╌>

The danger of partisan conservative moderators

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  11 years ago  •  1 comments

The danger of partisan conservative moderators

Byron York questions whether National Review should be allowed to moderate the February debate given some of its commentators’ remarks about Donald Trump. York notes National Review has been critical of other candidates as well, concluding:

The underlying problem here is that some of the networks have leaned so far left in the past that the RNC [Republican National Committee] felt the need to insist on including someone who “speaks conservative” among the debate panelists. But some of the best conservative speakers are prominent figures at opinion publications who are 1) appalled by Trump, and 2) unconstrained from expressing their feelings about him. That makes for a lively public conversation, but is it a good idea for a presidential debate?

Well, National Review journalists, as news reporters and analysts (from a conservative perspective, of course), certainly are more fit to moderate than talk show hosts proposed by Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Tex.). The latter have inveighed nonstop against anyone who might stray from their “no amnesty” (i.e. mass deportation or self-deportation) line. York nevertheless raises an interesting point about conservative moderators.

To the extent a Republican moderator has a stake in the outcome, favoring one or another candidate, he or she would be more objectionable than mainstream media reporters who are not rooting for a particular candidate. Say what you will about John Harwood, but he was an equal-opportunity aggressor. In that regard, the playing field was leveled. (The better debaters — including Cruz, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie and Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) — rose to the occasion and turned the tables on the sneering moderators.)

The idea that moderators should have some sympathy with the GOP or even be GOP primary voters, as some candidates have suggested, is deeply misguided. An ideal moderator should understand and grill the participants on the differences between the candidates and the issues of interest to Republican voters; that, however, does not require the moderator be a Republican. There is, we should acknowledge, a shortage of mainstream media figures who actually understand conservatives and don’t operate based on negative stereotypes, but that goes to a larger problem of ideological homogeneity in the mainstream media. The point here is that “having a stake” in the debate’s outcome is precisely what the GOP should avoid. The GOP should not seek to replace liberal antagonists with conservatives likely to show favoritism toward one or more contenders.

There certainly are conservative media figures who have not cheered for one or more candidates. Hugh Hewitt, who has interviewed virtually every candidate (many multiple times), has remained doggedly neutral. He therefore was an ideal participant in the CNN debate. But we have also seen mainstream media journalists (e.g. Jake Tapper, Anderson Cooper) who are fully able to refrain from hyper-partisanship.

The bottom line is that aside from the CNBC debate, the moderating panels have worked reasonably well. Rather than overreact by stacking the deck with self-identified Republicans who don’t bother to conceal their ideological favorites, the candidates should pipe down and return to a debate schedule that will include moderators with varying degrees of skill and restraint. Candidates need to be tested under adverse conditions, which sometimes includes nasty questioners. How else are they to prepare for the general election?

Jennifer Rubin writes the Right Turn blog for The Post, offering reported opinion from a conservative perspective.

 

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/right-turn/wp/2015/11/04/the-danger-of-partisan-conservative-moderators/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_popns

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The bottom line is that aside from the CNBC debate, the moderating panels have worked reasonably well. Rather than overreact by stacking the deck with self-identified Republicans who don’t bother to conceal their ideological favorites, the candidates should pipe down and return to a debate schedule that will include moderators with varying degrees of skill and restraint. Candidates need to be tested under adverse conditions, which sometimes includes nasty questioners. How else are they to prepare for the general election?

I couldn't agre more, though personally I think the CNBC crew did an excellent job. Still, that aside if the GOP candidates want to prove the can handle a General Election debate, where they get none of the hundreds of choices they are demanding for the primary debates now, they have to take a deep breath and actually answer some tough questions. Yes, I know they don't want to and several of them just plain can't, but they should look at this as training for the General Election debates and for (if a miracle on the order of the loaves and fishes occurs and one of them actually gets elected) confrontations in the real world when real lives and nations are at stake, instead of just playing at arguing games like they want to now.

 
 

Who is online





142 visitors