╌>

Tribal sovereignty act passes

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  1stwarrior  •  11 years ago  •  26 comments

Tribal sovereignty act passes

http://www.abcfoxmontana.com/story/30542389/tribal-sovereignty-act-passes#.Vky-D08zHUc.facebook

 

WASHINGTON D.C. -

Courtesy press release

Today, Congress passed the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act of 2015 (249-177 with 24 Democrats joining a majority of Republicans), which rolls back federal agency intervention in tribal affairs in order to restore greater sovereignty to tribes. Montana Congressman Ryan Zinke cosponsored and voted for the measure. The legislation will amend the National Labor Relations Act to affirm that the law does not apply to any business owned and operated by an Indian tribe and located on tribal land, restoring to tribal leaders control over employee-employer relations.

“This is about sovereignty, opportunity and respect,” said Rep. Ryan Zinke.  “The federal government already saddles our tribes with burdensome regulations that hamper their ability to achieve the same goals of prosperity and success that we all aspire to. Considering the fact that the NLRB notoriously overreaches in the private sector, imagine what damage they would do to Montana’s tribes. H.R.511 is supported by tribes all across the nation. This bill affirms my strong support for their sovereignty.”

Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act Of 2015:

  • Prevents the NLRB from exerting jurisdiction over Native American businesses operating on tribal lands by restoring a legal standard in place long before the board’s misguided decision.
  • Protects the sovereignty of Native American tribes, ensuring they are afforded the same rights and protections enjoyed by state and local governments.
  • Returns to tribes the ability to govern labor relations in their businesses in a way they determine is best for their workplaces, eliminating legal confusion and uncertainty.

Background: In 2004, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) issued the San Manuel Indian Bingo and Casino decision, overturning a long-standing precedent, and began using a subjective test to determine when and where to assert its jurisdiction over Indian tribes. Prior to its San Manuel decision, the NLRB respected the sovereignty of Native American tribes, holding that they were generally free from outside intervention. The board now decides on a case-by-case basis whether a tribal business on tribal land is for commercial purposes, and if it is, the board asserts its jurisdiction over that business. As a result, the NLRB is picking winners and losers among Indian tribes and creating legal confusion and uncertainty for tribal leaders and businesses.

Members of the Native American community have raised concerns about the NLRB’s “increasingly aggressive approach to enforcement,” saying it:

  • “Creates unacceptable risks and uncertainties for all tribal nation rights under federal law and to their dignity as sovereigns;”
  • “Infringes on the ability of tribes to govern activities on their lands and provide vital services to [their] members;” and
  • “Impair[s] tribal sovereignty and the developing economies in Indian country.” 

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    11 years ago

“The federal government already saddles our tribes with burdensome regulations that hamper their ability to achieve the same goals of prosperity and success that we all aspire to."

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   11 years ago

The bill still has to pass the Senate, correct?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

Yeah - the story is misleading by stating that Congress passed the bill - should have read the House passed the bill.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   11 years ago

Well let's hope that the Senate does the right thing.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

I hope so, too!

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    11 years ago

The tribes, as sovereign nations, are "supposed" to be autonomous with their tribal businesses.  The Indian Reorganization Act and the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistant Act furthered that fact that has been expressed by SCOTUS on many, many occasions.

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity    11 years ago

I am in agreement with the act, that tribes should have control over labor relations on their respective reservations. But the tribes should have in place a similar system to insure a level playing field for all members of the reservation.  I do not know about many other tribes, but I do see unfair labor practices on the reservation here on a consistent bases. If the shoshone tribe is in control of on tribal operations, qualified arapahoe tribal members will not be hired only Shoshone's will be hired, and it goes both ways for each tribe.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Jim Cassity   11 years ago

Jim - that is one of the issues with many of the tribes - their inter-tribal bickering causes many an organization to fall apart.  It's all going to boil down to trust within the Indian community to determine if this will work or not.

 
 
 
deepwaterdon
Freshman Silent
link   deepwaterdon    11 years ago

Writing my 2 Senators to pass this bill. Patty Murray and Maria Cantwell, both Dems., have many Indians as constituents, and have for the most part always done and voted on national interests, that benefits the citizens of Washington. The state, not D.C.

Thanks for the info., !st.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  deepwaterdon   11 years ago

Patty will jump in for sure.

 
 
 
deepwaterdon
Freshman Silent
link   deepwaterdon  replied to  1stwarrior   11 years ago

She will get my vote for re-election, if not for this, then definitely for her work with Vets and the VA, especially here in Washington, alone.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  deepwaterdon   11 years ago

She's definitely a constituent oriented person.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I have a stupid question (they didn't teach this or a lot of other things in the school I went to). If a NA is living on tribal land and that tribal land is a sovereign nation, then (and I'm not trying to offend anyone) why aren't those nations marked on the map as no longer being a part of the state they are in and why aren't they a citizen of that nation instead of the US? How can they be citizens of both? I mean the Navajo Nation is huge, but why, when you look at a standard American map, it's not shown as being separate from the states it covers? Why isn't it shown as a separate country? Also, if they are Sovereign nations, then why do residents of these independent nations vote in American elections and not just in their tribal elections?

I guess what I'm asking (stupidly), just what does being a Sovereign Nation mean, because it seems like it's part of the United States, but not, at the same time?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Randy - good questions.

Prior to 1924, Indians could not vote in local/state/fed elections because they weren't U.S. citizens.

Upon gaining citizenship, they could vote as does everyone else because all the activities in the outside community have an impact on the nation/tribal members - taxes on roads, food, clothing, education, etc..  In addition, they also vote in tribal/nation elections because of the impact on the immediate living area - even though the outside world is not allowed to get involved with tribal politics as they are not tribal.

Some tribal/nation members who are urban Indians "can" vote in tribal/nation elections through the absentee ballot purely because the outcome of the election will have an impact on them when they visit or on their relatives who still live there.

On the maps, USGS has plotted the boundaries of the reservations as identified in the treaties/as amended and, yes, they are very separate from the state they may be a part of.  Tribes/nations are sovereign entities and nothing the state/city/community can do will erase that sovereignty.

Helpful?

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Indian tribes are actually considered "domestic dependent nations". Just like  Federal government and state governments neither have absolute sovereignty (States and indian tribes have full police power, but neither have the power to print currency) they have parallel power.  

Article I, Section 2, Clause 3 states that "Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States ... excluding Indians not taxed." [2]  According to Storey's Commentary on the U.S. Constitution, "There were Indians, also, in several, and probably in most, of the states at that period, who were not treated as citizens, and yet, who did not form a part of independent communities or tribes, exercising general sovereignty and powers of government within the boundaries of the states."

Article 1 section 8 of the constitution states that " Congress shall have the power to regulate Commerce with foreign nations and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes”,  determining that Indian tribes were separate from the federal government, the states, and foreign nations;

The Marshall Trilogy which is a set of three Supreme Court decisions affirming the legal and political standing of indian nations.

Johnson v. M'Intosh - Private citizens could not purchase lands from Native Americans

Cherokee Naticon v. Georgia - Holding that the cherokee nation dependent, with a relationship to the United States like that of a "ward to its guardian."

Worcester v. Georgia - laid out the relationship between tribes and states and federal governments, stating the federal government was the sole authority to deal with Indian Nations.

The Indian Appropriations act ended the United states recognition of additional Tribes and prohibited additional treaties.  Requiring the Federal Government  to interact with tribes through statutes instead of treaties.

There are several other key Acts and Supreme court cases that formulate Indian law.

United States v. Kagama

Empowerment of tribal courts

General allotment act (Dawes Act)

Revenue and Indian Citizenship Acts.

Hope this helps but it is quite a complex area of law to try and explain in a post.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Jim Cassity   11 years ago

Jim and 1stwarrior. It does help, but it seems like it needs to be changed to make the NA Nations completely independent from the US, with their own money, governmental system (Congress or Parliament or whatever), supreme court, taxes, military, ambassadors, passports, border guards, police, etc. Everything an independent nation has or does. I mean they really wouldn't need military I guess, considering their surrounded by the US.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Randy, that will never happen. We are only as sovereign as the government wants us to be. If it suits there needs, then we are sovereign, if not, we are not.

It's really that simple. This is evident in the numerous court cases where we have to fight the encroachment on what sovereign status we have.

It was an excellent question Randy. I for one would like to see more questions like yours, as it opens up a new area to explore and for better understanding of Indian people.

1st, Jim and I may seen things a big differently. We each come from different tribes/nations, so some of our experiences within that realm will be different.

Jim mentioned the rivalry between the Shoshone and Arapahoe on the rez. History will show you exactly why that is taking place. The U.S. government decided that the two tribes should share the same land, even though they have been adversaries for generations. The outcome of today should have been seen by the government. They speak different languages, have different customs, etc. Not a invitation for a healthy relationship.

Can those two tribes overcome their differences and join forces for improvement for both tribes? I honestly don't know Randy, I would hope so.

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

Exactly we are only as sovereign as the Federal Government and courts will allow.  Complete Sovereignty would also come with it's own set of challenges, such as trade agreements, Passports to leave the reservation etc.  Each tribe or reservation would in effect be its own country.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Jim Cassity   11 years ago

To all three of you then. Is this something that most or some or all of the tribes would want? Would they want their nations as they are now, to become "real" independent countries, with completely independent governments and economies and such? It seems like it would be only fair to me, though I would be afraid that some of them would be really poor and need assistance. Or do most Nations prefer the limited sovereignty they have now?

As I said, these are issues they never taught in any of the history classes I ever went to and I loved history, although ancient was my favorite so maybe I just didn't take the right classes. Or more likely they weren't available 40 years ago. I have watched conversations on here for years and have always wanted to ask about these things, but never thought I knew enough to ask without being insultingly stupid. How's that for strange? I always thought I was too dumb to ask in order to learn.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Randy, I can only answer your question from my point of view and that of my tribe/nation. If, and it's a big if, the government would uphold their end of the agreements/treaties and not keep attempting to take or infringe on what sovereignty we have than there is no reason to change the current situation. From a geographical view, the limitations that it would put on both Indian and non Indians would, IMO, be a real problem area.

I don't believe that you'll find any classes in high school today, that teach this part of our history. In fact, Indian Law is probably the most misunderstood of all segments of the law. This would include judges, lawyers and even extends to SCOTUS.

Keep the question coming Randy.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

The whole thing sounds like a big mess that will take years to untangle. I remember when I was growing up part of my childhood in Hopkins Michigan and then living there as an adult for several years that there were Native Americans around, but that there was no nation or reservation. It would seem that there is one now. The Match-E-Be-Nash-She-Wish Band of Pottawatomi Indians was recognized in 1998, several years after I had moved to Phoenix.

The size of the land is only 147 acres and consists mostly of tribal offices and a casino, which many non Native residents think is the only reason for the tribe's existence. However there is a long history of the tribe in the area dating well back into the 1800's, but they had no land in more modern times. A treaty in 1821 provided for only 3 square miles land near Kalamazoo to be recognized as belonging to this band of the Pottawatomi tribe, which would not seem to be quite fair to say the least. I can not say for sure why the land was not there when I lived there, except to say that it's likely that it was just plain taken from them.

When my mother told me that she enjoys going over to the casino from time to time I was rather surprised, as no Nation or reservation existed when I lived in the area. Still, the history is there and is indisputable. While it's obvious that they would be self-supporting, there are many nations that I hear about, especially in places in South Dakota and that area, that would not be.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Randy, the first European contact with the Pottawatomi was by the French in the 17th century in upstate Michigan. They are part of the ''Council of Three Fires'', which are the Ojibwe, Odana (Ottowa) and the Pottawatomi. This confederacy was existed for centuries.

The Pottawatomi held vast tracks of land in the area, but through westward expansion and forced relocation to Oklahoma they had little left.

In the ''Council of Three Fires'' they are know as the ''Keepers of the sacred fire''. The Odana are the ''Trader People'', and the Ojibwe are the ''Keepers of the Sacred scrolls and waterdrum of the Midewiwin''.

Many of the customs/religion are quite similar between the three Nations.

 

 

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Randy - the lands that the tribe have now are known as "treaty" lands - i.e. they were granted the tribe by treaty but, when the Indian Reorganization Act was passed in 1934, the Termination Act of 1953 - the lands disappeared.  The Pottawatomie's sued, SCOTUS said PUBLIC LAW 105–143, DEC. 15, 1997 - MICHIGAN INDIAN LAND CLAIMS SETTLEMENT ACT, restored "some" of the treaty lands - proportedly up to the 3 sqmiles and maybe more, depending on the locale.  That is where the tribe was/is allowed to build their casino's.

Interestingly, the Fort Sill Apache Tribe was given 37 ACRES of land just off I-10, outside of Deming, NM, by the state and their first project is to build a casino.  The land is "former" Apache lands - known as treaty lands.

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Very tough question to answer!  If you asked all the independent tribes/nation if they wanted complete sovereignty I would venture a guess that they would say yes.  The question then comes to the point that many reservations are extremely poor with very little  economic development, and those tribes/nations would struggle greatly without any help from the government.  To add to the confusion you have tribes/nations that have been forced to live on the same reservation who have very opposing views of how that reservation should be governed.

Tribes/nations do have independent governments which run the functions of the reservation similar to state government. Some of the governing bodies do extremely well and some are quite lacking in the ability to govern themselves.  Take for example the Wind River Indian Reservation in Wyoming, although I am not a member of either of these tribes, I reside within the exterior boundaries of the Reservation. The Shoshone and Arapahoe tribes have been mortal enemies for as long as can be remembered.  the Shoshone tribe was settled on the Wind River reservation,  the Arapahoe tribe was  placed on the same reservation by the Federal Government. A joint business council, which has recently been dismantled was formed to run day to day operations on the reservation, (utilities, road repairs etc.), but each tribe function as a separate entity when it comes to dealing with inter-tribal matters.  So in Wyoming the Reservation is basically a state within Wyoming that governs itself, and within the reservation you have two tribes which again govern themselves. 

Some tribes/nations like my tribe would do quite well governing themselves and others would have an extreme difficulties.  Just like states, some fare better than others when it comes to governing themselves, some need more help from the Federal Government than others.

 

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Randy, to answer some/part of your question, it is true that the federal government signed many treaties with tribes promising various types of benefits. Treaties "established unique sets of rights, benefits, and conditions for the treaty-making tribes who agreed to cede of millions of acres of their homelands to the United States." However, Supreme Court decisions in the early 20th century "held that Congress has the power to modify or terminate Indian treaties without Indians' consent. These decisions opened the way for Congress to treat all Indians the same, regardless of the treaties they had signed." The Snyder Act of 1921 ended the delivery of the particular benefits specified in treaties. The Act unified federal benefits for the tribes, and made Indian social programs subject to the same congressional spending adjustments as other programs.

Another issue is that the federal government has a long-standing "trust responsibility" to Indian tribes. That means that while Congress holds ultimate power over tribal governments, it is supposed to consider the best interests of the tribes when it makes decisions. The BIA says that the trust responsibility is "a legally enforceable fiduciary obligation on the part of the United States to protect tribal treaty rights, lands, assets, and resources."

However, as the tribes move further toward self-governance, the trust responsibility becomes less relevant, as the Supreme Court has suggested. That is, as tribes gain greater control over their lands, natural resources, and trust funds, it becomes their own responsibility to manage them well, not the federal government's responsibility. It had long been understood that the BIA was supposed to "work itself out of a job" as it helped Indians become self-sufficient.

Indian advocates sometimes say that the federal trust responsibility includes not just the protection of Indian lands and resources, but the protection of subsidies as well—as if tribes should receive subsidies in perpetuity. But BIA expert Theodore Taylor noted that this is "loose use" of the trust idea that is factually incorrect, and that legally, Indian subsidies are "gratuitous" benefits that can be cut off whenever Congress decides to do so.

Indian self-determination is inconsistent with continued Indian dependence on the government for subsidies. Besides, Indian subsidies have similar negative economic effects as other government subsidies, such as farm subsidies and welfare subsidies. Subsidies reduce the incentive of recipients to pursue productive activities. As far back as the 1928 Meriam report, experts have observed that BIA subsidies reduced the incentive of Indians to work.

While ending subsidies is controversial, there is broader agreement that self-determination should mean greater Indian control over their lands and resources. Over the last century, the BIA has been a miserable failure at managing Indian resources. The agency has often sold timber, coal, minerals, oil, and natural gas on Indian lands at below-market prices. In reports dating back to the 1950's, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) has criticized the government's under-collection of income from the resources on Indian's lands and the general disarray of its accounting for these resources.

- See more at:

 
 

Who is online

Nerm_L
CB


114 visitors