The Most Radical Policy Idea Yet for 2016
John Kasich, the 16th Republican to enter the 2016 presidential election, has been portrayed as a member of the GOPs moderate wing, mostly because of his decision to allow Medicaid to be expanded in his state under Obamacare.
But while Kasich has refused to conform to right-wing orthodoxy when it comes to benefits for the poor, he is actually setting himself up to be the vehicle for the most radical policy proposal this election cycle that actually has a chance of become law.
The Ohio Governors main claim to fame is that he is a seasoned balancer of budgets, first during the Clinton administration when he served as Chairman of the House Budget Committee and helped move the country from deficits to surpluses, and then again as Governor of Ohio, when he lead the state from red to black between 2011 and today. He has also, in recent months, been visiting states as part of the Balanced Budget Forever campaign, which seeks to launch a constitutional convention which would then ratify an amendment to the constitution requiring the federal government to balance its budget every year. Roughly two dozen states have active resolutions calling for such an amendment. With Republicans in control of 69 of 99 state legislative chambers, its conceivable that enough states will pass such resolutions to force a Constitutional Convention to consider the issue.
Despite the fact that Americans generally support the idea of a balanced budget, balanced budgets are, historically, un-American. The following chart from the Tax Foundation shows the past century or so of budget deficits and surpluses, illustrating the fact that the U.S. government is hardly ever in the black:
A balanced budget amendment would also radically change the role of the federal government, at least as it has been understood since the New Deal. Though Kasich fought to expand Medicaid in his state as part of the Obamacare health care overhaul, using his Christian faith as a reason for not forsaking the poor when he had an opportunity to help, a balanced budget amendment would eviscerate the very entitlement programs Kasich has bucked Republican orthodoxy to support.
Thats because federal deficits are necessary during economic downturns to support programs for the poor and unlucky, like Medicaid and unemployment insurance, because tax receipts fall at the same time that people lose their jobs and health insurance. Deficits are also necessary to temporarily support the economy at a time when businesses and consumers are pulling back.
In fact, the whole idea that national debt is a toxic burden that one generation passes onto the other is a fallacy, too. As you can see, our forebears were quite good at racking up debt, but the size of the national debt doesnt affect any individual American materially. Thats because economic growth and inflation usually do a good job of keeping the debt load stable as a percentage of GDP even when the federal government consistently runs deficits.
Therefore, a constitutional amendment requiring a balanced budget at least the kind that Kasich is after would be a disaster, because it would hamstring the federal government and prevent it from supporting the economy when that support is needed the most. But it wouldnt have to be. Conservative economists Glen Hubbard and Tim Kane, in their 2013 book Balance , proposed a balanced budget amendment that would require revenues and expenditures to match only over a long time period, like 10 years. A more flexible amendment could conceivably give the federal government the flexibility it needs while still reassuring conservatives that, over the long run, we will live within our means.
http://fortune.com/2015/07/22/this-is-the-most-un-american-policy-idea-in-the-2016-election/?xid=timehp-popular

I thin the idea of a balanced budget in principle is a great idea and there are any on the left that point often and with pride to the fact that Bill Clinton turned a deficit budget situation into a surplus situation (more than balanced)
The author makes a good point though about whether the budget should be balanced annually or over a longer period
The arguments about spending reduction, tax increases, elimination of waste and redundancy, etc etc are many and all valid, but the question of whether it is better to have balance budget (over whatever period)seems worthy of discussion
And so long as people like to simply pontificate their view of why something cannot be then there will be no discussions which lead to compromises that benefit everyone.
Some people have no vision that things could better
If I'm not mistaken , US economic history consists of wars during which the govt ran a deficit followed by peace during which there was progress in moving back towards solvency ... Unless there are plans to make war illegal I expect there will be budget deficits .
Petey
That was the point of made in the article that perhaps a rolling period of perhaps ten years would be appropriate for balancing budgets rather than an annual balancing.
We conduct contingency operations rather than wars nowadays, but I think the point is the same.