╌>

Why you’ll always lose with drones alone

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  11 years ago  •  14 comments

Why you’ll always lose with drones alone

863_discussions.jpg?width=750 The U.S.-led air campaign against Islamic State militants in Iraq and Syria is having a devastating effect on the insurgent forces. That is, if you believe the Pentagons continuing tally of destroyed and damaged vehicles, facilities and troop formations.

But the official statistics are meaningless. Because U.S. pilots are flying blind. To a great extent, they dont know what if anything theyre hitting.

More so than in any recent conflict, American aviators soaring over Iraq and Syria rely on remote-controlled drones to spot targets for them. This is one consequence of President Barack Obamas policy barring U.S. ground troops from any direct combat role.

The big problem? Drones make terrible spotters. Even after decades of development, Americas unmanned aerial vehicles can provide only a narrow, grainy view of the battlefield. Contrary to popular belief, Andrew Cockburn writes in his new history of military drones, Kill Chain: The Rise of the High-Tech Assassins , the imagery tends to be fuzzy.

A war waged mostly from the air still demands people on the ground, people with eyeballs whose visual acuity still beats a drones sensors. As long as Washington refuses to deploy human spotters against Islamic State, it wont know for sure whether air strikes are hitting the right people or anyone at all.

On their face, the official Defense Department stats are impressive. Between the first air raids in August 2014 and June 22, no fewer than 15,000 U.S.-led strikes destroyed or damaged 7,655 militant targets in Iraq and Syria, including 98 tanks, 325 captured U.S.-made Humvees, 2,045 buildings and 1,859 fighting positions, the latter presumably occupied by Islamic State troops.

U.S. officials estimated that the air raids have killed around 1,000 militant fighters a month.

The destruction of ISIL targets in Syria and Iraq, the Pentagon claimed, using the administrations acronym for Islamic State, further limits the terrorist groups ability to project terror and conduct operations.

But there are good reasons to doubt the militarys damage assessments and body counts and its assertion that aerial attacks have badly hurt Islamic State. With their narrow field of view from a fixed overhead perspective, the drones that provide the main view of the war zone convey an imprecise picture.

This is also true for the drones that help guide many of the bombs the manned warplanes drop. The robot uses a powerful laser pointer to designate a target. A sensor on the bomb steers tiny wings that allow the munition to follow the laser all the way to the ground. But the bombs accuracy is only as good as the drones accuracy.

Drones can also fire their own missiles and drop their own bombs at targets they spot themselves, however imprecisely. One U.S. drone strike against an al Qaeda compound in Pakistan in January killed two innocent hostages: American contractor Warren Weinstein and Italian aid worker Giovanni Lo Porto. The White House admitted to the mistake in April in a rare bout of transparency regarding drone attacks.

Over Iraq and Syria, the drones stay very busy as they introduce dangerous uncertainty throughout the complex campaign. Were involved in pretty much every engagement, Colonel James Cluff, commander of the 432nd Wing, said of the U.S.-led air campaign over Iraq and Syria. The 432nd, stationed at Creech Air Force Base just north of Las Vegas, controls most of the Air Forces roughly 300 Predator and Reaper drones.

For operations in Iraq and Syria, small crews apparently launch and land the drones from a base in Kuwait. Operators at Creech control the robotic aircraft via satellite, staring at banks of video monitors displaying the grainy images that the drones sensors are seeing.

By relying solely on these drones to locate targets and guide bombs, U.S. troops run the risk of hitting nothing. Or worse mistaking civilians for fighters and sending bombs raining down on them.

It has happened before. U.S. drone strikes in Pakistan since 2001 have killed up to 3,976 people, according to the British-based Bureau of Investigative Journalism. As many as 965 of the dead were innocent civilians, according to the bureaus count.

U.S. drone operations in Somalia and Yemen have also killed hundreds of noncombatants in the two countries. As with the battle against Islamic State, these campaigns are strictly aerial. There are no U.S. troops on the ground to verify targets.

The Pentagon does employ thousands of joint terminal air controllers, highly trained spotters whose sole job it is to locate targets for air strikes, first-hand. And then to help guide attacking warplanes via radio. You have to calculate so many different things with you and with the aircraft, said then-Airman 1st Class William Chandler, a joint terminal air controller who served in Afghanistan in 2010.

Theyre the glue that holds this all together, explained then-Brigadier General Steve Kwast, Chandlers commander. What the JTAC [joint terminal air controller] does is have a conversation between the aircraft and the ground commander to make sure our operations are sophisticated enough to solve problems without doing harm to the Afghan people.

There are more than 3,000 U.S. military advisers in Iraq, including joint terminal air controllers. But Obama has specifically barred them from going near the front lines, where they would do their best work using their own eyes to scan the battlefield.

During a visit last September to a military headquarters in Tampa, Florida, Obama stressed that the U.S. forces in Iraq do not and will not have a combat mission. Public opinion toward American troops role in Iraq has whipsawed on this. In October last year, 52 percent of respondents to a Reason-Ruppe poll said they opposed deploying U.S. ground troops to fight Islamic State. By February, this had shifted. A CBS poll found 57 percent of Americans were in favor of deploying ground forces in a combat role.

Drones instead fill in for human spotters, with potentially deadly consequences for civilians. And disturbing implications for Washingtons strategy in Iraq and Syria. How can the U.S. government truly know whether its winning the war against Islamic State if it doesnt know for sure who or what its bombing?

The Pentagon is aware of the problem. During a Senate hearing in May, Lieutenant General John Hesterman, commander of Air Forces squadrons in the Middle East, admitted that having joint terminal air controllers on the ground would be helpful.

Hestermans admission may be the military understatement of the year, as bombs rain down on people that remote drone operators, scrutinizing grainy overhead video, decided must depict enemy fighters.

http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2015/07/12/to-accurately-strike-islamic-state-the-pentagon-needs-boots-on-the-ground/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Public opinion toward American troops role in Iraq has whipsawed on this. In October last year, 52 percent of respondents to a Reason-Ruppe poll said they opposed deploying U.S. ground troops to fight Islamic State. By February, this had shifted. A CBS poll found 57 percent of Americans were in favor of deploying ground forces in a combat role.

With a margin of +/- 3.5% ????

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

As bad as it is or could be, sometimes you actually have to do what is necessary to accomplish a mission. The question is what is your mission. If you want to overcome ISIS you have to really be there.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

If you want to overcome ISIS you have to really be there.

That's the reality of it!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

we just fight them endlessly

When in the ME.... best to do as the Middle Easterners do....

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

When a decision in finally made to kick the asses of ISIS, we will put boots with feet in them on the ground close enough to do the kicking!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

A target is pretty easy to lase at 200M.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

"Obama stressed that the U.S. forces in Iraq do not and will not have a combat mission.'

Double speak at its best. What are we doing in Iraq now Barry, if not a combat mission???

Same thing/problem in Vietnam - the light FO's/RO's could only get "snap-shots" of an area before we, the troops, were sent in to demolish the area. Lotsa civilians lost that encounter due to bad intel.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

There hasn't been any question for over 17 years now that the US Military can reach out and touch someone.

WE are only now getting around to seeing that we really need to know just whom we are touching?

To do this successfully, we need to be a LOT closer than 8 thousand miles away.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Selective targeting in Nam using agent orange, napalm and willie peter. Ooopss should have added the 52's.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Not much collateral damage, was there??? /s

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

How big of an area could a single B-52 carrying 104 Mk-20 cluster bombs cover?

ISIS knows to stay out of open country and stick to the towns and civilian populations. By doing so, they for the large part neutralize our air power advantage.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Way, way, way too much collateral damage. Let's not give them more of a reason to hate by doing something ISIS would do if they had the planes and bombs. Terror bombing by us is no answer.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I just remember seeing first hand a B-52 doing a mine laying exercise in a bay. A single BUFF layed an underwater minefield in about 30 seconds compared to what it would take 12 carrier based aircraft (2x mines each) about 90 seconds to lay.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

When they would carpet bomb during Vietnam they would destroy a 5 square mile area. Nothing at all would be alive in that area when they were done. Not a single thing.

 
 

Who is online






Tacos!


95 visitors