Federal appeals court upholds gun control laws passed after 2012 Newtown school massacre
By LARRY NEUMEISTER, Associated Press
NEW YORK (AP) — Gun control laws passed in New York and Connecticut to ban possession of semi-automatic weapons and large-capacity magazines after the 2012 massacre at Sandy Hook Elementary School were mostly upheld Monday by a federal appeals court.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan found core parts of the laws did not violate the Second Amendment because there was a substantial relationship between bans on assault weapons and large-capacity magazines and the "important — indeed, compelling — state interest in controlling crime."
"When used, these weapons tend to result in more numerous wounds, more serious wounds, and more victims. These weapons are disproportionately used in crime, and particularly in criminal mass shootings," according to the ruling written by Circuit Judge Jose A. Cabranes. "They are also disproportionately used to kill law enforcement officers."
The three-judge panel noted that the Newtown, Connecticut, shooting in December 2012 occurred when 154 rounds were fired in less than five minutes, killing 20 first-graders and six educators and renewing a nationwide discussion on the role of guns in America and how to diminish the threat of large-scale shootings.
But the court found Connecticut's ban on a non-semi-automatic Remington 7615 unconstitutional. And it said a seven-round load limit in New York could not be imposed even as it upheld other bans on magazines.
"Like assault weapons, large-capacity magazines result in 'more shots fired, persons wounded, and wounds per victim than do other gun attacks,'" the court said.
New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said he was pleased by the ruling. Connecticut Attorney General George Jepsen called the court's decision "deeply gratifying."
"At a time when many Americans have abandoned hope of government's ability to address gun violence in our schools and on our streets, Connecticut's laws — and today's decision — demonstrate that willing states can enact meaningful reform to improve public safety without violating the Second Amendment," he said in a statement.
"Now that the Court has ruled, it is time for everyone involved in the critical debate about how to keep weapons out of the hands of dangerous and unstable people to come together to work toward sensible solutions that will keep our communities safe."
The plaintiffs in the case were groups supporting gun rights, pistol permit holders and gun sellers. Lawyers for those groups didn't immediately return messages seeking comment.
Jake Palmateer, a spokesman for the gun rights group NY2A Grassroots Coalition, which wasn't a plaintiff, said he was disappointed.
"Just as no American citizen should face felony prosecution in one state for what is seen as free speech in another state, no American citizen should be denied their Second Amendment rights just because they live in New York or Connecticut," he said.
The appeals court addressed several gun rights groups' arguments, including that mass shootings are rare events that would be minimally affected by gun control laws.
"That may be so," the 2nd Circuit said. "But gun-control legislation 'need not strike at all evils at the same time' to be constitutional."
The appeals court said the claim by gun rights groups that the ban on assault weapons will primarily disarm law-abiding citizens was "speculative at best, and certainly not strong enough to overcome the substantial deference we owe to predictive judgments of the legislature on matters of public safety."
___
Associated Press writer Michael Virtanen in Albany contributed to this story.
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

Well, it's made it (mostly) past the Federal Court. Let's see if the Supreme Court will take take it up and what their ruling will be. My guess is they'll strike it down, sadly. Hopefully they won't take it up and let the ruling stand. Either way we'll know where this SCOTUS stands.
Until then, bravo NY and Connecticut and bravo to the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeal for getting this one right.
I posted this, so why does it say @community?
The intent is correct - the decision is wrong.
States should/do have the power to determine state laws and they should establish their parameters for those laws based on the envelope allowed by the Constitution.
SCOTUS does not/should not get involved in the state law realm UNLESS there is a strict violation of Constitutional law - which there isn't.
So if the SCOTUS doesn't get involved and let's the laws stand (by, say, not taking it up for a decision), then the ban in NY and Connecticut is the law in those two states. Works for me as a start.
We shall see. The SCOTUS may well refuse to take the case up and let the ruling stand.
I think they will leave it, because there is no Constitutional issue here. The states have not banned the 2nd Amendment and in fact have not harmed it.
SCOTUS does not/should not get involved in the state law realm UNLESS there is a strict violation of Constitutional law - which there isn't.
I agree. There isn't a strict violation of the Constitutional law. So the SCOTUS shouldn't get involved. Hey! We actually agree on something!
It'll be overturned. The ruling was specious at best. Most crimes are committed with semiautomatic weapons because most weapons are semiautomatic.
I don't see a 2nd amendment issue here. I see a state's right's issue here to protect the lives of their citizens and law enforcement officers. Also the states have made no attempt to ban the 2nd amendment at all. People in NY and Connecticut can still own and use a wide range of firearms to kill each other. It'll just be a little more difficult and slower. Maybe even with fewer deaths?
Still, we shall see.
I'm not the only one on this thread who doesn't see one. For one of the very few times I find myself in agreement with 1stwarrior. SCOTUS does not/should not get involved in the state law realm UNLESS there is a strict violation of Constitutional law - which there isn't.
Once done, it will end the debate once and for all. In the favor of the Second Amendment.
Then people will be able to carry shoulder launched missiles. Right?
Just remember, just like the freedom of speech, the 2nd amendment is not absolute.
But that's not what Scalia said. He said the 2nd amendment had not been ruled on shoulder fired missiles. "I mean, obviously, the (2nd) amendment does not apply to arms that cannot be hand-carried. It's to 'keep and bear.' So, it doesn't apply to cannons. But I suppose there are hand-held rocket launchers that can bring down airplanes that will have to be -- it will have to be decided."
I don't know about you, but to me that is Scalia saying any weapon that a single person can carry us not been ruled on yet and that it's possible that shoulder fired missiles may be allowed. He has as much as said that any weapon that a single person can carry is a "arm" under the 2nd Amendment. All he said was he 2nd amendment doesn't apply to weapons that can not be hand carried.
Typical "I get to get any kind of weapon I want" bullshit.
Justice Scalia wrote the Court's decision on District of Columbia v. Heller on Jun 26, 2008:
Overturning DC's handgun ban, the court ruled that the Second Amendment protects the individual right to own a gun for private use--not only in connection with service in a militia. The 5-to-4 decision, District of Columbia v. Heller, left unanswered questions, but also much room for continued gun regulation, short of an absolute ban.
HELD: Delivered by Scalia; joined by Roberts, Kennedy, Thomas, Alito
The Second Amendment protects an individual right to possess a firearm unconnected with service in a militia, and to use that arm for traditionally lawful purposes, such as self-defense within the home.
Don't see tank, rocket-launcher, RPG being utilized as self-defense within the home.
The 5-to-4 decision, District of Columbia v. Heller, left unanswered questions, but also much room for continued gun regulation, short of an absolute ban.
Which is what NY and Connecticut are doing. This is a state issue and the SCOTUS should not get involved. These states have not violated any SCOTUS ruling or the 2nd amendment. They have not banned gun ownership. They have not banned the 2nd Amendment in their states. There is no Constitutional issue involved here, IMHO.
"today's decision — demonstrate that willing states can enact meaningful reform to improve public safety without violating the Second Amendment,"
Nothing else needs to be said.
The Court, relying on historical analysis set forth previously in Heller, noted the English common law roots of the right to keep arms for self-defense and the importance of the right to the American colonies, the drafters of the Constitution. and the states as a bulwark against over-reaching federal authority.
Again, we couldn't agree more. I don't see a violation of the 2nd Amendment here. Your quotation by the Connecticut Attorney General is spot on.