╌>

Stop Dickin' Around with Terrorism

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  14 years ago  •  8 comments

Stop Dickin' Around with Terrorism

"THE GRID

Forget Tough Talk and Rhetoric Heres an Actual (Although) UGLY Plan for Fighting Terrorism

In military or police operations, the rules of engagement (ROE) determine when, where and how force shall be used. Such rules are both general and specific, and, there have been large variations between cultures throughout history; typically ROE are only fully known to the force that intends to use them. (Wikipedia)

The so-called War on Terror has been primarily reactionary to incidents perpetrated against civilization by Islamofacists whose ROE include the unconscionable murdering of innocent civilians and, their use of hostages and human shields.

Much of the so-called War on Terror has been the use of fear and propaganda to create windfall opportunities for war-profiteers; there were and still may be, more private contractors in Iraq than military personnel. And the war in Iraq had nothing to do with pursuing Al Queda until the resultant area destabilization brought the terrorists there.

By terrorist design, all nations, cultures and individuals are fair game, thus leaving potential target populations with a serious dilemma, namely; If innocent individuals will be harmed by terrorists in order to achieve their objectives, to protect ourselves, at some point, wont we need to choose between our innocent citizens or theirs?

By theirs I mean those innocent civilians living within geographical proximity to terrorist-sympathizer countries. In this group I do NOT include civilians who willingly harbor or subsidize terrorists. Innocent means innocent. Literally. Dilemma is defined as a situation requiring a choice between two evils; any embarrassing or perplexing situation; a difficult choice.

Given this dilemma, I offer the following as a DETERRENT TO TERRORISM, ONE I HOPE WE WILL NEVER NEED TO IMPLEMENT!

As follows:

1) State clearly and regularly to the world that these rules of engagement have been set by the terrorists, not the so-called civilized word.

2) Create a GRID, one that graphically divides the Middle East (primary home of Islamofacism) into blocks, and clearly and regularly make its existence known via the Internet, leafleting and any other viable means.

3) Encourage those citizens of the Middle East almost certianly having knowledge of terrorist individuals, camps, enterprises, etc., to hand them out (as opposed, for instance, to electing them to government office as in Lebanon and Palestine).

4) After an extensive world-wide campaign to publicize the GRID, declare that any and all acts of terror deemed to have originated directly or indirectly from within the GRID or its sphere of influence, will result in one or more blocks of the grid being rendered uninhabitable.

5) Regularly and through extensive means of communications, the U.S. and other interested nations will offer a willingness to attempt to end terrorism diplomatically without implementing these ROE.

And not everything is a diplomatic option. Ideas such as the forced or negotiated imposition of any, single religion upon the world would constitute a deal-breaker.

Am I aware of the ugliness of my own proposal; indeed I am. But my GRID strategy is directed at the tough-talking, indignant man-on-the-street who, in his frustration and vulnerability to political fear-mongering, wants to send everyones kid to war but his own.

It is equally directed at politician fear-mongers themselves, those who also have the power to hand out the blood money. I dont believe in coincidences.

The mere contemplation of such an idea reminds me of how imperfect we are as individuals and as a world. But just the acknowledgment of our shortcomings doesnt eliminate the problems we create for ourselves. I often fear that we are ultimately a hopeless species of hypocrites, and, from my fear occasionally emanates some harsh idea of a solution to things like terrorism.

An idea like the GRID.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    14 years ago

The article is clear ... it's about a "plan."

Discuss what you see as it's merits or drawbacks.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Depends on who gets belted.

Peaceful resolution of differences ... win-win ... is always preferable in my opinion ...

... but it's not always possible ...

As I stated, the U.S. did not impose ROE that used as a strategy, the threatening and intentional taking of innocent lives to advance an agenda (although you know I'd argue that Bush's Iraq war did). Terrorists who "live-by-the-sword" would do well to cease and desist were my plan to be implemented ... otherwise ... many would "die by the sword" because of the dilemma they created.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

I think we would end up where we are at now. Terrorists would simply do what they do now, which is move around and cause havoc.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

In theory this is a good idea . In practice , it seems that terrorists come in small counts from a large number of locations . A better way to proceed might be to pick one particularly troublesome country that would serve as an example to the other countries . I suppose Somalia is a good place to start since they harbor so many pirates .And after it is cleared there would be a lot of nice beachfront property available ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    14 years ago

The reason for the grid as opposed to going after one country, is that it places the entire region in fear every time there's a terrorist attack any where in the world ... and, living in fear that subsequent acts of terror may occur ... and the fear of " ... will my grid block be next?"

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

I think that the "grid" policy works good for Israel but I don't think that it will work for the US seeing it a broad area to cover. Israel is attacked byextremest who usebasically use conventionalweapons so itseasierto trace to its point oforigin. In cases ofsuicidebombersthey knowbasicallywhat are they came from. In our case those that plot against us can be a cell within a country, like any country so do we take out a grid in like France? We do somewhat "grid" attacks with our cruse missiles but howeffectivehas that been. I think our best weapon againstterrorismisintelligence, we need moreforeignersgiving us information so that we can respondaccurately. Spy'sand lots of them. Let's take a good look at how the FBIinfiltratesa group to bring them down.I think that is the only way to win is to have a goodintelligencenetwork.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    14 years ago

I also agree with the Israeli approach of killing the families of the terrorists.

Israel does not do that. What they have done in the past is destroyed the houses of terrorist families-- but I believe that their Supreme Court has even ruled against that--at least in some cases (?).

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

The reason for the grid as opposed to going after one country, is that it places the entire region in fear every time there's a terrorist attack any where in the world ... and, living in fear that subsequent acts of terror may occur ... and the fear of " ... will my grid block be next?"

Ok thanks. You said that the first time but it took me hearing it twice before I got it (duh!).

And in light of Rich's comment, I see how cuttingacrossnationalboundarieswould cause some consternation in the minds of those particular countries. But the "ugliness" youmention is already present in many M.E. countries; keeping that in check is beyond impossible, without tough mindedmeasures.

 
 

Who is online