╌>

'The Big Short' Shorts The Truth Of Financial Crisis

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  3 comments

'The Big Short' Shorts The Truth Of Financial Crisis
“The Big Short,” while entertaining, fails to describe what really happened.
“The Big Short,” while entertaining, fails to describe what really happened. View Enlarged Image

No event of the last 30 years was more financially traumatizing than the mortgage meltdown of 2007-08. Some 7 million Americans lost their jobs, 6 million lost their homes, and countless millions more lost their life savings.

One lesson of the real estate crash is that markets don't always work perfectly, far from it — but they work better than any alternative. It's critically important that investors, bankers, taxpayers and politicians learn why things went haywire so they don't happen again.
The new hit movie "The Big Short," based on Michael Lewis' bestselling book, is an entertaining and suspenseful reenactment of all the breakdowns in the banking and housing industries that caused the financial world to go collectively mad and the many unsavory characters.
It brings back bad memories of how symbiotic relationships among auditors, credit rating agencies, banks and insurance companies created dastardly conflicts of interest.
I've never understood why auditors and credit rating agencies work for the financial institutions, not the investors. It's like the old joke about the CEO who asks his accountant: "What is two plus two?" The accountant looks around and whispers, "What do you want it to be?"

Alas, the movie tells only part of the story. What it gets right is the preposterous overinvestment that occurred during the overinflated housing bubble in the 2000s.
McDonald's workers were getting half million-dollar mortgages. One Miami stripper owned five houses and had five mortgages. The credit agencies were giving triple-A bond ratings to junk mortgage-backed securities without even examining the unpayable low down payment "NINJA" (no income, no job) loans in the portfolios. These ratings were handed out right up to the very eve of the crash.
The big banks kept buying more and more of these MBSes, even as the default rates were skyrocketing. Government regulators encouraged them to buy as many of these "safe" mortgages as possible to meet capital requirements.You want to shout out: "Stop, you morons!"
Everyone was betting on the upside of the market. Who cares if this couple can't possibly pay off a $600,000 mortgage? In two years, the house will be worth $800,000. Or so the euphoric thinking went.
"The Big Short" portrays well the infuriating dereliction of the auditors, the rating agencies, the mortgage originators, the bankers, the securitizers — and, yes, the homebuyers too. The mortgage industry became a version of the old game "Pass the Bomb," where you quickly hand off the ticking plastic bomb on to the person sitting next to you before it detonates in your lap.
Where the movie falls short is its moralizing at the end. It portrays "capitalism" and "greed" as the villains.
But the real insanity of the bubble is that so few of the people who made financially reckless decisions went bankrupt. The government bailed most of them out with hundreds of billions of dollars through the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) of late 2008.
Quite a few liberals applauded the bailouts. When House Republicans voted down the original bailout bill, many on the left trashed them for trying to start the second Great Depression. Now, even they moan that the big banks are bigger and more powerful than ever.
Capitalism doesn't work if the government provides a trampoline-sized safety net for those who take risks that don't pay off. By encouraging the breakdown of due diligence and underwriting standards, bailouts create bubbles.
"The Big Short" also neglects to even once mention the worst actors of all in the financial meltdown: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. These two government-run institutions lost $150 billion of taxpayer money by securitizing mortgages and providing near 100% guarantees on repayment.
Also never mentioned was that government first caused the erosion of sound lending practices through the Community Reinvestment Act. The politicians kept pushing the banks to make riskier loans to lower-income borrowers in the name of "fairness."
In the years before the bubble popped, then-Rep. Barney Frank, chairman of the Financial Services Committee, which has regulatory oversight of banks and insurance companies, instructed the lenders: more, more, more.
Anyone who thinks greater regulation is the solution wants to deputize Larry, Curly and Moe to manage these institutions. Good luck.
The movie bemoans the fact that almost no one went to jail. But one line in the move explains why not: If being stupid were a crime, my brother-in-law would be in prison.
The movie ends with a printed message on the screen that the big banks are bigger than ever, and that in 2015 they're coming up with the same exotic mortgage packages to sell to investors. This is true, and — hello! — it's happening because of government regulation and bailouts. Fannie and Freddie are back guaranteeing high-risk, 3% down payment mortgage loans as well.


Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-viewpoint/122815-787087-stephen-moore-the-big-short-while-entertaining-comes-up-short-on-explaining-the-financial-crisis.htm#ixzz3vfBnfEIF
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Big government loves big business even if the model of that business is unsustainable ...

 
 

Who is online






81 visitors