Via: community • 11 years ago • 25 comments
MOORHEAD, Minn. -- Nearly doubled over in his seat in a Clay County courtroom, his skinny frame shaking with tears, 16-year-old Zachary Daniel St. Claire was barely audible as he replied to a judge's questions Tuesday.
"The defendant is distraught and is looking down," said Clay County District Court Judge Galen Vaa, asking the boy once again whether he understood he was being charged with first-degree premeditated murder in the death of 55-year-old Bradley Carrington -- a man the 16-year-old claims had been molesting him for years.
On the second try, St. Claire replied softly, "Yes."
Reached by phone Tuesday, Carrington's sister, Melody Acosta of Belcourt, N.D., offered a brief response to St. Claire's accusation that her brother sexually abused him.
"No matter what he did, he did not deserve to die like this. There's ways to go through the law to take care of things like this," she said before quickly ending the conversation.
Prosecutors allege after killing Carrington on Saturday night, St. Claire ran from the scene of the bloodied northside trailer straight to his mother's house at 1703 9th Ave. S. in Moorhead.
That's where a detective tracked him down within hours of a neighbor's discovery late Sunday morning of Carrington's beaten body.
On Sunday evening, Jolene Peltier brought her son back to north Moorhead, to the Moorhead Police Department headquarters to speak voluntarily with police, court documents filed in the case against him state.
Neighbors had described Carrington as a sort of caretaker or foster parent to St. Claire. But in his interview, the boy told police Carrington had been sexually abusing him for the last three to four years.
St. Claire allegedly told police that he'd been thinking of killing Carrington, and on Saturday night, while drinking with him, he saw an opportunity, the complaint filed against him states.
I fear you are most likely right about that Randy. There is still some investigating to do, but I do hope that if true, they find sufficient evidence to prove it.
He needs to be sent to a mental health facility. The judge may order him to be in one for a specific amount of time as he would a sentence and it has to be better then sending this kid to a prison.
Anybody that has ever been through molestation, or close to someone who has will tell you what a living hell it is. There is a reason why child sexual abuse has been termed soul death by it's survivors, because it kills the spirit, and steals all hope. There are very few things as heinous and hateful as child rape. personally if this is true, the creep got off easy in my book. Being flayed alive is too good a punishment imo.
I wonder how many people here are in favor of the death penalty for child molesters. While I do think that capital punishment is appropriate for certain crimes, child molesting is not one of them. Sadly, this kid will justly serve a hefty sentence for taking the law into his own hands, in the most serious fashion imagineable.
As a survivor myself, and as one who has lived and worked closely with children who have suffered at the hands of molestation, I have seen examples where it would have been kinder if the molester would have killed the victims instead. I have seen children left in a state of complete comatose horror and vegetation brought on by abuse and molestation, until they have withered and died after a long period of suffering. I have seen children who have lost there mind so completely that they now as adults still reside in state homes where they have to receive 24 hour care. I have seen kids who's spirit has been so broken that the only thing that brings them any solace at all are attempts at suicide.
Anybody who rapes a kid deserves to be treated like a feral rabid animal, and put down with extreme prejudice, and if we were a truly caring society, we would do so.
I completely disagree...child molestation is worth capital punishment in my view. It is much more than a sexual crime. It robs innocence and trust and can affect the victim long after the abuse ends. And the abuser simply goes on to another victim.
I am generally opposed to the death penalty, but only because there have been so many sentences overturned by DNA evidence in the last few years. If guilt can be proved at a high enough level of certainty, then I do believe that molestation of child warrants death.
Wow - Sharia Law, coming to a town near you! It seems that those who are the loudest about the threat that they think Islam poses inside our country, are also the most inclined to impose their own version of Sharia Law, in direct violation of our code of law.
It sounds as if you are suggesting that if he is found not guilty, that it would have to be because of the imposition of Sharia Law or an inclination to impose a version of Sharia Law. Do you see a possibility that he may be found not guilty, in complete accordance with US law?
I see numerous posts here saying "he got what he deserves", which is basically condoning the behavior of the killer. He murdered a man by his own admission. If that kind of behavior is treated lightly by the courts, then we are one step closer to mob rule.
I've known a few victims of pedophiles, but I've never met one who wanted to see the perpetrator dead - whether for reasons of personal morality or because they would only want the perp to suffer a harsh prison term because death is too easy. I'm not saying there aren't victims who want their abusers dead, I'm just saying that no victim should be further victimized by having to be the reason another human is dead, unless there was a murder involved.
What would be the difference between this scenario, and a case where a spouse is found not guilty of murdering her abusive husband, even when there were those who opined that the husband deserved it?
"No matter what he did, he did not deserve to die like this.
If molestation proves to be true, he got exactly what he deserved.
Yeah, but the kid will still go to jail, unless he can make an insanity defense work.
I fear you are most likely right about that Randy. There is still some investigating to do, but I do hope that if true, they find sufficient evidence to prove it.
He needs to be sent to a mental health facility. The judge may order him to be in one for a specific amount of time as he would a sentence and it has to be better then sending this kid to a prison.
God, yeah, I do hope he gets the help he needs.
Anybody that has ever been through molestation, or close to someone who has will tell you what a living hell it is. There is a reason why child sexual abuse has been termed soul death by it's survivors, because it kills the spirit, and steals all hope. There are very few things as heinous and hateful as child rape. personally if this is true, the creep got off easy in my book. Being flayed alive is too good a punishment imo.
Been there. It never, ever leaves you.
I wonder how many people here are in favor of the death penalty for child molesters. While I do think that capital punishment is appropriate for certain crimes, child molesting is not one of them. Sadly, this kid will justly serve a hefty sentence for taking the law into his own hands, in the most serious fashion imagineable.
As a survivor myself, and as one who has lived and worked closely with children who have suffered at the hands of molestation, I have seen examples where it would have been kinder if the molester would have killed the victims instead. I have seen children left in a state of complete comatose horror and vegetation brought on by abuse and molestation, until they have withered and died after a long period of suffering. I have seen children who have lost there mind so completely that they now as adults still reside in state homes where they have to receive 24 hour care. I have seen kids who's spirit has been so broken that the only thing that brings them any solace at all are attempts at suicide.
Anybody who rapes a kid deserves to be treated like a feral rabid animal, and put down with extreme prejudice, and if we were a truly caring society, we would do so.
I completely disagree...child molestation is worth capital punishment in my view. It is much more than a sexual crime. It robs innocence and trust and can affect the victim long after the abuse ends. And the abuser simply goes on to another victim.
I am generally opposed to the death penalty, but only because there have been so many sentences overturned by DNA evidence in the last few years. If guilt can be proved at a high enough level of certainty, then I do believe that molestation of child warrants death.
Wow - Sharia Law, coming to a town near you! It seems that those who are the loudest about the threat that they think Islam poses inside our country, are also the most inclined to impose their own version of Sharia Law, in direct violation of our code of law.
What part of capital punishment is "in direct violation of our code of law"?
The mob rule part that condones vigilante murder.
Hal,
It sounds as if you are suggesting that if he is found not guilty, that it would have to be because of the imposition of Sharia Law or an inclination to impose a version of Sharia Law. Do you see a possibility that he may be found not guilty, in complete accordance with US law?
I see numerous posts here saying "he got what he deserves", which is basically condoning the behavior of the killer. He murdered a man by his own admission. If that kind of behavior is treated lightly by the courts, then we are one step closer to mob rule.
I've known a few victims of pedophiles, but I've never met one who wanted to see the perpetrator dead - whether for reasons of personal morality or because they would only want the perp to suffer a harsh prison term because death is too easy. I'm not saying there aren't victims who want their abusers dead, I'm just saying that no victim should be further victimized by having to be the reason another human is dead, unless there was a murder involved.
What would be the difference between this scenario, and a case where a spouse is found not guilty of murdering her abusive husband, even when there were those who opined that the husband deserved it?
If it's not self defense, then murdering someone out of emotion is indefensible.
If he molested the kid, he got what he deserved.
The kid is 16, it isn't clear if he's being tried as a adult. I hope not.
And yes, the family sure sounds like they knew what was going on.