The ACLU's Way Around Citizens United: Tax Free Speech
View Enlarged Image
Justice Anthony Kennedy, speaking to a Harvard Law School crowd, on Wednesday gave a startlingly forceful defense of his Citizens United decision that scrapped the McCain-Feingold campaign finance law.
Disclosing that he believes "what happens with money in politics is not good," SCOTUS' Sultan of Swing said: "Remember: the government of the United States stood in front our court and said it was lawful and necessary ... to ban a book written about Hillary Clinton in the prohibited period of six, three months before the election. That can't be right."
Kennedy added that "I wasn't surprised the New York Times was incensed their little monopoly to affect our thinking was taken away. I was surprised how virulent their attitude was. Last time I looked, the New York Times was a corporation."
Enter the American Civil Liberties Union. ACLU of Northern California executive director Abdi Soltani recently reread some of the forceful language in Kennedy's 2010 decision, which is such a bane of the left, and was struck by the way the ruling presented the spectre of "fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for simply engaging in political speech," of "an outright ban, backed by criminal sanctions" against even "nonprofit advocacy corporations."
So Soltani came up with a solution: muzzle speech with taxes instead.
One section of his article for the Stanford Social Innovation Review is titled "Living Happily With Banned Speech." He argues that as the operator of a 501(c)(3) group, he lives with "a ban on certain words leaving my mouth. ... The sky does not fall. The First Amendment thrives. The Constitution endures."
And so, to get around the Supreme Court's protection of using the airwaves for political speech — whether you're an individual or a corporation — have the IRS pick the pockets of those who spend too much too effectively in propagating their political views through the use of communication technology.
According to Soltani, "after a certain threshold" of candidate advocacy spending "it no longer serves the public interest to make a nonprofit exempt from income taxes." He would "make the contributions to 501(c) entities that exceed the candidate advocacy limit .. . of $1 million subject to the gift tax."
Then Soltani would "use both the excise tax paid by these organizations and the gift tax paid by the donors to fund public finance" of campaigns through the government matching — or doubling or even quintupling — small-scale political contributions with the taxpayer's money.
"What happens with money in politics is not good," says Justice Kennedy. What will be happening with it, if the ACLU gets its way, would give liberalism absolute rule in America, with the tax man holding the baton and taxpayers paying the tab.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/blogs-capital-hill/103015-778298-the-aclu-wants-to-tax-policial-speech-to-get-around-citizens-united.htm#ixzz3q6OdKQN1
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Justice Anthony Kennedy, speaking to a Harvard Law School crowd, on Wednesday gave a startlingly forceful defense of his Citizens United decision that scrapped the McCain-Feingold campaign finance law.
Disclosing that he believes "what happens with money in politics is not good," SCOTUS' Sultan of Swing said: "Remember: the government of the United States stood in front our court and said it was lawful and necessary ... to ban a book written about Hillary Clinton in the prohibited period of six, three months before the election. That can't be right."
Kennedy added that "I wasn't surprised the New York Times was incensed their little monopoly to affect our thinking was taken away. I was surprised how virulent their attitude was. Last time I looked, the New York Times was a corporation."
Enter the American Civil Liberties Union. ACLU of Northern California executive director Abdi Soltani recently reread some of the forceful language in Kennedy's 2010 decision, which is such a bane of the left, and was struck by the way the ruling presented the spectre of "fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for simply engaging in political speech," of "an outright ban, backed by criminal sanctions" against even "nonprofit advocacy corporations."
So Soltani came up with a solution: muzzle speech with taxes instead.
One section of his article for the Stanford Social Innovation Review is titled "Living Happily With Banned Speech." He argues that as the operator of a 501(c)(3) group, he lives with "a ban on certain words leaving my mouth. ... The sky does not fall. The First Amendment thrives. The Constitution endures."
And so, to get around the Supreme Court's protection of using the airwaves for political speech — whether you're an individual or a corporation — have the IRS pick the pockets of those who spend too much too effectively in propagating their political views through the use of communication technology.
According to Soltani, "after a certain threshold" of candidate advocacy spending "it no longer serves the public interest to make a nonprofit exempt from income taxes." He would "make the contributions to 501(c) entities that exceed the candidate advocacy limit .. . of $1 million subject to the gift tax."
Then Soltani would "use both the excise tax paid by these organizations and the gift tax paid by the donors to fund public finance" of campaigns through the government matching — or doubling or even quintupling — small-scale political contributions with the taxpayer's money.
"What happens with money in politics is not good," says Justice Kennedy. What will be happening with it, if the ACLU gets its way, would give liberalism absolute rule in America, with the tax man holding the baton and taxpayers paying the tab.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/blogs-capital-hill/103015-778298-the-aclu-wants-to-tax-policial-speech-to-get-around-citizens-united.htm#ixzz3q6OdKQN1
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Tags
Who is online
153 visitors

I may not understand every little thing about all the money that is spent and used during elections, but it seems he or she who has the most money most of the time wins, not matter where that money came from and I for one would like to look into other means of supporting elections, but the money will slip in I'm afraid in other forms that are just as effective and still not represent the majority of Americans, but those with the money.
We should institute poll taxes too. /s
The only good thing that came out of Citizens United was Steven Colbert's legal exploitation of it to his average American audience.
The cat is out of the bag (it's too late). Even if the "Citizens United" decision is repealed, the wealthy have found pooling their resources (not necessarily in Political Action Committees) offers them an effective way to exercise their free speech rights to generate powerful propaganda (if only in the form of "creative" works of art, such as film or "journalism"). What elections offer is not so much the right to vote but the opportunity to influence many votes, even if you have none of your own! Even foreigners (including offshore media moguls) can invest in the propaganda machine!
The best counter to the big money political speech is an awakened electorate.
big money = "paid-for" speech (sophisticated propaganda)
no money = free speech.
Even free speech is not free. Free Speech and Assembly cost the public in positive enforcement such as police protection and tolerance of traffic and other disruptions.
As a constituionalist, you should probably be familiar with the part of the first amemdmemt that explicitly protects a free press, a press is that almost exclusively made up of corporate entities.