Ill. Supreme Court: Sex With 17-Year-Old Was Legal, Pictures Were Not
What total bullshit.
Seems to me that the damned state needs to get out of folks cosensual lives.
I have asked this question before, if a man legally marries a 14 year old girl, then takes pics of her, is that illegal.
Wellll, in the incredibly intelligent state of Illinois (you know the state that brought us Chicago), the answer is YES!
So, you can have sex with her, but just don't you dare take a pic of her naked or having sex with you, her husband/boyfriend/whatever!
So tired of fricking nanny state bs.

[[But prosecutors argued the child pornography statute was designed to protect children from the psychological and emotional harm that could result from distributing photos of their sexual activity.]]
Uh ....
[[Memorialization of the sexual act makes permanent an intimate encounter that can then be distributed to third parties. These concerns are exacerbated in the modern digital age, where once a picture or video is uploaded to the Internet, it can never be completely erased or eradicated, the court wrote. It will always be out there, hanging over the head of the person depicted performing the sexual act.
Hollins had argued the photos were meant to be kept private, but the court noted that there is no guarantee the photos would always remain private.]]
Duh ... so make the publication of them illegal , not the taking of the photos ... right ?
LOL
Or how about this, get the hell out of people's fricking lives!
This guy is serving EIGHT fricking years for this, EIGHT years for taking the picture of a girl he was having sex with, LEGALLY!
Sigh.
These prosecutors are NOT protecting the girls . They are protecting their own jobs ...
Just can't help becoming personal, can you John?
For you to demean someone else's intelligence, ANYONE else's intelligence is:
Have you EVER considered that it is you who are not understanding what people are writing?
Everyone but you, right Johnny? LOL
By the way, oh master of all, that would be "IS that complicated."
You're a commie John, doesn't that bother you?
Fact is that you wouldn't know an intelligent argument if it hit you in the ass!
But, hey, what the hell, keep trying to show us your intelligence.
But, try to do it with correct English, alright? LOL
[[The decision says it is illegal to take pornographic pictures of minors. What exactly is your objection?]]
If she can legally have sex then why is she considered a minor ?
LOL, interesting question.
Fact is that the dumbass Ill legislature makes arbitrary decisions regarding the ages which they place in their dumbass laws.
It is really quite that simple.
So, they put a guy away for 8 years for taking pics of a woman he's been banging for some time.
He could have invited a friend over, had HIM bang her as well as watch, and that would have been legal.
The idiocy of government. And John wants it to run our health care and every other aspect of our life!
Bah, humbug.
Huh ?
Got it . No interest in clarification ...
Note to self : Don't ask a confused person for clarification .
You know that this issue is not confined to Illinois , right ? It is a bigger issue than just one state's court decisions .