╌>

How Dodd-Frank Ate The U.S. Economic Recovery

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  43 comments

How Dodd-Frank Ate The U.S. Economic Recovery
IBD EditorialsHow Dodd-Frank Ate The U.S. Economic Recovery7 Comments06:51 PM ETSen. Chuck Schumer gives former Sen. Chris Dodd a fist bump during the Senate Democrats news conference to highlight the fifth anniversary of...Sen. Chuck Schumer gives former Sen. Chris Dodd a fist bump during the Senate Democrats news conference to highlight the fifth anniversary of... View Enlarged ImageRegulation: The Dodd-Frank Act's fifth anniversary this month has received surprisingly little notice. Too bad. It's a pernicious law, one that a devastating new report suggests is largely to blame for our lackluster economy.How bad is Dodd-Frank? One of its main goals, cited by both the White House and the then-Democrat-run Senate, was to get rid of the "too big to fail" doctrine that made some banks too important to allow to go bust.It sounded good at the time. But in fact, it's had the exact opposite effect, leading to a decline in small banks and rising market share for the very largest. A cynic might suspect this was how it was designed to be. But what it's done to the economy is worse.In eye-opening testimony to the House Financial Services Committee Tuesday, American Enterprise Institute fellow Peter J. Wallison said: "I believe that all the new regulation added by the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010 is the primary reason for the slow growth this country has experienced since 2010."For the record, Wallison isn't just another anonymous "expert" or media pundit. He was a member of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission and co-chair of the Financial Reform Task Force in 2009.And unlike many pundits still sounding off, he warned loudly and often in the early 2000s that our banking system was in danger of going off the rails. Later, he warned about Dodd-Frank's many flaws. Both times he was ignored; both times ended in disaster.In the 23 quarters since the recession ended, economic growth has averaged a meager 2.2%.As former Sen. Phil Gramm, an economist, recently noted, if this recovery had merely been as strong as the average post-World War II recovery, we'd have had 14.4 million more jobs, and per person income including children would be $6,042 higher.But that didn't happen, and Dodd-Frank deserves much of the blame, says Wallison. Instead of killing too-big-to-fail, as promised, it imposed massive new regulations on banks.As noted here last week, based on a report by the Mercatus Center, "Dodd-Frank's 27,669 rules are five times more than any other law and more than the total number of new regulations 'for all other laws passed during the Obama administration put together.'"This regulatory siege under Dodd-Frank has created what Wallison calls a "bifurcated" economy.While big companies can still raise money in global financial markets, small companies depend on banks for financing. So despite the Fed's zero-interest rate policy, the new rules have severely limited credit to small companies taking a huge bite out of our recovery.Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/072815-763894-dodd-frank-bank-regulation-killed-economic-growth-after-2010.htm#ixzz3hGCdLeDY Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

More than 27,000 rules ... holy crap . That could tire out a whole room full of lawyers .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The congressional GOP has smothered a more rapid economic recovery

The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (111thCongress)

It may seem odd to bring up ARRA in the context of obstructionismafter all, ARRA actually passed and really was the largest piece of discretionary fiscal policy stabilization ever to emerge from Congress. But its useful to remember that the ARRA passed without one single vote from a GOP Representative, and with only 3 of 41 GOP Senators voting for it (and one of these threeArlen Specterwas a Democrat within the year, in large part because of this vote).

So, they tried their mightiest to obstruct it. Even the opportunity cost of just getting these GOP Senate votes was expensive. These votes were needed to push past the filibuster-proof 60 vote thresholdand its a slam-dunk that ARRA would have been successfully filibustered without them. The price tag of getting these votes was nearly $30 billion in school construction funds stripped out of the bill at the insistence of Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), one of the three GOP votes in the Senate. These funds would have supported roughly 250,000 additional jobs. Further, the final version also included the nearly $70 billion cost of a one-year extension of the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) patcha provision that provided no stimulus at all, since it was done literally every single year, but which was included to woo another GOP Senator, Olympia Snowe. If this amount could instead have been spent on productive stimulus, it could have created roughly 750,000 jobs. In short, just luring the minimal GOP votes needed to pass ARRA in the Senate likely kept it from supporting or creating nearly a million more jobs than it did.

Filibusters of unemployment insurance and routine economic support (111thCongress)

Securing 60 votes for ARRA in the Senate was necessary because virtually every piece of economically supportive legislation has effectively been filibustered since the start of the 111thCongress (in Jan. 2009). In Feb. 2010, Senate Republicans blocked cloture on the HIRE Act (H.R. 2847) and managed to strip down stimulus provisions, paring the bill to about $15 billion in poorly targeted economic stimulus ; the bill originated as the House-passed Jobs for Main Street Act , a $75 billion package of infrastructure investments, aid to state governments, and other job creation measures. That same month, Sen. Jim Bunning (R-Ky.) filibustered the House-passed Temporary Extension Act (H.R. 4691), which would have extended emergency unemployment benefits, COBRA health insurance subsidies for the unemployed, and expanded Small Business Administration loan guarantees, among other provisions. In March 2010, Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) filibustered the Continuing Extension Act (H.R. 4851), a similar package of economic stimulus targeted toward the unemployed. In June 2010, Senate Republicans repeatedly blocked cloture votes on the House-passed American Jobs and Closing Tax Loopholes Act (H.R. 4213), which would have provided infrastructure investment incentives, business tax credits, a summer youth employment fund, and a six-month extension of emergency unemployment benefits, among other provisions. By July 2010, more than 2.5 million workers had lost unemployment benefits for at least a spell of time because Senate Republicans continued to block the Emergency Unemployment Compensation (EUC) program , objecting to typically pro forma emergency designations for routine economic support (i.e., demanding offsetting pay-fors).

Discretionary spending cuts (112thCongress)

At the start of the 112thCongress, incoming Speaker of the House John Boehner (R-Ohio) pledged to cut non-security discretionary (NSD) back to 2008 levels, which entailed decreasing spending by roughly $100 billion (22 percent). Senate Republicans had filibustered an omnibus appropriations bill in Dec. 2010, leaving the U.S. government running on a continuing resolution holding discretionary spending at current levelsan increasingly common practice in an era where partisan divides keep the full congressional budgeting process from functioning. In Feb. 2011, House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) and Appropriations Committee Chairman Hal Rogers (R-Ky.) proposed a budget that would reduce discretionary spending by a prorated $58 billion for the remaining 7 months of fiscal 2011, relative to the presidents budget request (a 21 percent cut on an annualized basis). After negotiating a series of shorter continuing resolutionsall of which cut spending levelsand with a government shutdown looming imminent, House Republicans and the administration compromised on a $1.049 trillion discretionary spending level for fiscal 2011, cutting NSD spending by $38 billion relative to fiscal 2010 levels . Much of the cuts for 2011 were phantom savings (e.g., rescinding funds that would never have been spent), but contrary to too much discussion of these phantom cuts, they had real consequences by substantially reducing the discretionary spending baseline from which subsequent cuts were made because the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) indexes discretionary spending levels for inflation. CBOs Jan. 2011 budget outlook showed the baseline for discretionary outlays revised downward by $351 billion over fiscal 20112021 because of decreased funding levels in continuing resolutions, with an additional $40 billion downward revision in their March 2011 baseline update . The full-year appropriations bill reduced projected discretionary outlays by an additional $122 billion over fiscal 20112021. Cumulatively reducing the baseline for discretionary spending by some $513 billion resulted in deeper and more damaging spending cuts extracted from last summers debt ceiling fight. In short, the GOP had much more success than is commonly recognized in forcing large spending cuts in the first half of 2011.

Hijacking the debt ceiling and extracting the Budget Control Act (Summer 2011)

In 2011, Congressional Republicans refused to undertake the customarily pro forma increase in the statutory debt ceiling, arguing that they would only vote to do so if coupled with much deeper spending cuts than extracted from the CR budget negotiations. And as the Washington Post detailed at great length, this economic hostage-taking was premeditated rather than spontaneous Washington dysfunction, a natural outgrowth of a years-long effort by GOP recruiters to build a new majority and reverse the partys fortunes.

The Obama administration unfortunately acquiesced to the GOP demand that each dollar increase in the debt ceiling be matched with a dollar reduction in spending. To be clear, the GOP members of Congress were not seeking deficit reduction , they were seeking spending cuts . Congressional Republican leadership abandoned negotiations over a deficit reduction grand bargain, first with Vice President Biden , then from negotiations with President Obama . To be clear, we do not think such a grand bargain would have been prudent economic policy, but this narrative does belie GOP claims to be motivated by concerns over large deficits.

Two-and-a-half months after the Treasury Department declared a debt issuance suspension period of unconventional cash-management tools to avoid a default on U.S. debt, the Budget Control Act (BCA) was enacted on Aug. 2, the last day Treasury could avoid defaulting . The BCA proved the second greatest budgetary impediment to recovery in the so-called fiscal cliff, as explained in this briefing paper . We estimated that the first phase of discretionary spending caps would shave 0.3 percentage points from real GDP growth in 2012 and lower employment by 323,000 jobs, as detailed in this briefing paper . Ratcheting down discretionary spending caps will shave 0.4 percentage points from real GDP growth in 2013, decreasing employment by 529,000 jobs relative to pre-BCA law; should they take effect, the second phase of scheduled automatic sequestration cutswhich have been postponed until Marchwill slow growth by an additional 0.6 percentage points and reduce employment by 660,000 jobs in 2013. Again, GOP success in using all legislative leverage at their disposal to force spending cuts has (and will continue) to slow economic recovery.

Blocking the American Jobs Act (Fall 2011)

In Sept. 2011, Obama proposed the AJA, a $447 billion package of infrastructure spending, unemployment benefits, funds for rehiring teachers and first responders, and tax cuts for households and businesses, among other provisions. Senate Republicans filibustered the full $447 billion AJA , and subsequently blocked smaller subsets of the AJA that would have put a dent in the unemployment rate, notably funds to rehire teachers and first responders as well as $56 billion worth of infrastructure investments. All variations of the AJA would have been financed with surtaxes on millionairesmeaning that long-run deficits would actually be reduced by the AJA. President Obama proposed another variation of the AJA in his fiscal 2013 budget, which we estimated would have lowered the unemployment rate roughly half a percentage point . Congress only enacted a scaled back extension of the payroll tax cut (the AJA would have expanded it for workers and employers) and EUC (Congress unwisely lowered the maximum duration of benefits in high unemployment states from 99 weeks to 73 weeks in the midst of a long-term unemployment crisis). We estimated that full passage of the AJA would have boosted real GDP growth by 1.4 percentage points and employment by more than 1.6 million jobs by the end of 2012, relative to the scaled back extension of ad hoc stimulus that made it through Congress.

Demanding offsets and pay-fors

As noted above, the AJA was scuttled by Senate Republicans demands that stimulus spending be offset to make it deficit neutralbut they demanded this offset come only in the form of spending cuts, not tax increases. All economic evidence shows that this is a deeply counterproductive demand . Nonetheless, Senate Republicans proposed paying for an extension of the payroll tax cut by cutting federal employees pay and reducing federal employment by hundreds of thousands of jobsboth of which would reduce aggregate demand. An additional $231 billion in spending cuts would have been layered on top of the discretionary spending cuts Republicans extracted with the BCAto more than pay for a $120 billion tax cut. (The purpose of a pay-for is to offset the cost of a policy, not its beneficial impact .) The payroll tax cut was eventually extended with an emergency designation (i.e., deficit-financed), but other demands for offsets will take a toll on aggregate demand. In 2010, a $26 billion package of aid to state governments for rehiring teachers and helping states pay for Medicaid (H.R. 1586) was partially paid for by rescinding $12 billion from the Recovery Acts expansion of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP, or food stamps). Food stamps, by the way, yield the highest fiscal multiplier of any fiscal stimulus, according to Moodys Analytics chief economist Mark Zandi . Most recently, House Republicans have proposed replacing sequester cuts to the Department of Defensepart of the Republicans price for raising the debt ceiling in 2011with even deeper domestic spending cuts ; the Spending Reduction Act of 2012 (H.R. 6684) would have replaced $98 billion of defense cuts with $334 billion in nondefense discretionary and mandatory spending cuts as well as revenue.

Hamstringing monetary policy

The congressional GOP does not have a direct means of obstructing expansionary monetary policy, of course, but their constant strategy in recent years has been to decry any attempt by the Federal Reserve to boost economic activity as dangerously inflationary. Some have even gone so far as to argue that the Fed should have its mandate changed to target only price stability and not full-employment. Needless to say, this claim that the Fed has been recklessly aggressive in trying to lower unemployment is clearly wrong . The Fed has actually been more aggressive than other macroeconomic policymakers in trying to address the crisis, its true. But thats a very low bar , and the congressional GOP have consistently tried to push back against even this too-mild effort by the Fed to engineer a rapid recovery. While it remains an open question about just how effective more-determined Federal Reserve policy could be to boost recovery, there is no question that the risks of pushing harder on the monetary policy lever to restore growth are deeply asymmetrical: there are huge upsides if it effectively spurs growth and very little downsides if it fails.

Conclusion

Concern that the GOP Members of Congress have a vested interest in slowing economic recovery has been brewing for quite some time. Speaking at Cuyahoga Community College ahead of the election, former President Bill Clinton accused congressional Republicans of deliberately trying to keep the unemployment rate elevated for political gain. Clintons remarks echoed similar comments made by Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) at the Economic Policy Institute during the 2011 debt ceiling fight:

[W]e need to start asking ourselves an uncomfortable question are Republicans slowing down the recovery on purpose for political gain in 2012? Senator McConnell made it clear last October that his number one priority, above everything else, is to defeat President Obama. And now it is becoming clear that insisting on a slash-and-burn approach may be part of this plan it has a double-benefit for Republicans: it is ideologically tidy and it undermines the economic recovery, which they think only helps them in 2012.

For those closely watching the budgetary and economic policy fights of the past four years, its pretty hard to refute the analysis of Clinton and Schumer.

Yes, it's copied and pasted; think of it as SPECIFIC REBUTTAL WITH CITATION!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

A blog that offers more specifics than does your article.

Just address the specifics rather than evade them. Righteous indignation is b.s. . Did any of the events in my post not actually occur? Respond it's a yes or no deal.

If you can't defend your position you have no VIABLE position.

Address each one specifically or back off.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I don't think your paste job is accurate .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I don't think your paste job is accurate .

I respect the fact that you disagree.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

XXJefferson#51

Why not respond with some thoughtful counter arguments?

It is funny that you call AMac's post left wing propaganda when yours is no more than reactionary propaganda from AEI and IBD. Somewhere between lies the truth of the matter, just that you seem to have trouble discerning the truth and prefer to wallow in the slanted, partisan filth published by IBD and the like.

As to the specifics of the article:

American Enterprise Institute fellow Peter J. Wallison said: "I believe that all the new regulation added by the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010 is the primary reason for the slow growth this country has experienced since 2010."

The editorial does not give specifics of how, it merely points a finger and says, "Blame that."

Further, it indulges in a more than a bit of hyperbole:

And unlike many pundits still sounding off, he warned loudly and often in the early 2000s that our banking system was in danger of going off the rails. Later, he warned about Dodd-Frank's many flaws. Both times he was ignored; both times ended in disaster.

Exactly what is the form of the second disaster? Seems a lot like begging the question to me.

From what I have observed, the economy is suffering not from overregulation, but from a lack of demand for products and services.

Why is an economy growing at 2.2% a bad thing? Is it better to have a super heated economy that will implode, leaving the carnage that we saw in 2008?

I just don't think that Dodd-Frank has had the effects that Mr. Wallison has suggested, not the least because he opened his statement with this:

...Phil Gramm, not only the teacher of the chairman of this committee but to my mind the greatest political economist ever to sit in the US Senate...

Balderdash.

The crux of his argument is this: Small buisness is the main provider of jobs in the US economy and small businesses have not been able to get the loans they need to grow because of the regulations produced by the Dodd-Frank Act.

The real question that needs to be answered is this: Is the actual lending of money being hampered by regulation, or is the lack of lending because there have not been the loan applications put in? I see smoke and mirrors from the AEI. If you ignore this question, the argument sounds convincing, but if you take this question into account with the latter answer, the argument that Mr. Wallisonis making falls apart.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

...Phil Gramm, not only the teacher of the chairman of this committee but to my mind the greatest political economist ever to sit in the US Senate...

This boy doesn't know Phil Gramm good thing McCain wasn't elected to the Presidency as Gramm was his economic advisor.

2007 Mortgage and 2008 financial and economic crises

Some economists state that the 1999 legislation spearheaded by Gramm and signed into law by President Clinton the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act was significantly to blame for the 2007 subprime mortgage crisis and 2008 global economic crisis. [16] [17]

The Act is most widely known for repealing portions of the GlassSteagall Act , which had regulated the financial services industry. [18] The Act passed the House and Senate by an overwhelming majority on November 4, 1999. [19] [20]

Gramm responded in March 2008 to criticism of the act by stating that he saw "no evidence whatsoever" that the sub-prime mortgage crisis was caused in any way "by allowing banks and securities companies and insurance companies to compete against each other". [21]

Gramm's support was later critical in the passage of the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000 , which kept derivatives transactions, including those involving credit default swaps , free of government regulation. [22]

In its 2008 coverage of the financial crisis, The Washington Post named Gramm one of seven "Key Players In the Battle Over Regulating Derivatives", for having "pushed through several major bills to deregulate the banking and investment industries, including the 1999 Gramm-Leach-Bliley act that brought down the walls separating the commercial banking, investment and insurance industries". [23]

2008 Nobel Laureate in Economics Paul Krugman , a supporter of Barack Obama and former President Bill Clinton , described Gramm during the 2008 presidential race as "the high priest of deregulation," and has listed him as the number two person responsible for the economic crisis of 2008 behind only Alan Greenspan . [24] [25]

On October 14, 2008, CNN ranked Gramm number seven in its list of the 10 individuals most responsible for the current economic crisis. [26]

In January 2009 Guardian City editor Julia Finch identified Gramm as one of twenty-five people who were at the heart of the financial meltdown. [27] Time included Gramm in its list of the top 25 people to blame for the economic crisis. [28]

Why don't you righties do some homework instead of shilling for the people who screw you? You post every piece of crap from the bowels of Organized Wealth the folks who own your legislators (and shamefully, some of mine).

You boys don't know what you don't know yet you plow along with your zeal-without-knowledge parade of ignorance.

I'll be calling you out every time.

Oh, did you enjoy the $4.00/gallon gasoline Mrs. Phil Gramm brought you that!

January 21, 1993. Wendy Gramm makes first major move to deregulate oil speculation. On the final day of the [George H.W.] Bush administration, January 21, 1993, [CFTC chairwoman] Wendy Gramm approved the rule exempting key energy futures contracts from government regulation and returned a great chunk of the energy market to the grand old days of unregulated futures trading, writes author Antonia Juhasz in the book Tyranny of Oil . The move mirrored the demands made by Kochs lobbying coalition

The Energy Group. Gramm, the wife of then-Sen. Phil Gramm (R-TX), leaves the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and a month later joins the board of directors of Enron.

Learn! Your blind support of the righty con-job is to your detriment as well as mine.

I'm hoping somewhere along the way, you have enough intellectual integrity to feel embarrassed.

See; I'm a little bit faith-based too.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

was to get rid of the "too big to fail" doctrine that made some banks too important to allow to go bust.

It sounded good at the time. But in fact, it's had the exact opposite effect, leading to a decline in small banks and rising market share for the very largest.

There would be empirical evidence of an effect of Dodd/Frank . Is it correct ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Are you contending that "too big to fail" actually was implemented, Petey?

And,

the structure of Dodd-Franks resolution authority is explicitly designed to avoid bailouts . Numerous regulators must approve the activation of this process, and they have to argue that either the bankruptcy code or a private sector alternative to prevent the default arent available or appropriate instead.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Mr. Wallison's statement (in PDF form) can be downloaded here .

He points to the increased regulation and says that as a result, banks have not hired as many loan officers, instead hiring compliance officers to maintain the banks regulatory status. This, he says, has lead to a decreased number of loans approved by the banks which, according to him, has had a chilling effect on the economy and is therefore the main cause of the economy rising as slowly as it has.

All this would be fine and dandy, but he does not complete the chain of evidence by showing 1) that the banks have loaned less money as a direct result of the Dodd-Frank Legislation instead of just retrenching their loan standards to those of pre 2000, and 2) has not shown that the businesses who were in need of loans to expand could not and did not get them as a result of the Dodd-Frank Act. As a consequence of not showing these parts of the argument, the argument is a non sequitur: The conclusion does not follow from the evidence given.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

A blog really? Why not make your own darn seed instead of polluting mine with left wing propaganda?

Are you saying that you don't want any discussions of opposing views? That people on the left should seed their own articles-- and only people who agree should participate there? And, similarly, that people on the right should do likewise-- and only people who agree with them should post there?

make your own darn seed instead of polluting mine

Correct me if I'm wrong, but that statement seems to imply that comments with different points of views are..."polluting"...the discussion?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

So what was it that made your left wing blogs better than my opinion article again?

You post your stuff and I respond with SPECIFIC COUNTER INFORMATION; rather than you countering with specifics refuting mine, you come back with editorial ad hominem crap like

Why should I believe what you respond with any more than you believe what I seeded? Do you think I haven't seen the left side in news and opinion? Why would I seed from a perspective that is 180 degrees different than my own?

That's not making an argument, it's a whine and a rant with no content.

If you can't deal with specific rebuttals, don't fire the first shot.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Everything to you is rhetorical ... is that it ? <==== see that ? Do you know what it means or is every question rhetorical ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Everything to you is rhetorical ... is that it ? <==== see that ? Do you know what it means or is every question rhetorical ?

When you're ready to discuss content and stop putzing around with word games and straw men, let me know.

The issue currently on the table is the realities of Dodd-Frank as applied to "too big to fail."

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

You are acting like an complete ass . I asked a legitimate question & you insist it must be rhetorical . Guess what , it wasn't . Stop being an ass .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

You are acting like an complete ass . I asked a legitimate question & you insist it must be rhetorical . Guess what , it wasn't . Stop being an ass .

And, as anticipated (and he did not disappoint), Petey gets to the "Name-Calling" phase of the debate.

Is there a content-laden segment anywhere in our future?

Stay tuned to find out.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

IBD? Not respected by me when they have lies in their editorials. AEI is a conservative/ reactionary shill for Big Business and laissez faire economic policies that have been shown to work only for the same.

How about you try your hand at shoring up your argument? You Contend that the Dodd-Frank Act has eaten the recovery. Show that. I showed how the argument made by Mr Wallison is flawed. Why don't you try to show how it is not? You know, logical argumentation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

IBD is a well respected financial newspaper. AEI is a very well respected think tank.

"Think tanks" are usually well-respected primarily by those who "think" similar thoughts and who all swim in the same tank.

But let's get specific:

Investor's Business Daily also carries editorials and columns on topics from "economics and government to politics and culture". [5] It carries columns from writers it describes as "On The Left and On The Right", [6] including L. Brent Bozell , Richard Cohen , E. J. Dionne , Victor Davis Hanson , Charles Krauthammer , and Thomas Sowell . Of these columnists, E.J. Dionne and Richard Cohen represent the liberal view, and the others represent the right. Pulitzer -winning cartoonist Michael Ramirez has worked for IBD since late 2005.

Investor's Business Daily also publishes editorials skeptical of peak oil and global warming , often proposing alternate solutions.

And

Some AEI staff members are considered to be some of the leading architects of the second Bush administration 's public policy . [4] More than twenty staff members served either in a Bush administration policy post or on one of the government's many panels and commissions. Among the prominent former government officials now affiliated with AEI are former U.S. ambassador to the U.N. John Bolton , now an AEI senior fellow; former chairman of the National Endowment for the Humanities Lynne Cheney , a longtime AEI senior fellow; former member of the Dutch parliament Ayaan Hirsi Ali , an AEI visiting fellow; and former deputy secretary of defense Paul Wolfowitz , who became a visiting scholar at AEI. Other prominent individuals affiliated with AEI include Kevin Hassett , Frederick W. Kagan , Leon Kass , Charles Murray , Norman J. Ornstein , Christina Hoff Sommers , Peter J. Wallison , and Mark J. Perry . [5]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Posting opposing viewpoints and links to back them are fine. Even a snippet from another countering source is fine by me. I am objecting to the posting of virtually or literally an entire article often longer than the original seed as a response.

Going forward, keep that in mind as you post ENTIRE ARTICLES/SEEDS and doso in multiples.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

If traditional GOP methods had been used to fight the Great Recession, growth would be double what has been and federal debt would have been smaller and its revenues greater.

I can again post the various Republican legislative efforts to sabotage the recovery or you can go back and read it.

Bush's tax cuts for the wealthy while simultaneously borrowing from China to fund the bullshit Iraq War are what destroyed a surplus and created a huge deficit/revenue problem; further, Bush kept the liability off of the books and it wasn't until Obama revealed the truth that the realities came to light.

Further, the sub-prime mortgage debacle, also coming under the Bush-regulators "watch," exacerbated the economic near-disaster.

As a "history major," you should understand the disingenuous and insidious realities of re-writing it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Really? I do that in other peoples seeds? That's what my comment was about as you well know.

It's not about WHERE YOU DO IT, IT'S ABOUT THE FACT THAT YOU DO IT WHILE SIMULTANEOUSLY DECRYING THAT OTHERS DO IT!

This is what my comment is about.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I get it . Every one who takes part has to declare himself an expert ... according to you anyway . I refuse to abide by your arbitrary rule . Answer a question once in a while . All you do is cut/paste massive volumes which you haven't read yourself . I reserve the right to think my questions out loud .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I get it .Every one who takes part has to declare himself an expert... according to you anyway . I refuse to abide by your arbitrary rule . Answer a question once in a while . All you do is cut/paste massive volumes which you haven't read yourself . I reserve the right to think my questions out loud .

Actually, you don't get it. In fact, if anyone poses as the last word the expert, it's you as you regularly conclude that others don't know what you know and you do that by declaration while criticizing those of us who bother to post "massive volumes" -- and then question our integrity by adding allegations like "All you do is cut/paste massive volumes which you haven't read yourself."

I reserve the right to think my questions out loud .

And I reserve the right to question what you refer to as thinking.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

"if anyone poses as the last word the expert, it's you as you regularly conclude that others don't know what you know"

I honestly think you are a complete incompetent when it comes to the subject of science ... especially those involving quantitative studies .

And I reserve the right to question what you refer to as thinking.

Yup still acting like an ass . You are an innumerate poser acting like you understand material when you don't . BTW , you just lied . You don't ask questions . If you did there wouldn't be a problem .

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

XXJefferson#51,

I am still waiting for you to address the specific issue that I raised in my post:

The real question that needs to be answered is this: Is the actual lending of money being hampered by regulation, or is the lack of lending because there have not been the loan applications put in?

Or, quite possibly, could it be because of something else?

C'mon, man. I am giving you the questions. All you have to do is answer them.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I think Romney had the right idea . It wasn't about merely cutting taxes but about revising the structure of the tax code . Businesses need more motivation to reshore from China . No one else had the expertise needed to correctly address the tax code itself . Everyone else is merely focused on rates .

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

And still waiting.....

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Absolutely backwards; by raising taxes on the wealthy, thus being able to reduce taxes on the middle and working classes, it increases the discretionary income of the consumer and infuses money into the 70% consumer-driven U.S. economy.

That in turn generates more revenue by way of more jobs because of the heightened consumerism. Business profit taxes will also provide revenue and potentially ease tax burdens on working individuals. It's win-win-win.

After raising taxes on the wealthiest Americans,

President Clinton oversaw a period of considerable economic growth and expansion during his tenure. In particular, real GDP per capita increased from about $38,000 in 1994 to about $45,000 in 2001 (in real 2011 dollars). [1] The U.S. national debt as a percent of GDP also declined from about 66% to about 56% during Clinton's government. [2]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The average rate of economic growth has been faster under Democratic presidents than under Republicans.

Republicans, like any politicians whose party is out of power, argue that the economy will improve under their watch. But if voters looked at history, thatd be a hard story to sell, according to a new study from the strictly non-partisan National Bureau for Economic Research.

For the past 64 years, since Harry Truman was first elected to the White House, Democrat presidents have presided over stronger economies than their GOP counterparts by almost any measure of economic health.

Its not just GDP, which Making Sen$e has shown is not always the most reliable of economic indicators. Under Democratic presidents, per capita GDP has been higher; job creation has been stronger; decreases in unemployment have been greater; the S&P 500 stock index has been higher; corporate profits have been bigger; and real wages and labor productivity have increased.

During the past 16 presidential terms, Republican presidents have presided over 41 quarters classified by the National Bureau of Economic Research as recessions. Democrats? Only eight.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Reagan lowered the top tax rate to 28% BUT

1. Reagan was a serial tax raiser. As governor of California, Reagan signed into law the largest tax increase in the history of any state up till then. Meanwhile, state spending nearly doubled . As president, Reagan raised taxes in seven of his eight years in office , including four times in just two years. As former GOP Senator Alan Simpson, who called Reagan a dear friend, told NPR, Ronald Reagan raised taxes 11 times in his administration I was there. Reagan was never afraid to raise taxes , said historian Douglas Brinkley, who edited Reagans memoir. Reagan the anti-tax zealot is false mythology, Brinkley said.

2. Reagan nearly tripled the federal budget deficit. During the Reagan years, the debt increased to nearly $3 trillion, roughly three times as much as the first 80 years of the century had done altogether. Reagan enacted a major tax cut his first year in office and government revenue dropped off precipitously. Despite the conservative myth that tax cuts somehow increase revenue, the government went deeper into debt and Reagan had to raise taxes just a year after he enacted his tax cut. Despite ten more tax hikes on everything from gasoline to corporate income, Reagan was never able to get the deficit under control.

3. Unemployment soared after Reagans 1981 tax cuts. Unemployment jumped to 10.8 percent after Reagan enacted his much-touted tax cut, and it took years for the rate to get back down to its previous level. Meanwhile, income inequality exploded . Despite the myth that Reagan presided over an era of unmatched economic boom for all Americans, Reagan disproportionately taxed the poor and middle class, but the economic growth of the 1980s did little help them. Since 1980, median household income has risen only 30 percent, adjusted for inflation, while average incomes at the top have tripled or quadrupled, the New York Times David Leonhardt noted .

4. Reagan grew the size of the federal government tremendously. Reagan promised to move boldly, decisively, and quickly to control the runaway growth of federal spending , but federal spending ballooned under Reagan. He bailed out Social Security in 1983 after attempting to privatize it, and set up a progressive taxation system to keep it funded into the future. He promised to cut government agencies like the Department of Energy and Education but ended up adding one of the largest the Department of Veterans Affairs , which today has a budget of nearly $90 billion and close to 300,000 employees . He also hiked defense spending by over $100 billion a year to a level not seen since the height of the Vietnam war.

So much for " the economy was booming and federal revenues increasing because of 28%.

Instead of making pronouncements and declarations without and specifics, paint the whole picture.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Fewer requests for loans is not the same as loans withering on the vine waiting for approval because of no loan officers, which is what Mr. Wallison's contention was.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Instead of making pronouncements and declarations without and specifics, paint the whole picture.

That's impossible in an over-politicized environment . For example , assigning blame to Reagan while he was pres. does not look at aftereffects the years past his term of office .

 
 

Who is online



100 visitors