Native American Women Are Rape Targets Because of a Legislative Loophole
On December 7, 2015, the Supreme Court began hearing oral arguments for the Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians , a case occasioned by the sexual assault of a 13-year-old Dollar General employee by his employer. While the Supreme Court doesn't often hear sexual assault cases, this one has a twist: The victim is Native American , and the assailant is white. The Dollar General store sits on the Choctaw reservation, land considered Indian Country (the legal term used by the federal government) and the legal question is whether tribal courts here have the civil jurisdiction to try non-Native individuals who commit crimes there. Many Native people and their allies fear the Supreme Court's verdict could render tribal sovereignty even more precarious than it already is.
No one knows this better than Native women who are survivors of sexual assault . Eighty percent of the reported sexual violence against Native women is committed by white men, who do so with virtual criminal impunity because, with very few exceptions, they cannot be tried in tribal courts. Federal authorities have the authority to step in for serious crimes, like rape or murder, but often decline to prosecute crimes that have been committed in Indian Country. This jurisdictional black hole has created a climate that many describe as "open season" on Native women on reservations.
Amy Casselman, a former case worker for the Washoe Tribe of California and Nevada, has authored a forthcoming book on the subject: Injustice in Indian Country: Jurisdiction, American Law, and Sexual Violence Against Native Women . I spoke to her to find out why Native women have been left so vulnerable, and what can be done about it.
Click link to read excellent article.

So much happens that many know nothing about. Without the jurisdiction, tribes are nothing more than . . . . .
I'll be back to comment later.
This is a area that most Americans have no idea what is happening to Native Women.
The statistics are something like 1 in 3 Native American women will experience sexual assault in their lifetime. Followed the incidents in North Dakota once the drilling boon began, the number of rapes and the lack of justice was startling. The boundaries of judicial authority has been and continues to fail miserably.
Respectfully disagree with your statement that many don't know what's happening. I've known and yet am impotent to bring about change. My sorrow, even empathy provides no solution. Charitable contributions help, but ultimately put band-aids on mortal wounds.
Unfortunately without civil disobedience moving our collective leaders has proved impossible. I suppose that's why groups like "Occupy" and "Black Lives Matter" receive attention...groups demanding a seat at the table, any table!
People who's lives are not a part of the dissenting group often look at them with disdain. They interrupt the daily ebb and flow of life. But groups grab media attention, local authority attention and ultimately their neighbors attention.
Lynne, you IMO are the exception. I would be very happy if that were not true.
Remember back a year or so ago. Indian women were added to the renewal of the VAWA. Congress fought it tooth and nail. Mostly republicans. It was a battle just to have Indian women covered by a law that should extend to all women. What they were saying IMO, is that Indian women are worth what a non Indian women is. Sadly that is what I took away from the whole thing. Native women in Alaska were exempt from the coverage of the law, and still are.
Got off topic there for a minute, but this loophole is another example of how screwed up the laws are regarding Indians.
Kavika,
I suppose each of us have varying issues considered near and dear, choosing to focus and commit our time and energy...no lack of issues!
The latest authorization of VAWA provided, what many would determine a landmark decision, the inclusion of a pilot program for tribal jurisdiction over domestic violence (extremely limited). It's too soon to glean any data from this decision and I believe other federally recognized tribes may "opt-in" although I've not found if any have done so...I'm assuming the process is long and arduous!
Here's a sight some may want to refer for additional information on this issue...
Of course the "accomplishments" regarding women's issues in this country is laughable as we/they are still underlings to a man driven society. Progress is always at a snails pace.
Lynne - two events that have helped the Native folks were the passage of the Tribal Law and Order Act and the Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act in 2010 and 2013. Each act gave the tribes just "a little" more jurisdiction regarding crimes against Indians on the reservations. Example - now, the tribes/nations can arrest and hold someone accused of any sexual misconduct until the Feds show up - previously, they couldn't do that.
1st, while both of these are certainly viewed as progress, victims still go through a dizzying array of tribal, state and federal wrangling to determine who has jurisdiction. Beyond the crime of sexual assault, the questions begin...did the assault happen on or off tribal land, is victim a member of a federally recognized tribe, is the assailant a member of a federally recognized tribe.
Would it help to have state and/or federal magistrates permanently on tribal land?
Would it help? No, and that is the issue the tribes/nations have been fighting for over 100 years.
The only beneficial and appropriate method of dealing with any injustice on a reservation is to allow the tribes/nations to administer/have jurisdiction. Remember, tribes/nations are independent, sovereign nations and had, for thousands of years, handled inappropriate actions within the tribe/nation.
For the vast majority of tribes/nations, the goal of proper justice is restoring balance/harmony and each tribe/nation has their own method of obtaining that balance/harmony. Dominant society's manner of justice always involves punishment - which was a rarity for our people. For the tribes/nations, there is no "Band-Aid" approach in the restoration of harmony/balance. It is always for the long-term, permanent impact.