Smooth Visa Process for Woman in Attack Is Focus of Inquiry
F.B.I. investigators on Thursday in front of the townhouse in Redlands, Calif., that had been occupied by Tashfeen Malik and Syed Rizwan Farook, the married couple who shot 14 people and wounded 21 others in San Bernardino, Calif., on Wednesday. Credit Mario Anzuoni/Reuters
The woman involved in the shootings in San Bernardino , Calif., on Wednesday passed through two rounds of criminal and national security background checks as she obtained a “fiancé visa” and later a resident green card to live in the United States, federal officials said.
Those checks turned up no negative information about the woman, Tashfeen Malik, a federal official said Friday. But after the F.B.I. said Friday that it was investigating the shootings as an act of terrorism — Ms. Malik pledged allegiance to the Islamic State in a Facebook post the day of the attack — officials were scouring her immigration record to see if there were any revealing details they might have missed.
“There was nothing she presented that would have been flagged,” a federal official said, speaking anonymously to discuss a fast-moving investigation involving several federal agencies. But, he said, “We’re going back right now and double-checking and looking over everyone’s shoulder who was involved.”
Photo
Tashfeen Malik
The information that Ms. Malik came to live in this country legally has heightened concern about security reviews in the immigration system. It has also renewed a tense debate in Washington, particularly after the Nov. 13 terrorist attacks in Paris provoked a furor in Congress and among state governments about the vetting of refugees from Syria and Iraq.
On Thursday, two Republican senators, Ted Cruz of Texas, who is running for president, and Jeff Sessions of Alabama, demanded that the Obama administration provide them with detailed information on the immigration history of Ms. Malik, who came to the United States and married Syed Rizwan Farook, an American citizen whom officials have identified as her partner in Wednesday’s shooting that killed 14 people and injured 21.
Ms. Malik, 29, was granted a K-1 visa, also known as the fiancé visa, in Pakistan in July 2014, the officials said, and she traveled to the United States that month.
The review process for a K-1 visa is “not as strict” as the vetting for refugees, Josh Earnest, the White House spokesman, said. But immigration officials said the K-1 review was more extensive than the vetting of a foreigner who planned to only visit. Mr. Earnest said Obama administration officials were examining Ms. Malik’s journey to this country to see if any policies should be changed.
As a routine part of the visa and green card applications, Ms. Malik gave fingerprints and other identifying information, which were passed twice through background checks using the State Department’s watch lists and the immigration, counterterror and criminal databases at the Department of Homeland Security and at the F.B.I.
For the K-1 visa, Mr. Farook, 28, started the application to bring in his fiancée, who provided a Pakistani passport.
Adhering to standard procedure for the K-1 visa, Ms. Malik had to demonstrate to State Department consular officials in Pakistan that their relationship was legitimate, and that she and Mr. Farook intended to marry in the United States within 90 days after she received the visa. Mr. Farook had to prove that he and Ms. Malik had met in person at least once in the previous two years, typically done by providing photos showing them together, personal messages and travel reservations. After the 90-day period, a K-1 visa expires and cannot be renewed.
As part of that review, Ms. Malik had a personal interview with a consular officer in Pakistan, federal officials said.
The couple came to the country in July 2014 on a flight that originated in Jidda, Saudi Arabia, two federal officials said. According to a certificate obtained by The Associated Press, the two were married in Riverside County, Calif., in August 2014, within the 90-day time limit.
On Sept. 30, 2014, Ms. Malik applied for a green card to become a permanent resident, based on her marriage to an American citizen. There is no limit on the number of green cards available to spouses of citizens, so the process generally moves quickly.
Since green cards are granted by a different agency, the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services, Ms. Malik had to undergo more background checks, probably providing a new set of fingerprints, officials said.
It is routine for an officer from the citizenship agency to interview both spouses, but officials there could not confirm that Ms. Malik was interviewed, citing privacy concerns.
Under the standard procedure, the couple would have had to provide documents and undergo questioning, primarily to persuade immigration officers their marriage was not fraudulent. Sometimes the officer will interview the spouses separately, asking highly personal questions about foods or pastimes the other spouse enjoyed or other intimate details, to make sure the immigrant and the spouse lived together.
Ms. Malik received a conditional green card in July 2015, officials said. After two years, the couple would have had to apply again to get a regular green card, showing they were still married.
Both were killed in a shootout with the police on Wednesday, leaving behind a 6-month-old daughter.
Correction: December 4, 2015
An earlier version of this article, using information from the police, misstated the age of Tashfeen Malik. She was 29, not 27.
Correction: December 9, 2015
An article on Saturday about the immigration record of Tashfeen Malik, the Pakistani woman who participated in the attack in San Bernardino, Calif., referred incorrectly to her request for a permanent resident green card. The application in September 2014 for Ms. Malik to receive a green card, after she had arrived in the United States on a 90-day K-1 “fiancé” visa, was filed by Ms. Malik, following a standard procedure — not by Syed Rizwan Farook, the American citizen she married who was the other assailant in the attack.
Tags
Who is online
95 visitors

Report: Jihadi Bride Passed 3 Visa Background Checks Despite Online Posts About Violent Jihad
Tashfeen Malik, the Pakistani woman who killed 14 people with her husband in San Bernardino earlier this month, openly advocated violent jihad on her social media accounts before coming to the U.S., but government officials approved her fiancee visa anyway, The New York Times reports.
Law enforcement officials discovered the posts, according to The Times . Had authorities found the messages when Malik applied last year for a K-1 fiancee visa to come to the U.S. with her husband, Syed Farook, she likely would not have been approved for entry. But, as The Times notes, immigration officials rarely check applicants’ social media posts for red flags. And female applicants are generally subject to less scrutiny than male applicants.
As one former senior Homeland Security Investigations officials told The Times, visa applicants’ identities are run against federal terror watch list databases, and if the person is not flagged during that process, they are usually not subject to further investigation.
Malik, who was born in Pakistan but grew up in Saudi Arabia, went through three separate screenings before being granted a green card. That despite the reportedly inflammatory social media posts and her reported association with radical elements as a student in Pakistan.
The first screening Malik went through was a criminal background and national security database check conducted by the Department of Homeland Security. The State Department conducted the second check, when the agency compared her fingerprints against national security databases. Lastly, she was interviewed by officials in the U.S. when she applied for her green card after marrying Farook.
The 29-year-old Malik also went through two in-person interviews, The Times reported — one with a consular officer in Pakistan and the other with an immigration officer in the U.S. during the green card application process.
Farook, who was born in Chicago and is of Pakistani descent, was also vetted by the feds. His background reportedly came back clean as well, as he was not on federal terror watch lists or a no-fly list.
That, too, has become a cause of concern. Farook was reportedly in the same social circle as one of four men arrested near San Bernardino in 2012 for plotting to recruit al-Qaeda fighters. It is still unclear how close Farook was to the would-be recruiter, who was recently sentenced to 25 years in prison for providing material support to terrorists.
~Link~
I put this comment on another article:
When our intelligence tell us ISIS is here. They can't vet these refugees. They have fake passports that have already been used by terrorists in the Paris attack. At least ABC did report that, but no one was interested in discussing it.
The media is in bed with the government, not much different than it was in the Soviet Union and still is in Russia. They can't control Trump and the GOP can't control Trump. The GOP would rather have a Democrat win an election if they can't control the candidate even if that person wasn't so outspoken as Trump is. If you are not part of the establishment on both sides, which is not only in this country, they will do anything to keep you from sitting in Congress or the President's seat.
So in spite of the fact that many of you are being bamboozled and want to paint others who don't agree with you in such a way they are not allowed to condemn this act, I condemn it anyway.
His actual statement was:
Donald J. Trump is calling for a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what the hell is going on. We have no choice.
And Randy responded:
Donald J. Trump is calling for a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what the hell is going on. We have no choice.
Which is the same thing as saying that all Muslims are responsible for Islamic terrorism, which simply is not true. He walked it back after the backlash, but it's still an incitement to fanatics on the right to attack anything an everything to do with Muslims. The only good part about it is that he is never going to be President, so his opinions are a moot point as far as policy goes. Still he makes the USA look like a nation of cowardly bigots and yes, that incites violence against peaceful Muslims (the vast, vast, vast majority of them are) living in this country. IMHO he is emboldening and encouraging domestic terrorism against American Muslims.
Pertinent part of my reply to him:
Which is the same thing as saying that all Muslims are responsible for Islamic terrorism
That's simply not true. We are talking about Muslims coming into this country such as the Syrian Refugees and other Muslims who could be using the fake passports ABC reported on and cannot be vetted as the FBI and other intelligence has told us.
If we don't get our act together there will be more acts like in San Bernardino and there will be more acts like the nut who burned the Mosque. It's really better for everyone, but it just wasn't presented by Trump in a manner that I like.
Perrie responded:
Six,
I am going to disagree.
We are talking about Muslims coming into this country such as the Syrian Refugees and other Muslims who could be using the fake passports ABC reported on and cannot be vetted as the FBI and other intelligence has told us.
Yet the last attack was done by an American. How does vetting apply? Now don't get me wrong, I am all for checking all new applicants, but people have selective hearing, and when something happens like San Bernardino, and the first thing out of a candidate's mouth is Trumps opening statement, no one hears the rest. I heard his whole statement, and I got to say, that I felt it was still fear mongering. If I were Muslim and I read his whole statement I would feel the same way.
Here is something to contrast it to. After 9/11, Bush got in front of the American people and comforted them. He also pointed out that we shouldn't blame all Muslims. He acted in a presidential manner. He didn't amp up the fear. I know what it's like to feel real fear... I was there... I had PTSD. But at least Bush didn't make me feel worse.
Now here is what I have to say about this:
On face value of only these comments I can see how each of us would feel the way we do, since each of us is only responding to my original comment found Here that started this conversation.
Although, everyone knows Trump has a big mouth and opens it quite often obviously without thinking what the consequences will be, his underlying idea has its merits in my opinion.
I put an article on here which hasn't been vetted by NBC or ABC yet, but even if it hasn't the premise of the article also has its merits. It can be found Here .
Lynne commented on the article referenced above and brought up the issue of civil rights. Her comments were valid as well as were A Mac's and John Russell's.
But even if the article where they commented on doesn't get vetted by NBC or ABC, the fact is Obama stopped the infiltration of Mosques, which had been going on since 911. Some of the things Mr. Haney said using names of organizations and movements, I've been able to find in other places where terrorist acts have been committed in other countries.
Here is a video which on the surface seems to present a very nice gentleman trying to make us aware if we don't put the Mosque at Ground Zero the news in the Middle East will infuriate the Muslims and cause them to attack various places across the world.
All he is really saying is no different than the comment my Randy Here when he basically said I've closed all the doors now and any conservative will not be allowed to condemn this act of violence. I've discredited them, taken their voice out of the conversation and it would be bigotry for them to show compassion now since they have spoken up in opposing any efforts in allowing refugees to enter this country disregard the fact all our intelligence plainly tells us they can't be vetted. We Conservatives are the bad guys. All of the Syrian Refugees and Muslims in this country are of pure heart and we Liberals have compassion for them while the other side hates all Muslims and if we aren't nice to them they will take offense, so let's show appeasement and they will do the same which brings us to Perrie's comment.
Perrie brought up the fact that Sayed Farook, the terrorist in San Bernardino was an American Citizen. Although that is true, there were many exchanges between Farook and Malik on social media which clearly exposed their Jihadist ambitions. The government didn't pick up on those conversations and also did not vet Malik, who should have easily been vetted to pose a threat to American Citizens, born in Pakistan, raised in Saudi Arabia with ties to radical Islam.
Wouldn't you love to be a fly on the wall where Tashfeen Malik studied Here.
I understand our Civil Rights must be preserved, but this was a tragedy that never should have happened and if our vetting process was working properly it would not have. I find it disturbing the NSA, IRS and other Intelligence organizations don't seem to have any problems with civil rights when it comes to American Citizens, but when it comes to Muslims who may be radicalized, organizations like CAIR threaten them they bow like Obama to the Saudi King, which was unprecedented.
Saudi Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal, the desert kingdom's richest man and a nephew of the late King Abdullah, demanded on Friday that Donald Trump abandon his White House bid.
Read more:
Saudi Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal, the desert kingdom's richest man and a nephew of the late King Abdullah, demanded on Friday that Donald Trump abandon his White House bid.
They don't seem to understand the current situation . Crude oil suppliers have no power these days even as a cartel .
BTW Trump's over-the-top position on muslims could be better modified to restrict those with professed radical ideas . All you need is someone to translate the Arabic social media .