╌>

Second Planned Parenthood Exec Caught on Film Apparently Negotiating Fetal Tissue Prices

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  11 years ago  •  14 comments

Second Planned Parenthood Exec Caught on Film Apparently Negotiating Fetal Tissue Prices

Just one week afterPlanned Parenthood Federation of America president Cecile Richards offered an apology for the tone of a video , released by the Center for Medical Progress last week, which appeared to showPlanned Parenthood senior director of medical servicesDr. Deborah Nucatola haggling over prices of aborted fetal tissue during a business lunch, another Center for Medical Progress video emerged on Tuesday, this time apparently showingPPFAMedical Directors Council president Dr. Mary Gatter attempting to maximize revenues by seeking higher prices for aborted fetal tissue specimens.

In Tuesdaysvideo, which can be seen in an edited format above, Dr. Gatterrefuses to quote the costs of fetal tissue specimens from abortions but instead asks actors posing as buyers at a business lunch to throw out an offer. The Atlanta Journal-Constitutions Kyle Wingfield uncovered a full-length version of the undercover video, which can be seen below.

During the negotiations, Dr. Gatter made a statement that seemed to imply that prior fetal tissue specimen transfers did not significantly increase Planned Parenthoods costs. It was logistically very easy for us, we didnt have to do anything. So there was compensation for this , she said.

I wouldnt object to asking Ian, whos our surgeon who does the cases, to use an IPAS [manual vacuum aspirator] at that gestational age in order to increase the odds that hes going to get an intact specimen , said Dr. Gatter, suggesting that she might encourage a surgeon to modify an abortion procedure out of an interest in obtaining revenues from fetal tissue specimens. She alsooffered to employ a less crunchy technique that would causeless damage to viable organ specimens.

Let me just figure out what others are getting, and if this ($100 per specimen) is in the ballpark, then its fine; if its still low, then we can bump it up , Dr. Gatter stated, seemingly seeking a market price. She then joked, I want a Lamborghini!

VIDEOS AND MORE INFO HERE


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Ever wonder why they spend so much effort making abortion easy as possible? Ever wonder why alternatives aren't offered and you have to ask about them? Ever wonder why so much more of your tax dollars are spent on abortion and abortion education and not on alternatives to abortion?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

What a country.... Profiting off baby parts.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

THESE ALLEGATIONS ARE FRAUDULENT FROM A GROUP KNOWN FOR SIMILAR FRAUDULENT "REPORTS"

Latest Video Attacking Planned Parenthood Full Of More Deceptive Edits

July 21, 2015 9:44 PM EDT ALEXANDREA BOGUHN

...

In its latest deceptively edited video, the Center for Medical Progress (CMP) claims to have caught a Planned Parenthood official "haggling" over the price of "baby parts" and agreeing to change abortion methods to aid the fetal tissue collection process.

But the full video and transcript show the official confirming that any change in procedure is done pursuant to medical advice without additional risk to the patient, and that the compensation being discussed was about legal reimbursement for costs associated with tissue donation.

Anti-ChoiceGroupReleasedAnotherDeceptively EditedVideo Purport...

DECEPTIVE EDIT:Center For Medical ProgressCherry Picks Quotes To...

DECEPTIVE EDIT:VideoCrops GatterTo Claim Planned Parenthood Modi...

Planned Parenthood Receives"No Financial Benefit" From Legal Donat...

Payment For Fetal Tissue May Be AcceptedOnly To Offset"Reasonable...

Previous Video From Center For Medical Progress Was Deceptively Edited

The Center For Medical Progress Has Almost No Internet Footprint

CMP's Founder, David Daleiden, Has A Long History With Discredited ...

A Center For Medical Progress Board Member Called Murder Of Abortio...

Center For Medical Progress Is Also Connected To A Disreputable Ant...

Anti-ChoiceGroupReleasedAnotherDeceptively EditedVideo Purporting To ShowPlanned Parenthood Official "Haggling Over Payments" For "Baby Parts"

Center For Medical Progress : "Planned Parenthood Senior Executive Haggles Over Baby Parts Prices, Changes Abortion Methods."

In avideo released onJuly 21,the Center for Medical Progress claimed to have recordedPPFA Medical Directors' CouncilPresidentMary Gatter"haggling over" prices for fetal tissue donations and offering to change techniques "to get more intact body parts."According to the organization's press release:

By the lunch's end, Gatter suggests $100 per specimen is not enough and concludes, "Let me just figure out what others are getting, and if this is in the ballpark, then it's fine, if it's still low, then we can bump it up. I want a Lamborghini

The sale or purchase of human fetal tissue is a federal felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison or a fine of up to $500,000 (42 U.S.C. 289g-2).

Gatter also suggests modifying the abortion procedure to get more intact fetuses: "I wouldn't object to asking Ian, who's our surgeon who does the cases, to use an IPAS [manual vacuum aspirator] at that gestational age in order to increase the odds that he's going to get an intact specimen."

Gatter seems aware this violates rules governing tissue collection, but disregards them: "To me, that's kind of a specious little argument." Federal law requires that no alteration in the timing or method of abortion be done for the purposes of fetal tissue collection (42 U.S.C. 289g-1).

The video, like last week's featuring Dr. Nucatola, was produced by The Center for Medical Progress and is part of CMP's nearly 3-year-long investigative journalism study, "Human Capital."[TheCenter for Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

DECEPTIVE EDIT: Center For Medical Progress Cherry Picks Quotes To Claim Video Shows Planned Parenthood Was Paid For Fetal Donations

Edited Video: Gatter Admitt ed "Planned Parenthood Received Payment In Spite Of Incurring No Costs." The Center for Medical Progress' press releaseclaims thatthe deceptively cut video showsGatter admittedthat Planned Parenthood receives payment for fetal tissue donation "in spite of incurring no costs,"pointing tothe 8-minute long videowhereGatter saying the process "was logistically very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. So there was compensation for this":

Gatter also admits that in prior fetal tissue deals, Planned Parenthood received payment in spite of incurring no cost: "It was logistically very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. So there was compensation for this." She accepts a higher price of $100 per specimen understanding that it will be only for high-quality fetal organs: "Now, this is for tissue that you actually take, not just tissue that someone volunteers and you can't find anything, right?" [The Center For Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

Full Video Shows Gatter Was Discussing Process Of Obtaining Consent And Sorting Donations. The Center for Medical Progress' transcript of the full-video revealsthat whenGattersaid"It was very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. There was compensation for this," she was discussingthe process of working with a companytoobtain consent for the donations and decidewhich donations could be used, citinghow itwas "logistically ... very easy"because arepresentative was there to help make the decision(emphasis added):

GATTER: So Novogenix was our partner in PPLA and they would send us- you know, big volume. They would send their staff to the site, and our staff, our medical assistants were used to discussing with the patients, do you want to consent? And they would say yes or no, and a lot of them said yes. Maybe it wasn't entirely sixty, and then once the patients have signed the consent form, the patients did not receive digoxin, and Heather would look at the tissue- that's probably Laura- she would take the pieces that she wanted and it worked out well for everyone. She was unobtrusive, she was helpful, she did all that kind of stuff.

LAUREL [Gatter's Colleague]: Oh, my apologies. Hi.

GATTER: So we just started the conversation.

GATTER: They're a start up, they've have been about a year in business. They are for profit company connecting researchers with people willing to donate tissue. We just started talking- they were a little bit concerned about the fact that they're in Long Beach, but they understand that every California affiliate is paired up in a tissue donation program, except for Pasadena. Volume, that you for getting it to me is eight hundred a year. We were just starting to talk about the process worked with Novogenix down in Los Angeles when I was there. To back up a little bit, PPFA, our parent body, is on board with tissue donation, but we have to ask for a waiver to do it, and we have to lay out for them what our program's gonna be like. And it's absolutely a requirement that we use only the official, federal government form for tissue donation, that we don't modify it in any way. Novogenix was working on a concept that California has slightly different requirements, and so it's different, and so they wanted to very reasonably insert the California requirements into the consent form, the federal form, PPFA said no, you have to have two separate forms, so it just added to the burden of consent issues. But I was also explaining to them, back when I was in Los Angeles maybe sixty to seventy percent of people said yes to tissue donation.

So Heather, a Novogenix person would come to the site, and our staff would sign the patients up, and get consent. Heather would look at the tissue and take what she required, so logistically it was very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. There was compensation for this, and there was discussion if that was legal, they have been paying by the case, and there was some discussion about do we, in a different way, or I don't know what you're used to doing, how you're used to doing compensation. Patients don't care what we do, of course, but-[The Center For Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Media matters... Can't scrape any lower than that.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
So you are saying that the video is a lie...aborted baby tissue and organs are not being provided to anyone at any price? Because just trying to discredit the editors does not mean that this horrific practice is not happening.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Media matters... Can't scrape any lower than that.

Actually, if you scrape Media Matters, you get to the right-wing outhouseslets.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Yes. It is a lie. Because that would be a crime. It is illegal to sell any human organs in the United States, including those from a fetus. Who has been arrested and charged? If this video were true, there would be Planned Parenthood personnel under arrest and being charged. It would be front page news around the world and the lead story on every nightly newscast for months. That hasn't happened because this video was heavily edited to lie about them and make it seem like they were committing a crime.

Read this one please: ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

So you are saying that the video is a lie...aborted baby tissue and organs are not being provided to anyone at any price? Because just trying to discredit the editors does not mean that this horrific practice is not happening.

If a video is selectively and intentionally edited and then run as if an accurate "report," there's obviously a reason for such deception.

The item I posted explains the difference between the edited and real versions; the information does the discrediting -- you can believe what suits your politics; I never discredit a source without explaining WITH CONTENT, why the source needs to be discredited.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Jennilee,

What Mac said. If a person is trying to decide if they are going to be pro-choice (as I am) or anti-abortion, that is their right. However it should be based on honest and truthful information. The videos being released by these particular people are not honest, nor truthful. Their goal is to horrify you into agreeing with their position, even if they have to lie to you to do it, which is what they are trying to do.

My advice (if you want it) is to research the truth for yourself and then make your decision. Either way you decide your decision will be an honest one that truthfully satisfies your conscience.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Randy, I am against abortion because I believe in my heart that it kills a living baby. That said, I do not judge anyone who has made the very difficult decision to have one, it is not my place to judge. But to sell the body parts of aborted babies is beyond wrong. It doesnt matter to me how the video was edited, the only question to be answered is are they doing this...yes or no. As you suggested, I will research further. But I have a feeling that if they are, the aren't publicizing it anywhere.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

If they really aren't doing this then it really leaves one to ponder the questions I asked doesn't it? What is the logic behind putting so much time, effort and money towards abortion instead of alternatives?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

If they really aren't doing this then it really leaves one to ponder the questions I asked doesn't it? What is the logic behind putting so much time, effort and money towards abortion instead of alternatives?

Again and as usual, a conclusion based on a false premise!

THE REALITY!

Q:How much of Planned Parenthoods services are dedicated to abortions? Does the federal government fund those procedures?

A: Abortions represent 3 percent of total services provided by Planned Parenthood, and roughly 10 percent of its clients received an abortion. The group does receive federal funding, but the money cannot be used for abortions by law.

FULL ANSWER

We received several questions on this topic during the recent budget debate in Congress, after Arizona Sen. Jon Kyl claimed this month on the Senate floor that "well over 90 percent of what Planned Parenthood does" is provide abortion services. That figure was wildly incorrect. Planned Parenthood says only 3 percent of its total services in 2009 were abortions. The other 97 percent of services were for contraception, treatment and tests for sexually transmitted diseases, cancer screenings, and other womens health services.

Heres a chart from a March 2011 fact sheet, which reported that the group performed about 11.4 million total services.

Kyls far-off claim was mocked by comedians Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert , and Kyls office later walked back the statement, telling CNN that "[h]is remark was not intended to be a factual statement but rather to illustrate that Planned Parenthood, an organization that receives millions in taxpayer dollars, does subsidize abortions." That statement, too, prompted ribbing by Stewart and Colbert. But the comedic clips apparently did not make it to the inboxes of many of our readers, who sent us questions about whether or not Planned Parenthood does little more than provide abortions, and whether or not taxpayer money goes to pay for them.

Planned Parenthoods chart shows that abortions made up 3 percent of its total services. Another way to measure the groups abortion services, however, is to divide the total number of abortions by the number of clients. For example, Planned Parenthood said that it provided nearly 11.4 million medical services for 3 million people in 2009. Its 2011 fact sheet says it performed 332,278 abortion procedures in 2009. That would mean that roughly one out of every 10 clients received an abortion.

Taxpayer Funding

Planned Parenthoods 2008-2009 annual report states that it received $363.2 million in "Government Grants and Contracts." (See page 29.) Thats about one-third of its total revenues for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2009.

However, not all of that money is from the federal government. Planned Parenthoods government funding comes from two sources: the Title X Family Planning Program and Medicaid. About $70 million is Title X funding, Planned Parenthood spokesman Tait Sye told us. The rest about $293 million is Medicaid funding, which includes both federal and state money.

But Planned Parenthood cannot use the money it receives from the federal government for abortions anyway. According to the Department of Health and Human Services website, "by law, Title X funds may not be used in programs where abortion is a method of family planning." Medicaid funding is restricted by the Hyde Amendment to only abortion cases involving rape, incest or endangerment to the life of the mother. Some states use their own funds under Medicaid to go beyond that. Seventeen states and, until recently, the District of Columbia pay for "medically necessary" abortions, according to the Guttmacher Institute . The federal budget deal now bans Washington, D.C., from using its funds to pay for abortions .

Lori Robertson and Michael Morse

Sources

Planned Parenthood. Annual Report 2008-2009 .

Planned Parenthood. Planned Parenthood Services . Fact Sheet. Mar 2011.

" CNN Newsroom ." Transcript. CNN. 8 Apr 2011.

Guttmacher Institute. State Funding of Abortion Under Medicaid . PolicyBrief. 1 Apr 2011.

DeBonis, Mike. " D.C. abortion funding: the facts ." The Washington Post. 11 Apr 2011.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

You do understand that you are arguing what percentage PPH spends on abortion and I am arguing that regardless of the percentage they use for abortion that the amount spent on abortion is ridiculously slanted in regards to the money spent on education and/or alternatives to abortion right?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

You do understand that you are arguing what percentage PPH spends on abortion and I am arguing that regardless of the percentage they use for abortion that the amount spent on abortion is ridiculously slanted in regards to the money spent on education and/or alternatives to abortion right?

Well, let's see.

771_discussions.jpg

Is CONTRACEPTION an alternative to abortion?

And how much is spent on abortion? If only 3% of all PPH does is abortion-related, how slanted is that?

Give me some specifics; your comment is an editorialized one.

 
 

Who is online





Dismayed Patriot


65 visitors