╌>

Obama Administration: Constitution's Treaty Clause Is Dead

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  37 comments

Obama Administration: Constitution's Treaty Clause Is Dead

C onstitution: Asked the right question, a suspect will often incriminate himself. Asked why the Iran deal isn't a treaty, Secretary of State John Kerry basically answered it's because we've killed the Constitution.

It's been quipped that the "Living Constitution" liberals believe in so deeply means that the real Constitution is dead. Its words as written can be twisted by judges, and the non-existent such as rights to abortion and same-sex marriage can be found written between its lines by the Supreme Court.

But Secretary Kerry, testifying before the House Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday, pumped another bullet into the legal foundation of the American system of government ratified by We the People nearly 227 years ago.

Asked by Rep. Reid Ribble, R-Wis., "Why is this not considered a treaty?" which would mean 67 senators would have to agree before the Iran deal would take effect former Sen. Kerry's startling and telling reply was:

"Well, congressman, I spent quite a few years trying to get a lot of treaties through the United States Senate, and frankly it's become physically impossible. That's why. Because you can't pass a treaty anymore. And it's become impossible to, you know, schedule. It's become impossible to pass."

Kerry recalled how "I sat there leading the charge on the Disabilities Treaty which fell to, basically, ideology and politics ." That treaty was blocked in the Senate last year.

The treaty clause of the U.S. Constitution, Article II, Section 2, Clause 2, is very clear: The president "shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two-thirds of the Senators present concur."

But according to Kerry, the Senate isn't passing treaties anymore, so we can just forget that pesky little section of our underlying legal document. Let's parse Kerry's words:

"Frankly it's become physically impossible." A treaty with Mexico helping us keep illegal aliens from crossing our border wouldn't be physically impossible to schedule and pass; tens of thousands

of demonstrators would probably gather at the Capitol steps from all across the country to demand it be ratified yesterday.

But a treaty that appeases the world's foremost terrorist regime, allowing it to keep the ability to become nuclear-armed; or a treaty that gets the United Nations involved in handicapped parking spaces at the local mall? Yes, Mr. Secretary, that kind of treaty is impossible. It has something to do with the people electing our lawmakers.



Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/072915-764121-kerry-says-iran-deal-not-treaty-because-it-would-fail.htm#ixzz3hLi2kgON
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
It's all about semantics and deception. Kerry has betrayed his position. Again.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
The Senate doesn't obstruct; they deliberate as the Constitution mandates. If you don't agree with their decision, elect someone else.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Executive Agreements

In addition to treaties, which may not enter into force and become binding on the United States without the advice and consent of the Senate, there are other types of international agreements concluded by the executive branch and not submitted to the Senate. These are classified in the United States as executive agreements, not as treaties, a distinction that has only domestic significance. International law regards each mode of international agreement as binding, whatever its designation under domestic law.

The challenge of obtaining two-thirds vote on treaties was one of the motivating forces behind the vast increase in executive agreements after World War II. In 1952, for instance, the United States signed 14 treaties and 291 executive agreements. This was a larger number of executive agreements than had been reached during the entire century of 1789 to 1889. Executive agreements continue to grow at a rapid rate.

In recent years, the growth in executive agreements is also attributable to the sheer volume of business conducted between the United States and other countries, coupled with the already heavy workload of the Senate. Many international agreements are of relatively minor importance and would needlessly overburden the Senate if they were submitted as treaties for advice and consent. Another factor has been the passage of legislation authorizing the executive branch to conclude international agreements in certain fields, such as foreign aid, agriculture, and trade. Treaties have also been approved that authorize further agreements between the parties. According to a 1984 study by the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, "88.3 percent of international agreements reached between 1946 and 1972 were based at least partly on statutory authority; 6.2 percent were treaties, and 5.5 percent were based solely on executive authority."

...

I'm not sure how minor this is though and should be considered a treaty.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Obama was a political incompetent when he entered office in '08 . He had time to learn how to negotiate but all he did was throw his weight around since the Dems had the majority . He wasted that time being ideological when he should have been practical . Now its too late .

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Under Obama, the senate has done little more than obstruct, thanks to the GOP.

Really?

The senate has been in republican hands for what 6 months?

You must mean the obstructionism of one Harry Reid. But the funny thing is, Harry is a democrat and yes he was a big obstruction, refusing to introduce just about anything from the House.

What we have here is a demonstration if liberal speak. Liberal speak means that anything they cannot get done is always the fault of the other side. Even if your completely in control like they were for their first two years.

Liberal speak has nothing to do with truth, even fact. It only has to do with blame, deflecting as much away from themselves and onto anyone else handy, preferably republicans, especially libertarians.

Thank you sincerely for such a CLEAR example.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
If he can't handle the job, maybe he should quit.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

YOU SAID...

Under Obama, the senate has done little more than obstruct, thanks to the GOP.

I SAID...

The senate has been in republican hands for what 6 months?

(with notations that Harry Reid in the senate has been the only real obstruction to things getting done)

And you calling ME a liar?

You, sir, are either a liar, or a victim of long-term memory loss.

Or suffering from some form of dementia.

OH boy, another burnt out true believer.

Like I said, can't accept reality and have to blame and turn on everyone that don't spout the liberal schlemiel. If republicans had control of the Senate for the last 8 years we wouldn't be in this mess. But according to you we did. (actually we would be in a different mess)

Please Please point out to me in the Senate records, where the republicans had control of the senate during Obamacare for instance. Or any of those government shutdowns or the backstabbing negotiations, Sequester anyone?

Democrat control of the Senate was a hallmark of all of those things that happened.

So since you don't even know recent history, why should we consider what you say anymore than the political ideological rantings of a brain dead liberal?

And trust me, we have quite a few well respected non-brain dead liberals on the board. who wouldn't make a statement like that in a thousand years.

Why? CAUSE IT IS FACTUALLY INACCURATE! If you want you spiel respected at least get the basic details correct otherwise you will be pigeonholed with the ideological brain dead, which of course we have a few of those also.

Other than that, be careful whom you call a liar son. You haven't a clue.

(and yes that was an invitation if you care to take it up)

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Yeah it was kinda low hanging fruit wasn't it John?

But we at least do have to let the newbies know that we have a higher standard of vitriol around here...

Don't we?

It's boring as hell going through all the brainless asinine statements.

Just trying to do him a favor is all by letting him know, he needs to raise the level of his true belief to at least be an honest representation.

I mean I wouldn't want anyone accusing him of being a LIAR now would we?

{Chuckle}

He can be as braindead as he wants to be, it's his right, but we as a group do have an image to maintain.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

LMAO. The senate, that has had a Democratic majority for just about all but six months?!?! That's almost as good as claiming he can't get anything done because of congress and ignoring that nothing got done when Dems had the majority there too.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

What we have here is a demonstration if liberal speak. Liberal speak means that anything they cannot get done is always the fault of the other side.

Summed up quite nicely.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Party of NO?

Harry "Can't ever post a House bill to the Senate floor" Reid.

There is your party of NO.

How long did he do that, 4 years? For something to come thru congress it has to be heard.

I give you Harry Reid, the "Party of NO" (the actual party saying NO in provable FACT! yes he actually did that)

Rhetorical party of no compared to the factual party of NO.

Hands down, the Democrats are the party of no based upon actual fact and provable actions. You can't fillibuster anything if it doesn't even make it to the floor.

So you claiming that the republicans fillibustered everything the democrats wanted to do is true, except your argument fails to mention that the democrats used the senate to block everything the republicans did, therefore the republicans returned the favor.

You learning anything yet?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

They didn't beat the candidate I wanted running, I predicted an Obama victory if they nominated Mittsey over a year before it actually happened. In fact, it is well proven that the republicans cut their own throat in getting Mittsey nominated.

If the popular republican candidate had been nominated, Obama would not have had a second term. AS it was even Obama thought he had lost. Until election night.

So I didn't let the lightweight beat them the lightweights of the republican party did that.

But that is the establishment for you, both parties couldn't care less about the people.

And I understand that your trying to interject a race issue here John, but it isn't about race, it is about a political establishment that doesn't want to listen to the people.

But it is real nice of you to step in and support the liberal newbie and attempt to change the discussion from the corner he was backing himself into into another liberal ideological schlemiel...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

This is what you said.

The attempt to equate Democratic obstruction with GOP/tea party obstruction has to ignore who is the occupant of the White House.

Every other time you have made that statement you were implying a racial component to the issue.

If as you now claim that it is only about party, then both sides are just as guilty, and the actual man in the office has nothing to do with it.

So on that basis political obstructionism takes many forms, and is what Congress was designed to do. Just because your party holds the office of president you don't automatically get what you want. Reagan had to work with a democrat dominated congress and did so, FDR had to work with a republican dominated Congress and did so.

Since this man equates himself with those two arguably great presidents, why can't he work with congress? He has never worked with congress very well.

It is this presidents hyper-partisanship that has gone a long way to causing the gridlock.

And why I think we will have a different party in the oval office come next cycle.

There has been nothing done cause democrats have not wanted anything done. And their effectiveness in blaming the republicans has long gone away.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You know what just happened here?

You have just categorized yourself on the board.

You are a proud member of the liberal brain dead.

Enjoy...

Unfactual opinion attempted to be passed off as truth reveals everything in sum total.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

So, All your saying John is the President and Reid conspired to subvert the legislative process. By not letting anything even come to the floor for discussion.

Shut down the whole process.

So you agreed with me. The only thing that would be allowed through is liberal policies.

The party of NO. Grin.gif

ps thank you for the admission Grin.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

It's irrelevant if they did or didn't, your equating the republican availing themselves of the legislative process as being bad.

Don't the democrats use the filibuster against things they do not like? Yes they do.

But as John pointed out above, the president and president of the Senate conspiring to subvert the legislative process.

Which is worse? which is using your office to subvert the congressional purpose?

To you, using the legislative process is wrong, subverting the legislative process itself is good.

The ends justify the means. Law and constitution means nothing when it comes to the liberal agenda.

That is the epitome of brain dead.

I'm done with you, it was easy pickings.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Not spinning reality, just highlighting the strange reality of the liberal brain dead.

And exposing it as well.

We've been down this road hundreds of times John. you usually wind up calling me a blowhard when you cannot refute the truth.

Is this going to be one of those occasions also?

Point the finger at the republicans but ignore the much much worse efforts of democrats to subvert this nation?

I said this..

What we have here is a demonstration of liberal speak. Liberal speak means that anything they cannot get done is always the fault of the other side.

That is a truth you cannot escape.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Yes. They need to take responsibility for their failure to govern.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The state of the union address is exactly that, the state of the nation.

It is not a policy declaration function.

A number of presidents have not even given one although is has become the custom.

To think of it as an official act of how the country is supposed to be run and proposed and directed legislation, just shows how much you do not understand separation of powers, or the constitution.

In the alternative, maybe it is the democrats putting into practice what they really want, which is more reminiscent of a king than a president. You know, that all powerful being that tells the legislature what they should be doing.

Interesting point John. and thank you for that tidbit on the presidents intentions with the state of the union and what it means to him.

Just one more admission that the ultra liberal democrats of today have zero intention to follow the constitution and to subvert it in every way possible to suit their ends.

All the more reason to filibuster them everywhere they are encountered.

Keep talking John, you reveal more with every comment. Grin.gif

The reality you preach is a reality we have never seen before except in some of the more autocratic nations around the globe.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

rougy said....

Blah

De blah dee

Blah,

Nowhere "Man"

yep, typical, run out of things intelligent to say, can't counter the logic or facts, so resort to blather. How intelligent. The board welcomes another brainless mass.

John Said....

I don't recall saying it is an official anything. You can't resist trying to categorize and define other people's comments.

I didn't categorize your comment, you did, by saying that the president told congress the way it should be in the SOTU address. YOU characterized it as something the president gives as official. Not me, I just took that idea to it's logical conclusion.

Please, tell us when was the last time the out of the presidency party dictated the legislative agenda.

Please tell us the last time a sitting president successfully directed congress in what it should do? The legislative agenda is set by each house individually, as mandated by the constitution's separation of powers clause. The Legislative agenda is usually given by the leaders that control each house. The president controls neither. Unless you have a Harry Reid or Nancy Pelosi in charge of them that will allow the president such power. BTW aren't they democrats? you see how the nations government can be perverted to one sides aims when they have all the power.

But you like it that way and want to ignore the constitution and establish the presidency as a kingship or premier as all powerful ruler in an autocracy.

Thank God that the founders envisioned such an occurrence happening and created very effective ways for the opposition to prevent it.

rougy further said....

The beautiful thing

Is that when you give a shit

You can change the world.

Nice thought, except for when it is other thoughts and Ideals of caring that are calling the shots. WE are changing the world, cause we do give a shit, even if you and your ilk don't like it.

Beautiful thing to see isn't it! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

WE are keeping it civil XX the new guy needed an education and asked for it. So I felt I would oblige him. and as a result, we learned where he stands in the world. A good thing all around. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

The exception of course is economic trade treaties. Both sides just love those. When dems and repubs agree, the middle class loses big time.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

rougy, only when it Counts?

You mean this didn't count?

It's already counted, and tallied for those paying attention. We learned what we needed to.

As far as you John, we already know you, and this is where it always winds up doesn't it. Smile.gif

It always makes good sense to not dig the hole deeper.

TTYL Smile.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

on the flimsiest of evidence.

Only a blockhead would call that flimsy ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Even if i were deluded [which I'm not ] you're still a class A blockhead in nearly everything you do .

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

John, John, John...

{chuckle}

you make this SOOOO easy....

(for which they need the cooperation of Congress)

Why does he need the cooperation of congress? If he is laying it out why does he need Congress at all?

Cause without Congress NOTHING gets done. And CONGRESS does as it wants to irrespective of what the president wants them to do.

WHY?

Congress has the sole power to legislate for the United States. Under the nondelegation doctrine, Congress may not delegate its lawmaking responsibilities to any other agency. In this vein, the Supreme Court held in the 1998 case Clinton v. City of New York that Congress could not delegate a "line-item veto" to the President, by powers vested in the government by the Constitution.

Where Congress does not make great and sweeping delegations of its authority, the Supreme Court has been less stringent. One of the earliest cases involving the exact limits of non-delegation was Wayman v. Southard 23 U.S. (10 Wet.) 1, 42 (1825). Congress had delegated to the courts the power to prescribe judicial procedure; it was contended that Congress had thereby unconstitutionally clothed the judiciary with legislative powers. While Chief Justice John Marshall conceded that the determination of rules of procedure was a legislative function, he distinguished between "important" subjects and mere details. Marshall wrote that "a general provision may be made, and power given to those who are to act under such general provisions, to fill up the details."

Marshall's words and future court decisions gave Congress much latitude in delegating powers. It was not until the 1930s that the Supreme Court held a delegation of authority unconstitutional. In a case involving the creation of the National Recovery Administration called A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States, 295 U.S. 495 (1935), Congress could not authorize the president to formulate codes of "fair competition." It was held that Congress must set some standards governing the actions of executive officers. The Court, however, has deemed that phrases such as "just and reasonable," "public interest" and "public convenience" suffice.

That was from Wiki, but I can give the direct sources if you really need any further explanation. Congress cannot give up it's legislative power to anyone, and the legislative agenda is the specific purveyance of Congress, to each house, individually.

The state of the union is a speech, a traditional one not a required one and some presidents have used it to whine at congress about what they want, But congress in under no requirement to give it to him, in FACT, they are mandated to do what they need to do and ignore the president when it comes to the legislative agenda.

And it's been that way since this country was founded, and the Supreme court has upheld that ideal.

Your argument is Bullshite, not factually nor legally correct. You obviously don't want it nicely so I'll give it to you directly without any sugar or spice.

But then again you wish to claim I make unfounded arguments?

Stick that in your pipe and smoke it. I can back up everything I claim and will be the first to admit when I'm wrong. You have yet to come up with an issue when I've been wrong. That is why you claim I just claim victory when I've done nothing.

I've done everything in my power to be nice, but your bullshite is just that, bullshite.

And you have been called on it AGAIN. and it's been proven bullshite, FACTUALLY and LEGALLY.

Your personal claims about me, you know what you can do with those...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

All that linkage is irrelevant John. You said that the President sets the legislative agenda.

I said that he didn't due to Separation of Powers, you responded that he did during the SOTU speech. I responded that he didn't that wasn't the point of the SOTU.

You presented a cut and paste from Wiki of the SOTU page claiming that that is what the pres uses the SOTU for.

I responded with a paste from Wiki on Separation of Powers, which showed not only the legal doctrine on the issue but some of the legal decisions backing it up.

Your point, the president directs the legislative agenda, was destroyed as absolutely incorrect.

All your linkage notwithstanding. Proves nothing but that politicians are partisan. NOT that the president controls the legislative agenda.

In fact if the president did control the agenda, why do we get republican bills going into the Senate for Harry Reid to block?

The president controls the agenda according to you.

The president doesn't control anything over the Congress.

You lost and your point was destroyed.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Big govt lives BIG business ...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You always lose interest John, AFTER you have been proven wrong.

No matter how you desperately want to wiggle or split hairs or change the point after you are proven wrong.

Taking up rougy's issue and trying to prove it is an example.

You know what? claiming the Republicans are the party of NO?

And you chose the Bush administration. {Chuckle}

All you did was prove what I said to rougy, BOTH SIDES DO IT.

Proving his claim as false.

You will never accept, none of you hard core liberals will accept that you are just as bad as the republicans you rail against.

Two peas from the same pod. One party in two factions.

That is the truth of it, and nothing you say or claim will change that.

Have a nice day.

 
 

Who is online



100 visitors