North Dakota Considers Eliminating Property Tax
Lived in N. Dakota for awhile when I was younger. Worked for a driller, and had a blast.
I love this!
I would like to be able to know that my home, no matter what happens to my income or my life, is not going to be taken away from me because I cant pay a tax, said Susan Beehler, one in a group of North Dakotans who have pressed for an amendment to the states Constitution to end the property tax. They argue that the tax is unpredictable, inconsistent, counter to the concept of property ownership and needless in a state that, thanks in part to wildly successful oil drilling, finds itself in the rare circumstance of carrying budget reserves.
But this is my favorite!
When, Ms. Beehler asked, did we come to believe that government should get rich and we should get poor?
That's it, in a nutshell. That is the lefty policy, the lefty belief, that "government" should get rich and the individuals merely get what government desires to give them.
After all, as lefties here have made clear, we voting folk are too damned dumb to understand the issues, as are our elected reps, so we's just need to shut up and do what those smart folks tell us to do!

Frankly, much of that growth comes from the Fed funds that are provided.
Scary how the tentacles of the Fed have insinuated themselves into every aspect of our lives and every level of government.
Agreed. Frankly, (and I know Perrie will dispute this, but C'est La Vie!) many teachers would prefer it if all of their male students were on some form of dampening drug!
Boys, especially in the early years, are tough to deal with, girls, not so much.
Speaking generally, of course.
The worst situation for property taxes happens when the economy goes south . People's ability to pay is less but the the government bureaucracy does not shrink with it . Why do the always set up gov bureaucracies as if they are made out of stone ?!
But this is not the case in ND right now. They are at a huge surplus. I think that the property owners should always pay a certain amount, perhaps less now due to the surplus. If they're not paying in, there's a chance they'll lose their voice on allocation.
The other issue has to do with doing and undoing legislation. While they're running a surplus, they don't need to tax heavily. But they'll need to recognize a change in a timely manner, so as not to get caught with empty coffers.
The % taxes as a function of the economy that you propose is interesting . Apparently , as the eonomy grows you are suggesting to decrease the %age . That could be accomplished by fixing the amount rather than the %age .
Again , just because ND is experiencing a boom does not mean it will continue . What should be done when the economy shrinks ? How can the gov shrink quickly in response to the new conditions ?
Actually, that is one of the problems with government, lack of flexibility.
Of course, one of the problems with government is, well, flexibility as well.
Government sucks, period. The goal is to have it do the minimum necessary for a society to prosper.
That is, of course, the basis for all the arguments on this forum!
Why shouldn't renters pay Jonathon?
Ah, just shrink. Simple.
Doesn't that require a council vote ? ... and time ? It also requires decisions of what to cut and how much ...
I'd love renters to pay me.
But if your question is whether or not renters should pay property tax, I'd point out that someone owns that property, and they're paying the appropriate tax on that property, and passing the expense on to the renter (if they know what they're doing).
And hopefully it will be a tax on the incremental success of the companies that are profiting from the boom there. As the boom subsides, the tax revenue will subside. That's why they have to be careful with the surplus that they are now experiencing.