Respectable Radicalism
Respectable Radicalism -- original article
by Paul Krugman -- NY Times
--------------
Brad DeLong , riffing off Larry Summers , asks about what is driving the Fed – and argues that Larry has it wrong, that the Fed’s problem is not an “excessive commitment to existing models.” On the contrary, the Fed seems to hold beliefs that are very much at odds with Macroeconomics 101, whose basic Hicksian models do not at all support the Fed’s eagerness to hike rates.
Indeed. This is a thesis I’ve tried to argue for a number of years; back in 2011 I noted that
[S]upposedly sober, serious people are actually radicals insisting that we can make the economy work in ways that it has never worked in the past … Meanwhile, the irresponsible bearded professors are actually the custodians of traditional wisdom.
I suspect that Larry is talking about hysteresis, which is indeed a departure from standard models. But the case that the risks of hiking too soon and too late are deeply asymmetric comes right out of IS-LM with a zero lower bound – which is basically the framework I used in the paper Brad addresses .
I think I understand how being an official, surrounded by men (and some but not many women) who seem knowledgeable in the ways of the world, can create a conviction that you and your colleagues know more than is in the textbooks. And that may even be true in normal times, when recent experience counts a lot. But in a world of zero-lower-bound macroeconomics, which is a world nobody not Japanese experienced for three generations, theory and history are much more important than market savvy. I would have expected current Fed management to understand that; but apparently not.
Tags
Who is online
139 visitors

The Fed's rate hike came because... Very Serious People said it was long past due.
Of course, there isn't the slightest hint of upward pressure on wages, which would be the first precursor of inflation... but who cares about Econ101??
These Very Serious People know that rates must be raised!
These serious people are seriously wrong.
This is not rocket science. The Fed is charged with preventing excessive inflation, which is defined as "more than 4%". We have been running under 2% for a few years. Wages are absolutely flat, so there isn't the slightest glimmer of a "wage/price spiral".
There was no reason for a rate hike.
Well... no economic reason.Politics, on the other hand...
Ahhh yes, politics, the bane of the thinking person.
There are certain sub-markets that do experience inflation ... and are inflated now .