╌>

A Tale Of Two Economies — Healthy Private Sector, Sick Public Sector

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  8 comments

A Tale Of Two Economies — Healthy Private Sector, Sick Public Sector
Is America is the next Greece or Detroit or Puerto Rico? Unequivocally, no. The U.S. economy especially the private sector is structurally very healthy.That wasn't the case on the eve of the great financial meltdown of 2008, when American companies and households were leveraged up to their eyebrows. What's different today from eight years ago is that now it's the government that's in the fiscal intensive care unit while companies and households have rebooted.The stunning improvement in business and family balance sheets is arguably the most impressive and underreported characteristic of this U.S. recovery. The latest government statistics indicate that the private sector has massively deleveraged following the debt binge from 2000 to 2008.In the last seven years, U.S. companies have become hyper- and even ruthlessly efficient, which has meant shedding unproductive operations and reducing employment, cutting debt burdens and focusing on profitability.It's the reason that the stock market has soared since 2008. Companies are now sitting on $1 trillion to $2 trillion in reserve cash, and balance sheets are generally pristine. Households have cut their debts, too.But the borrowing statistics from the Bureau of Economic Analysis and compiled by economist David Malpass of Encima Global also show that one sector of the economy has been largely immune from this American deleveraging crusade: the government.When private-sector debt burdens have flattened out and even fallen, the government debt has doubled to $16 trillion. If there's a fundamental structural weakness in the economy that's holding back growth, this is it.As the private sector has become lean and cost-conscious, government has become flabbier and more dependent than ever on debt. The numbers are even worse for government when including trillions of dollars of unfunded liabilities in pension and health-care obligations.(The statistics on borrowing also don't include the $4 trillion of assets now on the balance sheet of the Fed.)The government's borrowing binge didn't happen by accident. It was by design. Back in 2008 and 2009 the Keynesian economic modelers advised government that with the economy in collapse, now was the time to borrow even more money (government debt already had climbed from $5 trillion to $8 trillion from 2000 to 2008) to prop up demand for goods and services.On the face of it, this theory was always a non sequitur. Since unprecedented borrowing created the financial crisis in the first place, how could more debt spending by Washington be the solution? It wasn't.One summer after another has passed without a robust recovery, and we are now $1.5 trillion behind the average recovery in GDP growth.When I recently debated Paul Krugman of the New York Times and showed him these statistics, he argued that it was a good thing the government borrowed so much when the private sector was deleveraging, or else the economy would have collapsed again.He argues that the reason the Obama stimulus failed was that it was too small and the $7 trillion in federal borrowing should have been as much as twice as large. This is the best the deep thinkers of the left can come up with.Borrowing isn't inherently bad; it depends a lot on what the debt is financing. But under Obama, government bought all the wrong things.Huge increases in debt went to finance welfare programs such as food stamps; housing subsidies; unemployment insurance; ObamaCare subsidies; green energy failures such as Solyndra; giveaway tax credits; high speed rail to nowhere in California and the like.The rate of return on these "investments" was close to zero. Very little was used to increase the productive capacity of the nation through tax cuts or even infrastructure improvements.It turns out the borrowing blitz led to fewer jobs and less output than the administration predicted we'd see if we hadn't spent $830 billion in 2008 on the "stimulus" in the first place. It was a fiscal drag, not a fiscal stimulus.Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-on-the-right/072215-762915-while-private-sector-thrives-public-sector-dives.htm#ixzz3gisBDmWR Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The headline posits a flawed conclusion;

The REALITY is that the Private Sector was BAILED OUT WITH PUBLIC SECTOR (i.e. TAXPAYER) DOLLARS, that, because THE PRIVATE SECTOR IS CORRUPT AND WHEN CAUGHT IN CORRUPT PRACTICES, more often than not BENEFITS FROM CORPORATE LOBBYING THAT INFLUENCES THE WRITING OF THE TAX CODE IN A WAY THAT BENEFITS THE PRIVATE SECTOR, AT THE EXPENSE OF THE PUBLIC.

What is it with your incessant siding with Organized Wealth at the expense of the working person?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

And yet you consistently rail against those who work and live on "Main Street".

And perhaps your apparently greatest misunderstanding is with regard to just who are the "job-creators". They are NOT EMPLOYERS, rather, it is the CONSUMER that drives our 70% consumer-driven economy.

The more disposable income available to the working-poor and middle class, the more spending, thus more business profit and corresponding tax revenue, thus more jobs, thus fewer unemployed, thus fewer on welfare.

Until you allow this reality to color your posits, you are either the willing or duped water carrier for Organized Wealth.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

So how are there consumers to buy things if not for the jobs they have provided by their employer.

Without consumers/customers/buyers/clients there are no employers; and the roads, power, police and fire personnel, etc. none of that exists without the taxpayer/consumer.

I certainly agree that metaphorically, one hand washes the other, but remove the consumer from the picture and there are no employers.

Our consumption of goods obviously is a function of our culture. Only by producing and selling things and services does capitalism in its present form work, and the more that is produced and the more that is purchased the more we have progress and prosperity.

The single most important measure of economic growth is, after all, the gross national product (GNP), the sum total of goods and services produced by a given society in a given year. It is a measure of the success of a consumer society, obviously, to consume.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

government austerity and private-sector expansion are the way to prevent America from becoming the next Greece.

Absolutely NOT the case; austerity in an economic downturn kills any recovery due to lack of stimulus!

  • Direct government intervention during recessions, either through deficit-financed taxcuts or deficit-financed increases in government spending, is a more powerful tool forfighting recessions than we realized before the Great Recession.
  • In a slack economy, or one that is operating below its potential, austeritytakingmoney out of the economy to balance government budgetsis especially bad policy. Whether via tax hikes or cuts in government spending, contracting the governmentsbudget during a recession reduces gross domestic product, or GDP, by more than thesize of the cutspossibly as much as three times more.
  • The costs of doing nothing can be permanent and much higher than we previouslythought: U.S. GDP is currently 10 percent below its prerecession 2014 projection,and many economists believe that we have reached a new normal. If this is true, austeritycould cost the U.S. economy more than $1 trillion in economic activity everyyear, even after we have fully recovered from the Great Recession.
 
 

Who is online





Dismayed Patriot


65 visitors