╌>

America should regulate bullets

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  10 years ago  •  22 comments

America should regulate bullets


January 6

 


Ann Brown was chairman of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission from 1994 to 2002.


When I chaired the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, I was grateful that we had authority to regulate lead in household paint. Banning the use of lead-based paint in homes has prevented brain damage in countless children over the years.

So why wouldn’t Congress allow us authority over another dangerous consumer product often made with lead?

Specifically, why not bullets?

On Tuesday, President Obama unveiled a package of executive actions that he hopes will reduce gun deaths in the United States. I urge him to put one more proposal on the table: regulating ammunition. The idea is workable, and Americans could support it.

This idea isn’t new. In 1974, the CPSC’s first chairman made clear his belief that the agency could probably regulate ammunition, and a court agreed — whereupon a frightened Congress passed laws making it impossible even to try. Now is the time for the president to begin pushing to correct that mistake.

Do I say this swayed by all the horrific mass shootings we have seen in the past few years? Only in part. These are the tragic, visible tip of an iceberg. While mass shootings attract headlines and our grief, bigger problems with guns often go unnoticed: the hundreds killed annually in intimate-partner violence; those killed by kids too young to know what pulling a trigger can do; the 21,000 Americans who commit suicide with a firearm each year.

I admire the president for doing what he did this week. But the chance of achieving even a small reduction in this carnage through executive action is, well, small. And the chance of getting more effective gun-control measures through Congress this year is about zero.

How can we do more when the National Rifle Association has persuaded Congress to put roadblocks in front of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention research into gun deaths? When more than half of Americans oppose tighter gun control even after a year of such bloodshed?

Would Americans favor regulating ammunition any more than they would favor regulating guns?

Yes, for three reasons.

 

First, ammunition limits are clearly not prohibited by the Second Amendment. Some communities and states around the country — Sacramento, Los Angeles and Connecticut, for example — already regulate bullets. Is this effective? In 2008, Sacramento seized thousands of rounds, identifying 156 people prohibited from owning guns or ammunition in the process, while the city’s murder rate declined more than 30 percent between 2008 and 2013. It’s been “ a slam-dunk solid ,” one Sacramento detective told a reporter.

More important, unlike gun limits, Americans generally support restrictions on ammunition — 80 percent of them in one 2013 Fox News poll.

And, finally, we have the technology to do it. James Holmes bought more than 4,000 rounds online before his 2012 rampage in a Colorado movie theater. Twenty years ago, when purchases were offline, it would have been tough to spot someone like that. Today it would be easy.

Why should my old agency be the one to do the regulating?

One reason: We need a national standard. Having a hodgepodge of agencies and regulations govern ammunition would make flouting any regulation as simple as, say, driving across the Key Bridge from the District to Virginia.

Second, we need an authority that knows that one size does not fit all.

That is the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Under Republican and Democratic presidents, the commission has worked with manufacturers to create flexible guidelines for all kinds of hazardous products. It didn’t ban cribs, walkers, toasters — or paint. It worked out ways to address what made them dangerous — and saved children in the process.

The same flexible approach can work with ammunition. When someone who may be dangerous is prevented from buying ammunition, any gun he has hidden becomes like a car without gas: a useless hunk of metal.

There are many ways to move ahead. We could license ammunition purchases like drivers, ban online purchases and mandate background checks for buyers. But it would be pointless for me to outline the precise steps that should be taken up front — except for the first one: ending Congress’s disgraceful attempt to chill research . Funding to study regulating ammunition should begin now.

 

Times and cultures change.

When I was chair of the CPSC, I would have laughed if you told me same-sex marriage would become legal. It did. In 1984, a nonprofit staffer first thought up family and medical leave. It passed a decade later. Obamacare? Key parts of it can be traced back 25 years to the conservative Heritage Foundation . Today, it’s law. What we can’t win in 2016 we might win in 2020.

And regulating ammunition should attract some Republican support. In 2007, California condors were being poisoned by lead ammunition in carcasses left behind by hunters. To save them, Republican Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger signed a bill banning lead ammunition in state wilderness areas. Do Republicans believe in regulating ammunition to save condors but not children? I don’t think so.

It’s time to propose a step that won’t trigger a constitutional debate and to move forward on an idea that Americans favor in addition to ones they oppose. It’s time to start exploring sensible ways to stop gun violence and save lives by regulating ammunition. 

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/we-should-regulate-bullets/2016/01/06/62de9322-b3dc-11e5-a76a-0b5145e8679a_story.html?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_opinions



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    10 years ago

This is a reasonable idea.

So it has no chance whatever.

     not listening

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

It reminds me of the Chris Rock routine where he says bullets should cost $5000 each. "I would pop a cap in your ass...if I could afford to!"

Still it makes sense to me. forbid selling of ammo on the internet and limit the amount anyone person can buy in a year. Background checks for bullet purchases and registration of all of a persons ammo purchase. It doesn't have any effect on the 2nd amendment, so there could be no legal challenge to it.

It does make perfect sense.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Some states do require that purchased ammo be signed for , and the individual does have to have a state card, but as has been pointed out  there are those , such as myself whom reload , I can say for myself , I have not bought factory made ammunition  other than .22 cal for a very long time ( my case for my rifles and shotguns , 10 years on the conservative side , I actually have some brass cases that I reload that are head stamped with dates back in the 1940s).  then there are some like me into black powder shooting that collect wheel weights , mix them withlead such as fishing weights or decoy weights , and mold our own projectiles  for whatever guns we have , casting ones own bullets is easy. the last component is the powder , some like myself even make our own "Black powder , which is simply combining 3 easy to get components that happen naturally. One has to remember , todays smokeless powder is not really nessisary to load for modern bullets , and how to use these "recipies " as they are called is also available to anyone that wishes to look them up.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    10 years ago

Again, a solution that will affect law abiding citizens and have no affect on criminals.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Again, a solution that will affect law abiding citizens and have no affect on criminals.

Every law will be violated by some individuals at some time.

So, should we abolish all law?

Does "perfection" need to be on the table before we attempt to prevent whatever may be prevented?

I have raised a reasonable, unambiguous question; I'd appreciate an answer in kind.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

Does "perfection" need to be on the table before we attempt to prevent whatever may be prevented?

I have raised a reasonable, unambiguous question; I'd appreciate an answer in kind.

I am afraid it's obvious that you'll never get one, because one does not exist. The hyper-pro-gun people (of which there are several on this site) use the lack of perfection in any regulation as a pathetic, childish and transparent excuse to do nothing. It's sad that they can't come up with anything more rational then what a 10 year old would use as a reason, but it's all they have. A pathetic fig leaf.

They don't care how many innocent people die, because of them and their intransigence. Men, women, even children dying? They do not care. They are soulless and heartless. It makes one wonder if they are even human?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Again, a solution that will affect law abiding citizens and have no affect on criminals.

So you're saying that a criminal has never gone to a store that sells ammo and bought it there? I mean that IS what you just said. You know that, don't you?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    10 years ago

One of the largest hurdles I see is that ammo is quite easy to make.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

This idea is not intended to solve the problem completely. None of them (background checks, etc.) are. None of them can. They are all intended just to make some sort of dent in the problem and they will do that. The fall back, knee-jerk, position of far, far, far too many pro-gun people is that, when someone comes up with an idea, that it won't solve the ENTIRE problem COMPLETELY 100%, so fuck it, let's not even try it or add it into the mix. It's a bullshit cop out excuse not to do anything. That's like saying using antibiotics don't save everyone's life, so let's never try using them at all, ever. Besides there is the inconvenience of having to have a shot to use them. Or seat belts don't save everyone's life, so they shouldn't be required to be in automobiles. Besides there is the inconvenience of having to hook them up.

Also, if it's a bit more inconvenient for law abiding citizens, too damned bad. If it saves only ONE life, then ALL of the inconvenience of ALL of the law abiding citizens was and is worth it.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

I disagree it's like saying if we lower the speed limit to twenty five we will save lives. I'm willing to accept a extremely small amount of risk for a large amount of freedom. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Except that you wouldn't lose your freedom to buy ammo. However, depending on the limit set, do you really need to purchase large amounts at once? Is it really all that inconvenient or an affront to your freedom to sign a form saying you just bought some ammo, if it'll help save at least a few lives? I mean how about some consideration for your fellow citizens?

Also, remember that murder is against the law, yet people do it. So should we just forget that law? Is the law an inconvenience or an unreasonable infringement on the freedom of someone who wants to kill someone else? I'm willing to give up the freedom to shoot other people to save lives. Remember, these are cases of people dying. This is not like talking about how many Popsicles you can buy at a single time. The idea is just to limit the amount of ammo you can buy. Its not a law putting an ATF agent outside of your front door. Be willing to give a LITTLE!

Besides, there is nothing in the Constitution that guarantees you the freedom to buy ANY ammo at all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

I disagree it's like saying if we lower the speed limit to twenty five we will save lives. I'm willing to accept a extremely small amount of risk for a large amount of freedom. 

At what point does the line between "small amount of risk" cross over to "a risk that might save a life at the cost of a small amount of your freedom"?

Your "twenty-five mile an hour speed" is lowered from what … fifty MPH … sixty … seventy-five? How can you determine how many lives must be saved in order to justify a law that decreases the number of bullets sold while not preventing the purchase of bullets altogether?

 

 

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     10 years ago

just had a thought though, at what number  would the regulations kick in? what is a suitable amount of ammo ? and is that actual already made , ready to go ammunition? I keep all my components separate so they are basically abunch of "parts" . with the 'parts I have I am willing to bet I would be way over  any limit suggested here , I know I am way over 200 rounds of ready to go per gun.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

One would assume that, like with any regulation, there would be details to be worked out. I don't see why reasonable people (Ha! Ha! (when it comes to guns and ammo) can't come up with a figure that SHOULD make everyone relatively happy.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

I cant remember where, but back in the 90s someone suggested what you just mentioned about no constitutional guarantee to ammunition , I believe if I remember correctly it was mentioned to  the  USSC justices and they pretty much stated that ammunition is in deed covered by the 2nd , since without ammo firearms would be nothing but clubs , and that ammo being nessisary for firearms to work would in deed be protected by the amendment . Wish I could remember when it was but I got a case of brain fart with dates.

as for who would need a good quantity of ammo , I remember when they sold 22 lr in 500 round bricks , when I was teaching my kids to shoot at the range , it was not uncommon for each kid to have their own brick for a shooting session with an additional brick per person as a back up . with 3 kids , 2 adults , and usually a couple of the kids friends tagging along ( I will just say 1 friend per kid) and usually another adult along  5000 rounds of 22 was nothing in a 3-4 hr  period , now if the back up is also applied that's 10000 rnds .

 keep in mind kids will burn through a 500 rnd brick fast because they think its cool, they soon learned once they were out , they didn't get anymore , I used it as a lesson on making each shot count , and it was interesting to see that lesson sink in , usually by someone having to sit out some activity involving making presicion shots ( one of my favorite was to take a spent shotgun shell usually 1 12 ga , 1 20 ga and 1 410. set them out at a determined distance , and see who could knock then over , as they all could , we increased the distance . to make it even more challenging , lay the shells on their sides so that the butts were showing , what ended up being were targets that progressively got smaller ) one who could get through sll that got bragging rights , as well as a prize their mom determined.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

Wish I could remember when it was but I got a case of brain fart with dates.

I have the same problem (it's called age). That said I don't remember anything about that and sure would like to get a link from someone (anyone) on it. I don't see how they could rule that way, since a bullet is not an arm. Still, I could be wrong as is proved by my being married 3 times.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

LOL I only made that mistake once and once was enough for me , I am enjoying my life as a single man  and as much as I hate to admit it I am getting old myself  as my motorcycle accident in Aug has shown me ( got ran over by a DUI) I just don't heal as fast as I use to after bouncing across the pavement.

 I can see them saying that because without bullets as you stated , guns would be useless as a means of real self defense other than as expensive fancy ornate clubs. so to make a gun functional it must also have bullets. just l;ike that C Rock skit of taxing them , wasn't well thought out because all additional taxes ( other thn state sales tax) collected on them are earmarked by the pittman -robinson act that goes to the USFWS to purchase  land and maintain habitate for both game and non game speicies, that act was proposed sponsored and worked through congress by those that enjoy the shooting sports , such as hunting . And  those taxes cannot be used for any other agenda, and its written into the act that any additional taxes  so they wouldn't go to what some would like to tax it for.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   10 years ago

I have, in just a quick poking around, found a lower court ruling that Washington D.C. could not "ban" the possession of ammunition, but haven't found any cases (certainly no SCOTUS cases) that say an American has the right to posses it or not. My guess would be that they've never ruled on it and that its never been before them. Still it's sort of a moot point as the proposal is to have the CPSC regulate and restrict the SALE of ammunition, sort of like they do with things such as lead paint. Not to ban it outright. I don't see how that could be unconstitutional?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Randy I don't remember it being a case the high court heard , might be I remember them being asked about the lower court ruling.

 
 

Who is online


Right Down the Center


96 visitors