tax on the top 5% of income earners; a 10% tax on top 1% of wage earners
One quarter of one percent stock transaction tax

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

If you don't want me to "talk down to" you , then start speaking the language of economics instead of union based rhetoric .

Two things ... you're again giving me that condescending crap, and "union based rhetoric" is a personal attack.

We just went through this yesterday in another thread ... whether you know the occupation or history of a member has no bearing on your comments to that member. State your case and let the specifics of your argument rather that creating a straw man be what others use to evaluate your comment.

But the alternative to losing jobs is losing corporations . They don't have to stay in the US . They can move the entire operation including headquarters out of the country . Is that preferable ?

They cannot both kill American jobs and simultaneous save the American economy. Consumerism being some 70% of the U.S. economy, by eroding the number of viable consumers, a viable global economy may evolve, but an America as we know and prefer it will be gone. There's no democracy where there's no middle class.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

My company is self insured, but we had an 18% increase in medical costs this year. Exactly how is that going to be fixed by single payor

Under single payer/Universal Health Care, employers will no longer be involved in paying for employees health insurance! Premiums will be paid as in Medicare ... and, in the absence of profit, waste and outrageous CEO salaries, premium costs will drop. Fees will go for ACTUAL HEALTH CARE (rather than 31 cents of every premium dollar going to waste and CEO salaries as is the case now).

Read the whole House Resolution I posted ... it will answer your question.

If employers aren't contributing to employee benefits, they will enhance profits and hire more workers.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

You know the irony in having PPACA being brought up in this conversation is that health care costs, which companies currently largely bear the cost of, is one of the reasons why companies are offshoring jobs in the first place.

No question that those benefit costs precipitate job exportation (read the comment I left before this ... it addressed this very thing).

The irony ... Republicans who opposed health care (insurance) reforms altogether, are the biggest proponents of exporting the jobs!

They fuck us at both ends.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

OK , next time I will call it leftist rhetoric . Is that better ?!

[[They cannot both kill American jobs and simultaneous save the American economy. Consumerism being some 70% of the U.S. economy, by eroding the number of viable consumers, a viable global economy may evolve, but an America as we know and prefer it will be gone. There's no democracy where there's no middle class.]]

I agree with that . There are limiting factors in the economics as to how many jobs can be exported and that is one of them .

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Tell it to the millions who are not counted as unemployed solely because their unemployment ran out, and they aren't looking anymore. Sorry, Mac, but this is an "Agree to disagree" situation. Because Obama OR Romney are bad for the country. PERIOD.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

OK , next time I will call it leftist rhetoric . Is that better ?!

Yup! But you can't just label it without satisfying the burden of proof ... as with any allegation. If you can substantiate it with specifics, you're good to go.

[[They cannot both kill American jobs and simultaneous save the American economy. Consumerism being some 70% of the U.S. economy, by eroding the number of viable consumers, a viable global economy may evolve, but an America as we know and prefer it will be gone. There's no democracy where there's no middle class.]]

I agree with that . There are limiting factors in the economics as to how many jobs can be exported and that is one of them .

Then we're not that far apart.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

I don't see the point in talking analytically when the other party is talking moralistically .

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot


82 visitors