╌>

Seeking Refuge: Migrants say 'no thanks' to EU distribution plans

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  screminmimi  •  11 years ago  •  6 comments

Seeking Refuge: Migrants say 'no thanks' to EU distribution plans

In a ramshackle camp in northern France, migrants see problems with the formula proposed to 'share the burden' that a record influx of refugees is putting on Europe, and Italy and Greece in particular.

By Colette Davidson, Sara Miller Llana

Hundreds of black and blue tarps, many with thatched roofs, vie for space in this port citys migrant camp, a testament to the powerful flow of human migration across Europe this year.

The population of Jungle 2, as it's called, surged from 1,000 to 3,000 in the three months after spring broke, the typical annual pattern. Residents have built more than homes: makeshift churches, schools, and even restaurants selling chicken skewers and chai tea dot Jungle 2.

Camps like this are spurring some European nations to push for what they're calling burden sharing, particularly Italy and Greece. Unsurprisingly, many of the less affected countries are opposed, arguing they have neither the infrastructure nor the resources to house and care for asylum seekers.

But they have surprising allies in their opposition: the migrants themselves.

Even as Europe's leaders debate, refugees are focused on finding jobs and establishing community bonds. And it's not that they don't want to move on from the poorer southern European countries hosting them. But what they don't want is to farmed out to even poorer country's still instead of being settled in richer states like the UK or German.

A human being has his life plans and wants to go to the country where he has the best future, says Alberto Achermann, a migration law expert at the University of Bern in Switzerland. While relocation would help correct some of the dysfunction in Europe's current system, it overlooks human intention, he says. That is the biggest problem with all of these redistribution plans in Europe.

'IN ENGLAND, THERE'S NO JUNGLE'

This year has seen an unprecedented flood of migrants seeking a better life in Europe. In the first six months of the year, 137,000 people have crossed the Mediterranean Sea into Europe, compared to 75,000 in the same period last year,according to the UN High Commissioner for Refugees.

Under current rules called the Dublin regulation, migrants who enter in Greece or Italy are supposed to officially seek asylum there. But they often try to slip through those borders a fact those countries are accused of turning a blind eye to to file claims elsewhere.

That has helped turn Calais, the closest point in continental Europe to Britain, where the overwhelming majority of Jungle 2 residents want to settle, into a flashpoint. In 2011, 4,500 migrants were discovered trying to cross the port and tunnel in Calais. In 2015, there have been 25,000 attempts so far on the same crossing, says Gilles Debove, secretary general of the police officers union in Calais.

Last month, a ferry strike brought traffic to a standstill here and had many migrants sensing an opportunity. Hundreds tried to force their way onto trucks that were backed up in the traffic at the Channel Tunnel the ferry closures created. The situation led Britain to declare its intent to create a "safe zone" for trucks passing through Calais to ensure migrants won't be able to jump aboard.

The migrants' intentions are clearly visible in Jungle 2. From Alpha, a migrant from Mauritania, to Khan from Afghanistan, many bear the litter-strewn conditions that Frances National Consultative Commission for Human Rights declared recently inhumane and contemptible because they have no intention of staying. Instead they bide their time, on a recent day crouching under a line of taps to fill their water bottles, brush their teeth, or rinse off they can shower once every four days until they can make it farther north.

Mostly the migrant flow runs from south to north, east to west. A typical route is the one Alpha followed, having crossedfrom Syria, to Turkey, Greece, Belgium, and now Calais, even spending time in jail several times, he says on his attempt to reach Britain.

"In England, there's no Jungle, he says. After two or three days, they put you in a hotel. In two or three weeks, you have a place to live. Here in France, [there is only] the Jungle."

Khan says he and his peersgo where they can get papers and work. The idea of staying in Italy makes no sense, neither for the migrant or the EU as a whole, he says. Italians themselves dont have jobs, so how can they give me a job?

Philippe Wannesson, a local volunteer at the Jungle, says that most of the migrants here, who have fled poverty or war, simply sought to get into Europe. But a lack of jobs and welcome in Italy and Greece, where so many first arrived, prompted them on, many through France. The conditions here then prompted them onwards, to Britain. Theyre always looking to build a life somewhere else, Mr. Wannesson says.

In the heated debate on quotas, Calaiss fate might remain unchanged or even get marginally worse. The relocation formula only applies to 40,000 Syrians and Eritreans entering Greece and Italy over the next two years. Many of the men and women in Calais arent even refugees, but economic migrants whose asylum cases are likely to be rejected.

EUROPEAN RESISTANCE

Still, they bristle at the notion of someone deciding where they should live. No one talks of heading east. And judging from political rhetoric, that is how many of these countries would like it.

The countries of Central Europe Slovakia, Poland, Czech Republic, and Hungary have been some of the loudest critics of a scheme imposed on them to take in asylum seekers. Martina Sekulov,aresearch fellow at theInstitute for Public AffairsinBratislava,says that the issue of asylum shot to the top of the public debate in these countries for the first time ever.

Debates were full of prejudices, stereotypes, fears, and refusal of migrants in general, she says. Many politicians have argued that they dont have the infrastructure to become asylum welcomers, but she says her country, Slovakia, has the capacity to create a well-functioning system.

Slovakia should recognize the importance of the issue of humanitarian migration and its role already as awell-developed, rich, secure, and stable country in the wider geopolitical context.

Vincent Cochetel, theEuropean director of theUN High Commissioner for Refugees, says he supports Europes relocation plan because it can help countries see that the crisis is Europes, not just the countries where migrants enter or the countries like Germany, Sweden, or the UK, where many overwhelmingly want to go.

Not every refugee will want to travel to the countries that havent traditionally accepted migrants. But an asylum seeker, under the current rules, doesnt have that choice. Unless he has family or special ties to a certain European country, an asylum seeker has no automatic right to live in Germany or anywhere else he might covet. Seeking asylum is not, Mr. Cochetel says, traveling to a destination country.

http://news.yahoo.com/seeking-refuge-migrants-no-thanks-eu-distribution-plans-173921957.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

This article deals primarily with the Port of Calais, of which I have posted other articles detailing the growing problem the city has with illegal aliens turning the once beautiful city into a slum teeming with makeshift hovels, crime, illness, and body waste running in the street.

The "migrants" have made it dangerous for anyone traveling from France to England via the ferry at the Port of Calais, whether it be personal vehicles or the lorries that transport goods. The migrants will throw rocks, sticks and other materials at the vehicles to get them to slow down so they can jump on the hoods or try to cling to the door handles as the vehicles board the ferry.

They will rush the ferry trying to climb aboard before the gate is closed.

They try to jump inside the backs of the delivery lorries; the drivers are made to pay a stiff fine if they arrive in England with unauthorized people on board, and a couple of weeks ago the drivers went on strike with their safety and the fines a part of their grievance.

This article acknowledges, for the first time, that all these people are not fleeing war and danger. They are economic migrants. And now they are telling the host countries where they will and will not be relocated, and are refusing to leave the port city until they get what they want. They are willing to live in these deplorable, filthy slums until they blackmail France into sending them to England or Germany or another country that can guarantee them a successful future.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

They are all looking for handouts without the responsibility of having to provide for themselves. Case in point -"In England, there's no Jungle, he says. After two or three days, they put you in a hotel. In two or three weeks, you have a place to live. Here in France, [there is only] the Jungle." In France, you have to provide for yourself and your family. In England, they will provide for you.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

A human being has his life plans and wants to go to the country where he has the best future, says Alberto Achermann, a migration law expert at the University of Bern in Switzerland. While relocation would help correct some of the dysfunction in Europe's current system, it overlooks human intention, he says. That is the biggest problem with all of these redistribution plans in Europe.

The human beings living in the host countries have life plans, too, and they don't include having their culture restructured to fit the onslaught of foreign migrants who refuse to assimilate and insist on changing everything from the available food supplies to what is taught in public schools.

The "human intention" of the migrants should be the secondary consideration of all the humanitarians and the useless UN; it is the human intention of the citizens of the host countries to be able to leave something for the children and grandchildren, the great grandchildren of their great grandchildren, not see it all consumed by the selfish migration of millions of people calling themselves refugees who won't fight for their own culture and homes, but insist on taking the resources of host countries and supplanting the traditions and cultures already existing in the established societies.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

"Beggars can't be choosers" springs to mind.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

The anger of the people in the EU has reached a boiling point. I am posting another article about this subject; the Italians have burned the beds and TVs at the housing facility where migrants were to be given refuge.

At another location, protesters clashed with police when they tried to bring twenty migrants into a neighborhood.

They have had enough; there is no sympathy or empathy left, and they resent their resources being used on these migrants.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Why not kill 2 birds with 1 stone ? Sends the migrants to live in Greece . Maybe even toss some foreign aid to Greece for accepting them ...

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot


75 visitors