Noah Feldman: Dollar General, tribal sovereignty and the Supreme Court
http://www.tulsaworld.com/opinion/noahfeldman/noah-feldman-dollar-general-tribal-sovereignty-and-the-supreme-court/article_77fc288b-b502-5692-9eaa-e8150c758102.html?utm_content=buffereb0e2&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook.com&utm_campaign=buffer
The idea that American Indian tribes are sovereign has a checkered history, in which it’s been both a sword for taking away Indians’ land and a shield for protecting some vestige of self-determination.
Tribal sovereignty came before the Supreme Court on Monday in a case that asks whether tribal courts have authority over non-Indians in civil cases. You’d think that, more than 500 years after first contact, the question would be settled. But it isn’t, or not exactly — and therein lies a tale of big money, big principles and thorny legal details.
The facts of the case, Dollar General Corp. v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians, are pretty straightforward. The corporation runs a Dollar General store in premises it leases from the Mississippi Choctaws on the tribe’s reservation. The lease says that any legal dispute over the lease and its terms shall be resolved exclusively in tribal court, subject to the tribe’s Tort Claims Act.
The agreement is very similar to one the corporation would make with a foreign sovereign when leasing property to do business in the sovereign’s territory.
The store ran a “youth opportunity program,” and a 13-year-old tribal member said the store’s non-Indian manager, Dale Townsend, made sexual advances on him when he was participating in it. The boy’s family sued the store in the Choctaw tribal court. The question is whether the tribal court has authority over the store.
The stakes of the case are potentially very large: Non-Indians do billions of dollars of business — much of it gambling business — on reservations pursuant to commercial leases and contracts.
The controlling case — or rather the case that is supposed to be controlling — is a 1981 decision, Montana v. United States. It says that tribes can regulate nonmembers “who enter consensual relationships with the tribe … through commercial dealing, contracts, leases or other arrangements.”
It also says that tribal courts have civil authority over non-Indians on the reservation when their “conduct threatens or has some direct effect on the political integrity, the economic security, or the health or welfare of the tribe.”
The Choctaw court said it had authority over Dollar General because the company had a commercial lease with the tribe and Townsend’s conduct threatened the tribe’s health and welfare. A federal district court then held that the tribal court had jurisdiction over the company but not over Townsend, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit agreed. Townsend was then absolved of civil liability in tribal court, but Dollar General asked the Supreme Court to take its case.
Ordinarily, you’d have predicted the Supreme Court wouldn’t touch the case, because it doesn’t like to hear cases where settled law is being applied to particular facts. There was also no conflict among the circuit courts of appeal on the basic legal framework.
But Dollar General’s lawyers are asking the court to create a new rule that tribal courts have no civil jurisdiction over non-Indians unless Congress specifically and clearly grants them the right. That’s already the case for criminal proceedings, under a 1978 precedent.
The basis for Dollar General’s argument is that much of the U.S. Constitution doesn’t apply in tribal courts. There’s no automatic appeal to nontribal courts from the courts’ decisions. And, the company maintains, non-Indians “face distinct disadvantages” in tribal courts. In particular, some tribal law is unwritten custom that can in certain cases be ascertained only by asking tribal elders about it.
On the surface, these concerns may seem legitimate. But none of them would carry much water if made against a universally recognized sovereign nation. If you choose to do business in the United Arab Emirates, say, and agree to settle disputes under Emirati law, you assume the business risk of engaging in the UAE legal system, however arcane it may be and however much it may favor domestic actors.
So Dollar General has to go further — which it does by asserting bluntly that “tribal court jurisdiction over nonmembers is fundamentally incompatible with the United States’ ‘overriding sovereignty’” over Indian tribes.
This claim has the virtue of being honest: The company is asking the court to say that Native American sovereignty isn’t really sovereignty in a meaningful sense — not even when a non- Indian entity has voluntarily and contractually placed itself under the tribal court’s jurisdictional authority.
So what will the court do? Will the justices be prepared to depart from precedent and tell Native Americans that a convenient legal fiction of their sovereignty lacks even this shred of plausibility?
The fact that the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case strongly indicates that at least four justices, the number necessary to agree to hear it, would be prepared to do so. Before granting certiorari, the court asked the solicitor general for his views. The solicitor’s office recommended against taking the case, but the court did it anyway.
The gambling industry would love to see the court take away tribal civil sovereignty over non-Indians. That would strengthen the industry’s hand when negotiating contracts with tribal authorities by taking away even the option of a promise to adjudicate disputes in tribal courts. For their part, tribes could try to lobby Congress to authorize civil jurisdiction over non-Indians. But it’s highly unlikely that they could convince Congress.
Everyone understands that the ideal of tribal sovereignty has often been dishonored in U.S. law and practice. For precisely this reason, the court ought not to add further insult to historical injury. The federal government’s truly shameful treatment of American Indians is a tradition that deserves to be repudiated, not perpetuated.
Noah Feldman, a Bloomberg View columnist, is a professor of constitutional and international law at Harvard.
Tags
Who is online
96 visitors

So Dollar General has to go further — which it does by asserting bluntly that “tribal court jurisdiction over nonmembers is fundamentally incompatible with the United States’ ‘overriding sovereignty’” over Indian tribes.
This claim has the virtue of being honest: The company is asking the court to say that Native American sovereignty isn’t really sovereignty in a meaningful sense — not even when a non- Indian entity has voluntarily and contractually placed itself under the tribal court’s jurisdictional authority.
So what will the court do? Will the justices be prepared to depart from precedent and tell Native Americans that a convenient legal fiction of their sovereignty lacks even this shred of plausibility?
Please - don't tell me that this court has thoughts of overturning the Marshall Trilogy cases.
''Please - don't tell me that this court has thoughts of overturning the Marshall Trilogy cases.''
Yup, that is the thought and the final action IMO. Why else would 4 of them agree to take a case that is already settled law.
Just combine this with the latest action by congress, and you can see the handwriting on the wall, IMO.
The entire thing sounds like a Monty Python skit, without being funny. Sovereignty obviously don't mean shit.
One way or the other, either they are sovereign or not. with everything that goes along with such status either way.
If they are independant nations, then make them so, if they are not, then completely abolish sovereignty and make them full citizens..
Half status either way just makes the situation that much worse.
I agree it's an unfunny joke.
They've already been MADE sovereign nations - by existing for thousands and thousands of years before the dominant society got lost and claimed us as India.
There is no MAKING to it.
This country, the USA, does not have the power, in any form whatsoever, to say we are or are not sovereign, independent nations. We are, always have been and always will be - regardless of what the addled brained dominant government sez.
This country, the USA, does not have the power, in any form whatsoever, to say we are or are not sovereign, independent nations. We are, always have been and always will be - regardless of what the addled brained dominant government sez.
Glad you feel that way, then boot the addled brained government out of the res. They are your private nations anyway aren't they?
Kick the federal bureau of Indian affairs out of Indian affairs for once and for all.
Tell the US government to take a hike why don't ya, and ENFORCE IT.
Right, if your independent nations then be independent nations.
That will happen when hell freezes over.
And you comment on these thread for ???????
You have nothing to offer in the discussion of any Native American/American Indian topic - never have, never will.
Stick to the topic.
I have stuck to the topic, and I can appreciate that you do not want any discussion from anyone trained in anything except what you think is valid.
Which means you refuse any real knowledge.
So I'll make a deal with you, you can be the keeper of everything native American history,
I'll be the keeper of the rest, how does that sound?
I would ask that you not get involved in Native American/American Indian discussions - makes the world go rounder smoother.
Thank.s
No problem, but what do we do when NA history bumps up against and conflicts with real history?
I mean neither one of us is going to back off.
So how do you suggest we deal with such occurrences which will be inevitable?
I am not adequately familiar with the laws, bit it seems like tribal courts should have jurisdiction. If he opposed that, he should have located his business elsewhere.