Hey Conservatives Heres How Our Founding Fathers Protected Muslims Rights
Conservatives positively worship our Founding Fathers, quoting them almost incessantly — whether the quotes are real or fake — to support a number of points of view and invoke them with every idea presented, no matter how nonsensical. Ben Carson recently made the argument that a Muslim should never be President because our Founding Fathers would not approve.
“A good understanding of the Constitution answers that question for you,” Carson recently said ironically as he failed to understand the Constitution. “Because when you look at the Article II, and we’re talking about requirements for the president, they have to be a ‘natural born citizen.’ Now why is that the case?”
Not only does the Constitution prohibit “religious tests” for the presidency, but it does nothing to prevent a Muslim from becoming President. While a naturalized immigrant from Palestine could not be elected to the highest office in the land, a Muslim born in Iowa absolutely can be President.
“I’m sure if you had gone to the Founders and said, ‘but what about this person? They may not be a natural born citizen but you know they’ve been in America for most of their lives, and they’re a fine upstanding citizen, they served in the military, they came back they were on the police force, can’t they be the president?’… they would have said no,” Carson continued in his remarks to the National Press Club. “They said ‘We don’t even want to take the slight chance that we would put someone in that position who had different loyalties.’ That’s the answer to your question.”
It doesn’t take a genius to know that conservatives lack even a rudimentary understanding of the Constitution or the intentions of our Founders. In fact, despite a heavy Islamophobic sentiment even during the time at which the United States was born, our Founding Fathers wanted to make damn sure that everyone — no matter which imaginary friend they favored — enjoys equal protection and opportunity in the United States of America. In fact, Thomas Jefferson said that the protection of Muslims would show “how far tolerance and equal civil rights extends” in the Land of the Free, notes Denise Spellburg, author of “ Thomas Jefferson’s Qur’an: Islam and the Founders “:
“In the formation of the American ideal and principles of what we consider to be exceptional American values, Muslims were, at the beginning, the litmus test for whether the reach of American constitutional principles would include every believer, every kind, or not.”
Religious liberty was so important to Jefferson, the author of the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, the foundation of the religious freedom protections included in the Constitution, that he asked that his authorship of the law be one of just three accomplishments listed on his tombstone. When he was discussing the broad religious protections included in his piece of legislation, which was passed in 1798, Jefferson specifically mentioned Muslims. During debate, some legislators insisted that the term “Jesus Christ” be included, but Jefferson was clear in 1821 writings on the debate that the “that [the bill’s] protection of opinion was meant to be universal.” He added :
Where the preamble declares, that coercion is a departure from the plan of the holy author of our religion, an amendment was proposed, by inserting the word “Jesus Christ,” so that it should read, “a departure from the plan of Jesus Christ, the holy author of our religion;” the insertion was rejected by a great majority, in proof that they meant to comprehend, within the mantle of its protection, the Jew and the Gentile, the Christian and Mahometan [Muslim], the Hindoo [Hindu], and Infidel of every denomination.”
James Madison argued that an open society would welcome those “remaining under the dominion of false Religions,” and that the establishment of an official (Christian) church “discourages those who are strangers to the light of revelation.” Acceptance of all religions, he said, rather than bigotry, would actually promote Christianity, Madison theorized.
At the time, the Muslim population in the United States was not heavy, notes vice president of the Thomas Jefferson Foundation and Saunders Director of the Robert H. Smith International Center for Jefferson Studies at Monticello. While he says there “just wasn’t a large Muslim presence,” he says that “the real significance” was that Muslims were mentioned at all:
“It is very significant because they were clearly going out of their way to show just how broad and complete was the idea of religious freedom.”
In fact, the overwhelming sentiment in America among Christian churches was that Muslims should be accepted, says historian John Ragosta:
“Baptists and Presbyterians were really demanding religious freedom in the 18th century because they were dissenters from the established church. And they were talking about Muslims and ‘infidels’ and Jews.”
Evangelicals — perhaps the most bigoted sect of “Christians” today — were fully in support of religious liberty for everyone , he says. When opponents of Jefferson’s religious liberty bill spoke out, complaining that it would allow atheists, Muslims, and Jews to hold office, evangelicals responded, “That’s right,” Ragosta says. “These people knew what they were talking about.”
In support of Jefferson’s religious liberty law, the Hanover Presbytery sent a series of statements to the Virginia General Assembly in support of religious freedom for everyone . Once again, Muslims were specifically mentioned:
In this enlightened age, and in a land where all of every denomination are united in the most strenuous efforts to be free, we hope and expect that our representatives will cheerfully concur in removing every species of religious as well as civil bondage. Certain it is that every argument for civil liberty gains additional strength when applied to liberty in the concerns of religion, and there is no argument in favor of establishing the Christian religion but what may be pleaded with equal propriety for establishing the tenets of Mohammed by those who believe the Al Koran.
Conservatives are correct that the debate over Muslims in America has raged for centuries. They are correct that people didn’t quite like the Islamic faith — but they are absolute wrong when they say the sentiment at the time of the founding of our nation was that Muslims should not be accepted. Churches at the time still remembered what it was like to face persecution, Christians actually practiced Christianity, and our Founding Fathers — men much more intelligent than the Carsons, Palins, and Trumps of the world — absolutely believed in accepting everyone regardless of their faith.
In his first inaugural address, Jefferson said:
“Having banished from our land that religious intolerance under which mankind so long bled and suffered, we have yet gained little if we countenance a political intolerance.”
Unfortunately, while we still have religious liberty in America — a fact conservatives desperately want to change — we have, as Jefferson said, truly gained nothing because right-wing political intolerance is front-and-center in our country today. This is, of course, something conservatives need to think about. But they won’t.
Tags
Who is online
95 visitors

By all means periwinkle, advertise to the world that you get your news from a far left spam site that caters to the functionally illiterate. Given your trouble reading and comprehending the most basic of stories from sites like CNN, it makes sense you would be one of the fools that click bait sites sites rely on. In fact, your reliance on spam sites for news explains your almost unbelievable ignorance and uninformed partisanship.
I'm glad you finally admit you seed "stories" from known spam web sites to spam this site.. It's good you came clean, and it's not like anyone could possibly think less of you.
It would be nice to see some of resident constitutional experts address the article.
What's to comment? The article is just a hit piece. Carson never claimed it was illegal to have a Muslim president. The left has a hard time parsing anything with more than a few syllables.
To bad you feel it's a hit piece Cernenkov, that would put in the same class as our resident ''hit piece'' expert on the right. You know the one that has no facts in his articles.
Is the article re the constitution incorrect?
It's just a strawman to attack Carson and other conservatives. Of course a.muslim or an atheist can be president. No one pretended that they couldnt.
Shouldn't even be a topic or a seed - pure BS article from Washington Post, believed and bought for by blue, written by an author 214 years after Jefferson declared war on Tripoli and whipped their ass. Kinda showed what he thought of "terrorists", eh? Too bad Obama doesn't have those cajones.
Carson said that it is unconstitutional to have a naturalized Muslim as president, which is absolutely correct. Just as much as Arnold could be gov of California, but could never be seated as President. (naturalized Romanian)
You have to be a native born American Citizen to be President.
I'm surprised that JW attacked the point this way, he's obviously trying to paint Carson and his supporters as bigots, which fails miserably.
But then again, to JW anyone not a democrat is a bigot. Has to be, cause we think of different people as different. You know individuals. And since that is one of our strongest most important beliefs, we are naturally bigots to him.
But that is what happens when you lump all peoples into various herds, they are easier to lead down the garden path that way.
NWM - you still don't know your shit - do you ????
"No person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution,"
Quit claiming to be a historian when you can't even explain/quote a simple sentence without getting it wrong.
Well there are others that obviously need schooling also...
For educational purposes...
The third qualification to be President is that one must be a "natural born Citizen" (or a citizen at the time of the adoption of the Constitution). Although any citizen may become a Member of Congress so long as he has held citizenship for the requisite time period, to be President, one must be "a natural born Citizen." Undivided loyalty to the United States was a prime concern. During the Constitutional Convention, John Jay wrote to George Washington, urging "a strong check to the admission of Foreigners into the administration of our national Government; and to declare expressly that the Commander in Chief of the American army shall not be given to nor devolve on, any but a natural born Citizen." Justice Story later noted that the natural-born–citizenship requirement "cuts off all chances for ambitious foreigners, who might otherwise be intriguing for the office."
Under the longstanding English common-law principle of jus soli, persons born within the territory of the sovereign (other than children of enemy aliens or foreign diplomats) are citizens from birth. Thus, those persons born within the United States are "natural born citizens" and eligible to be President. Much less certain, however, is whether children born abroad of United States citizens are "natural born citizens" eligible to serve as President. As early as 1350, the British Parliament approved statutes recognizing the rule of jus sanguinis, under which citizens may pass their citizenship by descent to their children at birth, regardless of place. Similarly, in its first naturalization statute, Congress declared that "the children of citizens of the United States, that may be born beyond the sea, or out of the limits of the United States, shall be considered as natural born citizens." 1 Stat. 104 (1790). The "natural born" terminology was dropped shortly thereafter. See, e.g., 8 U.S.C. § 1401(c). But the question remains whether the term "natural born Citizen" used in Article II includes the parliamentary rule of jus sanguinis in addition to the common law principle of jus soli. In United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898), the Supreme Court relied on English common law regarding jus soli to inform the meaning of "citizen" in the Fourteenth Amendment as well as the natural-born–citizenship requirement of Article II, and noted that any right to citizenship though jus sanguinis was available only by statute, and not through the Constitution. Notwithstanding the Supreme Court's discussion in Wong Kim Ark, a majority of commentators today argue that the Presidential Eligibility Clause incorporates both the common-law and English statutory principles, and that therefore, Michigan Governor George Romney, who was born to American parents outside of the United States, was eligible to seek the Presidency in 1968.
The Presidential Eligibility Clause does not explicitly cover those who serve merely as Acting President, a constitutionally distinct office. Although Congress has imposed by statute, 3 U.S.C. § 19(e), the same eligibility requirements for service as Acting President, that provision may not be required as a constitutional matter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Firstwarrior, if your going to insinuate that I'm not a historian, by quoting the constitution, you might want to do it by quoting the constitution correctly, in context first. Instead of incorrectly out of context which reveals you own lack of knowledge..
But then again, no one has claimed your a historian in any manner.
Luv your BS - be nice if you knew what you were talking about.
Ark Kim vs US???? C'mon - immigration issue - not presidental issue - apples/oranges.
Your 2nd paragraph - prior to 1789.
Your 3rd paragraph - after Magna Carta and based on that document, not pertinent to ANY U. S. law.
Your 1st paragraph, as it actually is used in law - "The Constitution directly addresses the minimum qualifications necessary to serve as President. In addition to requiring thirty-five years of age and fourteen years of residency, the Constitution limits the presidency to “a natural born Citizen.”
×1. U.S. Const. art. II, § 1, cl. 5. All the sources routinely used to interpret the Constitution confirm that the phrase “natural born Citizen” has a specific meaning: namely, someone who was a U.S. citizen at birth with no need to go through a naturalization proceeding at some later time. And Congress has made equally clear from the time of the framing of the Constitution to the current day that, subject to certain residency requirements on the parents, someone born to a U.S. citizen parent generally becomes a U.S. citizen without regard to whether the birth takes place in Canada, the Canal Zone, or the continental United States."
In fact, despite a heavy Islamophobic sentiment even during the time at which the United States was born
It wasn't a phobia . It was a real fear . US sailors & seamen were being captured by muslim pirates . Maybe its time you understood the difference between a phobia & a real fear ...