Reality Check: Are Gun-Free Zones Ripe For Mass Shootings?
When I say “mass shooting,” there is something that immediately comes to mind: a very specific kind of public, media focused, random killing of innocent people by a gunman.
Is it true that those kinds of killings are virtually all taking place in areas known as gun-free zones?
If so, are these gun free zones actually ripe of mass shootings?
This is a Reality Check you won’t get anywhere else.
The debate over “gun free zones” is a heated one. Conservative media, after a shooting like the one at the Umpqua Community College in Oregon, immediately begin to say that we need to consider gun free zones as part of the problem.
Media on the left fires back that those claims are untrue.
Take for instance an article published by Media Matters for America, which states that despite claims about gun free zones, “The overwhelming majority of mass shootings actually occur where guns are allowed to be carried.”
So where are the numbers to back that up? It comes from this report by a group called “Everytown for Gun Safety.”
That report was published last year and states that only 14 percent of mass public shootings take place in gun-free zones. Everytown claims that 86 percent of such incidents occurred in places where guns were allowed.
The only problem with that analysis is that according to the Crime Prevention Research Center, the Everytown analysis is wrong—very wrong. “Everytown’s recent analysis of mass shootings is riddled with errors. Mistakes are made on the number of mass shootings as well as the extent of mental illness, the killers’ ages, and even where the attacks occurred.”
So what are the correct numbers?
In order to get them, the Crime Prevention Research Center looked at mass public shootings since the beginning of 2009. They focused on attacks that have “particularly terrified Americans – the mass shootings in public places.”
These are shootings about which they say “The point of such crimes is to kill people and creating as much carnage as possible to obtain media attention.”
Also, they focused exclusively on shootings, excluding such attacks as the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing. And they exclude gang violence and turf wars—again focusing on mass shootings designed to create terror.
So what did they find?
From January 2009 through the middle of July 2014, there were 25 mass public shootings where at least four people were killed with a gun.
Of those shootings, 8 percent of mass public shootings have occurred in places where civilians are allowed to defend themselves. The other 92 percent happened in a so-called gun-free zone.
Aside from those statistics, consider what some of these mass shooters themselves have said.
Elliot Rodger, who shot to death three people in Santa Barbara, explained why he picked his target. In his 141-page “manifesto,” he said he chose to skip one location for the shooting because he worried someone with a gun, specifically armed police, would stop him before he could kill enough people.
James Holmes, the killer at the Colorado movie theater, lived within a 20-minute drive of seven movie theaters that were showing the premier of the Batman movie, but he chose the one single theater that banned guns.
Possibly the most shocking example to people is the Fort Hood shooting in 2009, where 13 people were killed and 30 others injured. Or the Washington D.C. Naval yard shooting where 12 people were killed and eight wounded. Or the Navy recruiting center in Chattanooga, Tenn. where four marines were killed. All three are military installations that are “gun free zones,” with the exception of military police who are allowed to be armed.
What you need to know is that first of all, there is no way to know if most of these shooters knew they were in gun-free zones or if they targeted because of it.
But the question is still a fair one. Are these zones, which are designed to make people safer, with the best of intentions, making the victims of these attackers easy targets?
Take the politics out of it so that we can have a real discussion about whether gun-free zones are actually accomplishing what they are meant to do.
http://truthinmedia.com/reality-check-gun-free-zones/
Tags
Who is online
85 visitors
