The White House Lies About Gun Violence
August 26, 2015
Per a reporter at the Washington Post: Earnest reiterates WH call for tougher gun laws: Shooting is “another example of gun violence that is becoming all too common” in U.S. — David Nakamura (@DavidNakamura) August 26, 2015 This is wrong. “Gun violence” is not “becoming” anything. Rather, it’s down — and dramatically:
National rates of gun homicide and other violent gun crimes are strikingly lower now than during their peak in the mid-1990s, paralleling a general decline in violent crime, according to a Pew Research Center analysis of government data. Beneath the long-term trend, though, are big differences by decade: Violence plunged through the 1990s, but has declined less dramatically since 2000. Compared with 1993, the peak of U.S. gun homicides, the firearm homicide rate was 49% lower in 2010, and there were fewer deaths, even though the nation’s population grew. The victimization rate for other violent crimes with a firearm—assaults, robberies and sex crimes—was 75% lower in 2011 than in 1993. Violent non-fatal crime victimization overall (with or without a firearm) also is down markedly (72%) over two decades.
The available data is limited, but this trend does not seem to have changed since 2011. The bottom line: America is getting safer and less violent. Unfortunately, Pew reports, only 12 percent of Americans know this, which is why the Obama administration can get away with spreading falsehoods. If there is an argument to be made, it’s that America has too many gun-related deaths in absolute numbers, and that this drop does not make up for that. Personally, I don’t know what people who say this really mean. As always, we start from where we are, and we are going in the right direction. That’s good, especially given that the positive changes have come at the same time as the laws have been liberalized and the number of guns increased vastly. Either way, though, it is simply not true that there is an “epidemic” or a “surge” or that shootings are becoming “more common.” It’s not even true that mass shootings are up.
What has changed has little to do with firearms: Namely, that social media has become more powerful and round-the-clock news has become more prevalent. That, in my view, is the story of the day.

Actually, President Obama, Mass Killings Aren’t Uncommon In Other Countries
Let’s set aside the assertion that it’s too easy to obtain guns in America and deal with the implication that we are somehow uniquely violent or that “mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries.” The president has made this claim in various ways and with various qualifiers . *
Parlez vous Hebdo ? Because surely the president recalls that in January of this year two gunmen entered the office of a satirical magazine in France with an assortment of guns and murdered 11 people (and injured 11 more). After leaving, they killed a police officer. And in a marketplace catering to Jews another five were murdered and 11 wounded. France is, allegedly, an advanced country, is it not? Perhaps if Obama had attended the anti-terror rally in Paris like every other leader of advanced countries did, his recollection would be sharper.
It only takes some quick research to discover that rampage killers, acts of terror (as the Charleston shooting most certainly is), school attacks, spree killers are not unique to the United States .
In 2011, a deranged Anders Behring Breivik killed eight people by setting off a van bomb in Oslo, before going on to murder 69 more people, mostly children, at a summer camp. This is the single worst shooting spree incident in history . Obama surely remembers that he left the White House and visited the Norwegian ambassador’s residence to offer his condolences.
It takes only a rudimentary search to find out that mentally unstable killers can be found anywhere. In February of this year, nine people were killed in Czech Republic spree killing. In Erfurt, Germany, a couple of years ago, an expelled student murdered 13 teachers, 2 students and a policeman . That same year, in the Serbian village of Velika Ivanča, a gunman shot and killed 14 people —many of them his own relatives— and a Russia gunman opened fire with a semi-automatic rifle killing six people . A couple of years before that, in England, a lone gunman killed 12 people and injured 11 .
Advanced countries or developing ones, it’s the same thing. In 2013 a mentally unstable man in Rio de Janeiro killed 12 children and seriously wounded another 12 . And you might remember that China had an outbreak of mass stabbings, hammer and cleaver attacks not long ago. You don’t need guns to kill people. One man stabbed 22 children by himself . Two attackers killed 29 people and injured 143 at Chinese railway station last year.
It should be noted that not that long ago advanced nations in Europe were busy throwing people into ovens or starving millions on purpose. The idea that violence is uniquely American is best left to fringe leftists on college campuses. Moreover, as The Associate Press reported in 2012 , many experts contend that mass shootings are not growing in frequency at all. One has data that shows that mass shootings reached their peak in 1929 and have declined steadily since. Overall, gun violence has also been declining since 1993.
Now, even one shooting is a tragedy. What happened in Charleston is horrifying and heartbreaking, and there’s nothing wrong with having a debate about how to avoid shootings in the future. As for the frequency of these events, there can be a host of reasons why we might have more rampages. Maybe we’re freer and this puts us in more danger. Maybe we need better mental health policies. Maybe, as the president argues, we have access to too many guns. I don’t think so, but make that argument rather than trying to score political points with a falsehood.
*Update : Most of the pushback on social media claims that I’m being unfair to Obama. The president, they argue, is saying that we have a higher frequency of shootings, not that mass shooting are a predominately American event. ( Even then , he might not be right .)
It’s clear Obama is stressing separate points, and without doubt the perception he’s trying to create is that this type of “mass” violence is something that almost never happens anywhere else. It’s nothing new for him. Here’s his tweet from the speech yesterday:
Where did you get this chart from seeing as it's only 5 almost 6 year old data and does not represent anything close to what is reality.
The White House Lies About Gun Violence
JEESE! Say it ain't so!!!!
{chuckle}
What has changed has little to do with firearms: Namely, that social media has become more powerful and round-the-clock news has become more prevalent. That, in my view, is the story of the day.
I'm going to agree, but not for the reason you may think; it's not the increased number of armed individuals that has caused the decrease, it's the ever-increasing presence of cell phone video recording and surveillance cameras.
Otherwise, more shooting victims are shot by individuals they know, or, by shooters who live in proximity to their victims than the number of individuals are shot while in the commission of a crime i.e. by a homeowner or armed citizen defending himself against a criminal!
WH call for tougher gun laws: Shooting is “another example of gun violence that is becoming all too common” in U.S. — David Nakamura @DavidNakamura ) August 26, 2015 This is wrong. “Gun violence” is not “becoming” anything. Rather, it’s down — and dramatically:
Overall, probably correct; but the incidents of mass shootings is on the uprise (three or more victims at a time). For whatever the reason, one cannot disregard the ease with which crazies and hotheads can acquire firearms.
The premise may be correct but the cause-effect relationship I dispute.
Well the last few mass shootings were perpetrated by shooters that were sane enough to acquire their firearms legally, following all the laws for the most part.
So my question becomes, how do you quantify the idea that crazies and hotheads are acquiring firearms at any rate at all?
Are you judging sanity/insanity ex post facto? (which is a no no in judging such incidents as you are well aware)
I would like to know the basis for such statement, it rationally eludes me.
Well the last few mass shootings were perpetrated by shooters that were sane enough to acquire their firearms legally, following all the laws for the most part.
Sociopaths can be "sane" enough to do whatever they deem necessary to achieve their often-depraved objectives. When the laws or, lack thereof, allow such individuals to obtain guns "legally," the potential outcomes are not hard to predict.
We disagree, my friend.
We probably will be disagreeing my friend, but your admitting to an ex post facto view of determining crazy.
Very close to claiming that someone who purchases a firearm however legally is potentially an insane person.
You aren't directly saying such, but you are implying it. If your stating that someone buying a firearm is a sociopath.
How is the law going to adjudicate someone as a sociopath and limit their access to firearms before they exhibit any such sociopathic behavior?
The department of clairvoyance in legal matters disappeared way back in the days of predicting and accusing witches.
I'm unaware of them being reinstated anywhere.
So I'm still baffled by where this conclusion comes from.
We probably will be disagreeing my friend, but your admitting to an ex post facto view of determining crazy.
See below … I advocate the very opposite of "after the fact."
Very close to claiming that someone who purchases a firearm however legally is potentially an insane person.
Sorry … I don't follow that assertion.
How is the law going to adjudicate someone as a sociopath and limit their access to firearms before they exhibit any such sociopathic behavior?
The law doesn't make the determination … individuals with criminal records, documented violent episodes like spousal abuse, medical histories of mental instability … these need to be accessible via background checks. Gun dealers … LICENSED GUN SELLERS (no more gun show collector bullshit) need not be given the medical/psychological/legal specifics individual-by-individual, only that the background check affirms or denies the potential buyer's legal right to purchase a firearm.
No law will yield perfection … but every life spared is … A LIFE.
And essentially what your describing is already in place, if we can only get the government to pay for the technology improvements needed to make it happen as efficiently as it should.
Nothing your talking about isn't already in the current law. so why the push for more law?
I've yet to see a background check save a life. Yet it is claimed that is exactly what it does.
could someone PLEASE PLEASE point me to the data that proves once and for all that background checks save lives like is being described?
Pretty please? with sugar on top and all that nicey nice stiff?
I think I'm going to be waiting a long time. Cause such data does not exist.
So how does one get away with claiming that background checks save lives or potentially saves lives when there is no data ANYWHERE that suggest anything of the sort?
"individuals with criminal records, documented violent episodes like spousal abuse, medical histories of mental instability … these need to be accessible via background checks. Gun dealers … LICENSED GUN SELLERS (no more gun show collector bullshit)"
So your saying that the law has already made the determination, then he will be picked up by the existing background check system. No need for a new law. And dealers at gun shows are already licensed dealers that require background checks for purchases. (we all know about the phony "Gun show loophole")
so your argument still isn't proven, and seems like so much wish and dream, and it still doesn't address the point that the last few mass shooters bought their weapon legally. With no background to disqualify them
"Sociopaths can be "sane" enough to do whatever they deem necessary to achieve their often-depraved objectives."
Kinda like the current lame duck POTUS, right?
Sorry AMac couldn't resist , but I will add this , I read the NYT op-ed, and Earnest was dead wrong when he said that gun owners will have to comply for the safety and security of their neighbors , take one for society , I say for a society to have such anxiety over what someone owns and a fear of it when the majority of them have not shown a violent tendency , then those element of society need to visit the pharma companies , they have pills to deal with their anxieties and fears , they don't have pills that will make everyone safer though.
I am of this belief as a law abiding gun owner , when democracy becomes the tyranny of the minor majority , my firearms still give ME and those like me an over riding veto vote, so when guns are outlawed , only outlaws will have them , I know where ill be.
Agreed, I will be an outlaw also.
So am I to assume that your stating that any and every gun owner or prospective gun owner should be profiled? and once profiled mentally examined before allowing them to purchase a weapon?
I have a real hard time believing that you think that way Mac.
@nowhere-man :
So am I to assume that your stating that any and every gun owner or prospective gun owner should be profiled? and once profiled mentally examined before allowing them to purchase a weapon?
I have a real hard time believing that you think that way Mac.
So they will be examined by Obama's appointees and we'll prove once and for all the whole country is insane.
Then he'll accomplish his objective, but some of us crazies will still be a problem. Be wary of the days before November 2016 and if things aren't looking good for the Democrats, that could extend into the next year.
(chuckling) Amac, my dear Watson....
Amac , I have to think that , one of the reasons for such an uptick in these shooting incidents , mass or whatever name one wants to assign them , is the very reason you say the decrease is happening in the situation surrounding guns where gun crimes are falling , but the mass shootings are increasing , I feel its because of the instance news capabilities , everyone has a phone cam , social media uploads things as they happen , some of these disjointed and disillusioned perps, see this as the perfect 15 mins of fame , and most possably the only fame they will ever get, and of course , there is the thought , I have to top the last guy so im remembered more . yeah its a sick theory , but humanity has some very sick and demented individuals within its ranks. stop giving these idiots the headlines and the limelight in the media and see what happens .
how many of these shootings have been happening is what would be considered a soft target area? a good majority of them have happened in lawfully and legally declared gun free zones , those laws actually create the problem since a confidence is created that no one can fight back, and before you say ease of attaining the weapons look at the California laws , the so called role model for the rest of the country , even if the rest of the country had those laws , how far is it to mexico to the LA basin ? mexico has some pretty tough gun laws as well , no right to self defense really , but they also are awash in guns that can simply be smuggled in , and they will be the full auto version , and not the available civilian version available now. OH and the San B shooters did try and illegally convert their weapons to full auto , but they didn't do it right , its got to be done right in order for it to work.
It's easier to make a new automatic weapon that convert any semi. But it is done and yes you have to know what your doing, It's not something your going to get with a few internet downloads and made up blueprints.
You actually have to know how the specific firearm functions in all it's modes. Some are easier than others.
Some like the Glock, it's just a few alternate pieces that replace standard pieces that take but a few seconds to change.
But with an AR-15 to an M-16? takes some very specific engineering that if not done correctly will ruin the weapon.
So yeah it has to be done right and you have to know what your doing.
Is Barack Obama correct that mass killings don't happen in other countries?
After a gunman shot and killed nine worshippers in a historic African-American church in Charleston, S.C., President Barack Obama took to the White House podium the next day to "express our deep sorrow over the senseless murders."
In his June 18, 2015, remarks from the White House, Obama said , "Now is the time for mourning and for healing. But let’s be clear: At some point, we as a country will have to reckon with the fact that this type of mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries. It doesn’t happen in other places with this kind of frequency. And it is in our power to do something about it."
A flurry of PolitiFact readers -- some of them prompted by articles objecting to Obama’s claim -- wrote to us to ask us to check it, so we did.
An important point to make right off the bat is that many of the critics have pointed to the first part of Obama’s claim -- that "this type of mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries." As we’ll explain, the critics have a point here -- mass violence, including mass shootings, happen in a wide variety of countries.
However, the critics have truncated the quotation, leaving off the next sentence -- that "it doesn’t happen in other places with this kind of frequency." That’s also not fully correct, but it’s not quite as wrong as the first claim.
The White House argues that Obama's second sentence qualifies the first, and added that PunditFact rated Mostly True the claim that "Americans are 20 times as likely to die from gun violence as citizens of other civilized countries." However, that claim refers to gun violence generally, not mass killings specifically, the topic of Obama's comment.
For a look at the statistics, we checked with two researchers, Jaclyn Schildkraut of the State University of New York in Oswego and H. Jaymi Elsass of Texas State University. They have been collecting and analyzing mass-shooting incidents in 11 countries, covering the period from 2000 to 2014. Aside from the United States, the countries they studied are Australia, Canada, China, England, Finland, France, Germany, Mexico, Norway and Switzerland. (They also looked at less-developed countries, but we will exclude those since Obama specifically mentioned "advanced" countries.)
Schildkraut and Elsass shared the summary information from their database with PolitiFact. Here’s their table:
The chart does show that the United States has more mass shootings -- and more people cumulatively killed or injured -- than the other 10 nations combined, partly because it has a much bigger population than all but China.
Still, using this data, it’s easy to dispense with the first claim Obama made -- that "this type of mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries."
Over the decade and a half studied, the researchers found 23 incidents of mass shootings in the other 10 countries, resulting in 200 dead and 231 wounded. In the United States over the same period, there were 133 incidents that left 487 dead and 505 wounded.
Here are a just a few examples of mass shootings in other countries:
• On July 22, 2011, a total of 80 people were killed in Norway when Anders Behring Breivik, a political extremist, bombed a government building in Oslo and then went on a shooting rampage on the island of Utoya, just outside the city.
• On March 11, 2009, in Winnenden, Germany, a teenage gunman killed 15 people. The majority of the victims were children and teachers killed when the shooter opened fire in three classrooms in a local secondary school. The gunman shot two other people before killing himself after being cornered by the local police.
• On Sept. 23, 2008, in Kuahajoki, Finland, a gunman shot 10 people to death after opening fire on a classroom in the Kuahajoki School of Hospitality. After killing the students, the shooter burned the victims’ bodies.
In sum, then, Obama is wrong to say that "this type of mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries." Clearly it does happen elsewhere, and not in trivial numbers. Seven of the countries saw double-digit numbers of people killed in mass shootings during that period.
By contrast, the second part of Obama’s claim -- that "it doesn’t happen in other places with this kind of frequency" -- isn’t entirely off-base.
We compared mass shooting incidents across countries is to calculate the number of victims per capita -- that is, adjusted for the country’s total population size.
Calculating it this way shows the United States in the upper half of the list of 11 countries, ranking higher than Australia, Canada, China, England, France, Germany and Mexico.
Still, the U.S. doesn’t rank No. 1. At 0.15 mass shooting fatalities per 100,000 people, the U.S. had a lower rate than Norway (1.3 per 100,000), Finland (0.34 per 100,000) and Switzerland (1.7 per 100,000).
We’ll note that all of these countries had one or two particularly big attacks and have relatively small populations, which have pushed up their per-capita rates. In Norway, that single attack in 2011 left 67 dead by gunfire (plus additional bomb casualties). Finland had two attacks, one that killed eight and one that killed 10. And Switzerland had one incident that killed 14.
Still, while the United States did rank in the top one-third of the list, the fact that three other countries exceeded the United States using this method of comparison does weaken Obama’s claim that "it doesn’t happen in other places with this kind of frequency." In at least three countries, the data shows, it does.
Elsass warned PolitiFact of a few caveats about the data. While they believe their database "to be among the most exhaustive compilations available," Elsass noted that it may not include every instance of mass shootings. It also doesn’t include every example of mass killings -- just those committed by firearms, even though mass stabbings are not uncommon in such places as China. Finally, their database doesn’t include acts generally considered to be terrorism, such as the attack in Paris on the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo .
"If these were included, we are likely to see something much different statistically as there have been a number of very high-profile terrorist attacks in Europe, some including the use of firearms, that are excluded from the current analysis," she said. But in all likelihood, this would only make the case against Obama’s claim stronger.
The bottom line is that it’s unwise to take these numbers as gospel -- but the figures from this database are clear enough to cast significant doubt on the accuracy of the specific claim Obama made.
Our ruling
Obama said after the church shootings in Charleston that "this type of mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries. It doesn’t happen in other places with this kind of frequency."
The data shows that it clearly happens in other countries, and in at least three of them, there’s evidence that the rate of killings in mass-shooting events occurred at a higher per-capita rate than in the United States between 2000 and 2014. The only partial support for Obama’s claim is that the per-capita gun-incident fatality rate in the United States does rank in the top one-third of the list of 11 countries studied. On balance, we rate the claim Mostly False.
EDITOR’S NOTE , June 22, 2015: We heard from several of you regarding Obama's use of the word "frequency," and that frequency could refer to the incidents of mass shootings, not deaths as we examined. Looking at Obama's claim by incident, the United States has a higher rate of incidents than Finland, Norway and Switzerland. We agree that there is no preferred comparison and each is valid , and we've changed some language in this article to reflect that. We also agree that China has a larger population than the United States, a fact we weren't initially clear about but have since fixed. That said, we are sticking with our rating of Mostly False, in large measure because of Obama's claim that "this type of mass violence does not happen in other advanced countries." That is incorrect. We know some of you will disagree, and we'll be sure to air out some of your objections in our next reader mailbag.
I feel like someone just returned the world from its upside down state!!!!!!! Now I don't have to take one step forward and two steps back. Comments are actually in logical order. Thanks!!!!!
She put up a notice in red on the front page that she was going to do this.
Finally.
Reads much better!
Thank you!
One thing for sure is there are too many ways for people with bad intentions to get guns, so making it more difficult for law abiding citizens to get guns isn't going to stop non-law abiding citizens from getting guns. When anyone compares this country to European countries, all they have to do is look at Europe today and what is and has been happening in those countries and realize Europe will never be the same.
The people have already allowed their governments to "Fundamentally Transform" them and in the years to come you can forget Europe as it once was, because ever type of crime will go up just like it has already done in countries such as Sweden, England, France and others. There is a reason for that and it is the demographics of these countries are changing and we are already seeing the beginning of what is to come for them.
With our leaders on both sides and ourselves having allowed Obama nearly free reign to import so many people from these war torn countries with beliefs that are completely alien to to our way of life and the way this world is today our demographics are changing as well. Now is not the time to take away our only means of protecting ourselves. Obama signed on to ban handguns while a Senator in Illinois and that is his objective no matter what he says, some of us aren't fooled by his reiterate.
Mind you Alinsky has a tactic in his book about this. To paraphrase it:
When you want to push an agenda, go for what you can get. If you only get 20%, then you got 20% of what you wanted. Then go back to the table and ask for more.
An organizer will be entirely different from what he is later on before he builds his army, army being support from anyone he can get on his side. He will get these people from the streets, the prisons, the gangs, the churches and any other place he can get them. When he has a large enough army he will do whatever he wants to do. Remember the Obama who was going to bring us all together? It is true gun violence was at a peak in 1993. It has continually gone down until Obama was elected the first time. Obama is the greatest salesman of guns in this country. I think the way to reduce gun violence is to get rid of Obama. I'm afraid we will just be replacing him with another one possibly even worst than him though.