The Great Debate Initiative before Congress aims to slash student debt
For most of the 20 th century, higher education wasnt treated as a cash cow, and students were better off for it.
Consider: Thousands of college students recently had their school loans forgiven by the federal government. Few are celebrating, though. Washington stepped in to relieve students from paying a for-profit college that had defrauded them.
Corinthian Colleges, a chain of private universities, had been the target of class-action lawsuits and government investigations since 2004. It went bankrupt in May, not long after the U.S. Department of Education fined the company almost $30 million for lying to students about job-placement rates.
But thats just one settlement. We need a systematic approach to tackle the student-debt crisis. We can easily find one if we look in the not-too-distant past.
As recently as 1990, state governments and Washington all viewed higher education as a public good. The United States had a robust network of affordable state public universities, and students didnt have to take on oversized financial and emotional debt to get a good education.
But due to sharp state budget cuts, as well as wage stagnation and the rise of predatory lending, the path to a degree has become far more difficult. As is the path to financial stability after graduation.
Progressive members of Congress have now introduced a new debt-free college initiative , based on a blueprint from Demos and the Progressive Change Campaign Committee. It could, if passed, help all U.S. students graduate from a public college without accumulating a mountain of debt.
As the 2016 presidential campaign unfolds, students and their allies will be watching candidates to see where they stand on this key issue. Candidates, including Senator Bernie Sanders (D-Vt.) and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton , are already talking about it.
Meanwhile, Senator Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) on Tuesday again talked about his plan for wealthy people or hedge funds to underwrite college education as part of a student investment plan. Students would agree to pay back a percentage of the loan once they have a job. Rubio and Senator Mark Warner (D-Va.) had already introduced a Senate bill last year focusing on loan repayment.
Debt-free college means states would again fulfill their traditional role as education providers. At the moment, close to 75 percent of all college students are enrolled in public universities of some sort,up from about 50 percent in the mid-1960s. But just as American students began relying more on public universities, their prices have spiked.
The public higher-education sector saw strong growth throughout the 1970s and 1980s. In the past three decades, however, tuition has increased 250 percent. Almost 80 percent of these hikes , new research shows, are due to declining state subsidies.
State governments must go back to thinking that higher education is just about the best investment they can make in the future.
This recommitment to college affordability will also require a concerted effort from the federal government. With so many tight state budgets, Congress should pledge to cover 60 percent of the cost for states that commit to providing a debt-free education for low- and middle-income students.
The percentage of public-college tuition covered by Pell Grants has fallen by more than 40 percent since the 1970s. Here, too, the ball is in Congress court.
If the federal government took the step of increasing Pell Grant aid and indexing the grants value to the average in-state tuition cost, millions of students could reap the benefits.
The question U.S. leaders should be asking isnt, How are we going to pay for this? but rather, What happens if we dont?
We already know the answer. In 1993, the majority of U.S. college graduates did not have to borrow to pay for their education. Among those who did, the average loan was less than $9,500. Now, however, nearly 70 percent of bachelors degree recipients take on an average debt load of $30,000.
The need to pay back this money has blocked many young people from entry into the middle class and from saving for homeownership and retirement.
This college-debt boom has taken a particular toll on students of color or with low incomes those often in the greatest need for upward mobility. For bachelors and associates degrees, 81 percent and 57 percent of black students go into debt, respectively, compared to 63 percent and 43 percent of white students.
In the for-profit college sector, African-Americans and Latinos make up nearly half of students. Yet these schools graduate the lowest percentage of students of any education sector and saddle them with the most debt, $40,000 on average.
This is not sustainable. Governors have already recognized the problems these high college costs can create. It is undermining their states ability to train and retain a skilled workforce. President Barack Obamas free community- college proposal was partially modeled on a program by Tennessee Governor Bill Haslem, known as tnAchieves. It gives students scholarships to cover any gaps in tuition for two years. The program has helped increase the number of lower-income students who enroll and, more important, earn a credential.
Debt-free education isnt a radical new proposal.Its a return to the more equitable system that previous generations enjoyed.
http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2015/07/07/initiative-before-congress-aims-to-slash-student-debt/
Tags
Who is online
72 visitors

Education is still the greatest investment we can make for America, and always has been. It pays back that investment many times over.
FLY
Where do you stand on a term of national service (perhaps two years), not necessarily the military, in return for a four year college education.
The service could be in many forms, conservation corps type projects, teaching in high need areas upon graduation, service in the medical field, etc
I think it would be a very positive step Robert.
Many kids could use the discipline for a similar program prior to entering entering college as well. Earn money, some skills, all while in some cases making up their minds with their field of study.
I'm in favor of it as well RIO. There are a lot of benefits for the kid and society.
Now, investing in the future seems to be something that Americans have forgotten about.
FLY
All of that and their efforts benefit the society/country as a whole at the same time
That is what they call a "win - win" I guess
Think of it.... Every dollar invested would be paid back multiple times over through higher tax collection. This isn't a guess, this is well known economics.
Good question Feronia.......
I'd have to give that some thought. Robert is the smarter of the two of us so maybe he has some thoughts.
But definitely target our kids. Anyone know the age where kids start dropping out of school? I think this is where you start dangling the carrots.
FLY and Feronia
Itwould seem to me that the college entitlement in return for national service would be for four years of college, not for multiple degrees or advanced degrees etc.
In addition to the free four year for service, we need to figure out how to make college more affordable for those that pay for their attendance as well.
And p.s. I am not nearly as smart as you guys ......
I would suggest that not every college major be given tax payer incentives . There are some that are mostly for the entertainment of the student ...
This be true Petey....!
FLY
No argument from me on that point, I have longed advocated for national service as bridge to a free four year college education
Between my wife and I, in just the past four years, for us only, our student loan debt is over $100K. My Masters in Jurisprudence in Indian Law is $35K and her Foreign Language BS and MS are $72K. She is heading for a PhD - another $50K at a minimum.
Both of us use those degrees in our primary jobs - she's a high school language teacher, I'm a Federal Tribal Consultation Specialist.
None of our student debt is forgiven and nothing in the proposed language will benefit us (well, maybe her, but doubtful).
Then, our daughter starts college after next year
So then 1st..... If there is a robbery at Ft. Knox, one could assume that you're going to be high on the list of primary suspects....
College is over-rated, for me. The secret is to marry someone else who went to college and their parents paid for it. That way they make much more money then you and there are no student loans at all.
Then 1st just might have to sell....... Eh hem...... His services.
Now the time to pay off those loans will all depend on those pesky supply-demand-cost curves! He might want to consider getting "investing" in a Bow-Flex to boost that demand-cost side of the equation.