╌>

Why Germany wants rid of Greece

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  20 comments

Why Germany wants rid of Greece
When I recently visited Berlin, it quickly became clear the extent to which Germany had created a fantasy story about Greece. It was an image of Greeks as a privileged and lazy people, who kept on taking bailouts while refusing to do anything to correct their situation. I heard this fantasy from talking to people who were otherwise well informed and knowledgeable about economics.
So powerful has this fantasy become, it is now driving German policy (and policy in a few other countries as well) in totally irrational ways. In particular, Germany refuses to discuss debt relief with Greece, yet seems quite happy to see Greece leave the Eurozone, the inevitable consequence of which would be that Greece would obtain much greater debt relief through default. Talk about cutting off your nose to spite your face. What is driving Germanys desperate need to rid itself of the Greek problem?
One possible answer is that Germany finds the truth about Greece too upsetting, too challenging. This is because since 2010 Greece has done most of what the Troika asked of it. In particular, changes in its governments underlying primary budget balance (i.e. the degree of austerity enacted) have been greater, by a long distance, than any other European economy. For many outside Germany what has happened to Greece as a result is hardly surprising: austerity is contractionary, and austerity on steroids is ruinous. Yet Germany is a country where the ideas of Keynes, and therefore mainstream macroeconomics in the rest of the world, are considered profoundly wrong and are described as Anglo-Saxon economics. Greece then becomes a kind of experiment to see which is right: the German view, or Anglo-Saxon economics.
The results of the experiment are not to Germanys liking. Just as Anglo-Saxon economics would have predicted, the results for Greece under the Troika have been a disaster. After dutifully taking the medicine for years, and seeing the collapse of their economy, finally the Greek people could take no more. Confronting this reality has been too much for Germany. So instead it has created its fantasy, a fantasy that allows it to cast its failed experiment to one side, blaming the character of the patient.
The only thing particularly German about this process is the minority status of Keynesian economics within German economic policy advice. In the past I have drawn parallels between what is going on here and the much more universal tendency for poverty to be explained in terms of the personal failings of the poor. These attempts to deflect criticism of economic systems are encouraged by political interests and a media that supports them, as we are currently seeing in the UK. So much easier to pretend that the problems of Greece lie with its people, or culture, or politicians, or its resistance to particular structural reforms, than to admit that Greeces real problem is of your making.

----------------

Why Germany wants rid of Greece

by Simon Wren-Lewis

mainly macro


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Simple explanations of the Greek mess have the advantage of simplicity.

And the disadvantage of being at best misleading and often just plain wrong.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Here's a simple statement : The Greeks have made their problem worse with their referendum result .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Yes, Petey... It is a simple statement.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Here's another simple statement : When you feel defensive you give misdirections instead of commentary .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

When you feel defensive...

??

Why would I feel defensive about your post?

You yourself labeled your statement as "simple". I agreed. Where's the problem?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A timeline with a lot of decisions made by Greece and Greeks that have brought Greece to where it is today

2001: Greece became the 12th -- and last -- country to join the eurozone before the launch of the euro at the beginning of 2002.

To join, a country had to demonstrate that it had achieved "economic convergence" with the other eurozone members -- a requirement meant to ensure that different countries would not jeopardize the common currency.

When Greece was accepted, Finance Minister Yannos Papantoniou described it as a day that would place Greece firmly at the heart of Europe.

But even then, warnings were sounded. The president of the European Central Bank, Wim Duisenberg, warned that Greece had much to do in terms of improving its economy and controlling inflation.

2002: Everyone now agrees that Greece cooked its books.

One of the economic convergence requirements was that a country not have a budget deficit of more than 3% of GDP, or gross domestic product.

It was a requirement imposed on all countries, but one that has not been followed over the years by all eurozone countries -- not even that staunch advocate of strict discipline, Germany itself.

Yet the extent to which Greece hid its economic problems from its fellow eurozone members would prove staggering.

March 2004: In March, the center-right government of Prime Minister Konstantinos Karamanlis took power. And it took a look at the books.

What it discovered was appalling. The budget deficit was not 1.5%, as reported, but 8.3% -- five and a half times higher than thought.

The Karamanlis government faced a dilemma: What should it do with this shocking information?

August 2004: The Olympic Games were approaching -- returning to Greece, the land of their birth. This was the country's turn to shine on the international stage.

Well, no need to upset people, inside Greece or out, the government thought.

Instead of revealing the extent of the deficit -- and starting to deal with it -- the government covered it up.

2008: But few countries were less prepared to deal with an economic downturn than Greece. With a yawning gap between revenues and expenditures, it was vulnerable.

In 2008, the country's tax collection, such as it was, collapsed. The hole in the budget grew too big to hide.

Greece needed help.

And the other eurozone countries, fearing contagion -- that, if Greece defaulted on its debts, other eurozone countries' cost of borrowing would rise to unsustainable levels -- felt they had no option but to give that help.

2010: In 2009, international investors, understandably spooked by the revelation that Greece's previously announced debt and deficit figures were inaccurate, became worried about the country's ability to pay its debts.

The country's credit rating was downgraded, first by Fitch and then by Moody's.

With investor confidence disappearing, the country's cost of borrowing spiked and the situation ran the risk of running out of control.

So the other eurozone countries, in the form of the so-called troika -- the European Commission, the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund -- stepped in to prop up the patient.

2010: In May 2010, leaders of the eurozone and the Greek government agreed on the conditions for a 110 billion-euro bailout loan. But the bailout came with strict conditions -- among them that the government had to improve its tax collection and save money in an effort to bring its budget into balance.

Saving government money, though, meant laying off government workers. And that meant that those workers had less to spend, so other businesses suffered and laid of workers, too.

Unemployment rose, depressing government tax revenues.

2010-2012 Protests grew. The country tossed out the government of social democratic Prime Minister George Papandreou and ran through two provisional Prime Ministers -- all in 2011 -- before turning to the conservative party of Antonis Samaras.

But still, the bailout medicine didn't do the trick. In February 2012, the government accepted another bailout loan, bringing the total borrowed to 246 billion euros. A new austerity plan was agreed upon as well.

The amount owed to the international lenders was now 135% of the country's GDP.

And things were just getting worse.

Unemployment rose to near 30%. Youth unemployment soared over 50%.

2015: Still, the budget refused to balance.

More money was needed -- and realistically, debt relief as well, if the country were ever again to stand on its own two feet.

The country was now led by the left-wing government of Alexis Tsipras. Relations between representatives of the international lenders and Tsipras and his finance minister, Yanis Varoufakis, were poor -- hampering negotiations.

In June, the negotiations broke off, with each side apparently daring the other to be the cause of a Greek exit from the eurozone.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I can't force you to communicate . Some people try to suppress communication by being aggressive and nasty . I don't do that . Your choices determine how your article discussions proceed .

From my POV , you steadfastly refuse to ever admit you might be wrong .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

If we remove the gratuitous innuendo, we find some interesting phrases. I particularly appreciated

2015:Still, the budget refused to balance.

The article had previously recognized that

Saving government money, though, meant laying off government workers. And that meant that those workers had less to spend, so other businesses suffered and laid of workers, too.

Unemployment rose, depressing government tax revenues.

and

And things were just getting worse.

Unemployment rose to near 30%. Youth unemployment soared over 50%.

These trends were due to the austerity imposed by the Troika.

Like I said, Greece is hardly innocent. But the mess has been made worse and worse by the Troika's dogmatic insistence on austerity, despite unanimity among economists against it.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Decisions by Greeks caused the problems

You obsession with the Troika is more amusing that factual

There was no mention of the troika in the timeline of events and decisions (by Greece) that I provided

Accountability for the problems in Greece belongs to Athens and no other European city

I see no convergence on this issue for us so I guess we should agree to disagree if you are amenable to that

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I AGREED with you, for pity's sake! What do you want me to do?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Whatever...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

I used to hear that from my teenage grandson a lot

We considered it juvenile behavior at the time

....

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Have a nice day ... {insert picture of smiling people wearing mullets here} .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Robert,

I posted this article particularly for you. To give you a glimpse of more than your simplistic perception of the situation. You have chosen to ignore it.

You posted from CNN, and I took the time to show you that even that article recognized the toxicity of the austerity imposed by ECB / IMF / Commission (also known as the Troika). You ignored that too.

So... If you are satisfied with your knowledge of the situation, I see no reason to bother you further.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Money needs to circulate in an economy to do work.

Austerity pools money, and and keeps it on the sidelines.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

You do not bother me in the least, other than slight annoyance that you are unable to accept that Greece is largely responsible for the mess they find themselves in.

They made the decisions, bad decisions that go them to where they are today - institutions mat have facilitated those bad decisions, but the decisions were made by Greeks.

The buck stops in Athens on this mess.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I think you've got the game down pretty well Feronia...... the last one at the table gets stuck with the check!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Absolute debt, drives the austerity of hanging onto money.

Yes money must circulate to make an economy work. The more debt accumulated to make the economy work forces more to hold onto money. (or simply accumulate more and more debt)

It's a self defeating cycle, but one that fiat money brings on with the demand for even more debt to support it.

Fiat money eventually becomes worthless and the economy collapses until a new tender of value comes along.

Greece is only a small example of what is going to happen to us when the debt check comes due.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I don't get the austerity approach

I would suggest the lack of other successful approaches is part of the appeal . Austerity may be of value in a situation where there is too much frivolous spending going on .

 
 

Who is online







72 visitors