The Ryan Test: Do Republicans want to be martyrs or winners?
Having tested the thickness of the political ice, Paul Ryan seems convinced it will support the weight of a House speaker. Given the nature of the Republican coalition (in parts fractious, restless and heedless of political reality), he will end up in the water. But perhaps not immediately, and perhaps not until after considerable accomplishment. The most knowledgeable, thoughtful conservative in the House is now likely to lead the House, which is the sign of an institution still capable of random acts of sanity. And the manner of Ryan’s victory is worth considering, because it is the only way that Republicans will regain the presidency.
What might be called the Ryan Test — give me a meaningful job with a reasonable prospect of governing success and a shot at personal happiness or leave me the hell alone — applies most immediately to the workings of the House. In consultations with GOP colleagues, the Wisconsin representative has made clear that he wants to empower committees more than the leadership, while also making the speaker less vulnerable to challenge.
Rather than an inconsistency, this is an expression of Ryan’s broader political outlook. He is proposing to strengthen mediating structures — in this case, committees that allow members to exert influence and make their voices heard — within an institution capable of, and interested in, governing. The weakening of committees in both the House and Senate has been a source of dysfunction, encouraging frustrated, angry, political freelancing — and crackdowns on political freelancing that cause further bitterness.
But the Ryan Test has a larger application. Ryan is essentially asking conservatives within the GOP: What is your actual goal? Is it to govern in the public interest according to a conservative vision while building a political coalition capable of supporting needed reforms? Or is it the expression of outrage, rooted in a right-wing populism that is in fundamental (and continual) revolt against the political establishment?
This has been the main question posed to Republicans since the wave election of 2010: governing or rage? The fault line is clearest in the choice of political enemies. For some conservatives, the politically ascendant and intellectually exhausted liberalism of the Obama era is the target. For others, the real enemy is a Republican establishment complicit in a corrupt political order — a GOP establishment that “reflexively surrenders on every issue” (in the words of Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Tex.)) and must be razed before anything good can grow.
The House Freedom Caucus has exemplified the demolition option. During the past five years, some 30 or 40 House members took up permanent residence off the reservation, denying Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) an effective House majority. Cruz has been their instigator. Conservative media, particularly talk radio, have provided incitement and attention. Some of these legislators, no doubt, are acting out of conviction. But at least some of their zeal has come from the fear of primary challenges from the right, which has left self-preservation to masquerade as principle.
Now a clear majority of the Freedom Caucus has come out for Ryan , the peppy poster child for the governing option. This accommodation will quickly be tested on the debt ceiling and next year’s budget . Will the whole conference unite behind an approach to governing that doesn’t rely on showdown and shutdown politics?
Right now House Republicans are providing a lesson to their party, which is being roundly ignored by the Republican presidential primary electorate. The two current front-runners , Ben Carson and Donald Trump, are favored for their complete lack of governing experience . The main qualification to be president, apparently, is a lack of relevant qualifications. This is generally not the way airline pilots, neurosurgeons or speakers of the House (apparently) are selected, but voters can employ whatever criteria they wish in choosing the commander in chief.
Republicans should, however, be under no illusions. They are currently failing the Ryan Test. Trump is the truest RINO on the GOP savanna. He has no background or interest in governing. He has one thing to offer: a talent for outrage. And for many Republicans, this (so far) has been enough.
The movement that stands to lose the most is conservatism. Maybe the GOP’s back to the future is 1964, when Republican primary voters chose the candidate of outrage, Barry Goldwater, who promised “extremism in the defense of liberty.” The anti-Goldwater landslide entrenched the Great Society in American life. A right-wing populist who loses the 2016 election in a landslide would entrench Obamacare and the rest of President Obama’s legacy.
Ultimately, to govern is to win.
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

In the Ryan, the so-called (and seriously mis-named) Freedom Caucus will rather be martyrs then winners. In the end they'll fuck Ryan and he'll have to do what Boehner had to do to get the debt ceiling raised and kept the budget going. Make a deal with the Democrats and moderate Republicans.
All of the Republicans were elected to lower the debt ceiling not raise it. Any of them that vote to raise the debt ceiling should be voted out and replaced by real conservatives. They can make cuts not spend more. They should be busy making cuts right now if Obama vetoes them the debt problem will be his.
Dean, I'm trying to determine what a real conservative Republican is and whose definition to apply. By your account if they don't raise the debt ceiling, it's like job accomplished (over simplified I know). Yet they continue to tinker within the budget to water-down the sequester results...like the military budget.
Neither party is willing to CUT an expenditure or find creative ways to reduce costs that is considered near and dear to the individual party. Then comes the debt limit and we're back to square one, yet again.
When do the parties get together to reform the IRS, Medicaid/Medicare drug costs, VA system, or how about the Justice System? IMHO, if we started with the waste and bloat perhaps raising the debt ceiling wouldn't be required. It's time for our elected government officials to govern!
The Freedom Caucus has stymied this country for too long. It's about time these men and woman put on their grown up panties and explain to their constituents YOU DO NOT GET ALL YOU WANT!
When do the parties get together to reform the IRS, Medicaid/Medicare drug costs, VA system, or how about the Justice System?
As long as the so-called "Freedom Caucus" exists, never. They do not want to get anything done, because that would prove that government can work. Instead their only goal is to through sand into the machine to try to burn it out completely.
If he backs a rise in the debt ceiling, it will be viewed as caving to the special interests and liberals, he will lose the party majority he is seeking.
And he will, because he simply has no more choice then Boehner did. It has to get done and he'll have to do it the way Boehner did, with moderate republicans and a majority of Democrats. We are not going to default on the debt ceiling because the effects on our economy and that of most of the world would be catastrophic. It will get done and with Democratic help.