╌>

Is the Oregon standoff the inevitable result of anti-government rhetoric?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  10 years ago  •  7 comments

Is the Oregon standoff the inevitable result of anti-government rhetoric?

January 4

Out in Oregon, the Bundy clan has begun another heavily-armed standoff with the government, seizing control of a building at a wildlife refuge and talking about laying down their life for liberty, presumably in some kind of gruesome battle in which plenty of law enforcement officials are killed along with the martyrs to the anti-government cause. Most of the Republican presidential candidates have so far avoided saying anything about this event, but liberals are raising the question of how much responsibility the Republican Party and its leaders bear for this kind of radical right extremism.

It’s a complicated question, but the answer is: not as much as their most fervent opponents might claim, but not so little as they’d like.

This latest standoff is led by Ammon Bundy, son of Cliven Bundy and leader of what seems to be a band of freelance insurrectionists. If you’re having a conflict with the federal government, they’ll load up their weapons, come to your location, and set up a confrontation with law enforcement, whether you want them to or not.

You can read elsewhere about what led up to this standoff, but it has to be understood in context of the last one, when rancher Cliven Bundy got into a conflict with the United States government over grazing fees. The problem was that Bundy wanted to use public land to graze his cattle, but didn’t want to pay the fees that every other rancher does, since as he said at the time, “I don’t recognize the United States government as even existing.” Anti-government activists flocked to the standoff, pointing guns at government officials and talking of insurrection. Two of those present at the event would soon after go on a shooting rampage in Las Vegas, murdering two police officers and a bystander.

At the time, some Republican politicians, including Jeb Bush and Marco Rubio, said that whatever Bundy’s gripe with the government, he ought to follow the law. But others were far more indulgent. Ben Carson supported the protest. Ted Cruz blamed it on President Obama, calling the standoff “the unfortunate and tragic culmination of the path that President Obama has set the federal government on.” And Rand Paul not only supported their cause but later had a friendly sit-down with Cliven Bundy. Donald Trump took a middle position, saying that laws should be followed, but that when it came to Bundy, “I like him, I like his spirit, his spunk and the people that are so loyal…I respect him.” (For more details on these reactions, go here ).

But most critically, during the standoff Cliven Bundy and his supporters became heroes of conservative media. Sean Hannity practically made Bundy his Fox News co-host for a couple of weeks. Their bizarre claims about the government and the means they were using to lodge their complaints — an armed standoff — were validated and promoted again and again by the media outlets conservatives rely on for their news. It was only when Cliven Bundy turned out to be an unreconstructed racist , of the kind who begins sentences with “I want to tell you one more thing I know about the Negro,” that Fox and the Republicans who supported him finally distanced themselves from him.

 

Even if they hadn’t been so aggressively supported and promoted by elite conservative figures and institutions, the Bundys’ actions can be viewed as an outgrowth of conservative rhetoric over the years of Barack Obama’s presidency. From the moment he was elected, conservatives said that Obama was not legitimately the president (many of them charged that he wasn’t born in the United States). Virtually everything he did was given a given a dark and sinister spin, with the constant refrain that Obama was a tyrant who had not only usurped power but would shortly turn the United States into a terrifying nightmare of statist oppression. The line between mainstream rhetoric and that of the radical fringe disappeared, with popular television hosts and backbench Republican House members spouting conspiracy theories about FEMA concentration camps and the Department of Homeland Security stockpiling ammunition in preparation for some horrific campaign of repression. Nearly every policy with which conservatives disagreed was decried as the death of freedom itself.

Anyone who took all that literally and believed that the people saying it were actually sincere could well have concluded that armed insurrection was indeed an appropriate response to what was plainly a coup from the enemies of freedom within the government, led by a despot who was literally trying to destroy America. Now combine that with the way so many Republicans talk about guns — not just as a tool of self-protection, but as something whose essential purpose is to intimidate government officials. Second Amendment purists, some of whom are running for president, regularly justify their enthusiasm for loosening gun laws as a way to keep tyranny in check, by showing that gun owners are willing to fight against their government, should it become necessary. As Ted Cruz has said , “The 2nd Amendment to the Constitution isn’t for just protecting hunting rights, and it’s not only to safeguard your right to target practice. It is a Constitutional right to protect your children, your family, your home, our lives, and to serve as the ultimate check against governmental tyranny — for the protection of liberty.”

So on one hand, Republicans regularly say that we need so many guns in civilian hands in case it becomes necessary to wage war on the government, while on the other hand they say that Barack Obama’s government has become tyrannical and oppressive, and freedom is all but destroyed. So why is anybody surprised when people like the Bundys put those two ideas together?

It doesn’t stop there. Republicans were similarly divided on Kim Davis, the Kentucky county clerk who decided that because she doesn’t support same-sex marriage, she could defy the Supreme Court and refuse to grant marriage licenses to anyone in her county. Davis got full support from five of the Republican presidential candidates, while six opposed her move and the rest came down somewhere in the middle. But the point is that a meaningful contingent of elite Republicans said that when you don’t like the law, you can pretend the law doesn’t apply to you, even if you’re sworn to carry it out.

These days, every lunatic corner of the right can find respect and validation from at least some of the most prominent and respected figures in Republican politics and conservative media, at the same time as people are encouraged to strap on their AK-47 when they go down to the supermarket .

 

Today, Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio both condemned the actions taken by the insurrectionists in Oregon. There are surely plenty of other Republicans who are disgusted by the Bundy clan and actions like this standoff, so it wouldn’t be fair to blame the whole party for the rise of this kind of armed right-wing radicalism. But you also can’t say anti-government rhetoric had nothing to do with it.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/plum-line/wp/2016/01/04/is-the-oregon-standoff-the-inevitable-result-of-anti-government-rhetoric/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_popns


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

I think that "inevitable" is the perfect word. Many of the candidates don't seem to realize that words do actually have meaning and that some people take what they say as over-blown blowhard bullshit to try to pick up primary votes, seriously. And that's dangerous.

As for the Bundy Gang, I don't think the're right wing terrorists. However I do think that Ammon Bundy is dipping his toe in the terrorists/militia pool to see how it feels and if he wants to jump in whole heartily. I would hope for his own sake and the sake of those who might be stupid enough to jump with him, that he stays out of that line of protesting. In spite of what some right wing nuts may be whispering in his ear or yelling on radio talk shows, there is literally no chance whatsoever that there is going to be a new American Revolution any time in the foreseeable future. We're not even close to one. Not over guns or Federal Land or anything else. If he joins the dark side of the right wing and actually thinks he can start one, he'll lose very, very badly and people will die, mostly on his side.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Not over guns or Federal Land or anything else.

I'm not convinced by your flippant remark . There seems to be real complaints about how the FWS is handling their  control over lands . It wouldn't be the 1st time something like that has been abused . If the govt insists on having its way without setting up a grievance process for disagreements , this kind of result is all but inevitable .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    10 years ago

Personally, I suspect that internal psychological mechanisms are at least as important here as any dogma.

These guys are Rambo wanabees. They fantasize about "standing against the government's storm-troopers".

Last year, they all got a huge adrenaline rush, during the Cliven Bundy "clash". Now that high has worn off, and they need another dose.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Now that high has worn off, and they need another dose.

 It's become like hillbilly heroin to them. Which they probably also do. That or just plain moonshine.crazy

The group in the picture look like they're a lot more likely to accidentally shoot each other in a gun fight then any federal officer. A couple of them look too fat to hold their weapons up for very long anyway. Or is that just what their wives say? lol

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

What I don't get is don't these moron militia types realize just how silly they look all dressed up and trying to look tough? 99% of the pictures of see of American militia members, in their camouflage outfits, look like over-sized boy scouts with guns. They don't look threatening! They just look stupid, silly and laughable! If they came after me I'd die laughing at them before they could get a shot off!laughing dude

And yes, almost all of them look like this bunch of fucking clowns.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    10 years ago

What I don't get is don't these moron militia types realize just how silly they look all dressed up and trying to look tough? ........ And yes, almost all of them look like this bunch of fucking clowns.

..... and the Right Wingers wonder why they're referred to as the "Bubba Crowd"

These guys just haven't grown up and still want to play guns. Well they can play they're silly games all they want, but they need to should keep in mind that .... "It's all fun and games until somebody gets killed".

 

 
 

Who is online

afrayedknot


138 visitors