Four Big Surprises From the Denver Debate -- Michael Medved
The first presidential debate between Barack Obama and Mitt Romney, otherwise known as The Denver Donnybrook, offered the rarest of pleasures for attentive viewers: a series of utterly unexpected developments that could shock and shove the perpetually close campaign in dramatically new directions.
Excerpts:
Among the evenings most conspicuous surprises:
1. Romney came across as notably more youthful, energetic, and optimistic than his weary and piqued opponentdespite a 14-year age difference in Obamas favor.
2. The great majority of the evenings argument focused on Romneys plans for the future, not on Obamas first-term record or second-term agenda. The candidates quarreled and quibbled over Romneys tax plans rather than Obamas, and discussed GOP ideas to repeal and replace Obamacare as well as Dodd-Frank more than they evaluated the nature of the original reforms the president has already implemented.
3. While polls say that Obama holds a huge advantage over his wealthy adversary when it comes to relatability and understanding the concerns of ordinary Americans, in this first debate Romney (of all people!) played the compassion card more effectively. He spoke emotionally and repeatedly of the suffering of hard-working Americans, citing specific individuals he encountered on the campaign trail
4. Finally, and most consequentially, Romney stole Obamas banner as the candidate of compromise and conciliation, and the president will face a tough if not impossible struggle in trying to win it back. Even the incumbents most ardent admirers admit their disappointment that he failed so miserably in fulfilling his visionary promises to transcend Washingtons petty bickering and to inaugurate a new era of post-partisanship.
Conventional wisdom, backed by historical polling data gathered by Nate Silver and others, always suggested that the challenger usually wins the first debate just by showing up and standing shoulder-to-shoulder as an equal with the presidential incumbent. But the initial Romney-Obama matchup raises questions about a whole new paradigm: what happens when the challenger not only stands up to the perceived invincibility of the charismatic, regal commander-in-chief but, for most of the evening, enthusiastically mops the floor with him?
More: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/10/04/obama-s-big-whimper-four-big-surprises-from-the-denver-debate.html

In Major League Baseball, the apparent winner of the National League batting title, Melky Cabrera, disqualified himself after he was suspended for using performance-enhancing substances.
In other sports, when an infraction occurs, plays are often "called back"/nullified because a team/player violated some rule(s) of the game.
Romney certainly "won" the debate on style points ...
BUT HE LIED HIS ASS OFF!
VIOLATION!
The day follwing the euphoria of (apparent) victory, the Romney Campaign had to walk back the lies that falsely attributed the Romney "victory" to substance as well as style.
And from now to election day, Debate Number One will be, more than anything else, about Romney the Liar rather than Romney the Legitimate.
UPON REVIEW OF THE PLAY ... ROMNEY COMMITTED MULTIPLE VIOLATIONS OF THE TRUTH ...
The "win" is (de facto) nullified.
It is easier to be energetic when using a teleprompter that relieves one of the burden of thinking on his feet under pressure.
I have never found Romney uncompassionate even before supporting him.
Obama hasalso frequentlyflip-flopped during his public life. It is up to the voting public to take everything into account.
No argument with your other points.
Says you! Why didn't Obama call him on it?
If your view is plausible expect Biden to make a big deal of it and it will be up to Ryan to play defense. This may well be the Biden strategy; to ignore Ryan and blast Romney.
But Ryan can handle himself and Biden, as well as Obama, is known as an inveterateliar.
Easier yet is the Romney technique of just ...
LYING.
On Romney's compassion:
Whatever you may think of the former Massachusetts governors politics, there should never have been any hesitation about Romney the man . This is a bright, self-made man, one whose public and private philanthropy , which puts most of us to shame , should be legendary. It is not. Thats because his good works werent done to burnish his political credentials and his decency discourages their exploitation toward that end. You dont have to agree with Romney on everything to see that he is a mensch . He obviously loves the America that is the land of opportunity that has rewarded his work ethic. Like most of us, he wants that America preserved, not "fundamentally transformed."
Yet, for months, the Obama campaign has relentlessly portrayed Romney as an inveterate scoundrel: a dissolute shylock maybe even a felonious one who fleeced mom-and-pop stores, secreted his ill-gotten gains in offshore vaults, and, in his spare time, tortured his own pooch. "Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, polarize it" its the Alinskyites following their dog-eared rule book.
The problem for our community organizerinchief is the debate setting. With no slavish Obamedia filter between the candidates and the viewers, the Obama campaigns ludicrous distortion of Romney collided, one on one and for all to see, with the reality of Romney. The challengers upbeat energy simultaneously effused respect for the presidents office and sheer joie de vivre at the prospect of laying bare the presidents miserable record of forcing Obamas vision of Euro-America to compete with Romneys.
More:
Your speaking of lying reminds me again of the Obama 2007 tape about Katrina that recently surfaced. Obama was worse than lying there. Here is how Andrew McCarthy put it:
Speaking of fiction, an inconvenient videotape resurfaced the day before the debate. It was from 2007 in Virginia: Senator Barack Obama, presidential stars in his eyes, speaking to a largely black audience of religious leaders and inciting racial animus.
To be generous, Obamas performance is disgusting. Cynically adopting the black dialect of the American South, a dialect utterly alien to him, he demagogues against Washingtons supposedly selective waivers of the Stafford Act legislation that requires communities hit by disasters to match 10 percent of federal aid. They waived it for 9/11, he tells the crowd, and they waived it when Hurricane Andrew hit Florida: Those communities were allowed to keep their one dollar for every ten federal dollars. But when he comes to Hurricane Katrina, which devastated the largely African-American population of New Orleans, Obama implies that Congress refused the waiver: Whats happenin down in New Oleans? Wheres yo dollar? Wheres yo Stafford Act money?...Tells me that somehow the people down in New Oleans they dont care about as much.
In fact, ten days before Obama gave that speech, Congress had waived the Stafford Act requirement for Katrina. He was well aware of that fact, too. After all, he was one of only 14 senators to vote against the waive r. It was part of a bill to fund the war effort in Iraq. That is, to pander to his Bush-deranged, anti-war base, Obama decided that squeezing New Oleans was a price worth paying. Then, he lied about what happened in order to foment racial resentment an atmosphere that he calculated would help his presidential bid.
Just as hes doing today.
What, other than the Breitbart bullshit team, do right-wingers actually know about this?
Permit me to educate.
You missed the point of my citation. It is that Obama condemned not having the waver though he was one of the few who voted AGAINST it before he made that speech. That is in the Congressional record.
Andrew McCarthy, being a top-drawer prosecuter (who successfully prosecuted the blind shiekh) would not state a falsehood that can be easily verified.
Daily Kos is arguably not as accurate as Breitbart or National Review in which McCarthy's article appeared.
Thuis like the dog on the car or the "fact" (not true) that he never worked as a garbage man.
Romney's father was affluent. Why would he do what you say? These Alynskyite accusations are not worth responding to.
I am sure you have a million more.
The Birthing/Wright/Ayers/ghost-writing/Muslim stories about Obama are ffar more credible and more serious.