╌>

Technician details harvesting fetal parts for Planned Parenthood in latest video

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  15 comments

Technician details harvesting fetal parts for Planned Parenthood in latest video
A technician who said she worked for a company that partnered with Planned Parenthood to harvest fetal tissue said theres incentive to try and get the hard stuff cause youre going to get more money, in the latest undercover video targeting Planned Parenthood.For whatever we could procure, they would get a certain percentage, said Holly ODonnell, identified as an ex-procurement technician for StemExpress, LLC. The main nurse was always trying to make sure we got our specimens. No one else really cared, but the main nurse did because she knew that Planned Parenthood was getting compensated. plannedparenthood2.jpgHolly ODonnell says she worked for six months for a company that procured tissue and organs for Planned Parenthood, which then presumably shipped them to research labs. (Screengrab, Center for Medical Progress video)A technician who said she worked for a company that partnered with Planned Parenthood to harvest fetal tissue said theres incentive to try and get the hard stuff cause youre going to get more money, in the latest undercover video targeting Planned Parenthood.For whatever we could procure, they would get a certain percentage, said Holly ODonnell, identified as an ex-procurement technician for StemExpress, LLC. The main nurse was always trying to make sure we got our specimens. No one else really cared, but the main nurse did because she knew that Planned Parenthood was getting compensated.ADVERTISEMENTGRAPHIC CONTENT WARNING: Click to see latest undercover Planned Parenthood videoThe new, graphic video from the Center for Medical Progress appears to show technicians using tweezers to pick through aborted fetal tissue for baby parts. After one person in the video picks out a pair of intact kidneys someone off-camera laughs and says, Five stars!ODonnell said she fainted the first time she was part of this process and was told by someone in the room, some of us dont ever get over it.If you can somehow procure a brain or a heart youre going to get more money than just Chorionic villi or umbilical cord.- Holly O'DonnellO'Donnell said she worked for six months identifying pregnant women at Planned Parenthood who met the standards for fetal tissue orders and then helped to harvest fetal body parts after abortions at Planned Parenthood facilities.StemExpress, based in Placerville, Calif., supplies human blood, tissue products, primary cells and other clinical specimens to biomedical researchers around the world, according to its website.ODonnell describes the company a different way.Related Imageplannedparenthood1.jpgIn the latest video, the undercover team cites this fee schedule, which it says contains prices a lab will pay for fetal tissue and organs. (Screengrab, Center for Medical Progress)StemExpress is a company that hires procurement techs to draw blood and dissect dead fetuses and sell the parts to researchers, she said. Theyve partnered with Planned Parenthood and they get part of the money because we pay them to use their facilities. And they get paid from it. They do get some kind of benefit.Planned Parenthood has denied selling fetal tissue for a profit, which is against federal law.If you can somehow procure a brain or a heart youre going to get more money than just Chorionic villi or umbilical cord, ODonnell said.The video is the third to be released by the Center for Medical Progress. Like the first two, it contains undercover video of Planned Parenthood officials and associates, but is heavily reliant on an interview with ODonnell.Previous videos show Dr. Mary Gatter, a Planned Parenthood medical director in Southern California, meeting with people posing as buyers of fetal specimens. http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2015/07/28/new-planned-parenthood-video-focuses-on-payment-for-fetal-tissue/?intcmp=hpbt1

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

THE VIDEO IS A FRAUD -- SELECTIVELY EDITED BY AN ENTITY THAT HAS DONE SUCH FRAUDULENT EDITING REGULARLY.

If you are the good soul you present yourself to be, you will stop posting these incessant, insidious partisan lies!

Surprise! Yet Another Planned Parenthood Hoax Video

It's gotten so bad, the NYT editorial board weighed in on the latest fake Planned Parenthood video. And of course devoted Catholic Bill "Loofah" O'Reilly plays his part of the Mighty Wurlitzer production of "There Go Those Evil Baby-Killing Feminazis Again". Via the Daily Beast:

It has only been one week since the last Planned Parenthood sting video was released but Center for Medical Progress founder David Daleiden is already back with a sequel. The first of many, apparently.T he first CMP video of a now year-old conversation among Daleiden, another CMP actor, and Planned Parenthood official Deborah Nucatola was edited to suggest that Planned Parenthood sells fetal body parts for profit, though the full footage revealed that Nucatola was actually discussing the legal practice of fetal-tissue donation and its associated processing costs.

This new video makes a similar claim. Allegedly filmed in February of this year, it shows CMP actorsincluding Daleidenposing as a tissue-procurement company executive in a meeting with Mary Gatter, a Planned Parenthood medical director, at a restaurant. The video has been edited down to a roughly eight-minute runtime and full footage of the conversation had not been released as of 9:30 a.m. Tuesday.

Although mentions of dollar amounts in the conversation may sound alarmingas they were in the first video small payments for transportation and processing are legal in human fetal-tissue donation.

Under 42 U.S. Code 289g2 , U.S. law prohibits the valuable consideration of human fetal tissue, but it does allow reasonable payments associated with the transportation, implantation, processing, preservation, quality control, or storage of human fetal tissue.

In the video, one of the CMP buyers asks for a figure, Gatter suggests $75 per specimen, and then the fake buyer tries to goad her on, saying thats way too low. The video has been edited to highlight specific comments of Gatters that make the conversation seem like a negotiation over profitscomments like, Why dont you tell me what youre used to paying?

This time around, however, the CMP has also included statements by Gatter that debunk the idea that Planned Parenthood affiliates profit from the practice.Were not in it for the money, Gatter makes it clear to the CMP actors at one point.We dont want to be in the position of being accused of selling tissue and stuff like that, she says. On the other hand, there are costs associated with the use of our space, and all that kind of stuff.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

You realize that this is not an opinion article. It is a hard news article about the third video. PP supporters wish these stories about selling of baby parts wasn't really true.

It is an intentional misrepresentation and not only NOT HARD NEWS, but NOT NEWS AT ALL.

Once a premise is flawed, any/all conclusions based on that premise is also flawed and FLAWED BY INTENT WHILE PRESENTED AS FACT IS INSIDIOUS AND DISHONEST.

Using religious zeal as a catalyst for partisan vitriol is hypocritical.

Your zeal-without-knowledge continues to pollute the atmosphere of NT.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Edited or not, only one question needs to be answered. ...is planned parenthood selling aborted fetal tissue and organs? Yes or no.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The Videos, Edited and Unedited

At one point in the unedited video (which was also released by the group), Nucatola says : Affiliates are not looking to make money by doing this. Theyre looking to serve their patientsand just make it not impact their bottom line.

Nucatola also says, No ones going to see this as a money making thing. And at another point, she says, Our goal, like I said, is to give patients the option without impacting our bottom line. The messaging is this should not be seen as a new revenue stream, because thats not what it is.

The footagewas recorded secretly during a lunch meeting on July 25, 2014, between Nucatola and two people posing as employees of a company looking to procure fetal tissue for research purposes.

While eating a salad and drinking red wine, she casually discusses which tissues are valued by researchers and how to preserve thosetissues while conducting abortions. Planned Parenthood President Cecile Richards has apologized for Nucatolas tone and manner of speaking, which House Speaker John Boehner condemned as cavalier in calling for a congressional investigation.

In the edited video, Nucatolasays the cost for fetal tissue specimens wasbetween $30 and $100, depending on the facility and whats involved. She defined specimen as, one case. One patient.

Republicans have focused on those comments,characterizing the practice as a way to profit off abortion:

Rick Perry , July 14: The video showing a Planned Parenthood employee selling the body parts of aborted children is a disturbing reminder of the organizations penchant for profiting off the tragedy of a destroyed human life.

Rand Paul , July 14: a video showing [Planned Parenthood]s top doctor describing how she performs late-term abortions to sell body parts for profit!

Carly Fiorina , July 14: This latest news is tragic and outrageous. This isnt about choice. Its about profiting on the death of the unborn while telling women its about empowerment.

Nucatolascomment, though, isnt evidence that Planned Parenthood or its affiliates are selling body parts or fetal tissue for profit. The full video shows that after Nucatola mentions the $30 to$100, she describes how those amounts would be reimbursement for expenses related to handling and transportation of the tissues. Nucatolatalks about space issues and whether shipping would be involved.

We asked all three candidates listed above whether they believed the $30 to $100 per specimen amount constitutes making a profit from fetal tissue, and we did not receive specific answersto that question.Thechief political strategist for Rand Pauls campaign, Doug Stafford, sent us the following statement in an email:

Stafford, July 15: Planned Parenthood and their supporters in the media are willing to say anything to defend their taxpayer funded abortions and profiteering from selling aborted fetuses. They want to argue about what week they kill a child or how much they do or do not profit? Whats blatantly obvious is that Planned Parenthood is trying to distract from their extremist positions and immoral business.

We also asked experts in the use of human tissue for research about the potential for profit. Sherilyn J. Sawyer , the director of Harvard University and Brigham and Womens Hospitals biorepository, told us that theres no way theres a profit at that price. She continued in an email:

Sawyer, July 20:In reality, $30-100 probably constitutes a loss for [Planned Parenthood]. The costs associated with collection, processing, storage, and inventory and records management for specimens are very high. Most hospitals will provide tissue blocks from surgical procedures (ones no longer needed for clinical purposes, and without identity) for research, and cost recover for their time and effort in the range of $100-500 per case/block. In the realm of tissues for research $30-100 is completely reasonable and normal fee.

Jim Vaught , president of the International Society for Biological and Environmental Repositories and formerly the deputy director of the National Cancer Institutes Office of Biorepositories and Biospecimen Research , told us in an email that $30 to $100 per sample is a reasonable charge for clinical operations to recover their costs for providing tissue. In fact, he said, the costs to a clinic are often much higher, but most operations that provide this kind of tissue have no intention of fully recovering [their]costs, much less making a profit.

Carolyn Compton , the chief medical and science officer of Arizona State Universitys National Biomarkers Development Alliance and aformer director of biorepositories and biospecimen research at the National Cancer Institute, agreed that this was a modest price tag for cost recovery. Compton told us in an email: Profit is out of the question, in my mind. I would say that whoever opined about profit knows very little about the effort and expense involved in providing human biospecimens for research purposes.

Nucatola does make one statement in the unedited video that suggests to critics that some clinics would be comfortable with a payment that was slightly more than their expenses for providing the tissue. I think for affiliates, at the end of the day, theyre a nonprofit, they just dont want to they want to break even. And if they can do a little better than break even, and do so in a way that seems reasonable, theyre happy to do that, Nucatola says.

But immediately after this statement, Nucatola goes on to say: Really their bottom line is, they want to break even. Every penny they save is justpennies they give to another patient. To provide a service the patient wouldnt get. Planned Parenthood told us that she may have been referring to more general operations of the clinics.

SciCHECKinsert

Nucatola repeatedly talks about affiliates only wanting to provide a service to their patients, who electto donate the tissue for medical research, and not having that service impact their bottom lines. She says that its not a new revenue stream the affiliates are looking at and that nobody should be selling tissue. Thats just not the goal here.She says some affiliates might donate the tissue for free.

Nucatola also discusses Planned Parenthood clinics interactions with a tissue procurement company called StemExpress . The companys website says that partnering with StemExpress can be financially profitable for a clinic a point that some conservative websites have singled out. But this also does not constitute evidence that Planned Parenthood is profiting in such a way.

StemExpress, which provides other types of tissue aside from fetal tissue, did not respond to ourrequest for clarification on profitability. It did release a statement on its website expressing pride in its work to advance research and saying it complies with all laws.

According to another tissue procurement company called Advanced Bioscience Resources ,which hasprovided fetal tissues to researchers in a number of federally funded studies , the costs mentioned in the video are reasonable. Linda Tracy, ABRs president,told us in an email that[i]t is difficult to pinpoint the exact cost of tissue acquisition due to the many variables involved, such asthe location of the facility, the specific requests from researchers and any special handling that is required. She said, however, that $30 to $100 is within a comparable range of what ABR pays for reimbursement of costs.

At one point in the video,Nucatola tells the buyers (the actors purporting to represent a fetal tissue procurement company are described as buyers in a transcript provided by the Center for Medical Progress ) thataffiliates wouldnt make decisions about whether to work with a tissue research organization based on money. You could call them up and say, Ill pay you double the money,and theyre almost more inclined to say no, because its going to look bad. To them, this is not a service they should be making money from, itssomething they should be able to offer this to their patients, in a way that doesntimpact them.

She then suggests that these buyers might be able to compete with other companies by offering extra services, such as taking tissue the clinics would otherwise have to dispose of themselves.

In a statement on its website , Planned Parenthood defended its affiliatespractice of fetal tissue donationas standard across the medical field:

Planned Parenthood, July 14: At several of our health centers, we help patients who want to donate tissue for scientific research, and we do this just like every other high-quality health care provider does with full, appropriate consent from patients and under the highest ethical and legal standards. There is no financial benefit for tissue donation for either the patient or for Planned Parenthood. In some instances, actual costs, such as the cost to transport tissue to leading research centers, are reimbursed, which is standard across the medical field.

Richards, the Planned Parenthood president, said in a video response to the controversy: The allegation that Planned Parenthood profits in any way from tissue donation is not true.

On July 21, the Center for Medical Progress released a second, similar video , again featuring a discussion with a Planned Parenthood official in a restaurant. The numbers mentioned in the editedvideo are similar to what Nucatola said. The official, Mary Gatter, quotes a rate of $75 per specimen, and says she was thinking of saying $50. The discussion only reaches $100 because the buyers in the video mention higher prices. At one point, Gatter says that were not in this for the money, and later she reiterates that money is not the important thing.

Though few studies of costs associated with fetal tissue acquisition are available, existing evidence does suggest the prices named in the video are in line with general practices. The National Institutes of Health conducts research with fetal tissue, and in the late 1990s, the Government Accountability Office (then known as the General Accounting Office) looked into the acquisition of such tissue, finding that the direct cost to researcherswas low. GAO said payments primarily went to central tissue suppliers, as opposed to health clinics. In most cases, GAO found that clinics did not charge researchers, but when they did, the cost ranged from $2 to $75. The report did not address how much clinics might have received from central tissue suppliers, which is more analogous to the situation presented in the video.

What Does the Law Say?

In a statement made to CNN , another presidential candidate, retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson, called the practice discussed in the video a clear violation of federal law.The sale of organs, both adult and fetal, for transplantation is indeed illegal, but donation of tissue both from aborted fetuses and from adults is not. And payment for reasonable costs is also allowed under the law.

The video itself highlights a portion of title 42 of the U.S. code , which reads: It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation if the transfer affects interstate commerce. The law does include fetal tissue in its definitions. It says that the term valuable consideration doesnt include reasonable payments for removal, transportation, preservation and other associated costs.

In 1993, a law pertaining to federally funded NIH research was enacted that allows donation of fetal tissue from induced abortions if certain criteria are met. These include that the woman donating is not aware of the recipients of the tissue, and that the abortion timing, procedures or method itself wouldnot be altered for the sole purpose of obtaining the tissue.

The 1993 lawalso says that it is unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human fetal tissue for valuable consideration if the transfer affects interstate commerce. The law again excludes the types of costs Nucatola discussed in the video: The term valuable consideration does not include reasonable payments associated with the transportation, implantation, processing, preservation, quality control, or storage of human fetal tissue.

The American Medical Association echoes this in its ethical guidelines on the issue : Fetal tissue is not provided in exchange for financial remuneration above that which is necessary to cover reasonable expenses.

Why Is Fetal Tissue Scientifically Useful?

Historically, the use of fetal tissue has produced some groundbreaking scientific discoveries. According to the American Society for Cell Biology , a nonprofit representing a large and varied group of scientists, Fetal cells hold unique promise for biomedical research due to their ability to rapidly divide, grow, and adapt to new environments. This makes fetal tissue research relevant to a wide variety of diseases and medical conditions.

According to the Guttmacher Institute, a nonprofit focused on sexual and reproductive health, tissue from fetuses has been used since the 1930s for a variety of purposes. Perhaps most famously, the 1954 Nobel Prize in medicine was awarded to researchers who managed to grow polio vaccine in fetal kidney cell cultures.

In another example, Leonard Hayflick created a cell line from an aborted fetusin the early 1960sthat has been used to create vaccines against measles, rubella, shingles and other diseases. Paul Offit , director of the Vaccine Education Center at the Childrens Hospital of Philadelphia, told the journal Nature in 2013 that [t]hese cells from one fetus have no doubt saved the lives of millions of people.

In more recent years, however, the use of stem cells for therapeutic and research purposes has taken a more central role than fetal tissue. As Arthur Caplan , a bioethicist at New York University, told Buzzfeed News , fetal cells are not a big deal in science anymore.

In spite of the waning interest, it remains legal to donate tissue from a legally aborted fetus, and for that tissue to be used for research purposes.

Editors Note: SciCheck is made possible by a grant from the Stanton Foundation.

Dave Levitan and Lori Robertson

...

ACTORS MISREPRESENTING THEMSELVES AS PART OF A SCEME TO CREATE FRAUDULENT VIDEOS AND POST THEM AS FACTUAL.

Hey, Dude

  1. " Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour" is the ninth (respectively the eighth according to the Catholic and Lutheran count) of the Ten Commandments, which are widely understood as moral imperatives by legal scholars, Jewish scholars, Catholic scholars, and Post-Reformation scholars.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

FYI:

The Center for Medical Progress (CMP) is an anti-abortion political organization founded by David Daleiden in 2013. [1] It receives advice, consulting and funds from Operation Rescue . [2] [3]

Organization

Daleiden, an associate of Lila Rose , James O'Keefe , Troy Newman [3] and Cheryl Sullenger , [4] worked for Live Action for five years, and was the organizations director of research "during the early stages" of the project to make secret recordings of Planned Parenthood clinics. [5] Daleiden went on to set up a group called the "Center for Medical Progress" [6] and registered it as a tax-exempt biomedicine charity. [7] It receives advice, consulting, and funds from Operation Rescue . [3] [8]

The CMP's website initially described the organization as "dedicated to informing and educating both the lay public and the scientific community about the latest advances in regenerative medicine, cell-based therapies, and related disciplines." [9] Amid questions about the group's tax exempt status, the site was changed to state their mission as "a group of citizen journalists dedicated to monitoring and reporting on medical ethics and advances." [9]

Undercover videos

Daleiden set up a fake biomedical research company, called Biomax Procurement Services , and created secret recordings. The edited videos are promoted as showing Planned Parenthood officials "price haggling over baby parts'", [10] however, a Factcheck.org article notes that the full, unedited video "shows a Planned Parenthood executive repeatedly saying its clinics want to cover their costs, not make money, when donating fetal tissue from abortions for scientific research." [11]

In the first video, the senior director of medical services at Planned Parenthood describes altering the abortion procedure to preserve fetal organs. [12] "We've been very good at getting heart, lung, liver because we know that, I'm not going to crush that part." [12] In a second video, a Planned Parenthood official stated that if patients provide informed consent for fetal tissue donation then "If our usual technique is suction, at 10 to 12 weeks, and we switch to using an Ipas or something with less suction, and increase the odds that it will come out as an intact specimen, then were kind of violating the protocol that says to the patient, Were not doing anything different in our care of you.'" [13]

Reception

Sherilyn J. Sawyer, the director of Harvard University and Brigham and Womens Hospital s biorepository told FactCheck.org that "theres no way theres a profit at that price." She wrote that non-profit hospitals provide adult "tissue blocks from surgical procedures" at around $100500 per block, and noted that "$30-100 is completely reasonable and normal fee." [11] Jim Vaught, president of the International Society for Biological and Environmental Repositories said that "$30 to $100 per sample is a reasonable charge for clinical operations to recover their costs for providing tissue." [11] Carolyn Compton, the chief medical and science officer of Arizona State University s National Biomarkers Development Alliance said this was "a modest price tag for cost recovery." [11]

Art Caplan , a professor of bioethics at New York University said that altering the abortion procedures, including moving the child from head-first to the feet first " Breech birth " position, in order to get the organs in the best condition would be a "big no-no." [12] He made the analogy to changing how a doctor cares for a dying patient in order to harvest organs for after they die, instead of taking the best possible care of the patient. [12] Caplan said "that's a huge conflict of interest. ... If you modify how someone dies, that's unethical." [12]

In response, Planned Parenthood said that they may donate fetal tissue at the request of a patient, but that such tissue is never sold. [14] [15] In response to Planned Parenthood, CMP issued a statement saying: "The Center for Medical Progress follows all applicable laws in the course of our investigative journalism work, and we look forward to showing the public more clear evidence that Planned Parenthood routinely profits from the sale of baby parts and changes the abortion procedures it uses on pregnant women in order to do so. Congress and state authorities are right to continue to hold Planned Parenthood accountable for these atrocities against humanity." [15]

A New York Times editorial wrote that the "video campaign is a dishonest attempt to make legal, voluntary and potentially lifesaving tissue donations appear nefarious and illegal." [1] Supporters of Planned Parenthood have complained that the videos were edited, although the Center for Medical Progress released the full, unedited video simultaneously with the much shorter, heavily edited version, [16] [13] along with a transcript of the full video. [12]

Political impact

The videos were shown to Republicans Trent Franks and Tim Murphy two weeks before being made publicly available, [17] leading commentators to note that the timing of the release appears to coincide with a bipartisan bill to raise money for Susan G. Komen for the Cure . [18] Rand Paul and Diane Black introduced pre-prepared legislation to strip Planned Parenthood of all federal funding. [19] On July 14, 2015, House Speaker John Boehner ordered congressional hearings into these practices of Planned Parenthood, and at least one committee committed to scheduling a hearing. [20]

Several Republican Presidential candidates have focused on comments made by Planned Parenthood officials, characterizing tissue donation as a way to profit from abortion: Rick Perry stated "The video showing a Planned Parenthood employee selling the body parts of aborted children is a disturbing reminder of the organizations penchant for profiting off the tragedy of a destroyed human life." [11]

Carly Fiorina declared "This latest news is tragic and outrageous. This isnt about "choice." Its about profiting on the death of the unborn while telling women its about empowerment." [11] Rand Paul posted on Twitter "...a video showing [Planned Parenthood]s top doctor describing how she performs late-term abortions to sell body parts for profit!" and vowed to campaign to defund Planned Parenthood. [21]

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
They released the entire video, so calling it a hoax or fraud is a lie, plain and simple.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

They released the entire video, so calling it a hoax or fraud is a lie, plain and simple.

The fraudulent interviewers were ACTORS from CMP! They used phony ID's and may yet face prosecution.

Any individuals/entities with credibility DON'T MISREPRESENT THEIR IDENTITIES AND MAKE VIDEOS THAT FRAUDULENTLY STAGE THE CONTENT!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

"The folks behind this attack are part of the most militant wing of the anti-abortion movement --- that has been behind the bombing of clinics, and the murder of doctors in their homes and in their churches," she said. "This latest revelation shows that they made an incredible violation of women's privacy. Let's be clear: this group has zero credibility. They set up a fake company, they apparently used fake government IDs, they've faked tax filings and completely falsified what they were about, and have shown they would do anything in their quest to end safe and legal abortion."

Oh, and

A third video deceptively attacking Planned Parenthood has been released, and, like the previous two, the highly-edited video shows no evidence that Planned Parenthood clinics have broken any lawsby allowingwomen tovoluntarily andsafely donate fetal tissue from abortions. Media should know sevenkeyfacts about the video, including that the group behindit may have obtained the footage illegally; that the video features alab technician who admits PPFAonly receiveslegal reimbursement foractualcosts; and that the videois largely about aseparatefor-profit research tissue supply company.

Anti-Choice Organization Releases New "Documentary" Alleging ThatPlanned Parenthood Is Engaging In "Black Market In Baby Parts"

1. Lab TechnicianIn Latest Video Admits Planned Parenthood IsOnly Reimbursed For ActualCosts

2. Center forMedicalProgressMay Have Obtained The Footage Illegally

3. Procurement Companies Like StemExpress Act As "Middlemen," Reimbursing Abortion Providers ForDonationCosts Before Reselling To ResearchersAt HigherPrices

4. Latest Video Cherry-Picks From Previous Deceptively-Edited Videos

5. CriticalRepublican LawmakersVoted To Legalize Fetal Tissue Donations

6. It Is Legal To AcceptReimbursementFor Fetal TissueDonationTo Offset "Reasonable Expenses"

7. ExpertsAgree "There's No Way There's A Profit"For Planned Parenthood

Anti-Choice Organization Releases New "Documentary" Alleging ThatPlanned Parenthood Is Engaging In "Black Market In Baby Parts"

Center for Medical Progress Claims Planned Parenthood Is Participating In "Black Market In Baby Parts." In a video released on July 28 as part of their "Human Capital Project," The Center For Medical Progress (CMP) claimedthat Planned Parenthood is engaging in a "black market in baby parts" and using an "illicit pricing structure" to profit from fetal tissue donations. According to the organization's press release:

The first episode in a new documentary web series features a woman who once worked in Planned Parenthood clinics describing the profit motive involved in Planned Parenthood's sale of aborted fetal body parts, and includes new admissions from top-level Planned Parenthood leadership about the illicit pricing structure.

The "Human Capital" documentary web series is produced by The Center for Medical Progress and integrates expert interviews, eyewitness accounts, and real-life undercover interactions to tell the story of Planned Parenthood's commercial exploitation of aborted fetal tissue. Episode 1, "Planned Parenthood's Black Market in Baby Parts," launches today at:

Episode 1 introduces Holly O'Donnell, a licensed phlebotomist who unsuspectingly took a job as a "procurement technician" at the fetal tissue company and biotech start-up StemExpress in late 2012. "I thought I was going to be just drawing blood, not procuring tissue from aborted fetuses," says O'Donnell, who fainted in shock on her first day of work in a Planned Parenthood clinic when suddenly asked to dissect a freshly-aborted fetus during her on-the-job training.

For 6 months, O'Donnell's job was to identify pregnant women at Planned Parenthood who met criteria for fetal tissue orders and to harvest the fetal body parts after their abortions. O'Donnell describes the financial benefit Planned Parenthood received from StemExpress: "For whatever we could procure, they would get a certain percentage. The main nurse was always trying to make sure we got our specimens. No one else really cared, but the main nurse did because she knew that Planned Parenthood was getting compensated." [The Center for Medical Progress, 7/28/15 ]

Latest VideoAgainShow s Nothing Illegal . Like the two deceptively-edited videosCMP has already released, this latest "documentary" does not include any evidenceof illegal activity on the part ofPlanned Parenthood. Instead, the video once again featuresstrategically-edited conversations that merelyshowthat the organization is being reimbursed for costs associated with the procurement of fetal tissue,which federal lawallows. [ Media Matters for America , 7/14/15 ; Media Matters for America , 7/21/15 ]

1. "Procurement Technician"In Latest Video AdmitsOn Camera ThatPlanned Parenthood IsOnly Reimbursed ForActual Costs

" Procurement Technician" In Edited Video : Planned Parenthood Reimbursed For Donations "Because We Pay Them To Use Their Facilities." At the beginning of this Human Capital Project video (the third video released byTheCenter for Medical Progress), Holly O'Donnell, a former staff member of for-profit biomedical procurement company StemExpress, admitted that Planned Parenthood was being reimbursed for costs associated with thefetal tissue donationprocurement process in accordance with federal law. Speaking about the process, O'Donnell explained that StemExpress "partners with Planned Parenthood and they get part of the money because we pay them to use their facilities and they get paid from it" (emphasis added):

O'DONNELL: StemExpress is a company that hires procurement techs to draw blood and dissect dead fetuses and sell the parts to researchers. They partner with Planned Parenthood and they get part of the money because we pay them to use their facilities and they get paid from it. They get some kind of benefit. [The Center for Medical Progress, 7/28/15 ]

2. CMP May Have Obtained Their Footage Illegally

Portions Of The Third Video May Have Been Filmed In California, Where Secret Recording Is A Crime. According to the Digital Media Law Project, California lawmakesita crime to secretly record someone without their consentwhen the person being filmed has "an objectively reasonable expectation that no one is listening in or overhearing the conversation."The third video released by CMP on July 28 included undercover footage of a doctor identified as"Katherine Sheehan, Medical Director emerita of Planned Parenthood of the Pacific Southwest in San Diego."It is unclear whereSheehan was filmed, but if it was recorded where Sheehanhad a "reasonable expectation" ofprivacy, CMP could potentially becriminallyliableunder the law. [Digital Media Law Project, accessed 7/28/15 ;TheCenter for Medical Progress, 7/28/15 ]

RH Reality Check: Earlier Videos Also Potentially "Violated A Host Of Laws," And Third Video May Violate Patient Privacy. In a review of the first two deceptive videos released byCMP, RH Reality Check noted that at least one of CMP's previous videos was filmed in California, and the second likely wasin part. In addition, they noted Planned Parenthood's concern that some footage was taken in a "highly sensitive area in a clinic where tissue is processed after abortion procedures," which "would be an extremely serious invasion of our patients' privacy and dignity." Portions of that footagemay have beenfeatured in thethird film. From RH Reality Check (emphasis added):

CMP videotaped the conversations with Dr. Deborah Nucatola and Dr. Mary Gatter while they were each engaged in private discussions in restaurants. Nucatola's conversation took place in California; although the location of Gatter's is as yet unknown, she lives and works in California, which suggests that her meeting was also in the state. This fact is incredibly important, because it's very likely that CMP violated California's two-party consent wiretapping law.

[...]

Furthermore, any that were recorded in Connecticut, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, or Washington raise similar concerns, as these states also require that all parties consent to most recordings.

In addition to likely violating California's two-party consent statute, there are serious questions about CMP's invasions of provider and patient privacy. In a letter sent by Planned Parenthood counsel to the House Energy and Commerce Committee, Planned Parenthood disclosed it believed that "on at least one occasion a representative from Biomax was shown a highly sensitive area in a clinic where tissue is processed after abortion procedures." The letter continues, "[W]hile this work is standard and essential during any abortion procedure, any filming in such an area would be an extremely serious invasion of our patients' privacy and dignity." [RH Reality Check, 7/21/15 ]

3. Procurement Companies Like StemExpress Act As "Middlemen," Reimbursing Abortion Providers ForDonationCosts BeforeSellingTo ResearchersAnd Charging Higher Processing Fees

New York Times : Researchers Buy From "Middlemen" Who Reimburse Abortion Providers For Donation Costs Before S elling To Researchers "For Higher Prices." The New York Times reported that companies like those discussed in The Center For Medical Progress' videos are the "middlemen" inthe supply chain of fetal tissuedestined for vital medical research. Thearticle outlined how these companies procure fetal tissue from abortion providers such as Planned Parenthood and reimburse them for associated expensesrelated to donationprior to reselling to researchers with "higher prices that reflect the processing":

Fetal tissue can be used only with the consent of the woman having an abortion. Some researchers receive the tissue from abortion clinics at their own institutions, or from tissue banks maintained by some universities. Many buy the tissue from companies that act as middlemen. Those companies pay small fees, usually $100 or less a specimen, to abortion providers like Planned Parenthood, who say they charge only what they need to cover their expenses. The companies then process the tissue and sell it to researchers for higher prices that reflect the processing.

The fees, which can run to thousands of dollars for a tiny vial of cells, do not break the law, according to Arthur Caplan, the director of the division of medical ethics at NYU Langone Medical Center. [ The New York Times , 7/27/15 ]

4. Latest Video Cherry-Picks From Previous Deceptively-Edited Videos

DocumentaryRelies On First Two Deceptively-Edited VideosTo Leave Out Crucial Context. This video is the third entry in a series released byThe Center for Medical Progress (CMP) and relies heavily on the first two videos -- both of which were found to have been deceptively-edited in order to leave out crucial context. The first was a July 14 video, which relied onstrategic edits to falsely claim Planned Parenthood Federation of America's Senior Director of Medical Services Dr. Deborah Nucatola had discussed how the organization "sells the body parts of aborted fetuses." A second video released on July 21similarly claimed to have recorded a Planned Parenthood official "haggling over" prices for fetal tissue donations and offering to change abortion procedure techniques "to get more intact fetuses." The full, unedited footage of both videos debunked CMP's claims, showing the Planned Parenthood officials explaining thatany variation in the abortion procedure is done pursuant to medical adviceand patients arenotput atadditional risk. The unedited video also showed thatthe compensation being discussedreferred tolegal reimbursement for costs associated with tissue donation. [ Media Matters for America , 7/14/15 ; Media Matters for America , 7/21/15 ]

5.CriticalRepublican Lawmakers PreviouslyVoted To Lift Ban On Fetal Tissue Donations

GOP Lawmakers Supported Legalizing Fetal Tissue Donations. The Huffington Post reported that Congress lifted a ban on fetal tissue donation for medical research back in 1993. According to the report, current Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) was one of the Republicans who votedto legalize the donations, as did Reps. Lamar Smith (R-TX) and Fred Upton (R-MI), "all of whom have condemned Planned Parenthood in the past two weeks for its involvement in the practice." [Huffington Post, 7/24/15 ]

6. It Is Legal To Accept Payment For Fetal Tissue To Offset "Reasonable Expenses"

Federal Law Allows For Donations Of Fetal Tissue With Consent. Federal law regarding the use of human fetal tissue does not prohibitits use for research purposes. [Title 42 U.S. Code 289g-2, Accessed 7/14/15 ]

Factcheck.Org: The Law "Excludes The Types Of Costs ... Discussed In The Video." As Factcheck.org explained, the reimbursement for actual costs that are discussed are legal:

The "sale" of organs, both adult and fetal, for transplantation is indeed illegal, but donation of tissue -- both from aborted fetuses and from adults -- is not. And payment for "reasonable" costs is also allowed under the law.

The video itself highlights aportion of title 42 of the U.S. code, which reads: "It shall be unlawful for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human organ for valuable consideration for use in human transplantation if the transfer affects interstate commerce." The law does include fetal tissue in its definitions. It says that the term "valuable consideration" doesn't include "reasonable payments" for removal, transportation, preservation and other associated costs.

In 1993, a law pertaining to federally funded NIH research was enacted thatallows donation of fetal tissuefrom induced abortions if certain criteria are met. These include that the woman donating is not aware of the recipients of the tissue, and that the abortion timing, procedures or method itself wouldnot be altered for the sole purpose of obtaining the tissue.

The 1993 lawalso says that it is unlawful "for any person to knowingly acquire, receive, or otherwise transfer any human fetal tissue for valuable consideration if the transfer affects interstate commerce." The law again excludes the types of costs Nucatola discussed in the video: "The term 'valuable consideration' does not include reasonable payments associated with the transportation, implantation, processing, preservation, quality control, or storage of human fetal tissue."

The American Medical Association echoes this in itsethical guidelines on the issue: "Fetal tissue is not provided in exchange for financial remuneration above that which is necessary to cover reasonable expenses." [Factcheck.org, 7/21/15 ]

7. ExpertsAgree "There's No Way There's A Profit"For Planned ParenthoodAt Rates It IsReimbursed At

Biorepository Experts: "There's No Way There's A Profit At" Prices Discussed In Video. A July 21 post from FactCheck.org examinedThe Center for Medical Progress' claim that Planned Parenthood is profiting from the fetal tissue donations andcalled ituntrue.Citing the Planned Parenthood official in thefirst video "repeatedly saying its clinics want to cover their costs, not make money, when donating fetal tissue from abortions for scientific research,"FactCheck.org quotes "biorepository" experts explaining that the fees discussed in the video would not generate "a profit at that price":

We also asked experts in the use of human tissue for research about the potential for profit. Sherilyn J. Sawyer, the director of Harvard University and Brigham and Women's Hospital's "biorepository," told us that "there's no way there's a profit at that price." She continued in an email:

Sawyer, July 20: In reality, $30-100 probably constitutes a loss for [Planned Parenthood]. The costs associated with collection, processing, storage, and inventory and records management for specimens are very high. Most hospitals will provide tissue blocks from surgical procedures (ones no longer needed for clinical purposes, and without identity) for research, and cost recover for their time and effort in the range of $100-500 per case/block. In the realm of tissues for research $30-100 is completely reasonable and normal fee.

Jim Vaught, president of the International Society for Biological and Environmental Repositories and formerly the deputy director of the National Cancer Institute's Office of Biorepositories and Biospecimen Research, told us in an email that "$30 to $100 per sample is a reasonable charge for clinical operations to recover their costs for providing tissue." In fact, he said, the costs to a clinic are often much higher, but most operations that provide this kind of tissue have "no intention of fully recovering [their] costs, much less making a profit."

Carolyn Compton, the chief medical and science officer of Arizona State University's National Biomarkers Development Alliance and a former director of biorepositories and biospecimen research at the National Cancer Institute, agreed that this was "a modest price tag for cost recovery." Compton told us in an email: " 'Profit' is out of the question, in my mind. I would say that whoever opined about 'profit' knows very little about the effort and expense involved in providing human biospecimens for research purposes." [FactCheck.org, 7/21/15 ]

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
So, yes, they are.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The video was recorded and selectively edited by members of a political-agenda organization posing as a "medical" organization. The "interviewers" misrepresented themselves using fake I.D.s. . NO LEGITIMATE INVESTIGATION/JOURNALISM IS CONDUCTED IN SUCH A MANNER THEN SUBSEQUENTLY PRESENTED AS "REAL."

You need to stop posting "information" that is rebuttable by way of specific counter-information AND THE DOUBLING DOWN ON THE misinformation while off-handedly discounting it!

JOURNALISTIC ETHICS

Seek Truth and
Report It


Ethical journalism should be accurate and fair. Journalists should be honest and courageous in gathering, reporting and interpreting information.

Journalists should:

Take responsibility for the accuracy of their work. Verify information before releasing it. Use original sources whenever possible.annotate.png

Remember that neither speed nor format excuses inaccuracy.annotate.png

Provide context. Take special care not to misrepresent or oversimplify in promoting, previewing or summarizing a story.annotate.png

Gather, update and correct information throughout the life of a news story.annotate.png

Be cautious when making promises, but keep the promises they make.annotate.png

Identify sources clearly. The public is entitled to as much information as possible to judge the reliability and motivations of sources.annotate.png

Consider sources motives before promising anonymity. Reserve anonymity for sources who may face danger, retribution or other harm, and have information that cannot be obtained elsewhere. Explain why anonymity was granted.annotate.png

Diligently seek subjects of news coverage to allow them to respond to criticism or allegations of wrongdoing.annotate.png

Avoid undercover or other surreptitious methods of gathering information unless traditional, open methods will not yield information vital to the public.annotate.png

Be vigilant and courageous about holding those with power accountable. Give voice to the voiceless.annotate.png

Support the open and civil exchange of views, even views they find repugnant.annotate.png

Recognize a special obligation to serve as watchdogs over public affairs and government. Seek to ensure that the publics business is conducted in the open, and that public records are open to all.annotate.png

Provide access to source material when it is relevant and appropriate.annotate.png

Boldly tell the story of the diversity and magnitude of the human experience. Seek sources whose voices we seldom hear.annotate.png

Avoid stereotyping. Journalists should examine the ways their values and experiences may shape their reporting.annotate.png

Label advocacy and commentary.annotate.png

Never deliberately distort facts or context, including visual information. Clearly label illustrations and re-enactments.annotate.png

Never plagiarize. Always attribute.annotate.png

Minimize Harm

Ethical journalism treats sources, subjects, colleagues and members of the public as human beings deserving of respect.

Journalists should:

Balance the publics need for information against potential harm or discomfort. Pursuit of the news is not a license for arrogance or undue intrusiveness.annotate.png

Show compassion for those who may be affected by news coverage. Use heightened sensitivity when dealing with juveniles, victims of sex crimes, and sources or subjects who are inexperienced or unable to give consent. Consider cultural differences in approach and treatment.annotate.png

Recognize that legal access to information differs from an ethical justification to publish or broadcast.annotate.png

Realize that private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than public figures and others who seek power, influence or attention. Weigh the consequences of publishing or broadcasting personal information.annotate.png

Avoid pandering to lurid curiosity, even if others do.annotate.png

Balance a suspects right to a fair trial with the publics right to know. Consider the implications of identifying criminal suspects before they face legal charges.annotate.png

Consider the long-term implications of the extended reach and permanence of publication. Provide updated and more complete information as appropriate.annotate.png

Act Independently

The highest and primary obligation of ethical journalism is to serve the public.

Journalists should:

Avoid conflicts of interest, real or perceived. Disclose unavoidable conflicts.annotate.png

Refuse gifts, favors, fees, free travel and special treatment, and avoid political and other outside activities that may compromise integrity or impartiality, or may damage credibility.annotate.png

Be wary of sources offering information for favors or money; do not pay for access to news. Identify content provided by outside sources, whether paid or not.annotate.png

Deny favored treatment to advertisers, donors or any other special interests, and resist internal and external pressure to influence coverage.annotate.png

Distinguish news from advertising and shun hybrids that blur the lines between the two. Prominently label sponsored content.annotate.png

Be Accountable and Transparent

Ethical journalism means taking responsibility for ones work and explaining ones decisions to the public.

Journalists should:

Explain ethical choices and processes to audiences. Encourage a civil dialogue with the public about journalistic practices, coverage and news content.annotate.png

Respond quickly to questions about accuracy, clarity and fairness.annotate.png

Acknowledge mistakes and correct them promptly and prominently. Explain corrections and clarifications carefully and clearly.annotate.png

Expose unethical conduct in journalism, including within their organizations.annotate.png

Abide by the same high standards they expect of others.annotate.png

The SPJ Code of Ethics is a statement of abiding principles supported by additional explanations and position papers that address changing journalistic practices. It is not a set of rules, rather a guide that encourages all who engage in journalism to take responsibility for the information they provide, regardless of medium. The code should be read as a whole; individual principles should not be taken out of context. It is not, nor can it be under the First Amendment, legally enforceable.

 
 

Who is online



100 visitors