╌>

HILLARY CLINTON’S MISADVENTURES IN BASIC ECONOMICS

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  3 comments

HILLARY CLINTON’S MISADVENTURES IN BASIC ECONOMICS
Presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton on Wednesday unveiled a tax plan that includes a proposal to penalize any American company that legally relocates part of its operations outside of the United States, a process that Democrats like to call “corporate inversion.” Clinton says that if Congress doesn’t act, she’d be willing to take executive action on her own using the U.S. Department of the Treasury.

Due to an unfavorable business climate at home, many U.S. corporations expand overseas. Instead of depicting it honestly as a means of survival, Democrats portray so-called “corporate inversions” as a scheme for companies to dodge their patriotic obligations in hopes of getting rich elsewhere. Since vilifying job creators has always been a favorite pastime for a Democratic Party ever eager to pit workers against those who employ them, Clinton’s promise to exact punishment upon these corporations dovetails nicely with the resentment they have spent generations fomenting.

Although Clinton means to convince America’s workers that her plan would guarantee their jobs would remain in the United States, her plan would actually exacerbate the conditions that have sent so many businesses running for the border.

“Hillary has a great idea to stop overtaxed companies from fleeing our country for saner tax laws: threaten to raise taxes on them,” Ryan Ellis, Director of Tax Policy at Americans for Tax Reform, said. “It’s like telling a beaten dog that just one more kick to the ribs ought to do it.”

Currently, the U.S. government punishes job creators by imposing the industrialized world’s highest corporate income tax rate. At nearly 40 percent, it discourages American companies from making meaningful capital investments at home — from hiring new people and boosting existing workers’ benefits to purchasing new equipment and expanding within the United States. The rate is even higher for partnerships, LLCs, and S-corps.

So, American companies, rightfully concerned with their bottom line, begin to move significant segments of their operations overseas where it’s much cheaper to do business. When they earn a profit, the country in which they are operating taxes their income.

Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton speaks during a town hall meeting, Wednesday, Dec. 9, 2015, in Waterloo, Iowa. (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall)When the U.S. has the highest corporate tax rate in the developed world, it’s no surprise businesses relocate to cheaper shores. | Photo: AP
Most nations allow companies headquartered within their borders to return overseas profits (also known as repatriation) without a penalty, recognizing that these corporations have already paid taxes on their income elsewhere. Nearly the entire world is governed by this territorial tax system.

The United States, however, remains an outlier in this regard. The federal government imposes its corporate income tax rate (less a tax credit for the value of the tax rate levied overseas) on capital that is returned to our shores. This is a nasty political move meant to castigate American companies for daring to operate in a more pro-business country.

Here’s a very common scenario: Mike and his brothers run a very successful widget factory in the USA. They want to hire more people and create new kinds of widgets.

They’re proud Americans, but with Obamacare costs, mounting regulations and a 39.1 percent corporate income tax rate, they just can’t afford to expand in the United States.

So, they open up a new shop in Manchester, England. They hire lots of English workers and contribute to the local economy. In fact, Mike’s company now earns more at its new location than it did in America. After a successful year, the United Kingdom taxes the corporation at a rate of 20 percent annually.

With soaring profits, Mike finally feels comfortable opening a new factory in the United States. But, when he returns his British earnings to America — income that has already been taxed in the U.K. — the IRS notifies him that he owes an additional 19.1 percent for all the money he’s made overseas.

Now double-taxed on the same bit of income, Mike cannot afford to open his new factory in the USA. He won’t be able to hire the 50 new employees in desperate need of work or to buy the equipment he wanted from a local supplier. This leaves his hometown and nation’s economies without the growth they could otherwise have enjoyed.

It also keeps the federal, state and local governments from obtaining the money they would have received from his prospective workers’ income taxes, sales taxes and other business taxes.

If Mike were Indian or Swedish or Iraqi or Cuban or South Sudanese, he would not be double taxed on the income he earned in the U.K. But because he’s an American, Mike’s company is forced to pay twice for the income they generated from overseas operations – operations they felt forced to relocate because of America’s existing astronomical corporate income tax rate.

But this economically nonsensical policy doesn’t just have disastrous consequences for people like Mike. It hurts our entire economy.

“It’s like telling a beaten dog that just one more kick to the ribs ought to do it”
In order to avoid double taxation, American companies will simply leave their profits overseas. This impedes job creation and economic growth at home (and, in turn, fiscal improvements for the federal government’s ledger) during a time when it’s badly needed.

How severe is this problem? Right now, economists estimate that about $2 trillion sits in the international bank accounts of U.S. companies, of which $93 billion belongs to Microsoft alone. This is money that has already been taxed in the countries in which they’ve earned it.

Eliminating taxes on repatriated profits in the United States would inevitably boost our economy in a meaningful way. It would create jobs, increase tax receipts to the IRS and allow American companies to keep feeling American. If coupled with a major reduction in the corporate income tax rate, the U.S. could return to economic dominance on a global scale, prod American companies back home and attract international investment, too.

Hillary Clinton is more interested in scoring cheap political points than in actually expanding the American economy, creating American jobs or encouraging American companies to operate in America.

But, Republicans want a different solution — one that actually expands the economy and creates jobs. Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.), a leading GOP presidential candidate, teamed up with another conservative reformer, Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), to offer a massive tax reform package that includes a restructuring of the corporate income tax rate.

In their plan, the United States would move to a territorial system, like the rest of the free world. To manage the flow of companies rushing back to America under these new favorable conditions, the Rubio-Lee proposal would impose a meager one-time 6 percent tax on existing overseas earnings that could be paid over a 10-year period. After that, companies would be free to return their income to the United States as they wish.

The Rubio-Lee plan would also drop the corporate income tax rate from nearly 40 percent to 25 percent. Coupled with real personal income tax reform for families, their comprehensive tax reform plan would actually create jobs, spur economic growth and boost personal wealth.

If Clinton were genuinely interested in improving America’s economy and keeping workers employed, perhaps she should consider adopting the Rubio-Lee plan instead of her own, which is merely political posturing and not serious policy. http://opportunitylives.com/hillary-clintons-misadventures-in-basic-economics/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Reforming the tax code isn't just about tax  rates . It's also about eliminating corporate loopholes which should be done as soon as the rates are lowered .

 
 

Who is online

Gazoo
Hal A. Lujah


83 visitors