The Republicans are right. We in the media do suck.
The Republicans are right. We in the media do suck. by Catherine Rampell , Washington Post
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video segments from the debate are here
The Republican presidential candidates are right. The media does suck.
But not for the reasons the candidates complained about Wednesday night.
We in the media suck because we have rewarded their rampant dishonesty and buffoonery with nonstop news coverage. Which, of course, has encouraged more dishonesty and buffoonery.
Hence the aggravating behaviors that candidates doubled-down on during the debate, based on lessons that we in the media taught them. To wit:
Lesson No. 1: Lie, but lie confidently.
Look straight into the camera, and with complete conviction, say something that is not true. Maybe your lies will get fact-checked later, but if your certainty can sufficiently excite pundits in the interim, no one will care (or notice) that you lied.
We saw this strategy successfully executed in the second Republican debate, when Carly Fiorina confidently described a horrifying undercover Planned Parenthood video.
The footage in question turned out not to exist . (At best, she was describing a reenactment .) But by the time her statements were checked, Fiorina had been annointed the winner of the debate, thanks largely to that riveting, shocking sound bite. Since then, any time someone has called her out on this missing footage, she has just claimed media bias (see Lesson No. 3).
No surprise, then, that on Wednesday the candidates lied boldly, and repeatedly, even when their statements were easily disprovable.
Donald Trump denied ever taking a dig at Facebook chief executive Mark Zuckerberg, even though the dig in question was on Trump’s Web site.
Ben Carson denied having any “involvement” with a sketchy maker of nutritional supplements, even though evidence of this involvement (including a video testimonial ) is easily findable online .
Chris Christie claimed Social Security money was “ stolen ” and that the system will be “insolvent” in seven to eight years, even though both claims are wrong . Fiorina recycled a statistic about women’s job losses that Mitt Romney used in 2012 and subsequently abandoned when it, too, was proven wrong .
And so on.
Fact-checkers had lots of material to mine, but the candidates’ dramatic delivery — and the immediate plaudits they earned from talking heads — made post-debate truth-squadding seem pedantic and tone-deaf.
Lesson No. 2: Invent your own math.
This is related to Lesson No. 1, but more quantitative. Or less, depending on how you look at it.
In recent weeks, Trump has suggested that he can simultaneously cut tax revenue by trillions of dollars, protect entitlements from cuts and balance the budget . He’s also pledged to raise taxes on the rich while simultaneously cutting taxes for the rich.
This legerdemath, as a friend of mine put it, has proven successful; despite disobeying all laws of arithmetic, Trump’s policies have been characterized as coherent, fiscally conservative, even populist . Maybe this has something to do with America’s declining math scores .
In any case, the other candidates lived and learned. When Marco Rubio was asked why his tax plan gave the average rich person a bigger tax cut than the average middle-class person in percentage terms, Rubio decided he would just redefine how percentages work.
“Five percent of a million is a lot more than 5 percent of a thousand,” he countered triumphantly.
Likewise, after CNBC’s Becky Quick informed Carson that his flat tax would blow a $1.1 trillion hole in the budget and require spending cuts of 40 percent, their exchange went like this:
CARSON: That’s not true.
QUICK: That is true, I looked at the numbers.
CARSON: When — when we put all the facts down, you’ll be able to see that it’s not true, it works out very well.
So, you know, Q.E.D.
Lesson No. 3: If you can’t think of something better to say, just bash the media. (This is good advice for the media, too, as this column illustrates.)
At first it seemed risky when Trump attacked conservative darling and Fox News host Megyn Kelly for asking tough questions during the first debate. But his attacks paid off, earning him several news cycles’ worth of free advertising.
Accordingly, by Wednesday, the candidates had all learned to dodge difficult questions by accusing the moderators of bias. Usually, the charge was that they were too liberal. (Yes, CNBC, the channel that launched the tea party and employs the United States’ most famous supply-sider , is apparently a commie paradise.) Or they accused the media of not asking substantive questions, right in the middle of ducking substantive questions.
In the end, the biggest applause lines were all media insults. They came from Rubio, Ted Cruz and Christie.
Guess whom CNBC then crowned the winners of the debate? Rubio, Cruz and Christie.
Well done, gents. We’ve trained you well.
Tags
Who is online
153 visitors

The media still have not integrated the very simple fact that these candidates lie. These people have all been lying through their teeth for years, but the media simply refuses to imagine that they will lie the next time, as well.
So these "journalists" came to the debate unprepared. For example, with a screenshot of Trump's webpage criticizing Zuckerberg.
The only way to make them admit that they are bullshitting is to stick their noses in their own bullshit.
Of course, that would mean coming to the debate with documentation. Preparation. HARD WORK. I'm not sure that's part of very many "journalists' " job description...
Why is this stupid woman, Sarah Palin, still around? Thank you media, for giving her unending attention!
I agree-- their utterly stupid comments are given credence as if it were the Gospel of Politics-- which they are not.
Why is this stupid woman, Sarah Palin, still around?
Palin is known as "a good subject". She'll always have something "newsworthy" to say... in a world where "crazy" and "newsworthy" are synonymous.
Politics as theater.
Same as Trump. He's right, he's spending his own money because he doesn't have to spend much. He's a celebrity and they always get free publicity. Of course we never learn anything about what that idiot would do if he were President, except cartoon ideas. John Harwood was right to ask if he was running a cartoon campaign, because he really is.
NPR and BBC are the pretty much the only mainstream media I can listen to. All the others are not worth the time.
We did it to ourselves. It's the stuff we seem to want to see. We deserve it.
There is no doubt biased in the debates. The Democrats are never vetted or questioned in getcha questions. The difference in the questions the Democrats are asked compared to the questions the Republicans are asked are biased in favor of the Democrats.
Neither side is without guilt, but don't you like the vetting question? You would never hear a Democrat being asked anything like that. It's really obvious.
Did you watch the Dem debate?
The CNN Democratic debate transcript, annotated
Secretary Clinton, I want to start with you. Plenty of politicians evolve on issues, but even some Democrats believe you change your positions based on political expediency.
You were against same-sex marriage. Now you're for it. You defended President Obama's immigration policies. Now you say they're too harsh. You supported his trade deal dozen of times. You even called it the "gold standard". Now, suddenly, last week, you're against it.
Will you say anything to get elected?
That was the first question, almost all were like that.
Cletus,
That was the first question, almost all were like that.
IMHO, that's a perfectly legitimate question. (Not the form. Something like, "Would you please take a moment to explain to the public your reasons for reversing your positions on these topics?" would have been a lot better.)
Politicians, like everyone, have the right to change their minds, and quite often their intellectual path from position A to position B is very revealing. So, basically, "Why did you flip-flop?" is legit.
I think a lot of people have changed on each one of those items. Same-sex marriage has gone from a few percent approval to wide majority approval in a couple decades. The trade deal has evolved enormously since negotiations began, and not (in the opinion of a couple experts whom I trust, since I don't know a thing about the subject) in the right direction. So Hillary explaining her change of opinion is actually a good topic.
I think that the decision to attack the media was agreed upon by at least a couple of the candidates at the last debate and picked up on by the rest. It happened too often to avoid questions for it to not be done on purpose. Unless, of course, none of them wanted to discuss any real policy and didn't want to answer questions about things they know nothing about (like policy?) or are telling bald-faced lies, like Trump and Carson did. The moderation was fine until it was attacked from the stage and spun as bad (They were mean to me mommy! They asked real questions!!!'') in the spin rooms. The truth is that no one learned a damn thing at that debate except that republicans depend on getting applause lines by attacking the mean old media. Bunch of big babies is what most of them were.
Now they only want to be questioned by other republicans and that means no one learns anything true about them, like that some of them are low grade morons when it comes to the government. The moderators might as well be their campaign managers and they're only allowed to ask questions of the own candidate and be in individual rooms. In other words they only want to give interviews from their own people and make live speeches on the GOP side and not answer any straight forward questions, because they have no answers or ideas for any real policy questions. The fact is that they just can't handle a real debate, because they got nothing.