╌>

Seattle sees fallout from $15 minimum wage, as other cities follow suit

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  35 comments

Seattle sees fallout from $15 minimum wage, as other cities follow suit
Seattles $15 minimum wage law is supposed to lift workers out of poverty and move them off public assistance. But there may be a hitch in the plan.Evidence is surfacing that some workers are asking their bosses for fewer hours as their wages rise in a bid to keep overall income down so they dont lose public subsidies for things like food, child care and rent. Full Life Care, a home nursing nonprofit, told KIRO-TV in Seattle that several workers want to work less.If they cut down their hours to stay on those subsidies because the $15 per hour minimum wage didnt actually help get them out of poverty, all youve done is put a burden on the business and given false hope to a lot of people, said Jason Rantz, host of the Jason Rantz show on 97.3 KIRO-FM.The twist is just one apparent side effect of the controversial -- yet trendsetting -- minimum wage law in Seattle, which is being copied in several other cities despite concerns over prices rising and businesses struggling to keep up.The notion that employees are intentionally working less to preserve their welfare has been a hot topic on talk radio. While the claims are difficult to track, state stats indeed suggest few are moving off welfare programs under the new wage.Despite a booming economy throughout western Washington, the states welfare caseload has dropped very little since the higher wage phase began in Seattle in April. In March 130,851 people were enrolled in the Basic Food program. In April, the caseload dropped to 130,376.At the same time, prices appear to be going up on just about everything.Some restaurants have tacked on a 15 percent surcharge to cover the higher wages. And some managers are no longer encouraging customers to tip, leading to a redistribution of income. Workers in the back of the kitchen, such as dishwashers and cooks, are getting paid more, but servers who rely on tips are seeing a pay cut.Some long-time Seattle restaurants have closed altogether, though none of the owners publicly blamed the minimum wage law.Its what happens when the government imposes a restriction on the labor market that normally wouldnt be there, and marginal businesses get hit the hardest, and usually those are small, neighborhood businesses, said Paul Guppy, of the Washington Policy Center.Seattle was followed by San Francisco and Los Angeles in passing a $15 minimum wage law. The wage is being phased in over several years to give businesses time to adjust. The current minimum wage in Seattle is $11. In San Francisco, its $12.25.And it is spreading. Beyond the city of Los Angeles, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors this week also approved a $15 minimum wage.New York state could be next, with the state Wage Board on Wednesday backing a $15 wage for fast-food workers, something Gov. Andrew Cuomo has supported.Already, though, there are unintended consequences in other cities. http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2015/07/22/seattle-sees-fallout-from-15-minimum-wage-as-other-cities-follow-suit/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Just read this. Who could have predicted it would turn out like this........?
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

/s

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

LOL...

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Sometimes, jennilee, "I told you so" is so hard to keep to yourself, isn't it?

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Yes it is, mimi, yes it is.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

SORRY RIGHTIES, SEATTLE RESTAURANT CLOSURES ARE NOT DUE TO $15 MINIMUM WAGE

Why are Seattle restaurants closing?

It is true that Seattle is seeing a large number of restaurants closing their doors. So, what exactly is going on, if its not the new minimum wage? Its a variety of things. According to Seattle Magazine, Anthony Anton, the head of the Washington Restaurant Association, says that each year, about 17 percent of Washington restaurants go out of business, or change owners. That amounts to about 400 restaurants in a good year, he says.

Seattle Met highlights some of the closings, and the reasons for them. Renee Erickson is closing her Boat Street Cafe so that she can concentrate on two other restaurants , both of which she is opening this summer. Wait. Shes closing one, and opening two, and were supposed to believe that the one that is closing is due to a higher minimum wage?

Little Uncle is closing their restaurantbecause they have decided that bigger is not necessarily better. The owners say that the larger location doesnt fit their personal and professional goals. After closing the larger venue, Little Uncle continues to do business out of their original, smaller, take-out location.

Grub, an upscale restaurant highlighted in the right-wing coverage of restaurant closings, closed simply because the owner has decided to move on. Sharon Fillingim explains on the restaurants Facebook page that she believes it is sometimes best for an entrepreneur to leave at the top of [her] game. She makes no mention of the minimum wage increase having any influence in her decision. In fact, contrary to what right wing sites would have you believe, the space occupied by Grub will not be left vacant. Fillingim introduces the new restaurant, Bounty Kitchen, that will take over from Grub, and its owner, in the same Facebook post.

As usual, the right manages to take something, and spin it into something completely different than what it is. While there may be some Seattle restaurateurs who are concerned about the phasing in of the minimum wage increase, none who have been interviewed by media have indicated that as a primary concern, or for that matter, as a concern at all. But, facts be damned, the conservative war on working people continues, unabated.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

ECONOMY

Conservatives Say $15 Minimum Wage Is Killing Seattle Restaurant Scene, Restaurateurs Disagree

MAR 18, 2015 2:26PM

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

It would be nice if the article had some actual facts, instead of the vagueaccusations made.

There are business that have been paying well above the minimum wage for years.

Our corporation paid $4 to $5 above minimum wage back in the 1990's. Right now they are paying $13 to $15 per hour, with full benefits as a starting wage.

What we found that by paying a living wage to new employees with no experience, we were able to draw a more motivated/educated and with a willingness to stay on board with the company. The amount of money we paid out in wages at the minimum level was exceed by cost saving of constantly training new employees because of turnover. Productivity was higher from day one.

This nonsense about minimum wage and paying the less about you can get away with is bullshit. Always has been, always will be.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Was that supposed to "prove" that the minimum wage increase was not responsible for business closings ? I see little evidence and no proof whatsoever .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

So the minimum wage is not $15 per hour in Seattle, as the title says? Or in San Francisco? Or in Los Angeles?

So how could a city see the fallout of a minimum wage that is not there?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

WTF?

Seattle's minimum wage is not $15/hr!

(I knew there was a reason I've been spending less and less time on this site . . . )

Its not even $13 . . .

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Phased in over 7 years, 5 more years to go. By that time the weak business will have phased out anyway. Therefore you will never be able to attribute it to the wage hike.

I'm waiting for pierce county to do it, they are not planning a phase in, an immediate jump to 15.00.

That will tell the tale. (if they ever bring it off, Tacoma/Pierce County isn't anywhere near as socialist as Seattle)

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

In California they raised the min wage from 8.25 to 10.00 in two stages, 9.00 jan 1st and ten next July 1st. Fast food prices went up As soon as the law passed and before it went into effect.

Citation please.

In the interim

California lawmakers vote to raise minimum wage

The proposal by Sen. Mark Leno, D-San Francisco, comes just two years after Gov. Jerry Brown signed legislation giving California one of the highest minimum wage rates in the nation. It is currently $9 an hour and will rise to $10 an hour in 2016.

But Leno said that rate does not reflect the cost of living in California. He says his plan would bring workers to the federal poverty level while stimulating the economy. The measure would boost the minimum wage by an additional $1 in 2016, then to $13 an hour starting in 2017.

"Full-time workers in this state should not be forced onto public assistance simply because they earn the minimum wage," Leno said in a statement.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago
ECONOMY

States That Raised Their Minimum Wages Are Experiencing Faster Job Growth

JUL 3, 2014 11:53AM


CREDIT: AP

Think a higher minimum wage is a job killer? Think again: The states that raised their minimum wages on January 1 have seen higher employment growth since then than the states that kept theirs at the same rate.

The minimum wage went up in 13 states Arizona, Connecticut, Colorado, Florida, Missouri, Montana, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington either thanks to automatic increases in line with inflation or new legislation, as Ben Wolcott reports in his analysis at the Center for Economic and Policy Research. The average change in employment for those states over the first five months of the year as compared with the last five of 2013 is .99 percent, while the average for all remaining states is .68 percent.

Digging deeper, all but one of those states are experiencing increases in employment, and nine of them have seen growth above the median rate.

wolcott-2014-06-30_494

CREDIT: CENTER FOR ECONOMIC AND POLICY RESEARCH

Wolcotts analysis builds on a previous one from Goldman Sachs, which did the same evaluation for just January and compares it to December of last year. It found that the states that had minimum wage increases experienced faster job growth than those without a raise.

This doesnt mean that increasing the minimum wage necessarily creates more jobs. While this kind of simple exercise cant establish causality, it does provide evidence against theoretical negative employment effects of minimum-wage increases, Wolcott writes. Indeed, it adds to the evidence that higher minimum wages may not hurt job growth as much as some have warned . Washington has the highest minimum wage and saw the biggest increase in small business jobs last year. Its job growth has also remained steady and above average in the 15 years since it raised its wage. When economists studied state-level minimum wage increases over two decades they didnt find any conclusive evidence that the raises impacted job creation.

Thats all good news for the ten states that have increased their minimum wages this year. Massachusetts went the furthest, raising its wage to $11 by 2017, but three Hawaii, Maryland, and Connecticut passed the $10.10 minimum wage being pushed at the federal level by Democrats and Vermont increased its wage to $10.50. And some cities have gone even further, with Seattle enacting a $15 minimum wage .

Progress in raising the entire countrys minimum wage has stalled, though. Republicans blocked a bill that would have increased it to $10.10 an hour.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

States with right to work laws grow faster than coerced Union states too.

That is factually not validated

'Right-to-Work' Economics

States That Bar Mandatory Union Dues Tend Toward More Jobs but Lower Wages

...

And since the Right-to-Work states are primarily RED STATES, how do you explain

As it turns out, it is red states that are overwhelmingly the Welfare Queen States. Yes, that's right. Red States the ones governed by folks who think government is too big and spending needs to be cut are a net drain on the economy, taking in more federal spending than they pay out in federal taxes. They talk a good game, but stick Blue States with the bill.

Take a look at the difference between federal spending on any given state and the federal taxes received from that state. We measure the difference as a dollar amount: Federal Spending per Dollar of Federal Taxes. A figure of $1.00 means that particular state received as much as it paid in to the federal government. Anything over a dollar means the state received more than it paid; anything less than $1.00 means the state paid more in taxes than it received in services. The higher the figure, the more a given state is a welfare queen.

Of the twenty worst states, 16 are either Republican dominated or conservative states. Let's go through the top twenty.

  • New Mexico: $2.03
  • Mississippi: $2.02
  • Alaska: $1.84
  • Louisiana: $1.78
  • West Virginia: $1.76
  • North Dakota: $1.68
  • Alabama: $1.66
  • South Dakota: $1.53
  • Kentucky: $1.51
  • Virginia: $1.51
  • Montana: $1.47
  • Hawaii: $1.44
  • Maine: $1.41
  • Arkansas: $1.41
  • Oklahoma: $1.36
  • South Carolina: $1.35
  • Missouri: $1.32
  • Maryland: $1.30
  • Tennessee: $1.27
  • Idaho: $1.21

Does anyone else notice the overwhelming presence of northern "ruggedindividualist" states, like Alaska, the Dakotas and Montana, along with most of the South? Why it's almost like there's a pattern here or something.

Where can we find liberal bastions California, New York, and Massachusetts? California is 43rd, getting back only $0.78 for every dollar it sends to Washington. New York is 42nd, and one penny better off, at $0.79 per dollar. Massachusetts is 40th, receiving $0.82 for every dollar it sends to DC.

Go ahead and bookmark this article. The next time some smarmy teabagger tries to tell you it's liberals who are ruining the country and spending us into oblivion, kindly point them to the evidence that shows it is GOP states, not Democrat states, who are Welfare Queens. It is GOP states who spend more than they collect in taxes. It is GOP states who are out of balance, nationally.

See if they still want to cut off funding when it means no more socialism for slave states.


Read more: ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Slave states? Really?

Interesting how the once-slave states, for the most part are today's Red States and primarily the "right-to-work" states.

So, from an (pardon the expression) "evolutionary" perspective, yeah, really!

For clarity sake match 'em up. Note the tell-tale alignment of then and now.

Toss in W. Virginia as a slave state and California, Minnesota, Oregon and Kansas as free states.

Before proceeding

to pay some money for doing a job or task that is around minimum wage or below and offer them no dignity or appreciation.
Slave States Year Free States Year
Mississippi 1817 Indiana 1816
Alabama 1819 Illinois 1818
Missouri 1821 Maine 1820
Arkansas 1836 Michigan 1837
Florida 1845 Iowa 1846
Texas 1845 Wisconsin 1848
Slave States Year Free States Year
Delaware 1787 New Jersey (Slave until 1804) 1787
Georgia 1788 Pennsylvania 1787
Maryland 1788 Connecticut 1788
South Carolina 1788 Massachusetts 1788
Virginia 1788 New Hampshire 1788
North Carolina 1789 New York (Slave until 1799) 1788
Kentucky 1792 Rhode Island 1790
Tennessee 1796 Vermont 1791
Louisiana 1812 Ohio 1803
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

What is factual is that large Japanese companies like to build their factories in the southern states that used to be slave states . As a result labor growth tends to favor such states .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

What about Wisconsin, Indiana, Michigan as well as the plains states, Kansas, Nebraska, the Dakotas and the mountain west?

I'm so glad you asked; read on and you'll see.

Right to Works Dark Side Low Wages, Economic Decline

DECEMBER 17, 2012

Michigan Republicans are pushing low wages, claiming that right-to-work laws will attract businesses. Does it work?

Conservatives argue that strong unions cost jobs and anti-union right-to-work laws will bring jobs, because companies will move to places where workers are less able to fight for good pay and benefits . What do the numbers tell us?

Last week the far-right CNSNews carried a post, Right To Work States Have Lower Unemployment, Higher Income and Healthcare Coverage, NRTW President Says , quoting the head of the corporate-funded, anti-union organization, National Right To Work. He claimed that passing right-to-work laws not only increases employment but actually increases wages and benefits.

Mix notes that workers in Right to Work states not only tend to have as much as $4,300 more purchasing power, but also are more likely to have health insurance:

And if you look at the other 22 Right to Work states, you find when it relates to private sector job growth, when it relates to increase in private sector per-capita purchasing power, or adjusted for cost of living, you find those states are doing much better.

So, theres lots of data out there that talks about this, including a study from the George Mason Department of Economics. They did a study when, adjusting wages for cost of living, they found workers in Right to Work states have about $2,300 more to spend than workers in forced-unionism states.

More on this in a minute

The Detroit Free Press took a deeper look at the numbers, in Right-to-work laws impact on Michigan debatable based on other states , and found that it was inconclusive. While they fond that some right-to-work states do have lower unemployment, the reasons are not clear.

You can cherry-pick individual states that have done well, said Michael Hicks, director of the Center for Business and Economic Research at Ball State University in Muncie, Ind. What nobody has done is report convincing, statistical evidence that right-to-work by itself makes a statistically discernible difference in economic outcomes, whether for good or ill.

Hicks studied right-to-work laws and their effects on manufacturing. His findings: Right-to-work can indicate a more accommodating business climate, but the law itself will not attract more manufacturing or result in better wages or employment numbers.

Another factor to consider is the race-to-the-bottom effect asotherstates (like Alabama) suppress unionseven more, forcing wageseven lower, and also offer tax incentives to attract businesses. From the Detroit Free Press report,

The Economic Policy Institute, a Washington-based liberal think tank, published an article last week about Indianas right-to-work experience that highlighted tax credits and state assistance packages as a less-hyped factor in some businesses expansion decisions.

The article noted how Busche Enterprise obtained $750,000 in assistance from the Indiana Economic Development Corp., the states main economic development agency and recruiter. The article also noted that Indianas right-to-work law didnt keep Busche from recently acquiring another plant site in October for a separate project in Alabama, its first non-Indiana production site.

Indiana offered up the moon, but Alabama offered up the moon and the stars , so they went with Alabama.

Neither the Detroit Free Press nor CNSNews factored in that their statistics were influenced by states like North Dakota that are currently enjoying an energy boom. Also, this idea that these low-wage states have a lower cost-of-living is another way of saying that they are poor.

And they are poor because their leadership is offering them up as low-wage states to attract businesses.

Energy Boom States

Advocates of pushing down wages and suppressing workers rights use numbers that include the gains in energy-boom states to make their point.

The statistics that show job and wage growth in RTW states rely heavily on gains in North Dakota, Wyoming and otherstates that are currently having an energy boom .This would clearly indicate that the gains have nothing to do with suppression of unions. (Unless suppressing unions causes supplies of energy to suddenly appear under the ground.)

Note which states show significant job and wage gains in the Detroit Free press report :

Right-to-work states added a total of nearly 2 million jobs a 3.4% increase over that period. The big winners were North Dakota (21.8% jump), Wyoming (15.8%), Utah (12%) and Texas (11.5%).

Meanwhile, employment dropped by 2 million jobs in non-right-to-work states, or a 2.5% decrease.

The average annual pay in right-to-work states grew from $30,172 to $41,243 from 2001 to 2011, a 36.7% increase.

Average pay in the other states rose 32.4%, from $35,505 to $47,002.

Obviously the employment and good wages in energy-boom states swings the averages. But this has nothing to do with right-to-work union-suppression laws.

Other Studies

There have been some good studies of the effect of these union-suppression laws apart from the energy-boom effect occurring in states like North Dakota.

A Feb., 2011, Economic Policy Institute (EPI) study, Does right-to-work create jobs? Answers from Oklahoma , found overwhelming evidence:

Despite ambitious claims by proponents, the evidence is overwhelming that:

Right-to-work laws have not succeeded in boosting employment growth in the states that have adopted them.

The case of Oklahoma closest in time to the conditions facing those states now considering such legislation is particularly discouraging regarding the laws ability to spur job growth. Since the law passed in 2001, manufacturing employment and relocations into the state reversed their climb and began to fall, precisely the opposite of what right-to-work advocates promised.

For those states looking beyond traditional or low wage manufacturing jobs whether to higher-tech manufacturing, to knowledge sector jobs, or to service industries dependent on consumer spending in the local economy there is reason to believe that right-to-work laws may actually harm a states economic prospects.

A Sept., 2011, study, also by EPI, Right to work, The wrong answer for Michigans economy , found that,

Right-to-work laws lower wagesfor both union and nonunion workers alikeby an average of $1,500 per year, after accounting for the cost of living in each state.

Right-to-work laws also decrease the likelihood that employees get either health insurance or pensions through their jobsagain, for both union and nonunion workers.

By cutting wages, right-to-work laws threaten to undermine job growth by reducing the discretionary income people have to spend in the local retail, real estate, construction, and service industries. Every $1 million in wage cuts translates into an additional six jobs lost in the economy. With 85 percent of Michigans economy concentrated in health care, retail, education, and other non-manufacturing industries, widespread wage and benefit cuts could translate into significant negative spillover effects for the states economy.

A January, 2012 study by American Rights at Work, New Research Counters Arguments for Right-To-Work Laws , examined a number of studies and found that recent studies rebut claims of economic growth and instead find that laws suppress wages.

A May, 2011 Bureau of Labor Statistics study found that right-to-work states have lower wages (examples: 9.4% lower for all occupations, 11.4% lower for teachers) than states with union rights.

In Nonunion Wage Rates and the Threat of Unionization Henry Farber, Professor of Economics at Princeton University found that after Idaho passed a RTW law in 1985, there was a statistically-significant drop innonunionwages relative to other states.

The Larger Effect Of Race-To-The-Bottom Policies

While it might sound sensible to say that lowering wages and benefits and suppressing worker rights (along with giving tax incentives) will attract businesses to a state, what is the effect on the larger economy? What happens in the states where these businesses if any come from ? And what happens to the tax base in states that push lower wages?

I f these low-wage policies are successful, two things happen. The states that lose the jobs are poorer, and the workers in the low-wage states they came from (if any actually do) are poorer. And these low-wage states put pressure on wages for the jobs that remain,so wages are driven down economy-wide, across the country. This means that overall economic demand decreases so businesses have fewer customers, and tax revenue decreases because of lower wages and lower demand. As tax revenue decreases schools are defunded, infrastructure is not maintained, and economic conditions deteriorate for businesses throughout the economy.

Cutting wages and offering tax incentives to attract businesses sounds like it makes sense, but really it is penny wise and pound foolish. In the long run everyone is hurt, except the few already-wealthy billionaires pushing these policies.

...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

If these low-wage policies are successful, two things happen. The states that lose the jobs are poorer, and the workers in the low-wage states they came from (if any actually do) are poorer. And these low-wage states put pressure on wages for the jobs that remain,so wages are driven down economy-wide, across the country.

Yeah , business means competition between states within the US if we're lucky but OTW the movement goes out of the country . The right to work states provide the best opportunity for keeping jobs in the US . Not your problem ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The right to work states provide the best opportunity for keeping jobs in the US . Not your problem ?

And that is what drives the "race-to-the-bottom", Petey.

We are becoming like third-world, low wage countries. Jobs that reduce the standard of living ARE MY PROBLEM -- YOUR'S TOO.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

What drives the race to the bottom is the inflated wages paid in the past to US workers . Now things are being restored to "normal" .

We are becoming like third-world, low wage countries.

Yes . That is inevitable . Why should US workers earn so much more than those of 3rd world countries ? Things have changed . Why did you think they wouldn't ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Why should US workers earn so much more than those of 3rd world countries ? Things have changed . Why did you think they wouldn't ?

So all this conservative "let's take back our country" crap, and blaming minorities for being on welfare, and blaming liberals for wanting a better life for the middle class and working poor -- all that conservative talk is bullshit because Republicans and their zeal-without-knowledge base sell out to corporations, encourage the exportation of good jobs and expedite the race to the bottom.

Sorry, Petey I DON'T ACCEPT THAT OUTCOME AND WILL WORK TO PUT PEOPLE IN OFFICE WHO ARE POPULISTS.

Why should US workers earn so much more than those of 3rd world countries ?

How about because THEY'RE AMERICANS!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

How about because THEY'RE AMERICANS!

How about because they're Chinese ... or Mexican !!

I DON'T ACCEPT THAT OUTCOME AND WILL WORK TO PUT PEOPLE IN OFFICE WHO ARE POPULISTS.

Yeah ... that "hope and change" BS is working out so well ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Yeah ... that "hope and change" BS is working out so well ...

Just what we expect from the "I hope he fails" crowd.

End of my conversation with you on this one Petey; the cut-off-your-nose-to spite-Obama is a manifestation of wrong-headedness.

You can have the last word.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I don't have to hope it . His ideas have been almost universally ineffective . The economy is in shambles largely due to Obama's major incompetence in that area . I have a theory that he failed econ101 in college . That's why his grades were sealed .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It is Seattle law for their minimum wage to reach 15 dollars an hour soon.

So you only think a $15 dollar minimum wage is going to bad for Seattle (and other cities that are very slowly raising theirs up to it also), since it hasn't happened there yet and you can not say that it will be or has been. Right?

 
 

Who is online





Dismayed Patriot


65 visitors