The Supreme Court Could Further Strip Native Communities Of Their Once-Promised Powers
http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2015/12/07/3728938/scotus-tribal-court/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=tptop3&utm_term=2&utm_content=5
The Supreme Court will hear a case on Monday that could significantly damage the little power that the Native American community has to address crimes committed by someone who is not a tribal member. The case , spurred by the alleged sexual assault of a minor in Mississippi, focuses solely on how courts may prosecute cases involving indigenous people.
The original case is pretty straightforward: A 13-year-old boy, involved in a youth career skills program, said he was sexually assaulted by Dale Townsend, his manager at Dollar General, a store on land belonging to the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians. The boy is a member of the tribe. The manager is not. The boy’s family sued Dollar General and Townsend in tribal court.
However, Dollar General argues that the court has no power to try the case — and instead has managed, after losing in two federal courts, to bring it before the highest court in the country.
“Dollar General stands poised to become one of the century’s fiercest challengers to tribal communities,” wrote Ned Blackhawk , a Yale professor of history and American studies, in a recent New York Times editorial. “This case has the potential to jeopardize tribal governments’ ability to develop their economies, to make binding contracts, even to protect their citizens.”
The reality is, we are the exception to the rule to be treated like a citizen.
Currently, tribal courts only have jurisdiction over civil cases , not criminal, when a non-native person is accused. So instead of trying Townsend for the crime, the boy’s family filed a civil lawsuit against him and Dollar General, hoping to claim at least some kind of compensation for the boy’s trauma and recovery. In return, Dollar General sued the tribal court, declaring it had no legal jurisdiction over non-natives, even as a civil case.
This wasn’t the family’s first action. Before filing in tribal court, the family took the case to the county, but the attorney assigned by the U.S. Attorney’s Office (USAO), which has exclusive jurisdiction to prosecute non-natives who commit crimes against natives in tribal territories, declined to prosecute.
This is far from unusual. Between 2005 and 2009, the USAO declined to prosecute 46 percent of assault matters and 67 percent of sexual abuse matters. Meanwhile, at least 67 percent of rapes against Native Americans and Alaskan Natives are committed by non-natives. Tribal courts have traditionally brought more justice — when they’re allowed to.
“It is clear [federal courts] do not have the capacity to respond to the needs and safety of our people,” said Lisa Brunner, an advocate for abuse survivors in her community, the White Earth Nation in Minnesota.
The amount of native women raped is more than double than of the entire country, according to Brunner. With a long history of rape and assault cases involving non-natives being disproportionately ignored, she calls tribal lands a literal “hunting ground” for predatory men who know they won’t be stopped. And native people have become frighteningly accustomed to it.
“For many young girls, it’s not an issue of if they’ll get raped, it’s when they’ll get raped,” she said.
After the boy’s alleged assault, Dollar General — with a market value of $20 billion — could have easily settled with the boy’s family and moved on. But instead, the company pushed the case through two different federal courts, losing each time. Why are they so adamant to prove the courts wrong?
The Monument Quilt displayed in front of the Supreme Court on Monday morning.
CREDIT: FORCE
“This is serious push to erode our tribal sovereignty. Who’s backing them?” asked Brunner. “This wouldn’t happen if it wasn’t one of us. They would have settled. The reality is, we are the exception to the rule to be treated like a citizen.”
Attorneys say this should have never gotten this far.
“Getting this in front of the Supreme Court is not a good thing,” said Mary Kathryn Nagle, an attorney who co-authored the amicus brief on the behalf of the National Indigenous Women’s Resource Center (NIWRC) for Monday’s case. “I can only hope it’ll attract a national outcry and get more non-native people talking about it. But it’s worrisome that the Supreme Court would even consider hearing this.”
Specifically, she said, because there’s nothing to clear up. The Choctaw tribal court is legally allowed to try civil cases. Jacqueline Agtuca, a lawyer and policy consultant to NIWRC, agrees. The Supreme Court shouldn’t be questioning cemented laws — especially ones could have devastating effects to a fragile community, she said.
“The reality…is very disappointing,” Agtuca said. “This isn’t an unsettled law that needs to be examined. This is a matter of settled law. There shouldn’t be any question about it. It’s incredibly intimidating.”
Advocates for native rights and sexual assault victims will use Monday’s case as an opportunity to shed light on a national issue with a rally on the Supreme Court steps. Activists plan to display survivors’ stories of rape and abuse by erecting a makeshift monument out of 100 quilts — part of an ongoing project called the “ The Monument Quilt ” — and wearing pieces of the quilt on their backs.
Agtuca, who’s joining the rally, said that while there’s no legislation on the horizon to further fight for native sovereignty, an increasing number of grassroots programs are working to create social change to spark legal action. Simply having native women speak about their stories outside of their tribal communities could bring much needed attention from the non-native majority. Agtuca hopes that a new generation of progressive activists — from members of Occupy Wall Street to Black Lives Matter — will finally shine a light on the injustices she’s seen.
“The reason we haven’t seen a case like this before is because for the first time, the Indians won,” added Nagle, alluding to the trials Dollar General lost prior to Monday’s case. “We’re actually being heard. We’re letting the government know that if they want to strip us of our rights — we’re not okay with that.”

Tribal Law and Order Act and Violence Against Women Act as amended - tops Dollar General in so many ways.
This will be another Baby Veronica case...VAWA or the Tirbal Law and Order act doesn't mean shit to SCOTUS.
Maybe the manager should have a near fatal, life crippling 'accident'. Off reservation, of course. Not surprising how SCOTUS ruled. Their pockets, and bank accounts are filled with corporate monies.
The rapist is convinced he will get off in a white man's court... that is if the feds even try the case at all. Don't have the budget, don't have the time, more important issues at the moment...
Indians need to start taking the law into their own hands to stop rape on the reservations. Vigilante justice is he only justice he Indians are going to ever get when non-Indians are involved with crimes on the rez, so go ahead and create a carefully selected group of Hector's. After all, Indians all look alike to the white man in the dark... be hard to identify the Hector's for prosecution.
Hoka Hey!
FREE LEONARD PELTIER
The question to be answered - "In Montana v. United States, 450 U.S. 544, 565 (1981), this Court held that generally "the inherent sovereign powers of an Indian tribe do not extend to the activities of nonmembers of the tribe." The Court recognized as an exception to that rule that a "tribe may regulate, through taxation, licensing, or other means, the activities of nonmembers who enter consensual relationships with the tribe or its members." Id. (emphasis added). The Court subsequently recognized in Nevada v. Hicks, 533 U.S. 353, 358 n.2 (2001), that it has "never held that a tribal court had jurisdiction over a nonmember defendant" in any context, so that it remains an "open question" whether tribal courts may ever exercise civil jurisdiction over nonmembers. In Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land & Cattle Co., 554 U.S. 316 (2008), this Court granted certiorari to decide whether Montana's undefined "other means" include adjudicating civil tort claims in tribal court. However, the Court resolved the case on other grounds. In this case, a divided panel of the Fifth Circuit held that tribal courts do have that jurisdiction. Five judges dissented from the denial of rehearing en banc. The case accordingly presents the issue the Court left open in Hicks and the Question the Court granted certiorari to decide in Plains Commerce: Whether Indian tribal courts have jurisdiction to adjudicate civil tort claims against nonmembers, including as a means of regulating the conduct of nonmembers who enter into consensual relationships with a tribe or its members?"
Think on this - sexual assault - civil or criminal??? I think they are looking at this the wrong way as it, in no way, compares to fishing licenses (Montana), hunting license (Hicks), or loan damages (Plains).
What do you think?
''What do you think?''
I'm not an optimist any time cases like this go before SCOTUS. It is a criminal case, but the original case was filed by the parents as a civil case. I'm aware that criminal charges would not be brought by the locals.
Dollar General has the money to keep appealing, as they have done thus far. Now we are at SCOTUS. If past history holds to form, we will lose.
I hope that I'm wrong, but past history is not favorable.
To me, it's as simple as that.
Nope - the Feds wouldn't prosecute (as usual) because they "assumed" this fell under the "new" laws (TLOA/VAWAR) which it doesn't 'cause it happened before they became laws with the new jurisdictional boundaries.
Nope - the Feds wouldn't prosecute (as usual) because they "assumed" this fell under the "new" laws (TLOA/VAWAR) which it doesn't 'cause it happened before they became laws with the new jurisdictional boundaries.
"Round and round the mulberry bush the monkey chased the weasel.... "
Now, if "I" were a SCOTUS, I'd send it back to the lowest court and have them rule on the criminal side as this is not a civil case. That's what I'd do
If Indians are citizens, (and I strongly believe they ARE!) They are entitled to the same protections under the constitution the rest of us are.
the fact that the US prosecutor refused to charge is a serious issue here. the idea that the nations cannot charge or prosecute such an individual is a travesty in both law and justice.
I guess so much for all men are created equal.
This should be kicked back for criminal prosecution and civil damages taken up after that.
Then the tribe should be entitled to make the determination if they wish this organization doing business on it's land in the future. (I wouldn't)
Someday, we as a nation will get back to principles of right and wrong over the principles of profit.
This is an example of a case where the Indians have it RIGHT!
And I support them 100%
They are entitled to the same protections under the constitution the rest of us are.
There is a separate Constitution that deals with Indians, NWM. Believe it or not.
As mimi sez - American Indians/Native Americans are not covered under the U. S. Constitution. It wasn't until 1968, with the passage of the Indian Civil Rights Act, that Indians received the same Constitutional protections - from their tribes/nations. As U. S. Citizens, when "Off" the rez, they received the same protections as other citizens - but, "ON" the rez - sorry Charlie.
In a nutshell - Anybody can be prosecuted in Indian Country. Typically, for a “Major” crime, the feds and tribe/nation can prosecute Indian accused, Indian victim, and Indian accused and non-Indian victim; feds can prosecute non-Indian accused and Indian victim, states can prosecute non-Indian accused and non-Indian victim.
For non-major crimes, tribes/nations can prosecute Indian accused and Indian victim, feds and tribes/nations can prosecute Indian accused and non-Indian victim; the feds can prosecute non-Indian accused and Indian victim; and states can prosecute non-Indian accused and non-Indian victim.
I wonder how much of that jurisdictional snafu is based upon racial fears?
I mean would it just be easier to extend reciprocity to the tribal courts in good faith with appeals court oversight?
Would be one hell of a lot more efficient.