╌>

Doubling Down on W

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  15 comments

Doubling Down on W

Doubling Down on W   --   original article
by Paul Krugman  --   NY Times
------------------

2015 was, of course, the year of Donald Trump, whose rise has inspired horror among establishment Republicans and, let’s face it, glee — call it Trumpenfreude  — among many Democrats. But Trumpism has in one way worked to the G.O.P. establishment’s advantage: it has distracted pundits and the press from the hard right turn even conventional Republican candidates have taken, a turn whose radicalism would have seemed implausible not long ago.

After all, you might have expected the debacle of George W. Bush’s presidency — a debacle not just for the nation, but for the Republican Party, which saw Democrats both take the White House and achieve some major parts of their agenda — to inspire some reconsideration of W ­type policies. What we’ve seen instead is a doubling down, a determination to take whatever didn’t work from 2001 to 2008 and do it again, in a more extreme form.

Start with the example that’s easiest to quantify, tax cuts. 

Big tax cuts tilted toward the wealthy were the Bush administration’s signature domestic policy. They were sold at the time as fiscally responsible, a matter of giving back part of the budget surplus America was running when W took office. ( Alan Greenspan infamously argued that tax cuts were needed to avoid paying off federal debt too fast.) Since then, however, over-­the-­top warnings about the evils of debt and deficits have become a routine part of Republican rhetoric; and even conservatives occasionally admit that soaring inequality is a problem.

Moreover, it’s harder than ever to claim that tax cuts are the key to prosperity. At this point the private sector has added more than twice as many jobs  under President Obama as it did over the corresponding period under W, a period that doesn’t include the Great Recession.

You might think, then, that Bush-­style tax cuts would be out of favor. In fact, however, establishment candidates like Marco Rubio and Jeb Bush are proposing much bigger tax cuts than W ever did. And independent analysis of Jeb’s proposal shows that it’s even more tilted toward the wealthy than anything his brother did.

What about other economic policies? The Bush administration’s determination to dismantle any restraints on banks — at one staged event, a top official used a chain saw on stacks of regulations — looks remarkably bad in retrospect. But conservatives have bought into the thoroughly debunked narrative that government somehow caused the Great Recession, and all of the Republican candidates have declared their determination to repeal DoddFrank, the fairly modest set of regulations imposed after the financial crisis.

The only real move away from W ­era economic ideology has been on monetary policy, and it has been a move toward right­wing fantasyland. True, Ted Cruz is alone among the top contenders in calling explicitly for a return to the gold standard — you could say that he wants to Cruzify mankind upon a cross of gold. (Sorry.) But where the Bush administration once endorsed “ aggressive monetary policy ” to fight recessions, these days hostility toward the Fed’s efforts to help the economy is G.O.P. orthodoxy, even though the right’s warnings about imminent inflation have been wrong again and again.

Last but not least, there’s foreign policy. You might have imagined that the story of the Iraq war, where we were not, in fact, welcomed as liberators, where a vast expenditure of blood and treasure left the Middle East less stable than before, would inspire some caution about military force as the policy of first resort. Yet swagger-­and-­bomb posturing is more or less universal among the leading candidates. And let’s not forget that back when Jeb Bush was considered the front­runner, he assembled a foreign ­policy team literally dominated by the architects of debacle in Iraq .

The point is that while the mainstream contenders may have better manners than Mr. Trump or the widely loathed Mr. Cruz, when you get to substance it becomes clear that all of them are frighteningly radical, and that none of them seem to have learned anything from past disasters.

Why does this matter? Right now conventional wisdom, as captured by the bookies and the betting markets , suggests even or better­than-­even odds that Mr. Trump or Mr. Cruz will be the nominee, in which case everyone will be aware of the candidate’s extremism. But there’s still a substantial chance that the outsiders will falter and someone less obviously out there — probably Mr. Rubio — will end up on top.

And if this happens, it will be important to realize that not being Donald Trump doesn’t make someone a moderate, or even halfway reasonable. The truth is that there are no moderates in the Republican primary, and being reasonable appears to be a disqualifying characteristic for anyone seeking the party’s nod.

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I'm a bit more cynical than Krugman.

I know that Donald Trump is crazy in very much the same way P.T. Barnum was crazy. That is to say... not at all.

He never expected to be President. If by some cosmic buffoonery it came to pass, he'd be very happy... but he isn't putting any of his own money on the bet.

Mr Trump's mission is not to become President. His mission is to skew public debate so far to the right that no matter who becomes President, he and his ultra-rich friends will be easily served... even better than they are served today.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Mr Trump's mission is not to become President. His mission is to skew public debate so far to the right that no matter who becomes President, he and his ultra-rich friends will be easily served... even better than they are served today.

I love Donald Trump! Ted Cruz also for that matter and the rest of the GOP tossed in! The only way the Democrats lose the White House in 2016 is if we nominate Bernie Sanders.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

Bush Derangement Syndrome apparently has a long half life...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Cerenkov   11 years ago

Did you even read the article? 

           patience

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Pot meet kettle ...

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Yes. Did you?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Cerenkov   11 years ago

Krugman is the irrational loon who stooped to using Nazi imagery on the cover to sell his book of rants about Bush. He's just trying to drum up royalties from the ignoramuses who fall for his simplistic red meat. 

 
 

Who is online






81 visitors