Major Garrett's Tough Question For Obama Sparks Liberal Outrage
During today's press conference, one exchange in particular has been making the rounds regarding the failure of the Iran Deal to address Americans being held hostage by Iran. Major Garrett of CBS News asked Obama a tough question on the topic, and in return, the President told him "you should know better."MAJOR GARRETT: Thank you, Mr. President. As you well know, there are four Americans in Iran three held on trumped-up charges and according to your administration and one whereabouts unknown. Can you tell the country, sir, why you are content with all the fanfare around this deal to leave the conscience of this nation, the strength of this nation unaccounted for in relation to these four Americans?Certainly a tough question, though one cannot help but recall the Bush administration, where this question would not only be de rigueur, but Garrett's particular phrasing would be, if anything, out of place as too respectful. Still, it was a bridge too far for Obama and the liberal press that worship him.OBAMA: I've got to give you credit for how you craft those questions. The notion that Im content as I celebrate with American citizens languishing in Iranian jails Major, thats nonsense, and you should know better. Ive met with the families of some of those folks. Nobody is content, and our diplomats and our teams are working diligently to try to get them out.Predictably, the liberal outrage meter went into overdrive at this tough question for the President. Blogger Soopermexican notes some of the Twitter rage.But it is not limited, naturally, to simple Twitter outrage. Mediaite reports that CNN's Dana Bash had a similar moment of partisan bluster.You've been a White House reporter, I've been a White House reporter. you know what it's like to stand up and ask the President a question and you do want be tough, but there's a fine line, especially, maybe, a multiple standing in the East Room, a fine line between asking a tough question and maybe crossing that line a little bit and being disrespectful, so I think that that happened here.It is an especially galling reaction from the press considering that one of the people being held by Iran, with no immediate relief in his future, is himself a reporter.Since Obama has taken office two things are routinely painted as "disrespect": asking questions of the President, and disagreeing with the President. It is a far cry from the relationship the press had with the Bush administration. Any interview, any question by a reporter, that is not obsequious and designed as a method for him to further his own messaging is called disrespectful or racist. http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/major-garretts-tough-question-obama-sparks-liberal-outrage

Ironic, isn't it, that when the US was urging Israel to give Abbas everything he wanted to continue peace talks, the first thing on the agenda was the release of over a hundred known hard line terrorist criminals in Israeli prisons.
I guess the US didn't have anything Iran wanted bad enough to even bring up the possibility of releasing four average Americans.
Obama might possibly be the worst negotiator in history. We just gave Iran approximately half their GDP in sanctions relief. If Obama had simply said include the hostages must be included in the deal, of course Iran would have released them.
A success at what, is the horrifying question.
I'm not an Obama fan but I think the question was insulting. The purpose of the deal was to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon and it was a multinational negotiation, not simply a negotiation between the US and Iran. This was a difficult negotiation because we can't have effective unilateral sanctions and Russia/China want the sanctions to end. Russia/China are not concerned with American hostages and we can't make sanctions work without the support of the world community. Complicating matters is the fact that Iran is supplying the boots on the ground (either its own boots or the Shia militias it supports) to fight ISIL in Syria and Iraq. It's awkward to ask for Iran's help while cracking them in the head.
Garrett's question implies that Obama was content to let the hostages rot simply because he didn't insist on risking a nuclear deal by making it contingent on their release. Iran routinely holds Americans, in my opinion, as an implied bargaining chip. They are arrested for little or no reason and released the same way but the release often coincides with an event that pleases Iran. Sanctions don't please Iran, so Americans are arrested and held in captivity; if the sanctions are lifted, then the hostages may go free. Even dogs get the message if, after doing what you want, they get a treat. I guess we'll see what happens if Congress approves the nuclear deal.
Your enthusiasm for kissing Obama's butt is well established by now . If Obama is for it , so are you , no questions asked .., and anyone who disagrees is a racist . Your views are a sick parody of democracy .
What the nuclear dealisnotis a broader deal on myriad other issues we have with Iran. We are not close to opening full diplomatic relations with Iran, as we are with Cuba.
(But, who knows, maybe the gates are open for making some other deals, similarlylimited in scopeanddo-ablewith difficult negotiations).
It's a "nuclear" deal that includes lifting conventional arms and ballistic missile embargoes. To say it's a limited "nuclear" deal is simply false.
If Obama made the release of the hostages a condition for giving Iran the jihadist stimulus package, it would have taken Iran 5 seconds to agree.
"Ive met with the families of some of those folks. "
"Some of the families" of four hostages who have been there for four years.
What a caring legacy to leave, eh? "Oh I care for some of you"
The arms embargo was imposed by the international community in response to Iran's nuclear program so the two are clearly linked. The detainees/hostages, on the other hand,havenothingto do with a nuclear program and would muddy an already difficult negotiation that has missed several deadlines. I assume that the goal of the negotiation was to stop Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon (as opposed to nuclear power) and keep the international community united in doing so (while ignoring the fact that Israel has already done what Iran is supposedly doing and has suffered nosanctionsat all). Anyway, throwing the detaineesinto the mix would complicate things. Iran could counter and say release particular detainees at Guantanamo or bargain forsomethingelse altogether. Russiaand China could say that we're only here to resolve an issue of interest to the international community, not resolveunrelatedissues between the US and Iran, but if you want to throw unrelated issues on the table then we have a few of our own. Opening this can of worms could mean that the negotiation falls apart and the detainees would still be detained, which accomplishes absolutely nothing.
The fact that it was not an issue in the nuclear negotiation doesn't mean it's not a priority. There are lots ofpriorities thatweren'tpart of the negotiations but they're still priorities.
They conventional arms issue only entered the deal when it became clear as negotiations were winding down that the US was folding on all points in a desperate attempt to secure any deal, Iran decided to shoot for the moon. That's the only reason they got tossed into the mix at the end.
It's axiomatic that parties set the terms of an agreement and hostages could just as easily been inserted into the negotiations as conventional arms and ballistic missiles. However, to so do successfully, the US had to create the perception that it would walk away from a deal, and no one involved in this fiasco could possibly believe that the US would walk out over any issue. It's been clear that a deal, any deal, was the only goal for this President.
That's the tragedy of this deal. The US entered negotiations holding the upper hand and were left simply begging for a deal at the end after abandoning issue after issue to the Iranians. Say what you will, but the Iranians know how to take advantage of a President who was only concerned with obtaining a deal, not its contents. Once it became clear that the US would never walk away from a deal, any chance to rescue the hostages, not to mention the stated goal of stopping Iran's nuclear program, was lost.
. Russiaand China could say that we're only here to resolve an issue of interest to the international community
Illegallydetaining foreigners is an issue of interest to theinternationalcommunity. A competentnegotiatorwould tell Russia and China that's fine, I'll announce to the world that talks havebroken down because you support Iran's illegal hostage taking and then let Russia and China deal with the blowback. Holding illegal hostages is not a good p.r. move. It should be easy to takeadvantageof it. In fact it should have been aprecondition to even having talks.
Of course, Russia and China have billions at stake so they'd never let the deal flounder over 4 hostages, if they believed Obama could actually walk away. That's the thing though, Obama is such an obvious supplicant that Russia and China could ignore any such requests, if theadministrationeven bothered to make them.
pening this can of worms could mean that the negotiation falls apart
So what? Iran had much more to lose than the US ifnegotiationsfell apart. Sanctions reliefalone equates to essentially half their GDP. It's thisnonsensicalneed to have adeal at all costs that turned it into such a travesty.
It's almost incomprehensible how badly thesenegotiationswent. Five years olds know how tobargain better.
The conventional arms issue was in the mix from the beginning because the arms embargo was a response to Iran's nuclear program. Detainees have nothing to do with it. There's a great deal more in play here than US interests and 4 detainees (especially when every country involved probably has detainees). It wasn't a US dominated negotiation but rather an international effort involving the US, Russia, China, France, and Germany. China wants access to Iranian oil and would frown upon Russia gumming things up. Russia wants access to Chinese markets, now more than ever because of US/European sanctions over Ukraine. Russia wants to be able to sell conventional weapons to Iran to offset losses resulting from a drop in oil prices. Russia also wants the US to drop the notion of a European missile shield since the reason for the shield was the Iranian nuclear bomb and that threat has been taken off the table. Russia also wants contracts in Iran's peaceful nuclear energy development and has an interest in thawing US/Russian relations. The US wants to stop Iran from building a nuclear bomb as long as possible and needs international support. If the US acts like a spoiled 5 year old brat (threatening to grab his marbles and going home), then Russia and China could simply stop cooperating. . . . and this all falls apart. So I think brinkmanship under these circumstances would be foolish. This was not the place to put detainees on the table so I agree with Obama on this one. Instead, conclude the deal, set an environment of improved relations with Iran, and then negotiate a release of the detainees.
The conventional arms issue was in the mix from the beginning because the arms embargo was a response to Iran's nuclear program
The original fact sheet in April said it would not address the conventional arms issue, let alone the ICBMs. Iran only insisted upon it after the US caved on everything else in the final negotiations
If the US acts like a spoiled 5 year old brat (threatening to grab his marbles and going home), then Russia and China could simply stop cooperating. . . . and this all falls apart..
I see. Insisting that innocents not be illegally detained is acting like a brat. Imagine how bratty we would have been to insist that Iran stop supporting terrorism in order to get access to billions of dollars. Much better that Iran continue to fund terrorists than anyone think us brats.
Sadly, America didn't act anything like a brat or even a competent negotiator, it acted like a beggar content to receive whatever scraps Iran deemed worthy of giving it. You'd think Iran was the global superpower and the USA an impoverished country desperate to have crippling sanctions lifted.
Who cares if it fell apart? We didn't obtain our goals, the hostages remain hostages, and Iran now has billions of extra dollars to fund international jihad with and a clear path to a nuclear bomb whenever it wants one.
This attitude is precisely why we negotiated such a terrible deal. But hey! it's a deal!!!
What do you expect from the world's worst negotiator? The more details come out on this deal, the worse it looks.
Whether or not it was in the original fact sheet, the link between the nuclear issue and conventional arms is patently obvious because the embargo was areactionto Iran's nuclear program. In contrast to the obviousconnectionbetween an arms embargo and Iran's nuclear program,detaineeshave no connection whatsoever.
And Iran could insist that we stop supporting Israeli expansion through the occupied territories. Neither demand has anything to do with Iran's nuclear program and either demand could collapse negotiations . . . which was not Obama's goal.
To me, the US was neither beggar nor brat but rather one voice in a chorus and behaved as such. Although we are a global superpower, and Iran is not, we cannot unilaterally impose crippling sanctions or continue them without cooperation of the other powers atthetable.
If we make clear that we don't care about any interests other than our own, then we set a precedent for others to express the same opinion in future negotiations. The sanctions could fall apart as countries makedecisionsbased exclusively on their interests and Russia and China could simply stop enforcing the sanctions and decline to implement others. If sanctions fall apart, Iran will get billions, thedetaineeswill continue to be detained, and Iran will resume its previous course of action. It's not a great deal but I'm not seeing how Obama could have gotten a better one by stamping his feet or by walking out and essentially throwing the baby out with the bath water.
When it comes to rogue nations there are many far better candidates for that descriptor . Iraq used to be until Bush took out S. Hussein . Right now the most rogue nation in many years is being born in the region of Syria & Iraq . It doesn't have formal recognition yet but it calls itself ISIS . If you are trying to compare Israel to ISIS you are badly deluded .
Your ignorance of the facts is of no surprise . N. Korea might be the only 1 of those 4 that has signed the treaty . It is "rogue" [whatever that means] because it won't abide by the treaty . The others have no such obligation including Israel . Iran chose to sign so they are in violation until they comply with the demands .
So , you're OK with ISIL getting the bomb ?
Of course I don't want them to have a bomb.
For Petey twisting one's words into outright lies is his hobby...and obsession.
As for the rest of your comment...Absolutely correct!