Criminalizing Lies -- An Unusual Free Speech Case in Supreme Court
People tell lies. Even politicians tell lies. And sometimes lies are punished; just ask Martha Stewart, "Scooter" Libby, and Bill Clinton. Lying involves speech, but the First Amendment's protection of speech provides no refuge for some lies, notably false statements to government, defamatory falsehoods, fraud, perjury, false advertising, baseless litigation, and false-light torts. There are other categories of speech that enjoy no First Amendment protection, such as obscenity, hate speech, and speech that is integral to criminal conduct such as conspiracy and threats, but these categories typically do not involve the criminalization of lies. And, needless to say, drawing lines between lawful lies and criminal lies is not easy.

Yup, what a creep!
I'm surprised that this had to go all the way to SCOTUS . Is this about the constitutionality of that act ?
It seems that they can't figure out how far to allow freedom of speech. When does a lie become criminal?